Uk Legislation: The Preliminary Reference Procedure Under Article 267 Tfeu

1997 words - 8 pages

Summary
• The ECJ can only give rulings on the interpretation of the Treaties and validity of secondary EU legislation, under Article 267 TFEU.
• References are either discretionary or mandatory.
• Bodies that can make a reference have to be courts or tribunals that satisfy the Dorsch criteria.

Conclusions
• If there is a judicial remedy available from a certain UK court, then that specific court has discretion on making a reference.
• If there is no judicial remedy available (usually the court in question being the Supreme Court) then a reference would be mandatory.
• Before making a reference, the courts have to take into account the case law guidelines.

Recommendations
• The UK courts will have to be certain of the issues that would be referred, especially since the procedure is time-consuming and expensive.
• Guidelines should always be considered in detail, to ensure that making a reference is the right choice for the specific case.

Introduction
The aim of this report is to explain the preliminary reference procedure, under Article 267 TFEU, and how it relates to UK legislation, to discuss its guidelines, present potential criticism on the matter and provide some recommendations on dealing with preliminary references.
Preliminary References
Preliminary references are used on matters concerning EU legislation such as:
1. The interpretation of the Treaties ;
2. The validity of EU measures, bodies, offices or agencies of the Union .
These can either be discretionary or mandatory . The function of the preliminary reference procedure is to make sure the interpretation and validity of the EU law is the same across all member states.
Who can make a reference?
Any court or tribunal can make a reference on EU legislation to the ECJ.
In order to determine the meaning of a court or tribunal, the bodies must :
• Be established by law;
• Be permanent;
• Have mandatory jurisdiction;
• Apply inter partes procedure;
• Apply rules of law;
• Be independent.

Procedures
When making a reference there are certain procedures that can be followed, namely:
• The standard procedure, as set out in the Rules of Procedure of the Court of Justice (OJ 2012 L265/1), Title II;
• The expedited procedure, set out in the Rules of Procedure of the Court of Justice (OJ 2012 L265/1), Title III, Articles 105-106;
• The UPP (urgent procedure), which is set out by Articles 107-114 of the Rules of Procedure of the Court of Justice (OJ 2012 L265/1), Title III.

Discretionary references
If there is judicial review available from a national court, then that court has discretion as to whether to make a reference or not. Such courts are, for example: the Magistrates Court, the High Court and the Court of Appeal .
Case Law Guidelines that the UK courts have to take into account when exercising their discretion to refer are:
If a previous ruling exists on a case which has ‘materially identical’ facts , the UK courts can decide not to make a reference.
National rules of precedent do...

Find Another Essay On UK Legislation: The Preliminary Reference Procedure Under Article 267 TFEU

Hemp Legislation And The Global Economy: (Criminal Law And Procedure)

1685 words - 7 pages the over 50,000 uses of hemp and hemp derivatives. Hemp legislation, if taken seriously by the United States federal government, will once again push the United States into the forefront of the world stage. Following the very first federal drug law in 1906, (The Food and Drugs Act), the economy of the United States has suffered needlessly; due to racially bias political ideologies, corporate greed, and government corruption. The re-introduction of

Anaylsis of the Article The Role of Custom and Traditional Leaders Under the Yap Constitution by Brian Tamaha

703 words - 3 pages In the article “The role of custom and traditional leaders under the Yap constitution”, Brian Tamaha explains the various traditions as well as the Yap legal system. The constitution of Yap consists of a common legislature (executive, judiciary) with a fourth branch dedicated solely for traditional leaders. Tradition and customs are how rules are made and how there abided by, in every legal system, there is a set or rules which direct people on

How far should the UK Licensed Retail industry be responsible for the actions of its customers? Critically discuss with reference to the social,

724 words - 3 pages the law and check their understanding before they are allowed to serve alcohol; provide the relevant company training/reference manual on the retailing of alcohol; consider formal qualifications to an appropriate standard (e.g. BII qualifications); if appropriate, training in how to deal with potential conflicts should be considered (e.g. situations arising from refusal to serve someone who is under the legal purchase age or already intoxicated).

This is a journal Article... I read the article and then made the paper.. Processing speeds of children in the 1st year of life....Psychology class.. w/ reference

573 words - 2 pages Journal Article Report:Processing Speed in the 1st Year of LifeBackgroundIn earlier studies it has been suggested that individual differences in processing speed hasits roots in infancy. Also in those studies it was suggested that preterm infants were significantlyslower with processing and memory skills than full-term infants. The study that was done in thispaper was to prove whether or not infants of preterm and full-term pregnancies had any

An article citing the reasons the line "under god" should be removed from the pledge of allegiance

571 words - 2 pages ...One Nation, Uh, Indivisible...Two words in the Pledge of Allegiance - "under god" - have sparked a firestorm from the schools of California to the halls of the Supreme Court, which will decide next June about the legality of the phrase. In a diverse country with a great variety of religious faiths running the gamut from devoted believers to atheists, issues of government and religion are a touchy subject. However, it is clear that the phrase

With reference to the evolution of policing discuss the concept, theories and practise of policing in the UK today and the challenges that the pol

1095 words - 5 pages the community assume formal responsibility for protection and social control. Styles Legalistic style – emphasis on law enforcement function of policing Watchmen style – emphasis on maintaining order in the community Service style – emphasis on delivering service to the community. There are 3 main policing styles in the UK, the first being legalistic style. The legalistic style focuses more on the law enforcement, arresting and detaining

EUROPEAN UNION LAW

1702 words - 7 pages being completely dismissed. Articles 263 and 267 of the TFEU can be used to solve the problems Albus and Bellatrix are facing. Under the law of Article 263, there is a chance for the validity of EU legislation to be examined . To go more into detail, in Article 267 (1)(b), opportunity is provided for the validity of acts by EU institutions to be evaluated through a preliminary ruling by the Court of Justice for the European Union. Regulation 2014

Potential Actions for Annulment Concerning Best Beers Ltd. Import

843 words - 4 pages litres for import. However, since the locus standi of Best Beer Ltd. is that of a non – privileged applicant, there is a difficulty bringing the case before the General Court. It would be better to go before a national court, and then get the United Kingdom, as a Member State, who is a privileged applicant, and working under the EU decision, the national court can grant preliminary referencing, the function of this is to ensure even interpretation and validity of EU law across all the Member States and is found in Article 267 TFEU. Yours Sincerely, Milica Milicevic

EU Law and Legal Aspects

1211 words - 5 pages . Article 165 (1) TFEU was also brought in which stated that education in the European Union needs to be developed and supported through all the Member States and that mobility among students is also encouraged. The judgment in this case was that Article 20 and 21 TFEU need to be interpreted as meaning that the national legislation of Germany, regarding the three year residence prior to starting an education in another Member State, is in

Lisbon Treaty

2224 words - 9 pages used on the level of the Treaty in extremely restricted connections just, not all of which concern common law (e.g. Lawful cooperation in civil matters under Article. 81 TFEU and civil assurance under Article. 196 TFEU). The level of secondary law, a significant part of the secondary legislation customarily concerns the legitimate relationship between private people. Further, there are intriguing undertakings in the field of civil law, for

EU Law

1490 words - 6 pages , Alec is also an EU citizen . Article 21(1) and Article 45 TFEU guarantees the rights of EU citizens and their families to move freely and reside within the territory of other Member States provided that they are engaged in the internal market economic activity or are financially self-sufficient . As such, he is entitled to move to Bulgaria to work as a plumber. The meaning and scope of the word ‘worker’ is not defined in any EU legislation , but is

Similar Essays

Discussing Whether The Spanish Medical Council Should Refer Maria's Case For Preliminary Ruling Under Article 234

1820 words - 7 pages to article 234(3) EC Treaty, a court is under the obligation to refer where a question relating to the interpretation or validity of Community law is raised in a case pending before a court or tribunal of a member-state against whose decisions there is no judicial remedy. Therefore it clear that the tribunal should in fact make a reference for preliminary ruling as it is vital such as in the case of Case 6/64, Costa/ENEL where it Cleary shows that

History Of Education Legislation In The Uk

1170 words - 5 pages One of the first pieces of education-related legislation goes back as far as 1870, when Free State education was introduced. Although school attendance wasn’t compulsory, it did offer children from less privileged backgrounds the opportunity to attend school for free. This is clearly an education policy reducing social class inequality, as it is allowing those having no money being allowed to attend school without having to pay. A second

To What Extent Have Changes In Legislation Achieved Equality In The Labor Market? With Reference To 'gender'?

2327 words - 9 pages To what extent have changes in legislation achieved equality in the labour market? With reference to 'gender'?In this essay I will be examining the concept of equal opportunities in relation to the diverse work force in Britain. This essay will develop a comprehension and recognition of the anti- discriminatory legislations, the implementation of this and the effectiveness of it within the labour market: it will also principally concentrate on

Article Review Of The Role Of Custom And Traditional Leaders Under The Yap Constitution

1443 words - 6 pages In the article, “The role of custom and traditional leaders under the Yap constitution”, Brian Tamaha explains the various traditions as well as the Yap legal system. The constitution of Yap consists of a common legislature—executive and judiciary—with a fourth branch dedicated solely for traditional leaders. Traditions and customs create rules and the methods they are abided by. According to Hart, every legal system has a set of rules directing