This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The United Nations Security Council Is In Need Of Reform

1967 words - 8 pages

The United Nations Security Council is in desperate need of reform because of the current dysfunction which surrounds it. Any suggestion of reform could be idealistic. To not enlarge the Security Council is an option too. Over the years, proposals on the reform of the Security Council have included the enlargement of the Security Council, changes to the categories or proportions of membership of the Security Council, the addition of Regional Representatives and changes to the relationship between the Security Council and the General Assembly. Another option for veto reform is to abolish the veto over resolutions concerning genocide and other crimes against humanity. Various international relations perspectives, including Idealists, Liberals, Marxists and Realists, align with each of these proposals. The best hope for the future lies in the expansion of Security Council members and possibly some control over the exercise of veto power by Security Council members.
It may be argued that any suggestion for reformation of the United Nations Security Council is by definition idealistic. The charter of the United Nations way shaped by the major victors in the Second World War and, not surprisingly, was shipped in their national interests. Any resolution that would effectively reduce the power of the resulting five permanent members of the Security Council - “China, France, Russian Federation, the United Kingdom and the United States” (United Nations Security Counsel, “Members of the United Nations Security Counsel.” Unknown.), often referred to as the “P5”, would likely be opposed by them since it would reduce their power. And it would be effectively opposed, since they have the power to veto any such resolution. Similarly, any resolution that could have the effect of increasing the powers of the P5 would be opposed by the General Assembly, although no realistic reformation suggestions involve changes of this nature. Reforming the UN Security Council is idealistic.
To remain the status quo and not enlarge the Security Council is a consideration. The current Security Council consists of the P5 plus ten non-permanent members (increased from six non-permanent members in 1965, the only successful reform of the Security Council to date). This could be considered a Marxist perspective, since the Marxist view is that politics and economics are affiliated with each other and that politics controls the production system, with the Security Council in this case being considered the production system. Further, the Marxist ideal is “a stateless and classless society”. (Oxford University Press. “Introduction to Politics” Brief Second Edition. Textbook. 2014.) Therefore, a Marxist might argue for no expansion of the Security Council since, by adding additional permanent seat holders to the P5 it would cause a larger production system. To not enlarge the Security Council is an option.
A real possibility is to enlarge the Security Council. Recent proposals for...

Find Another Essay On The United Nations Security Council is in Need of Reform

United Nations Human Development Report and the Need for International Democratization

1801 words - 7 pages United Nations Human Development Report and the Need for International Democratization The 2002 United Nations Human Development Report (UNHDR) is the result of many years’ study of international human progress and development. As declared in the first page of the report, "[This report] is about how political power and institutions, formal and informal, national and international, shape human progress". This statement outlines the principal

United Nations Arms Treaty Impacts to Americas Homeland Security

1614 words - 7 pages threat to U.S. foreign and domestic policy to criticize the United States (: ▪ On October 3, 2013, Vann Van Diepen, principal deputy assistant secretary in the Bureau of International Security and Nonproliferation in the U.S. State Department, argued that it is incumbent upon treaty signatories to take measures not specifically required by the treaty in order to “help achieve its ideals.” Although, Van Diepen stated this argument did not apply to

The Insanity Defence, in Need of Reform?

1869 words - 7 pages current law, there is still need for reform. Removing the common law insanity defence and creating a statutory defence with set criteria would eliminate questions of when, and in which courts the defence can be relied upon. Furthermore, the reformed law should reflect current medical understanding, not placing those with ailments such as diabetes in the same group as those with actual mental disorders. This creates uncertainty and in some

Role of the United Nations

1963 words - 8 pages not accomplished, but still the UN continues to hold its members to its standards in whatever way possible. A very common criticism of the UN is that it disproportionately represents the top five global powers, the permanent members of the security council, because each state has the ability to veto any resolution that isn't advantageous to their state. This argument, however, leaves out two important points. First, even a biased resolution is

About role of the United Nations in the changing World

3994 words - 16 pages Washington from paying its authorized share of the costs of any such operation. U.S. influence is greatest in the Security Council, but some organs of the UN, such as the General Assembly or bodies dealing with economic and social issues have had a Third World majority ever since the era of decolonization. Accordingly, U.S. policy has been to undermine and marginalize the UN. The United Nations should have an important role in world affairs, but U.S

Comprehensive Immigration Reform is Necessary in the United States

1014 words - 4 pages thought of that being me or one of you. So in recognizing the immediate need of a wise and comprehensive plan to combat the growing number of illegal immigrants entering the nation through the southern border, it is imperative that the United States implement a comprehensive plan for Immigration reform. My fellow American youth I come to you today with hopes of raising your awareness on the major issue of national security because our government is

Reform in the United States

921 words - 4 pages 4 million young Americans. The Works Progress Administration, heralded as the largest work relief program in history, employed over 8 million Americans. These social reform initiatives changed the way that and the number of Americans that worked, and helped those who could not. The reform initiative that had the most change to society and the most lasting is the Social Security Act. This is because of the nature of the act, how it was completely

Should Veto Power be Abolished in the U.N. Security Council?

2532 words - 10 pages law, states that it is a country’s job to protect their citizens from mass atrocities, however, if the nation fails to do that, it becomes the international community’s responsibility (White 545,547). Recent events have, unfortunately, caused some to question whether the U.N. is fulfilling its purpose, and all because of one reason: the five veto powers present in Security Council (Reuters Para. 12). Currently the nations of the United

UN Security Council and the International Court of Justice

1396 words - 6 pages countries because of their different ideologies. The United Nations was set up at the end of the Second World War. Its founders were anxious to avoid not only another such catastrophe but also the mistakes which had led to the failure of the League of Nations . It is well settled that although the countries have vested their powers for maintenance of Peace and Security in the UN Security Council, yet it is an accepted fact that if not primary, then one

The Process of Reforming the United Nations

2410 words - 10 pages and Interdependent World. 3rd ed. Colorado: Lynne Rienner Publishers. Maley, W., 2002. Twelve theses on the impact on humanitarian intervention. Security Dialogue, 33(3), pp. 265-278. Reus-Smith, C., Hanson, M., Charlesworth, H. & Maley, W., 2004. The challenge of United Nations reform. Canberra: ANU. Rieff, D., 2002. A bed for the night: Humanitarianism in crisis. New York: Simon & Schuster. Teng, M., 2003. United Nations Security Council

The Issue of Healthcare Reform in the United States

2393 words - 10 pages in a justifiable way. Americans are well aware that our healthcare system is one of the worst when comparing outcomes to other nations (Antony & Steven, 2002). Works Cited 2012 Alliance for Health Reform. (2012). Quality of care. Retrieved from http://www.allhealth.org/sourcebookcontent.asp?CHID=66. Antony, R. K., James, K. & Victoria, D. W. (2011). Health care delivery in the United States. Puchong: Springer

Similar Essays

The Security Council Of The United Nations

2269 words - 9 pages . reform. He went on to say, "If you add another five permanent members, all of them casting vetoes, forget about anything being accomplished” (as cited in “Veto Power in the United Nations Security Council (sidebar)”, ¶3). His point is clear, and his point makes sense. When five more members are added on top of the original five, so that ten now have a veto power, nothing will get accomplished. That means on every vote, ten nations now have

United Nations Security Council Is Unsuccessful In Keeping Peace

1318 words - 5 pages United Nations Security Council Is Unsuccessful in Keeping Peace The threat of a nuclear attack on the USA has become a common topic after terrorist attacks on September 11. A lot of people have been talking about a missile defense system for the US. With the kinds of terrorist attacks being executed today, who knows what will come next. Some people worry that next time it will be a nuke knocking on Uncle Sam's door instead of a few

The Importance Of The United Nations Security Council

2118 words - 8 pages What is the importance of the UN Security Council? “The United Nations Security Council (UNSC) has primary responsibility, under the Charter, for the maintenance of international peace and security” (UNSecurity Council 2010). The end of the 1980s and the 1990s has been marked by major changes in international relations, both as practice and as an academic discipline. The collapse of the multi-polar system in the world politics, fall of the

Recommendations For United Nations Drug Legislation Reform

1745 words - 7 pages We are a network of professionals and volunteers working in the areas related to the drug production, drug use and drug policies in various countries around the world. We associate doctors, politicians, social workers, former and current law enforcement officers, human rights activists, lawyers and others whose work is akin to wide spectrum of drug problems. United Nations legislation The present global drug policy is based on three United