This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Understanding Evolutionary Misunderstanding Essay

1111 words - 4 pages

The debate among creationists and evolutionists as to the origin of modern life on Earth has pushed increasingly into the limelight over the last several years. Unfortunately, such mainstream coverage has caused many of the related issues to become skewed and misinterpreted. In the article “Five Major Misconceptions about Evolution,” Mark Isaak attempts to make clear the true nature of evolutionary theory so that, if it must be challenged, such arguments can be made on a purely factual basis rather than, as Isaak says, “against a set of misunderstandings that people are right to consider ludicrous” (“Misconceptions” Para. 1). He presents these misconceptions and his explanation of the faulty logic behind each one in five main categories: “Evolution has never been observed,” “Evolution violates the 2nd law of thermodynamics,” “There are no transitional fossils,” “The theory of evolution says that life originated, and evolution proceeds, by random chance,” and “Evolution is only a theory; it hasn't been proved” (“Misconceptions” Para. 2). In addressing each of these proposed falsehoods individually, Isaak forms an argument with few faults that is clear, precise, and effective.
Mark Isaak is not the most well-known or established author, but he has written numerous articles, mostly about creation and evolution issues, but also on subjects as different as mythology and philosophy (“Home Page”). While not explicitly claiming to be any sort of expert in this particular subject, Isaak cites reliable scientific sources like Natural History in support of his argument.
Isaak doesn't seem to have one specific intended audience. His emphasis on systematically dissolving common misconceptions points to an intended audience of creationists. However, his tone points to the contrary – he makes a few points that come off as rather condescending towards creationists and therefore may appeal more as reassurance to people who already believe in evolution. Either way, Isaak does retain some credibility by remaining humble, as demonstrated by a web link to a creationist rebuttal to his own article. This shows that his intent is not to “fight fire with fire” by ignoring the opposing viewpoint, but to keep the debate civil and mature.
As such, unbiased knowledge-seeking individuals will not be disappointed by this article; its main purpose is to inform, even though it may appear to persuade in a rather dogmatic fashion at times. Like his tone, Isaak's purpose may be up for interpretation depending on the reader's point of view. Evolutionists may see it as information in the form of “ammunition” for a debate. Creationists could interpret it as more persuasive, but probably not an all-out catalyst for conflict, since the author expertly avoids potential opportunities to demean creationist-specific beliefs.
One notable negative aspect of the argument is Isaak's use of generalizations. He refers to creationists as a whole rather than attributing certain claims...

Find Another Essay On Understanding Evolutionary Misunderstanding

Planning methodologies for IT projects Essay

1768 words - 7 pages software/system developments as software evolves as the process progresses. Hence, the customers and project team can easier identify risks at each evolutionary level. The spiral model provides a useful tool for risk assessment that earlier models lack. However, it demands considerable risk management expertise and it can be difficult to convince the customers that the evolutionary approach is controllable.Hard ParadigmsTwo of the hard paradigms

Methodological individualism Essay

1065 words - 5 pages which “operated... through group selection.” The core of the theory of incompatibility is that an explanation of cultural evolution in terms of group-selection is inconsistent with the concept of 'individualism' (Vanberg, 1994). However, the argument made by Hayek is a misunderstanding of methodological individualism, which references to societal and systematic concepts of groups and group-advantages and does not presuppose the hypostatization of

Barriers to Intercultural Communication

1705 words - 7 pages In the contemporary global economy which can be categorized as dynamic and evolutionary in nature, one needs to be cognizant of change that is inevitable within the tourism industry. Due to the demands of the global customer the world can be viewed as being more so inter-connected, owing to this fact the traditional workplace has become more diverse. With diversity in mind the barriers to communication have become prevalent. Within the ambit of

Business Body Language

7011 words - 28 pages (1903-89) was a founding figure in ethology. Desmond Morris, author of The Naked Ape, discussed below, is an ethologist, as is the evolutionary biologist Richard Dawkins (b. 1941) a leading modern thinker in the field. Ethology, like psychology, is an over-arching science which continues to clarify the understanding of body language. The popular and accessible study of body language as we know it today is very recent. In his popular 1971 book

The Evolution of Ethics

2894 words - 12 pages multinational corporation. Rule systems evolve along the lines of an efficiency algorithm that effectively organizes the prevailing state of affairs in small increments of change over long periods of social time. In the beginning of the formation of social systems, rules may not have been as refined as they are today. But rules necessarily existed from the beginning simply to keep volatile passions, immaturity, ignorance, and misunderstanding from

Reflecting on the Statement: The Psychopath is Not Mentally Ill, He is Evil

2393 words - 10 pages Within this essay I will reflect upon the statement “The psychopath is not mentally ill; he is evil. “by corresponding this with my understanding of mental illnesses and its repercussions. Secondly I will reflect upon understanding of Evil by applying the Christian values I witness when I was little , and secondly the philosophical thought of Thomas Hobbes in comparison to psychopaths The first half of statement “The psychopath is not mentally

Latitudinal Gradient of Species Diversity

2015 words - 8 pages soils of and research occurring in Latin America. Tropical Soils In the past, tropical soils have been over-simplified and misunderstood (Sanchez, 1976), and this situation plagued soil science at least until the late seventies (Van Wambeke and Dudal, 1978). Sanchez (1976) attributes this misunderstanding of tropical soils to the fact that when temperate region-trained soil scientists first went to the tropics, attention was naturally

Finding Truth in Constructivist Psychotherapy

2050 words - 8 pages antirealistic, but rather it is Held who holds this belief. It seems that in making this statement, Held contradicts herself by allowing her own terminology to invade the viewpoints of others. It seems that misunderstanding and misjudgement are at the center of the controversy between traditional cognitive approaches and constructivist approaches to psychotherapy. There must be a more clear understanding of what it means to construct subjective

Compare and Contrast Brick-and-Mortar Versus Virtual Organizations

1793 words - 7 pages adaptive change systems to learn new organizational practices that will enable organizations to adapt and improve making them competitive in the evolutionary marketplace of modern society. Organizations that have enough organizational flexibility to successfully implement and incorporate strategic change into their organizational environments by implementing sustainable continuous improvement programs that have the ability to transform

Sources of Data in The Golden Bough

1949 words - 8 pages while looking at customs cross culturally and systematically analyzing hundreds of cultural references in separate regions and areas, in order to find a commonality to religious practices that strectched through time and geography. Although Frazer presents a comparative and evolutionary model of the development of magic and religion in primitive cultures he however did not initially travel the world to search for the materials but relied much on the

Sources of Data in The Golden Bough

1949 words - 8 pages while looking at customs cross culturally and systematically analyzing hundreds of cultural references in separate regions and areas, in order to find a commonality to religious practices that strectched through time and geography. Although Frazer presents a comparative and evolutionary model of the development of magic and religion in primitive cultures he however did not initially travel the world to search for the materials but relied much on the

Similar Essays

Turmoil Of The Middle East, Would It Led To Democracy?

1347 words - 6 pages alternatives theories , which are based on a more realistic understanding of how change happens in reality. So what if history is not cyclical and slow-moving but sometimes arrhythmic almost constant , but also capable of accelerating suddenly , like a sports car ? What if collapse does not arrive over a number of centuries but comes suddenly , like a thief in the night? We can say that the great powers and empires can be described as complex

Epistemology Are Science And Religion In Conflict?

1949 words - 8 pages and faith.” (Merriam-Webster, 2012) The key to the definition of religion is faith which is: believing in something that may or may not have tangible proof of existence. Religious leaders insist that without faith we do not have anything. Science is defined as: “the state of knowing: knowledge as distinguished from ignorance or misunderstanding.” (Merriam-Webster, 2012) The conflict between science and religion is clear, it is simply the “state

An Being An Theist Essay

1572 words - 7 pages , creates a better understanding of God and how He works. (Evans & Manis, 2009, p. Loc: 835) McCloskey claims that the presence of imperfection and evil in the world argues against “the perfection of the divine design or divine purpose in the world.” (1968, p. 52) However, this shows McCloskey’s misunderstanding of the conclusions that the teleological and cosmological arguments come to. All that the two arguments claim to show is that there was an

On Being A Theist Essay

1973 words - 8 pages his opinion, the weakest arguments for theism, such as the cosmological argument, teleological argument, and the problem of evil. In the end, McCloskey asserts that atheism is more comforting than theism. Through the course of the article, McCloskey brings up constructive points of theism, however at the same time shows his misunderstanding of theism. Therefore, McCloskey acts as a “devil’s advocate” of theism, ultimately helping to strengthen the