This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Special Needs Cases Essay

1980 words - 8 pages

Special needs litigation is one of the most common legal issue dealt with in educational circles. IDEA (Individuals with Disabilities Act) does not define “appropriate” which leaves the interpretation of an adequate level of educational services and responsibilities open to a great deal of subjectivity. This analysis provides a brief summary of special needs cases and the implications for school systems and educational administrators.
In Cedar Rapids Community School District vs. Garrett F., the parents of a mentally coherent but wheelchair and ventilator bound student wanted the school district to provide nursing services for their child so he could attend school. The US Supreme Court decided that it was the school’s responsibility to provide this student with continuous nursing supervision while he was at school. The court stated that the nursing service was a supportive service necessary for the education of the child.
Shannon Carter’s parents appealed to Florence County School District Four to appropriately assist their learning disabled daughter for years. The Carters continued to watch their average intelligence daughter lag behind in the public school setting and decided to enroll her in a private school that specializes in teaching learning disabled students. The US Supreme Court ruled that the school district must compensate the Carters of the educational expenses they incurred because the district failed to provide appropriate services for the child.
The Felix and Gonzales cases demonstrate that if schools are not held accountable they may not even make an attempt to meet the special needs of students. The Felix probe discovered that the state was not providing funding near or even close to an adequate amount for schools to meet the requirements of IDEA. Although the Gonzales case occurs in the voluntary education arena, it highlights the struggles that individuals with disabilities incur throughout their lives and clearly points out that the definition of appropriate accommodations is highly subjective.
These cases demonstrate the challenges that are brought before educators as they attempt to provide an “appropriate” education for each child. Special needs students must be evaluated individually and their individual education plan must be designed around realistic standards. School systems and administrators walk a tight-rope between adequately meeting the needs of every student and balancing educational integrity issues with the fiscal budget. In a perfect world, there would be plenty to go around for everyone and everybody’s needs could be met to the fullest. In reality, we are left to prioritize spending as best we can. Decisions within the schools must be made as quickly as possible based upon the legal precedents set forth by case law and within the financial constraints of the school.

CEDAR RAPIDS COMMUNITY SCHOOL DIST. V.GARRET F. (96-1793) 526 U.S. 66 (1999)
106 F.3d 822, affirmed

A student named...

Find Another Essay On Special Needs Cases

Special Education Implementation For Native American Girls

1827 words - 7 pages Special Education Implementation For Native American Girls Quality education for children has been an ongoing issue for today's society. There has also been an increasing concern for the education of students with special needs. The effect of these concerns has been noted in many communities, such as the Native American community. The population of special education students in the Native American communities is not

Minority Students in Special Education Programs

1613 words - 6 pages The special education programs in the United States have been designed to help children with special needs learn easier and fit in better with the education program. Unfortunately, many minority students get caught up in the mix and don’t get the proper attention they deserve. Furthermore, minority students are seriously over-represented in the educational programs. Many minority students are misdiagnosed and put into special education

History of Special Education

1216 words - 5 pages History of Special Education The recent history of special education began in 1975 when Congress passed the Education for all Handicapped Children Act (EAHCA). The law was renamed the Individuals with Disabilities Education act (IDEA) in 1990. These laws made it mandatory for schools to meet the special needs of all students. Special education was around prior to 1975, but in most cases in a very different manner than it is today. Special

Minorities and Special Education

2097 words - 8 pages Disproportionate identification of minority students in special education is a major concern in schools today. This paper describes the issues in the assessment process with minority students and how we have arrived at a situation where minorities are being misdiagnosed into special education programs. Additionally, several legal cases are mentioned which show numerous actions and rulings that have tried to correct the disproportionate

Role Stress Has On a Family With A Child With Autism

2008 words - 8 pages children grow up and become independent depending on the care given to them as they grow up. However, some cases are life long extending to the parents’ death. Families should work on taking care of their children with special needs by training them how to become independent in adulthood, other than neglecting them. Astonishingly, little is acknowledged about the ripple effects of a child with special needs on a family. Population based

Special Education: Getting Rid of the Stigma

891 words - 4 pages Not many people who are not already involved with special education understand what exactly a student in a special education program does. Most people assume special education is for only the worst cases, such as autism or Down syndrome or that the students are completely different from any other student. However, this assumption is not the case. These assumptions only show some of the stigma against special education. Special education is the

Mainstreaming and Inclusion of Exceptional Children?

2204 words - 9 pages , these programs also give students the opportunity to participate in several regular classes throughout the school day. Inclusion methods are also used to incorporate students into the regular classroom, but tend to do so on a full time basis. Like all students special needs children progress at various levels. By evaluating children through the IEP process, students gain the opportunity to receive the best education possible. In many cases

Special Ed. Scenario

1156 words - 5 pages Running head: SPECIAL ECUATION SCENARIO 1[Type text] [Type text] [Type text]SPCECIAL EDUCATION SCENARIO 7Special Education Scenario9/9/13Five QuestionsHow does the school identify children with special needs? What is the referral process? Is it best-practices based?Rationale: I would ask this question because of the concern for minority students being placed inappropriately.Type of data needed: Documentation of the referral/testing process.Data

Special Education Placement in Public Schools

1795 words - 7 pages the mainstream of school life with higher-achieving peers, but may not be able to provide the intensive help some students need” (Mauro, 2011). Resource Rooms are where students with special needs have the opportunity to work with special education teachers in small groups. These resource rooms do provide assistance to the special needs population, but in most cases lack structure. “Resource Room placements have the benefit of providing help

Ferguson v. Charleston, S.C

678 words - 3 pages enforcement (Dubin, 1999, pg.280). This finding of the Court distinguished Ferguson from previous cases because MUSC turned the results of the tests over to police without the patient’s knowledge or consent (Dubin, 1999, pg.279). If MUSC had not done this, then the Supreme Court would have ruled the tests to be of special needs. The use of law enforcement to force the patients into substance abuse treatment, changed the purpose of the tests from

The Importance of Education for Children with Disability

1547 words - 7 pages identified disability attended public schools. Unfortunately, of the three million special needs children who attended school, many received little or no effective instruction. After IDEA, the number of such children in public schools grew by 100 percent, a proof that the effort of the government has paid off. The special education system has not only given students with disability an opportunity to obtain public education but also formulated an

Similar Essays

Disabilities Essay

671 words - 3 pages individuals who differ from societal standards of normalcy. For that very reason, many children require individualized educational plans to meet their needs. Despite the progress made with the enactment of IDEA, many problems remain, in some cases, students are inappropriately and erroneously qualified for special education services. The aforementioned usually results in disproportionate percentage of group membership in special education. This is

Compares/Contrasts Continuum Of Services And Inclusion For Educating Students With Special Needs In A General Education System (About 4 Pages)

1320 words - 5 pages services approach, on the other hand, point out that even those jurisdictions committed to an inclusive approach have had to arrange for special settings for some exceptional students. They argue that total integration is unrealistic and, also, in some cases more harmful to the student than segregated placement. These advocates for a continuum of settings point out that this approach is more educationally effective for meeting the needs of all students.

Special Education Essay

1219 words - 5 pages The goal of special education is to provide all students with and equal education. (Edwards, "Special Education") In 1997 Congress revised the Individuals with Disabilities Act to ensure that all students with a disability are given equal access to education. (Edwards, "Special Education") School districts must provide all children with disabilities a "free education" that meets their individual needs. (Edwards, "Special Education") "Special

Should Special Education Students Be Accepted To Learn In Mainstream Classrooms?

858 words - 3 pages is trying to tell all parents with special education students, that their child will get the correct education they need rather then being in a regular equipped classroom. Another interesting article states "Those who believe that separate classrooms are better for children with special needs feel that they cause a distraction to the other kids, and in some cases, prohibit the teacher from doing their job (Analysis mainstreaming)." From this