Unraveling The Issues Of Compensated Organ Donations

2067 words - 8 pages

Compensated organ donations – one of the most controversial issues we have today. The scarcity of organ donations in America is the main reason there is a sudden diversion of possible source of organs. Beginning with donations of organs from cadaver to living donors, different strategies sprung just to reduce the said shortage; as a result of this quest, sale and paid organs is one of the approaches that gathered too much attention from the public. The controversy of paid organ donations entered the limelight when the state of Wisconsin offered incentives to the living donors. This law, which was created in the year 2004, grants tax deduction and repayment of donation expenses such as travel cost and lost earnings. Historically, neither property right to human corpse nor license to remove and transfer the organs of a cadaver is evident in the universal law. Hence, when transplants became possible, there were no legal systems that would allow individuals to donate their organs upon death for the purpose of transplants. To resolve this problem, UAGA or Uniform Anatomical Gift Act was publicized in the year 1968. This act grants individual the right to choose before death whether their organs will be donated or offered for transplants. In case, the individual can no longer decide because of his condition, the relatives have to right to decide for him. UAGA openly deals with organ donations but it is silent with the issue of sales and compensated organs. Buying and selling of organs remained unclear after the National Organ Transplant Act (NOTA) was approved in 1984. It improves the system of voluntary organ donation and prohibits the commercial markets of organs by turning it into a federal crime. Experts say that the act of buying and selling transplantable organs is morally wrong. There are socioeconomic disadvantages associated with this action. Moreover, it also violates human dignity because it treats the organs and human body parts as commodities. Not to mention the fact that such action weakens and demoted altruism. However, the real picture of compensated organ donations is actually the opposite of “unethical and self-interest”; it promotes life and therefore regarded as a good and moral deed.

Organ Donation’s Supply and Demand
Knowing the rate of supply and demand of organ donation helps in establishing a clear background about the issue. For instance, Monti (2009) explained the reality of supply and demand of kidneys. The supply of this organ coming from deceased and altruistic donors are not enough to support the demand of those individuals who are in need. Approximately there are 73,000 people who wait for kidney donations and 18 of those who are in the wait list will die by tomorrow. Accordingly, the list is being added by 6,000 individuals every year. An individual has to wait for five years before he/she can get an organ donation. The facts and figures presented by Monti shows that there is a big gap between the...

Find Another Essay On Unraveling the Issues of Compensated Organ Donations

The Solution to the Problem of Teenagers Compensated Dating

1115 words - 4 pages Have you ever heard the word ‘Enjo Kosai’? It means compensated dating, which is defined as men give money or luxury to attract women for companionship, some especially for sex. In 2008, an appalling new shocks all the Hong Kong people. Wong Ka-mui, a secondary student who did compensated dating, was killed and dismembered (Lo, 2008). This tragedy raised the concern of public to teenagers compensated dating, and citizens started to comprehend

The Importance of Organ Donation Essay

1721 words - 7 pages The Importance of Organ Donation      Each day approximately 6,300 people die and what makes this haunting is that presently there are 83,513 people waiting for organs to be donated, yet each day 17 people die because they do not receive a transplant (http://www.donatelife.net/facts_stats.html). These statistics show that people who are waiting for organ transplants have a good chance at being saved and get what they need. The sad truth is

Ethics and the Commercialization of Organ Transplants

1084 words - 4 pages commercialization of organ transplant can be considered ethical. Seeing the wide gap that exists between the availability and the need of organs for transplant, it really seems essential to facilitate sales of organs to meet the demand and to save lives. Consented organ donations till now in our society have remained limited and not all people agree to it. Seeing the demand for cadaveric organs for transplantation, it does not appear possible that the

Organ Donation : The Gift of Life

1335 words - 5 pages think for one minute of not giving an organ if it proved to prevent their child from dying, and who should stop them? Another myth stemming from this is that; organ donations are not successful so why bother doing them. This statement and belief is false, according to the CPA directory they stated that, ?More than 19,000 organ transplants are performed in the United States every year. Transplants have become a successful form of treatment for end

The process of organ and blood donation

2519 words - 11 pages donation, and blood donations; patients are put on a waiting list. A new person is added to the list every 10 minutes. The factors of being the next one to have a transplant range from how severe the patient is, and how long they’ve been on the waiting list down to their blood type. Up to 1,000,000 people need lifesaving and improving tissues each year, you’re never to old to donate! Some people think that if they become an organ donator they won’t

The Process of Organ and Blood Donation

2624 words - 10 pages ), are active with intravenous (IV) drugs, or are a male that has been in prison in the past six months. When it comes to organ and blood donations, patients are put on a waiting list. A new person is added to the list every ten minutes. (Unknown) The factors of being the next one to have a transplant range from how severe the patient is, and how long they have been on the waiting list, down to their blood type. Up to 1,000,000 people need

Early History of the Pipe Organ

1588 words - 6 pages wind-chest to store and distribute it, keys and valves to admit wind to the pipes, and one or more graded sets of fixed-pitch pipes." (Randel 583) These early organs used water as a means to supply air-pressure, hence the use of the terms hydraulic and hydraulis.Hydraulic organs were in use for several hundred years before the concept of bellows, similar in concept and style to those of a blacksmith, came into use with the organ. Numerous

How to Save a Life: The History of Organ Transplantation

1739 words - 7 pages Check yes or no if you would like to become an organ donor, as a fifteen and a half year old about to receive ones learners permit this is one of the main question they must answer. At this young age does one accurately know what they are signing up for? For most fifteen year olds the answer is not, they are most likely unaware of the entire organ transplantation process. They simply look at this question and answer yes or no, but in reality


753 words - 4 pages Organ transplantation is apperceived as one of the most prehending achievements for preserving life in medical history. This procedure provides a means of giving life to patience’s who suffer from terminal organ failure, which requires the participation of individuals; living or deceased, to donate their organs for the more preponderant good of society. The question arises whether a person’s claim to determine what transpires to their bodies

What If It Was You: The Ethics of Organ Sales

724 words - 3 pages Allie Lowery Mrs. Eimiller English 12 22 March 2014 What If It Was You There are many different opinions regarding selling of organs. Although some people believe selling of the organs should be allowed a lot of people don’t think it is a good idea. I think it is a good idea and will help save people's live. The selling of organs should be allowed in order to save people who will die without a organ transplant. People

The Definition of Death: An Ethical Issue in Organ Donation

644 words - 3 pages According to The President’s Council on Bioethics, a group of individuals appointed by President George W. Bush to advise his administration on ethical issues related to advances in biomedical science and technology, the need for criteria to define death became important after the invention of the mechanical ventilator, an artificial support for patients who cannot breathe on their own due to injury or infirmity ( The President’s Council 2

Similar Essays

The Importance Of Organ Donations Essay

671 words - 3 pages Organ donation is very generous of people to do. When people die they have a choice of whether to give their organs up or not. The organs in your body are your stomach, pancreas, liver, kidney, and small intestine. Some people get their mouths swabbed so someday they can give their organs. When your body gets a new organ the body tries to attack it so that means you would take medication. The organs come from people with brain injuries so

The Importance Of Promoting Organ Donations

1211 words - 5 pages recipient that is severely ill or in need of a transplant (What Can Be Donated, 1999). Generally, the reality is countless of people are dying each year because they are placed on a waiting list to receive an organ transplant which usually never reaches the person in time due to organ shortages. Therefore, if more people got involved with organ donations there would be less of a wait time which would equal more lives being saved, and it would

The Pros And Cons Of Xenotransplantation: Organ Donations

1367 words - 5 pages Xenotransplantation The topic I would like to talk about today is called xenotransplantation. If you haven’t ever heard about xenotransplantation that’s okay, a lot of people haven’t. As you know many of the people who need organ donations need them because of new and old health issues. The worldwide demand for organs far surpasses the supply. A study done by the United Network for Organ Sharing in 2004 found that over one hundred thousand

The Global Need For Organ Donations

850 words - 4 pages an organ. (1) These new ideas seem to be pretty radical, but what is America doing to solve this issue? In the past America has implemented educational programs for the public regarding the need and benefits of organ donation, as well as pushed for a system of “rewarded gifting” for the family from a living donor to an unknown recipient. (2) Indeed these ideas sound ethical and proper, but I believe we should look into harvesting organs of