Uses Of Identity By Gltb Movement

9421 words - 38 pages

Celebration and Suppression: The Strategic Uses of Identity by the Lesbian and Gay Movement1
Mary Bernstein Arizona State University
Critics of identity politics decry the celebration of difference within identity movements, yet many activists underscore their similarities to, rather than differences from, the majority. This article develops the idea of "identity deployment" as a form of strategic collective action. Thus one can ask under what political conditions are identi- ties that celebrate or suppress differences deployed strategically. A comparison of strategies used in four lesbian and gay rights cam- paigns shows that interactions between social movement organiza- tions, state actors, and the opposition determine the types of identi- ties deployed. The author suggests the model's application to the Civil Rights and feminist movements.
[The organizers of the 1993 lesbian and gay march on Washing- ton] face a dilemma: how to put forward a set of unsettling demands for unconventional people in ways that will not make enemies of potential allies. They do so by playing down their differences before the media and the country while celebrating it in private. (Tarrow 1994, p. 10)
Sidney Tarrow's portrayal of the 1993 lesbian and gay march on Wash- ington highlights a central irony about identity politics and the decline of the Left: Critics of identity politics decry the celebration of difference
1 I thank Edwin Amenta, Ellen Benoit, Nancy Cauthen, Kelly Moore, Gilda Zwer- man, Yvonne Zylan, and the members of the New York University Politics, Power, and Protest Workshop for comments on earlier drafts of this paper, as well as the AJS reviewers for helpful suggestions. I greatly benefited from both discussions with and comments from David Greenberg and Francesca Polletta. I would also like to thank Elizabeth Franqui for her crucial assistance on this paper. This research was supported by a National Science Foundation Dissertation grant (9623937) and by a New York University June Frier Esserman Dissertation Fellowship. Direct correspon- dence to Mary Bernstein, School of Justice Studies, Arizona State University, P.O. Box 870403, Tempe, Arizona 85287-0403.
 1997 by The University of Chicago. All rights reserved. 0002-9602/98/10303-0001$02.50
AJS Volume 103 Number 3 (November 1997): 531-65 531

American Journal of Sociology
within contemporary identity movements, charging them with limiting the potential for a "politics of commonality" between oppressed peoples that could have potential for radical social change (Gitlin 1995). On the other hand, the lesbian and gay movement seems largely to have aban- doned its emphasis on difference from the straight majority in favor of a moderate politics that highlights similarities to the straight majority (Seidman 1993).
Over time, "identity" movements shift their emphasis between celebrat- ing and suppressing differences from the majority. For example, the Civil Rights movement underscored...

Find Another Essay On uses of identity by gltb movement

Critical Analysis Of "Identity risis" by Minabrere Ibelema , and "Oppositional Dress"by Elisabeth Wilson

707 words - 3 pages In Minabrere Ibelema's essay 'Identity Crisis', Ibelemasuggests that the mainstream american culture is so powerful thatall cultures conform to it. Ibelema does this by showing how themass media portrays African Americans in relation to theircultural identity by using situation comedies as a measuringtool. Of the episodes Ibelema uses very few of them look atAfrican Americans cultural identity. However, what they do isbriefly address a cultural

Thoroughly Post-Modern: Defining My Practice of Photography by Defining an Art Movement

3308 words - 13 pages Thoroughly Post-Modern: Defining My Practice by Defining an Art Movement As a young artist, recognising and being aware of your own photographic practice is extremely important; it allows you to understand the ways in which your work fits into the wider context of Art and the way in which your work functions to mean. I have been studying and practicing photography since I was sixteen years old, but it wasn’t until my university study

The Naturalist Movement: The Monster, and The Red Badge of Courage by Stephen Crane

3668 words - 15 pages made the people reflect on their beliefs and standards. When these two novels are compared in the use of irony a key difference arises. In The Red Badge, irony is used to give the outside world’s perspective on the role of the soldiers while The Monster uses irony to make a remark about society. The latter takes the idea of an uncaring world a step farther by making the world hostile to the hero of the fire while The Red Badge only has a world

Use of TV by Martin Luther King and Malcolm X During the Civil Rights Movement

2044 words - 8 pages why he was doing wrong. The reactions of people after that is one of the most enduring images of the Civil Rights Movement is that of Birmingham firemen and policemen using water hoses and police dogs against African-American demonstrators in 1963 Birmingham. The episode came during the first week of May, following a month of peaceful demonstrations by Birmingham's African-American community against the arrest and the

Accounts of the civil rights Movement: This essay is an account of the civil rights movement as told by African Americans living in the US at that time

780 words - 3 pages understand how we got to the point that we atnow. Our ancestors shaped not only American society but global society. One of these life-changing events was the civil rights movement. African American's lives were forever changedby several courageous and heroic actions. The importance of these actions are preserved throughmovies, books, and physical evidence. The most important aspect of preserving these memoriesis speaking to the people who lived through

The concept of Identity in "About A Boy" by Nick Hornby

913 words - 4 pages Identity, as Oxford Dictionary defines, is simply who someone is. This definition opens up the concept of identity to many interpretations, an example of which is shown through the novel, "About A Boy" by Nick Hornby. The novel is essentially about a man and a boy helping each other find their own identities. Will, is a 36 year old man who is unwilling to settle down in life, while Marcus is a 12 year old boy who spends the day stressing about

The theme of identity as developed within the novel "The Woman Warrior" by Maxime Hong Kingston

1220 words - 5 pages find her identity, the narrator has to start by sorting out the truths from the lies in the Chinese culture presented through these stories. She questions the stories that her mother tells, whether they are "true stories,.. or just a story,.. [she] can't tell the difference" (202). For example, when the narrator first starts menstruating, her mother uses her father's unspoken sister, the "No Name" aunt as an example to warn her of the dangers of

Concept of identity explored in ' when i was growing up' by Nellie wong

780 words - 3 pages ?'When I was growing up' and 'Preludes' by T. S Eliot share a similar connection in terms of identity. The impact of society on the individual in 'When I Was Growing up' is similar to how society caused the people in Preludes to lose their identity. In 'Preludes', patterns of imagery appear throughout, especially in the first part, where people's lives are controlled by what goes on in the world around them. The images of decay and disintegration

Representations of cultural identity influenced by historical conditions in Brian Friels Translations.

1422 words - 6 pages With reference to Translations discuss how the representations of a cultural identity are influenced by the historical conditions in which they are produced.Brian Friel is an Irish playwright and a founding member of the Field Day Theatre Company. Friel's plays most often centre around colonial relations between Ireland and Britain, and although his plays are of significant artistic value, it is Friel's approach to dealing with the volatile

Symbolism and Loss of Identity in The Handmaid's Tale by Margaret Atwood

932 words - 4 pages Symbolism and Loss of Identity in The Handmaid's Tale by Margaret Atwood In Margaret Atwood's The Handmaid's Tale, Offred recounts the story of her life and that of others in Gilead, but she does not do so alone. The symbolic meanings found in the dress code of the women, the names/titles of characters, the absence of the mirror, and the smell and hunger imagery aid her in telling of the repugnant conditions in the Republic of Gilead. The

The concept of identity in the poem 'Mirror' by Slvia Plath

553 words - 2 pages The poem “Mirror” by Sylvia Plath explores many concepts, including self-discovery and identity. The mirror lives within the poet and is personified to speak its thoughts and understanding of the world around it. “I’ am…exact. I have no preconceptions”. This truthful mirroring is devastating to the woman when she honestly confronts her image. Only the mirror refects truth, which is her aging self, her pain. The

Similar Essays

Soil Spatial Variability Of Fluoride As Affected By Land Uses

1767 words - 7 pages fifty five topsoil samples (0- 20 cm) in a study area of 6800 km² were collected. Total fluoride and water soluble fluoride were measured. The results of this research showed that two forms of soil F were controlled by intrinsic factors such as parent material and extrinsic factors such as fertilization. The total fluoride concentration in 96% of the data was less than the globule suggested average (200 mg kg‾¹) and water soluble fluoride

The Development Of The Civil Rights Movement By Protests

1476 words - 6 pages “I have a dream”, these are some of the most famous words from a civil movement and even in any protest in the world. These words were spoken by Martin Luther King in a peaceful protest, but there were more than just peaceful protest in the Civil Rights Movement there were also violent protests in the Civil Rights Movement. One of the most violent protests of the Civil Rights Movement is now called “Bloody Sunday”. Protests had a big role in

Quest For Identity In The Life Of Galileo By Brecht

1600 words - 6 pages Quest for Identity in The Life of Galileo by Brecht Throughout the course of history, from era to era, mankind has been on a continuous attempt to perpetuate what they perceive as the truth; and in doing so, embark on a quest to find their true identity and place in life. One must realize that the common theme in all literature is the search for identity and belonging. Bertolt Brecht, author of "The Life of Galileo," effectively uses

In "The Adventures Of Huckleberry" By Finn, Mark Twain Uses Satire To Reveal Faults In Society.

626 words - 3 pages Satire censures things, people, activities, or ideas, and makes people see things that they normally wouldn't permit to exist. Often times, satire is used to relay a message between an author and his reader. In The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn, Mark Twain uses satire to reveal faults in society. The humor he includes leaves his reader laughing at him or herself, and often times responding with a "That's me" statement. By the end of the novel