Utah, California V. Secretary Of Transportation

1311 words - 5 pages

Significant facts
In 1994, Congress pass a bill, with President approval, that withheld ten percent of federal highway funds from states who fail to penalize drug offenders by suspending the drivers license for six months. A condition the federal government placed on the grants for highway funds is states’ must suspend the drivers license for any drug conviction, regardless of severity, including marijuana possession. However, states do have the ability to “opt out” by passing their own state law stating they will not suspend drivers licenses for such violations. The clause was used by Congress in the hope that states would not want to be recognized for allowing drug offenders to keep their license, but most states opted out.
Issue
Both California and Utah sued the Secretary of Transportation for the release of funds. California legislature challenged the federal law in light of the withholding of federal highway funds were not related to the suspension of drivers licenses, and the “opt out” clause was not a rational or uniform national policy. California’s legislature is arguing this requirement is to initiate debate between the governor and the state legislature. The requirement for the governor and legislature to agree or forcing the legislature majority to override a gubernatorial veto violates the state’s sovereignty basic function and specifically the absence of a uniform national policy.
Utah passes a law that suspends drug offenders drivers license for all drug violations, however, Utah has also decriminalized the possession of small amounts of marijuana and redefined offense as a misdemeanor: “burning without a permit. The Secretary of Transportation believes Utah’s motive to decriminalize and redefine the offense violates the federal requirement and is withholding the federal highway funds. Utah is now suing for the release of funds, arguing the state has complied with the federal regulation and that crimes against state law are central to the state’s sovereignty, which is not supported the South Dakota v. Dole, 483 U.S.203, (1987), doctrine. Utah has also brought to light there is an absence of federal uniform drug laws and sentencing for violations.
Question
1. Does Congress have the authority to withhold federal highway funds from states who fail to comply with suspending drug offender’s drivers license for six months, or failing to “opt out” by the state passing a law that specifically states they will not suspend drivers license for drug violations?
2. Does Congress intrude on the state sovereignty by requiring the state legislature and governor to debate about a particular federal regulation?
3. Does Utah fail to comply with the conditions placed upon the federal highway funds by decriminalizing small amounts of marijuana, then reclassifying as a misdemeanor “burning without a permit?”
Recommendation
Firstly, Congress does have the authority to withhold federal grant moneys from states’ that fail to comply with conditions...

Find Another Essay On Utah, California v. Secretary of Transportation

Knowledge Based Expert System in Transportation Engineering and Traffic Adaptive Signal Control System

1462 words - 6 pages unexpected incidents occur, by utilizing experts' knowledge accumulated in the system. Real-time KBES has studied in a similar case. Stack and Ritchie has researched real-time freeway incident management by using G2, which is an expert system shall designed for the development and execution of complex applications that require intelligent monitoring and control [7]. This system has tested in Transportation Management Center in California and have

Texas, Utah and Tennessee Tax Systems

1327 words - 6 pages taxes, it seems as property tax in Tennessee, is more favorable for its citizens comparing to Texas, even the Utah offer more incentives to its citizens, but as I mentioned before the higher cost of property tax in Texas could be due to the lack of the income tax. The building of roads and bridges to make transportation more efficient depends on the state funding, by collecting the fuel tax, toll fees, and other taxes. The gasoline tax charged by

Ewing V. California/ Andrade V. California

1565 words - 6 pages to felonies (Andrade v. California). Andrade also had prior convictions for misdemeanor theft in 1982, a federal felony transportation of marijuana offense in 1988, a state petty theft offense in 1990, and a 1991 parole violation for escape from federal prison (Andrade v. California). California law classifies residential burglary as a serious felony, making Andrade subject to California's "three strikes" law. Under the three strikes statute

The Public Opinion of the Japanese American Internment During World War Two:

1965 words - 8 pages over United States citizens. Executive Order 9066 was issued by President Franklin D. Roosevelt on February 19, 1942. This gave authority to the Secretary of War Lieutenant General DeWitt, and military commanders to evacuate any persons from designated areas for “protection against sabotage and against espionage”. Persons who outwardly opposed the evacuation were almost nonexistent, and those who did oppose were often vilified. One member of

The Japanese-American Internment in Topaz, Utah

2469 words - 10 pages ). There were ten WRA camps during WWII. Most were in remote areas in the states of Arizona, Wyoming, Utah, Arkansas, and California. The most infamous was the camp in Topaz, Utah where 8,130 Japanese were detained (Taylor 19). The move to these internment camps was a difficult journey for many of the Japanese Americans. Many of them were taken directly from their homes and allowed only to bring what they could carry

United States Involvement in World War II

1510 words - 6 pages Britain promised to aid the United States if negotiations with Japan were unsuccessful. On November 20, the Japanese opened discussions with Washington. Japan’s demands included the following: 1) The U.S. must abandon China. 2) Lift the freezing of Japanese Assets. 3) Resume full trade with Japan. 4) Help Japan get supplies from the Dutch East Indies. 5) Stop U.S. naval expansion in the western Pacific. United States Secretary of State Hull

Asian Americans: Exclusion and Segregation

1905 words - 8 pages . In fact, immigration has played a main role in the growth and development of the term Asian American. The first migrations that arrived in the United States was the Chinese. In the 1850s, many were driven by the lure of gold. “These first arrivals were free laborers who paid their own transportation to the gold fields of California. By 1852, there were about 20,000 Chinese immigrants in California. By the 1860s, approximately 16,000 Chinese

Delegation of Legislative Authority by Congress

3299 words - 13 pages Textile Manufacturers Institute v. Donovan, 452 U.S. 490, the American Textile Manufacturers Institute, et al., challenged the validity of employment standards adopted by the Secretary of Labor. In 1978, the Secretary, acting in pursuance of the Occupational Safety and Health Act of 1970, sec 3(8), established guidelines limiting the occupational exposure to "cotton dust" and set a fixed timetable for enactment of the policy. The U.S. Court of

Stretching The Commerce Clause

868 words - 3 pages State of Florida, South Carolina, Nebraska, Texas, Utah, Louisiana, Alabama, Colorado, Pennsylvania, Washington, Idaho, South Dakota, Indiana, North Dakota, Mississippi, Arizona, Nevada, Georgia, Alaska, Ohio, Kansas, Wyoming, Wisconsin, Maine, Iowa, and the National Federation Of Independent Business, Et Al.. Now that I have your attention; do you know what all these states and NFIB have in common? They are involved in a lawsuit against the

Secretary of Defense

993 words - 4 pages received his Bachelor's degree in 1971. After he received his degree he went to work for Congressman John McCollister as a staffer, and eventually became Chief of Staff to the Congressman. In 1980 he served as an organizer for the successful presidential campaign of then California Governor, Ronald Reagan. In 1981 Secretary Hagel was nominated by President Ronald Reagan to serve as Deputy Administrator of the Veterans Administration. There he helped

Legalizing Same Sex Marriage

1560 words - 7 pages define marriage in traditional terms in the face of a society that was becoming increasingly tolerant of people, images and messages that didn’t fit that traditional mold. Prop 8 passed with roughly 52% of the overall votes, significantly less support than Prop 22, however still not enough to ensure equal rights to same-sex couples (California Secretary of State). However, this increasingly sparked outrage in the LGBT community and questions on how

Similar Essays

Summary And Key Notes On The Case Of Regents Of The University Of California V. Bakke

845 words - 3 pages Regents of the University of California v. Bakke, 438 U.S. 265 (1978)Facts: Allan Bakke, a thirty-five-year-old white man, had twice applied for admission to the University of California Medical School at Davis. He was rejected both times. The school reserved sixteen places in each entering class of one hundred for "qualified" minorities, as part of the university's affirmative action program, in an effort to redress longstanding, unfair

The Massacre Of Captain John Gunnison And His Explorers In 1853

2674 words - 11 pages amount of land. Ownership of the future states of California, New Mexico, Arizona, Nevada, Utah and part of Colorado were conveyed to the U.S. The acquisition of these additional lands brought with it the difficulty of overland travel for trade and national defense. An efficient means of cross country transportation became more imperative, particularly if the U.S. wanted to hold on to the lands it had recently acquired. Although America owned the

National Parks And Air Traffic Essay

3064 words - 12 pages helicopter. About 800,000 people per year fly over the Canyon. In the peak summer periods, there are over 1,000 flights every day. 31 air companies operating out of five states (Arizona, Nevada, California, Utah, and Colorado) operate tours over the Grand Canyon. In 1995, the total air tour revenue was approximately $115.9 million. An average 30-minute helicopter flights costs $100 per person. The air tour companies argue that they provide a

The American Transcontinental Railroad Essay

4318 words - 17 pages development. The Union Pacific Railroad Company was established before the Civil War, although it was not until after, that construction began. The company planned on laying down tracks westward from Omaha, Nebraska. The Railroad’s president was William B. Ogden, whose elected provisional secretary was Henry V. Poor. The Union Pacific’s workforce consisted of former African American Slaves, and predominantly, Irish immigrant workers from the Western