Using The Power Of Both Phonics And Whole Language

3366 words - 13 pages

Whichever way you learned to read, chances are you never knew what the terms “phonics” or “whole language” meant. However, these are the terms that are at opposite ends of an on-going debate over the best way to teach children how to read. “Simply stated, supporters of the whole language approach think children's literature, writing activities, and communication activities can be used across the curriculum to teach reading; backers of phonics instruction insist that a direct, sequential mode of teaching enables students to master reading in an organized way” (Cromwell, 1997).
Critics of phonics claim that the curriculum is too boring, that the endless worksheets will turn children away from the joy that could be reading and writing. Critics of whole language, however, claim that there is too little structure and that the students will fail to properly comprehend what they are reading and spell words correctly (Curtis, 1997). At times the debate has become rather polarized, despite the fact that the methods are not necessarily dichotomous. People have often politicized the debate as well, which fails to keep the best interest of students in mind (Rothstein, 200; Strickland, 1998). Instead of choosing between a phonics based and a whole language method of teaching reading, educators should use a combination that is specifically tailored to the needs of his/her individual students. This allows the students to use their phonics knowledge within a larger whole language context, eventually instilling in children a desire to read and enabling them to read well.


Phonics is a very systematic approach to teaching reading that involves the breaking down of words into smaller parts. This process is called decoding. It focuses on letter/sound relationships and teaches children to “sound out” unfamiliar words. Children are also taught encoding, which helps them to learn to spell new words correctly by putting together the sounds/letters that they hear. Children learn, memorize, and apply rules, formulas, and patterns of reading and speech (Curtis, 1997; Wiber, 2002). This approach has also been called a “bottom-up” approach because the teachers believe that by focusing on the smaller parts and equipping children with the ability to figure out new words, meaning and comprehension will follow. The strong supporters on this side of the debate want phonics taught in an intensive and systematic manner (Strickland, 1998). These phonics supporters criticize whole language, claiming that the approach is too disorganized and phonics taught in such an incidental manner that some children will never have the right tools to learn to read well (Cromwell, 1997).

There are many advantages to using phonics. Children who learn to read by using phonics generally have better pronunciation, spelling, and word recognition. They have been given a tool that can be used over and over again while reading and writing, without having to memorize vocabulary and...

Find Another Essay On Using the Power of both Phonics and Whole Language

The Power Of Language Essay

1177 words - 5 pages The Power of Language      Of all possible human qualities, the one that wields the most power is the ability to use, understand and communicate effectively through language. A proficient use of language allows us to clearly communicate an exact idea from one person to another person or group of people. This precise science of being able to convey exactly what you want equates to the acquisition of power. An

the power of language Essay

960 words - 4 pages away from writing and into math and science” (624). She explains this is the same thing that happened to her as a child. Tan uses Pathos to explain how she can relate to Asian-American students. Teachers made her feel as though she was not worthy of the English language and she should just stick to what society thought she would be best at. Tan uses the archetype power to explain language. “The power of language--the way it can evoke an emotion

Jamaican Patois and the Power of Language in Reggae Music

4923 words - 20 pages Jamaican Patois and the Power of Language in Reggae Music Introduction Creole languages are found all over the world on every continent. When two or more languages come into contact to form a new language a Creole language is born. Some type of human "upheaval" that forces people to find a way to communicate, without using their own languages, stimulates the creation of a Creole language. In the case of Creole languages in the Caribbean

It is valuable to study both the verbal and non-verbal language of a culture

710 words - 3 pages High-tech rapidly changes our daily lives, bringing us lots of new communication modes, for example, computers, Internet, mobile phone and so on. However, verbal and non-verbal language is still the most familiar way to communicate through the evolvement of human's civilization. It is important that we study both of the verbal and non-verbal language when we try to communicate with in a culture.There is no doubt that we use the verbal language

Are Apes Capable Of Using The Language?

834 words - 3 pages Are Apes Capable Of Using The Language? Scientists have shown that such mammals as chimpanzees, gorillas, and orangutans are capable of learning and using ASL (American Sign Language) and several artificial languages like, for example, «Yerkish.» However, there is a controversy in how far that ability of great apes spans. There are two different groups of researchers, experimenting with language and apes, those who are in favor of a

language and power of literature - class - essay

1200 words - 5 pages Examiner Name: Dr. K. R. Sowmya Designation: Professor and HOD ABSTRACT I am privileged to do my project study entitled “A STUDY ON PERFORMANCE EVALUATION OF SELECTED MUTUAL FUNDS IN INDIA” at GEOJIT FINANCIAL SERVICES LTD., Chennai. Indian Financial System was rejuvenated with the introduction of multiple financial institutions, financial services and financial instruments in the post LPG era. This process has opened doors to the private

The Power of Language in Shakespeare's Othello

1187 words - 5 pages The Power of Language in Othello      In Othello, Shakespeare explores the relationship between words and events. Spoken thought, in the play, has all the power of action; speaking about an event will make that event become reality for those who hear - it will affect reality as if that event had taken place. Shakespeare demonstrates the power of words poignantly through Othello's monologues. Othello struggles with the reality that Iago

Using literature in ESL and the principles of Communicative Language Teaching

1741 words - 7 pages Using literature in ESL and the principles of Communicative Language Teaching Among the reasons Van (2009) believes studying literature in the ESL classroom is advantageous (providing meaningful contexts, a profound range of vocabulary, enhancing creativity and developing cultural awareness and critical thinking), he mentions the fact that it is in line with CLT (Communicative Language Teaching) principles. It is worth to elaborate this last

"Frankenstein" by Mary Shelley: Look at the significance of Chapter Five to the novel as a whole. Focus on the relevance and effect of writer's use of language

605 words - 2 pages merciless killings. Frankenstein accepts this offer. This shows how Frankenstein is a decent man; he will devote two years of his life to creating a hideous monster, so that people can live in peace. And nobody will be hurt by the Monster again.The writer Mary Shelley uses language in this chapter to develop atmosphere. Firstly, there is a dull scenery setting at the start of this chapter, "It was a dreary night in November." This sets a sinister and

Mysterious Power of Language

818 words - 4 pages “Broken” English, people see it as something that is limit’s people because of the incorrect grammar spoken and a burden to carry. Amy Tan thinks otherwise because it’s how she communicates with her mother and how she understands the world she lives in. Tan goes on talking about “the power of language” and goes to a point where her mother “broken” language can affect the effectiveness of what she’s trying to convey, negatively; then explain how

advantages and disadvantages of using jargons on one's language development

514 words - 3 pages . She was so strict in teaching me that I really have to follow her instructions so I will learn. I understand that it was for my own good.There was an instance where my mother left me in my Auntie's house so she can go to market. that time my auntie has something to attend to, what I did was I get out of the house and followed her without my auntie's knowledge, I was running to look for her but eventually she got out of my sight and I don't where

Similar Essays

Phonics Vs. Whole Language? Essay

2374 words - 9 pages (Washington Post, 2002, ¶7). Whole Language Defined On the other side of the reading instruction coin is whole language, an approach that “stresses that children should use language in ways that relate to their own lives and cultures” (Phonics & Whole Language, 2002, ¶5). Educators originally termed whole language the “’whole word’ method” at the same time that Thomas Gallaudet was using it to teach reading to deaf children (Anonymous, 1997, ¶2

The Power Of Language Essay

781 words - 3 pages nonetheless became an affluent writer. Language has the power to change a single person, to the whole world. Writing, what does it take? The ability to put sounds together, to make words, and to complete thoughts. It almost seems unfeasible to me that some one who cannot hear or cannot see would be able to write. For example, Helen Keller did not know the sound sounds that words made until one special lady gave her the power of language. That person

The Power Of Language Essay

912 words - 4 pages The way that we choose to speak to others is crucial for determining how they interpret messages being sent through spoken language. Even the simplest statements can effect another person either negatively or positively, depending on the words used to convey the message. Word patterns in spoken language hold power when influencing others (Adler and Proctor, 2014). Word choices in communication determine the amount of confidence (or lack thereof

The Power Of Language Essay

1066 words - 4 pages The Power of Language The unity of a nation is one of the most important factors that determine its prosperity. In this case, language has become one of the most influential driving forces in its ability to enhance communication with others. Wherever people from some country travel through another countries, they carried with them, a national identity, which is usually involved in languages. In the United States, most of people speak English