This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

V For Vendetta Vs Nineteen Eight Four

653 words - 3 pages

Many modern stories appear to parallel classic novels. While the setting may be the same, or even the initial conflict, the modern story can still present new content that differs from the novel it was inspired by. Alan Moore’s graphic novel, V for Vendetta, appears to be heavily influenced by George Orwell’s novel, Nineteen Eight-Four. Both stories, set in dystopian future Englands, have a government that controls the populace through fear and manipulation, but similarities between these two stories are superficial. V for Vendetta is different from Nineteen Eight-Four because of the stories’ atmospheres, empowerment of the protagonists, and rebirth.
The tone in both stories is initially one of hopelessness. Winston and Evey each become disillusioned with their governments, and strive to fight back after falling in with charismatic conspirators, but the results are quite dissimilar. Winston is forced to accept that he has been ineffective at every turn, and never had any real chance of affecting a change, while Evey witnesses a genuine catalyst take place, and is inspired to continue fighting. This feeling of hope is not only germinated in the story’s protagonist, the general public is moved by V’s actions. The ultimate lessons from these stories are polar opposites; in V for Vendetta there is still hope despite all efforts to crush it, but in Nineteen Eight-Four there is no hope despite all efforts to start it.
The ability to make a difference is itself a difference between these fictional worlds. Orwell’s government is a self-perpetuating machine, and the steps are already in place to ensure its continued existence no matter who is in charge or what the political climate becomes; there is no single head that can be severed from a seat of power to disable or cripple that government. Winston and Julia try to be more than just victims of their environment but ultimately fail, because one...

Find Another Essay On V for Vendetta vs Nineteen Eight-Four

V For Vendetta Essay

1561 words - 6 pages Of the many symbolic masks, the Guy Fawkes mask stands out as one of the most effective, often being used as a “masked identity” in order to make profound statements. Not only does this secret identity create more attention to the “masked one” but it also diverts attention to the cause rather than the identity. Literally using a mask, Fawkes was the main influence of the character “V”, in James McTeigue’s, V For Vendetta. V’s connections and

Animal Farm/V for Vendetta Essay

2494 words - 10 pages time period implores. Warner Brother's 2005 film "V for Vendetta" and George Orwell's 1945 novelette "Animal Farm" both deal with concepts present in the political climates of their times and the problems associated with them; the cost of apathy towards injustice, propaganda and its influence, and the crippling aspect of fear. The representation of the themes present in the two texts contrast and compare in many ways due to the diversity in the

V for Vendetta: a Critique

748 words - 3 pages When I was 14, I watched “V for Vendetta”, a movie based on the graphic novel of the same name. It’s an action movie about a dystopian, Orwellian future in the UK, and one man’s attempts to bring freedom back. Many denounce the movie as merely anarchist propaganda, but I believe that it is more than just that. I believe that it is about modern moral ambiguity, taking responsibility for one’s own wants and needs, and freedom conquering oppression

V for Vendetta Changing Perspective Essay

606 words - 2 pages identity change, her perspective constantly changed until her fear fuelled her to the point of power. Through Vs actions and that of the retaliation of Norsefire, the people of London go from being oblivious to fearful to powerful. Through his investigations in V, Finch changes from thinking loyally, to becoming fearful to the point of power where he must pursue justice. Each characters perspective changes gradually throughout the movie to the point where they understand that "people should not fear their governments, governments should fear their people."Bibliography"V for Vendetta" film, directed by James Mcteigue

"V is For Vendetta": A Civics Lesson

751 words - 3 pages V for Vendetta is a great movie to watch in Civics class. It is a perfect film to discuss issues related to civics as it talks about citizen’s duty to overthrow corruption and more. As it is set against the ‘futuristic landscape of a totalitarian Britain’, this story focuses on a young working-class woman named Evey. In the event of being in a life-death situation, she meets V who rescues her. V makes her realize that she has the potential to do

V for Vendetta, film by James McTeigue

1371 words - 5 pages and psychological torture for their rehabilitation of homosexuals. But the use of the Guy Fawkes mask does not stop there. More recently, protesters wearing the mask appeared in public demonstrations in what political pundits call the Arab Spring. Anonymous’ denial of service attacks on Tunisian government websites resulted in an “upsurge of internet activism among Tunisians” (Randeree). In Egypt, V For Vendetta became a wellspring of ideas from

Review of Film V for Vendetta

1470 words - 6 pages This movie “V for Vendetta” was taken from a book written by Alan Moore and it was written years before all the things that started happening in the world, like the war, and all the problems that the government is going through. He tells us that “the people should not be afraid of the government, that the government should be afraid of their people”. People can realize that there are no coincidences in this world, everything happens for a

V for Vendetta: Comparing the Novel and the Film

977 words - 4 pages V for Vendetta is a graphic novel written by Allan Moore. It is a story full of comedy with V as the protagonist who is out to fight and destroy the government and affects innocent people. The novel was later adapted into a film and directed by James McTeigue and written by Wachowski Brothers. The graphic novel was set in 1990’s during the time where the world had suffered from a nuclear war and everything was left destroyed. The movie was in

V for Vendetta: The Movie and the Book

1137 words - 5 pages several years, there have been many movies devoted to the issue of future alternative reality. This essay is devoted to one of the alternative reality movies. V for Vendetta was shot in 2006. However, not many people know that in 1982, there was a graphic book V for Vendetta. The movie was based on that very graphic book. The main idea of the essay is to compare and contrast both the movie and the graphic book. The essay will consist of several parts

Critique and Commentary of Film "V for Vendetta"

857 words - 4 pages Set in a realistic adaptation of a totalitarian, despotic Britain, V for Vendetta is the striking tale of V, hero stamped terrorist, and his seditious scheme to ignite a revolution. This is a terrific movie that captivates the audience amid an eerily relatable setting. With our world in a state of political turmoil, the film is very relevant to humanity’s history and gives the movie a true-to-life ambiance. The all-star cast makes the characters

Evey Hammond as a Revolutionary in V for Vendetta

980 words - 4 pages Alan Moore's graphic novel V for Vendetta is not only a call for revolution, but also an explanation of how such process should materialize. V, who transcends beyond a character and embodies the concept of revolution, establishes the procedure for social change. He understands that his role is to avenge and “make rubble” of injustice and corruption; however, true social reform must move beyond destruction and forge an improved society on the

Similar Essays

V For Vendetta Essay

2007 words - 9 pages There are many different dystopian science fiction films out there. Dystopian science fiction usually is about the problem at hand in that society and It tries to call for action from the audience. V for Vendetta is not any different than other dystopian science fiction . V for Vendetta ( adapted from a comic book series by the same name written by Alan Moore) is a 2005 dystopian science fiction film with an appropriate amount of action. this

V For Vendetta Essay

1249 words - 5 pages V for Vendetta Essay Henry CostelloIn the film V for Vendetta, the director, James Mcteigue uses camera work and dialogue to highlight the nature of a character in the film. In the film we can see a parallel connection between Evey and V, which is in the first scene, the nature of the character "Evey" was influenced by the torturing of V, the nature of the character "V" was changed by the experimental study of the Government. The influence "V

V For Vendetta Essay

1905 words - 8 pages In many films the protagonist who is the main character, helps viewers to understand the main themes or messages in greater depth. In the film “V” for vendetta, the main character “V” highlights and reinforces the main messages and themes for viewers through his point of view. In “V” for Vendetta, “V” the protagonist takes viewers through a variety of themes such as the fear that society had over government. The Revenge that “V” wanted for

V For Vendetta Essay

787 words - 3 pages Politicians lie to hide the truth, artists tell lies to reveal it, so proclaims from the creators of The Matrix. Although, parents must be cautious of an exceeding amount of violence from knifing, shootings and torture in the prison cells, since the level of violence was probably the best way to lure as many people into seeing it. But really this isn't an action film or a superhero movie or even really science fiction. V for Vendetta is an idea