Validity Of History. Essay

1099 words - 4 pages

Jane Tompkins, author of "'Indians': Textualism, Morality, and Problem of History," questions the validity of every history book and most facts that have been written. She first writes her perspective as a small child and her own young understanding of American Indians. She imagines herself as an Indian playing in the caves that is the pleasurable perspective of an Indian. When her parents took her to meet real Indians, it "was always a disappointment" ( 718) for her. She would see them for who they were: real Indians in full headdress were not fun. Perhaps this perspective would be different if the Indians were excited to see her, as she was to see them, perhaps not. After Tompkins starts researching the relationship between the Indians and the Europeans she reached an "impasse". The difficulty she faced in finding the truth about what happened to the Indians at the hands of the Europeans questions the value of what society has been assuming is the truth. In almost every history book she read different interpretations which have the same story and what were found were not only different, but completely opposite recordings of history. "In simpler language, it concerns the difference that point of view makes when people are giving accounts of events, whether at first or second hand. The problem is that if all accounts of events are determined through and through by the observer's frame of reference, then one will never know, in any given case, what really happened" ( 719). Thinking critically about this can lead to the questioning of every thing ever written about history, and to the question of which research to believe and why. After researching the facts of the relationship between the Indians and the Europeans, those facts, although it seems to be true, has unfairness attached with it.Tompkins, who was encouraged to conduct this research because she was teaching a lecture about the subject for college students, could have easily followed the standard of today's lecturers and restated the first thing she read about the Indians and Europeans' relationship. That is the way our educational system works for many of the students today. Students hear what teachers want them to hear, and many teachers validate what they are teaching because they read it in some book claiming to be the truth. The truth is that history might not ever have an accurate description of what happened hundreds of years ago. People might think they do, but proof of this is almost impossible to come by. Even the most authentic source, such as Tompkins example of the writings of, Heard, a girl taken prisoner by the Indians, can be biased. "Upon reaching the village, the child might face such ordeals as running the gauntlet or dancing in the center of a throng of threatening Indians" (727). The writings taken from the prisoner girl seemingly must be true because the girl was actually there, but the perspective she was taking tainted her truths.Tompkins also illustrates the...

Find Another Essay On Validity of History.

The Validity of Creationism and Evolution

3644 words - 15 pages to come because science cannot and may never explain creation. They simply ask to allow biology and science to take its own course. To determine the validity of creationism, one must look back at its roots and trace it through history. In the Middle Ages, Thomas Aquinas was the most systematic and influential author of science and religion. He believed that the biblical God was the intelligent Designer and First Cause of all effects

The Validity of The Evolutionary Theory

1396 words - 6 pages every life form is the creation of a supernatural being, to reinforce the validity of the evolution theory. Gould undermines creationism by emphasizing its misused concepts of theory and popular philosophy, proving that it is not science. Besides denouncing creationism, Gould also provides theoretical examples as evidence to prove evolution is a theory. Despite their different approaches, both Darwin and Gould effectively prove the existence of

Isaac Asimov's Foundation - Validity of Science Fiction

1178 words - 5 pages science fiction as candidates for more prestigious awards. Instead, science fiction is often dismissed as technology-dependent literature, immature in character development, theme, and structure. A large portion of the literary world still levels a sniff and a scoff toward Foundation and indeed the entire genre of science fiction. Asimov's Foundation can be seen as an archetype demonstrating the validity of science fiction and refuting these

Testamentary Freedom and Validity of Wills

2616 words - 11 pages Equity Essay Legislation and case law has been evolving throughout history surrounding testamentary promises. The attitudes of the courts have ebbed and flowed towards claims testing the validity of a will. New Zealand was the first country in the commonwealth jurisdiction to enact a family protection act, the Testators Family Maintenance Act 1900. Although legislation has changed considerably since the incorporation of the first act, the

The Validity of Henry Miller's Radical Pacifism in Tropic of Cancer

2771 words - 11 pages repetition of “to me” in “It seemed incomprehensible to me” and “A madhouse, it seemed to me” and “I might say” emphasizes the “subjective truth,” and therefore the validity of the individual’s opinion (Miller, 222; Orwell, 1). He’s not trying to convert, nor is he saying “everyone feels this way;” but instead it’s a claim that there is inherent value in the individual’s opinion. For the individual, it’s an empowering claim. Furthermore, by

The Validity of Plutarch

3232 words - 13 pages The first century AD gave birth to Plutarch of Chaeronea. He was born into the Greco-Roman world during the Pax Romana, a time of peace that which had not been seen in all of the country's history. Plutarch, coming from an upper-class family, was able to get a good education and find a purpose to his life1. Philosophy was his calling and he was brilliant in his work. An aficionado of the works of his forefathers in thought (from Zeno to

Medicinal Validity of Cannabis

1060 words - 5 pages nice, safe medication that will be very effective. Works Cited Zuardi, Antonio Waldo. "History of Cannabis as a Medicine: A Review." Revista Brasileira De Psiquiatria 28.2 (2006). Web. 28 Nov. 2013. Schofield, Micheal. "A Description of Cannabis." Http://www.drugtext.org/pdf/The-Strange-Case-of-Pot/a-description-of-cannabis.pdf. 17 Sept. 2010. Web. 29 Nov. 2013. Seamon, M. J., J. A. Fass, M. Maniscalco-Feichtl, and N. A. Abu-Shraie. "Medical

Analyzing Validity of Text

1256 words - 6 pages Risk and Benefits of Marijuana Medical marijuana: a public health perspective The article is written by Ushang Desai and Paras Patel. Desai is affiliated with the Department of Environmental and Occupational Health, University of South Florida and Patel is affiliated with College of Pharmacy, Nova Southeastern University. The article was published on January 27, 2013 in the International Journal of Basic & Clinical Pharmacology. The article

Validity of the Constitution

1353 words - 6 pages liberty (Doc. E). Hence, the immorality of slavery would appear paradoxical to the promise of freedom. As can be seen, the Constitution was flawed with concepts that were diametrically opposed, driving an ideological wedge between the Union. The validity of the Constitution was further questioned legally and authoritatively. The supreme court was seen as the final arbiter of law, but Dred Scott v. Sandford heavily tarnished the court's

Establishing Reliability and Validity

895 words - 4 pages Establishing Reliability and Validity In conducting a research or survey, the quality of the data collected in the research is of utmost importance. One’s assessment may be reliable and not valid and thus this is why it is important that when designing a survey, one should also come up with the methods of testing the reliability and validity of the assessment tools. For MADD (Mothers Against Drunk Driving) to conduct a survey, the questions

How standardisation, reliability and validity play a role in determining whether a test is a good measure of personality

2064 words - 8 pages PSY11 Assignment 2 Introduction to Psychology 1A Maria Cahill ID 11367156 How standardisation, reliability and validity play a role in determining whether a test is a good measure of personality.AbstractPersonality tests are used extensively by psychologists to determine traits, behaviours and characteristics of subjects. There are many tests available however only the Rorschach, Inkblot Test, the Minnesota Multiphasic Personality

Similar Essays

Ap Advanced Placement U.S. History Dbq Essay: "During The Colonial Period, Religion Provided The Primary Rationale For The Authority Of The King." Task: Assess The Validity Of This Statement

993 words - 4 pages Puritans, the Catholics, etc. This was done because they set certain limits and freedoms according to the way they believed God meant to govern. The colonists used similar concepts to that of England which justified powers of the government with religious support and the supremacy of God as being a primary rationale of its authority. The King of England ruled by divine right, which forced people who were strong followers of their faith to submit to him. Thus, the king had secured his own position.Source: AMSCO United States History - Preparing for the Advanced Placement Examination by John J. Newman, John M. Schmalbach.

Threats To Validity Essay

963 words - 4 pages In every research there are always potential threats to validity and in the reviewed article Boffetta et al, there are several like; confounding, situation, and single group threats among others. Before we proceed with the explanation of the above identified threats to validity, perhaps it is important to first understand what validity is with respect to research methods and its key components. Validity is the greatest estimate of the

Validity: External, Internal, And Construct Essay

2088 words - 8 pages will be attained. Instrumentation, testing, maturation and history are the most common variables related to external validity (Creswell, 2000, p. 126). In conclusion, external validity in research paradigms accepts universal theoretical measures and rejects conceptions of common sense like random sampling automatic superiority. It is evident that researchers are not able to emphasize inferences of external (generalizability) validity at a point

External, Internal, And Construct Validity Essay

1286 words - 5 pages the independent variable, are responsible for the effect. There are a number of possible threats to internal validity, the seven most commonly referenced threats include history, maturation, testing, instrumentation, mortality, regression, and selection. History refers to any event, in addition to the treatment, that takes place during the duration of the experiment. For example, a bomb threat that happens during a professional development session