Value In Design Essay

1893 words - 8 pages

Value in graphic design can possibly be summed up with some of the following criteria; is it informative? Is it aesthetically pleasing? Is it eye-catching, clear or interesting? What makes this piece of design good, or possibly, bad? Is it valuable to society? Though there is no definitive list…
The People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals Foundation (PETA), a non-profit UK organisation, are notorious for their shocking and often distasteful advertising campaigns that are usually very difficult and uncomfortable to look at. Along the same lines are Amnesty International, a human rights charity, who also produce shocking advertising to stir emotions and to make the general public aware of ...view middle of the document...

There were various taglines and images but the one I want to discuss is the “To animals, all people are Nazis” photograph. On the left side of the billboard is a picture of fully grown adults, packed like sardines in a room and on the right hand side is a picture of battery chickens kept in cages. The tagline “To animals, all people are Nazis” is strikingly bright with a red background and black writing blazoned across the top of the billboard, appearing as if the pictures have been ripped away to reveal this message.
Firstly, this advert is incredibly effective in jolting the public’s consciousness for PETA, so its value is intrinsic in gaining acknowledgement and support. It turned a lot of heads and caused a lot of controversy, which heightened PETA’s status and voice. It has incredible emotional value as it instantly provokes an emotional, yet uncomfortable, reaction.
The Uses and Gratification Theory describes mass communication and it argues that we, as a public, turn to media to satisfy pre-existing needs. For example, if you like gossip, you read tabloid newspapers. Some of the reasons we enjoy arts and culture are to be amused, to see authority figures exalted/deflated, to experience the beautiful, to satisfy curiosity and to be informed, to experience empathy and to experience, in a guilt-free situation, extreme emotions, as well as to affirm moral, cultural and spiritual values, to explore taboo subjects with impunity and to experience the ugly. Taking this into account, PETA’s advertising campaign can answer some of the mentioned criteria, for example, it allows people to experience the ugly, it affirms most people’s moral values that animals should be treated better and it also explores taboo subjects, like the Holocaust and animal cruelty. However, I do not believe these aspects of the advertisement are enough. Does it stir feelings of empathy or compassion for the animals or does it only provoke the feeling of shock and disgust? That was my initial reaction to this advert.
Rather than having an aesthetic value, I would argue that the advert has negative aesthetic value – it is not pleasant to look at, nor does it evoke positive emotions. The billboard advertisement contains ugly and uncomfortable images that the general public would usually choose not to see, though they have been chosen specifically to shock the audience. I do not believe that this devalues this piece of graphic design or the point it was trying to make. A piece of art or design does not have to be aesthetically pleasing or beautiful to be valuable. W. Somerset Maugham believed that beauty was not the ultimate goal of art and that it should be moral, not aesthetically pleasing; “Art, if it is to be reckoned as one of the great values of life, must teach man humility, tolerance, wisdom and magnanimity. The value of art is not beauty, but right action” (W. Somerset Maugham) You could argue that PETA was at least trying to raise awareness of animal rights and...

Find Another Essay On Value In Design

Design innovators Essay

3655 words - 15 pages interactions with technology. For example, Verganti(2009), analysing four cases (Wii of Nintendo Corp., Swatch, iPod of Apple Inc. and ST Micro Electronics) reveals that an industrial design feature unveils substantial value of technology innovation, and even in the high technology firm design is a core driver of technological wrinkle. These cases imply not only industrial design features contribute user’s cognition of the meaning of the technology

The importance of the value proposition in identifying the value offered to customers, and the processes involved, are equally important to both customers and value chain partners

1454 words - 6 pages proposition is the company's strategic statement about what is to be delivered to the customer and by what means. It uses aggregate capabilities, skills and resources to identify the benefits and costs to the customer and the necessary processes. Davenport & Short (1990) describe these processes as a set of tasks, related in a logical order. Walters (2002:6) specifies the generic processes of the value chain as being design and development

Identity Politics within Design Literacy

1957 words - 8 pages , their roles and even their value within the design industry. In her commentary on graphic design she wrote: "A critique of women in graphic design becomes a critique of graphic design itself. Any historical narrative of graphic design must include an understanding of how women have been positioned within the institutional or patriarchal framework of design". Indeed Triggs is in concurrence that literacy in design demands an informed understanding of

The Role of Design Leadership in Achieving a Company's Strategic Goals

2220 words - 9 pages brand designers is higher than expected; but most importantly, this role must be aligned with the strategic goals of the company. References De Mozota, B. B. (2003). Design Management: Using Design to Build Brand Value and Corporate Innovation. Skyhorse Publishing Inc. Forbes, N. & Wield, D. (2002). From Followers to Leaders: Managing Technology and Innovation in Newly Industrializing Countries. UK: Psychology Press. Lawson, B. (2006). How

What Should 'good' Design Have As Its Principle?

3548 words - 15 pages recognized by noticing part of the design.8. EnduringDesign can be used efficiently as possible with a comfortably and minimum weariness from time to time. A static design will eventually be outdated and resulting in the down of revenues.We value permanence and tradition, but we also value creativity, changes, improvements, and relevance to the time in which we live. If a design can stand the test of time, is it better than a new design that rejects

Graduate Studies in Aerospace Engineer

998 words - 4 pages components and design them better. Graduate studies have always been my priorities and I felt working in this industry will be the right preparation for this field. Thus I wish to pursue graduate studies in Aerospace Engineering at your esteemed university with a specialization in structure and materials, adding value to my work experience. I have been interested in airplanes since my childhood. The first airplane I built was a paper fold plane

The Future of Graphic Design

2137 words - 9 pages According to a poll question that was conducted in 2012 by, about 93% of Graphic Designers agreed to the statement that the Graphic Design industry is in bad shape and do not know where the discipline is headed. The root of Graphic Design is communication of an idea through art or graphics. And it has been in human history for the longest time, from cave drawings to hieroglyphs and from physical prints to the digital media. It

The History of Graphic Design

1280 words - 6 pages European and America’s graphic design and movements such as cubism and constructivism. He also influenced marketing outlooks of most companies by attaching a lot of significance to the role played by logos and adverts. He notes in his book thoughts on design that any art that separates artists from their products would eventually diminish the value of the products and that of the maker of the product (Rand, 1970). References Meggs, P. B., Purvis, A. W

Interpretation of Urban Design

1208 words - 5 pages Interpretation of Urban Design There is a precedent need for the presence of urban design. Urban design is the collection of arranged urban structures that creates functional spaces for people. This is an interdisciplinary practice that can involve multiple actors in fields such as urban planning, architecture, engineering, landscaping, economics, law, and many more. Strong urban designs can lead to the success of linking built structure

Durability Design of Structures

1298 words - 6 pages , some of the durability issues are chloride attack, carbonation, freezing and thawing action, chemical attack, alkali silicate reaction etc. For chloride induced corrosion, durability verification could be done by γ_i C_d/C_lim ≤1.0 Where, γ_i=structural factor, C_lim=Threshold value of chloride concentration, C_d=Design value of chloride concentration at rebar Similarly in case of carbonation, durability verification y/y_limit <1 Where, y


1825 words - 7 pages IntroductionThis research addresses the concept of design thinking as a strategic tool in business leadership. The design thinking concept and general process is introduced along with market examples of its implementation. A critical analysis including positive and negative implications of the concept on the market is provided in this research. The study also discusses case study of the Nestle Company's design thinking process. It draws some

Similar Essays

The Value Of Art, Craft And Design In The Primary Classroom

1355 words - 6 pages The Value of Art, Craft and Design in the Primary Classroom This rationale is going to discuss the value of art, craft and design in the primary classroom. I am going to emphasise the importance that art and design has, within the primary curriculum. I will also emphasise, how my resource pack promotes the value of creativity in the primary classroom. The teaching of art and design has many benefits, one main benefit is that it promotes

“Design Should Never Say, ‘Look At Me.’ It Should Always Say, ‘Look At This.’ ”

1535 words - 6 pages as construction techniques and material choice, whereas fashion journalist may be looking for the brand name. “Design is a messy kind of business that involves making value judgements between alternatives that may each offer some advantages and disadvantages. There is unlikely to be a correct or even optimal answer in the design process, and we are not all likely to agree about the relative merits of the alternative solutions.” (Lawson, 2005

Design Driven Innovation Essay

1336 words - 6 pages driven innovation is not isolated from technology innovation, but includes interactions with technology. For example, Verganti(2009), analysing four cases (Wii of Nintendo Corp., Swatch, iPod of Apple Inc. and ST Micro Electronics), revealed that an industrial design feature unveils substantial value of technology innovation, and even in the high technology firm design is a core driver of technological breakthrough. These cases imply not only

Robust Design, Quality Loss Function, System Design, Parameter Design And Tolerance Design

1194 words - 5 pages 1. Explain robust design, quality loss function, system design, parameter design, tolerance design Answer: 1.1. Robust design: Though robust design can be explained in different way, it can be generalized to: one step/stage of product design development process at which design experiment is made on multiple factors so that to minimize the effects of variation without avoiding the causes (since they are too difficult or too expensive to