This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Variables Affecting Competency And Restoration Decisions

3102 words - 13 pages

Throughout history mental health has played an important role in the legal system, specifically regarding matters of competency and sanity. Issues concerning competency to stand trial have grown throughout history and cover a large breadth of topics including, but not limited to: predictor variables, malingering, mental retardation, competency standards in execution, and the validity of competency assessments. The issue of competency in legal proceedings is rooted in English Common Law as early as the 17th century (CITE- ALawPsych&pol). Common law states that the standard for competency to stand trial requires that the defendant understand the proceedings against him or her and be able to assist in their defense (Cite-lackinsight) William Blackstone alluded to competency to stand trial in his Commentaries on the Laws of England (1783), which questioned the abilities of mentally impaired defendants, then considered to be “mad”, to plead with the “caution that he ought” (CITE-). The inability for a defendant to exercise caution goes against their right to a fair trial because they cannot render decisions necessary to creating a defense. Although it was realized early on that competency is an important matter preceding trial, a legal standard for competency was not defined until 1960 in the case of Dusky v. United States.
The decision resulting from Dusky v. United States (1960) gave rise to the “Dusky standard”, which works to prevent an unfair trial by allowing a defendant to be deemed incompetent if he does not meet the standards for competence. Once deemed incompetent to stand trial, the defendant may be restored back to competence and subsequently referred back to court for a trial setting. Many variables affect whether a defendant is deemed competent or incompetent to stand trial, as well as whether the defendant is able to be restored to competency. This paper will examine the variables involved in competency decisions, specifically how legal, clinical, and sociodemographic variables affect competency to stand trial and restoration to competency decisions.

Literature Review
Variables Affecting Competency to Stand Trial
It is important to know and understand not only the process of assessing competency, but also the decision makers involved in the competency to stand trial process. Additionally, it is equally important to know the legal cases involved in defining competency in order to accurately assess the construct for which predictor variables are being sought. The ability to deduce what legal (legal knowledge, severity of offense), sociodemographic (age, race), and clinical (diagnosis, severity of diagnosis) variables affect competency and restoration decisions could give way to expediting the process of competency assessment. Knowing the variables involved in competency decisions may also unearth any potential bias present in the decision making process.
Legal Variables
Legal and criminal variables involved in competency decisions...

Find Another Essay On Variables Affecting Competency and Restoration Decisions

Adult Learning in an Online Environment

1321 words - 6 pages distance (Tomei, 2010). Distance learning requires students to make decisions based on facts as well as experience; instructors must become facilitators of the process, ensuring students receive the necessary data, time, and experimental opportunities to foster this aspect of learning (Tomei, 2010). The reasons for delay vary are based on student. Critical thinking is a form of judgment based on reflection as well as action (Tomei, 2010

Developing a Competency Leadership Model for a Mayor

1290 words - 6 pages can avoid synthetic or process which often fail to address certain organizations’ cultures, environments, and distinctions. Competency model is an assortment of competencies when conveyed together delineates a positive execution in specific work setting. Competency models are also a core part of human resource operation like staffing, training and development, and performance management. According to Emiliani (2003) in the development of leadership

Wetland Restoration

1170 words - 5 pages wetland restoration and creation to reduce the impacts of activities in or near wetlands, compensate for additional losses, and to restore or replace wetlands already degraded or destroyed (Nicholas, p. 39). Wetlands serve many purposes and are considered one of the most productive natural systems in the world. They serve as crucial "pit-stops" for migratory bird, house several species of plants and animals, cleanse and purify water, as well

Competency to stand trial in United States Court Cases

1201 words - 5 pages During a criminal proceeding there are many aspects taken into consideration, in order to properly declare someone ‘competent’ to stand trial. Many would mistakenly interpret competency to stand trial as a psychological term, although it is in fact a legal definition. Legal competency consists of many components, which vary from: competency to confess, competency to waive Miranda rights, competency to make decisions over the medication imposed

Applying ANOVA and Nonparametric Tests

653 words - 3 pages three major assumptions and know if they are met:•Errors are random and independent of each other.•Each population has a normal distribution•All the populations have the same variance.(Lind, Marchal, & Wathen, 2004).A one-way analysis only looks at one variable such as client satisfaction. A two-way analysis compares two variables such as project complexity and employee competency. The variables are compared against the variances


3678 words - 15 pages information, perspective and ability to make decisions. After the war they still lived under a command and control hierarchy.In the post war decade the demand was unparalleled and competition was little. The turnaround came when in the early 1960's when McClelland wrote a landmark article in the American Psychologist asserting that IQ and personality tests that were then in common use were predictors of competency. He felt that companies should hire people

Core Competences

587 words - 2 pages A Core Competency is a deep proficiency that enables a company to deliver unique value to customers. It embodies an organization's collective learning, particularly of how to coordinate diverse production skills and integrate multiple technologies. Such a Core Competency creates sustainable competitive advantage for a company and helps it branch into a wide variety of related markets. Core Competencies also contribute substantially to the

How BP's Press Releasees After the Deep Water Horizon Explosioin Helped Regain Public Favor

3225 words - 13 pages , image repair strategies and the contingency continuum are factors that may aid in image restoration, but may not guarantee it. It is important to note that crisis management and image repair is dynamic in nature, and hence is dependent on the individual case and variables for success. References Benoit, W.L. (1997). Image repair discourse and crisis communication. Public Relations Review, 23(2), pp. 177-186. Brinson, S. L., & Benoit, W. L

Competency Traps

2519 words - 10 pages A competency trap is the false belief that the same practice that led to a past success, it will necessary lead to a future one. Even though this term was introduced in management literature, "competency trap" is wide in scope and can be applied in different fields such as business, military and in the personal.Competency traps derive from excessive specialization, "Competency traps represent a tendency to maintain existing and familiar

Analyzing Factors That Influence Infant Birth Weight

3272 words - 13 pages was obtained was not available. 2.3: Methodology: A background literature search was carried out to identify similar papers on internet based search engines (MEDLINE, OVID), using the search criteria ‘factors affecting birth weight’. Data was analysed using the statistical soft ware STATA. An initial examination of variables contained in the dataset was carried out to ascertain credibility and check for consistency. There were a large number of

Identifying Long Term Trends

1262 words - 6 pages In this module case study I will briefly review Nike Inc. (NKE) and how important it is for the financial managers to use economic variables in order to identify their long term financial goals. I will also go over a few techniques that the financial managers of Nike Inc. could use for economic forecasting in the global economy. Financial managers must be able to understand as many economic aspects affecting the market in any part

Similar Essays

Quantitative Research Design: Combine The Previous Two Parts Of The Design Project Along With Enhancements From Feedback. Create A High Level Prop

2423 words - 10 pages infrastructure in Academic Libraries, it will bridge the gap that exists in the literature on ICT use in Ghana and also provide a useful resource or basis for further research in the application of ICT in libraries and education in general. Quantitative Research questions and hypotheses Research Questions a. To what extent does performance expectancy of using ICTs has effect on the ICT staff’s competency levels? b. To what extent does effort

Jolonde Essay

5183 words - 21 pages issues are organized coherently to ensure clear and effective communication Dialogue is initiated with appropriate personnel Communication problems and issues are raised as they arise RANGE OF VARIABLES VARIABLE RANGE Methods of communication Non-verbal gestures Verbal Face to face Two-way radio Speaking to groups Using telephone Written Internet EVIDENCE GUIDE Critical aspects of Competency Assessment requires evidence that the

Applying Anova And Nonparametric Tests Simulation

719 words - 3 pages such as project complexity and employee competency. The variables are then compared against the variances such as high, medium, and low. One must also know if the data has a normal distribution this will determine if ANOVA is used or if another nonparametric test such as Kruskal-Wallis test is used (Lind, Marchal, & Wathen, 2004).Another key lesson learned is that one must consider the right variables, if one fails the correct variable it

Restoring Nature Essay

870 words - 4 pages occurring seed and human decisions in the placement of the seeds. While successful, this restoration was a “substitute for the real savanna, one based on human technologies and designed for human purposes: a pure and grand vision of the old Midwest” (Katz Restoration, 447) in short it was for anthropocentric reasons. The part of a law that created the Forest Preserve District, which he quotes as what justified him accelerating the burning