Should We Support Virtual Pornography? Essay

1707 words - 7 pages

In today’s fast developing and modern society the thought of seeing two grown adults having sex is still considered taboo. Most Americans cringe at the thought of seeing pornography and dismiss the act as nothing more than a senseless lewd act. Yet, the Supreme Court held that pornography was to be considered a form of personal expression and should be protected under the first amendment (New York v. Ferber, 1973). The Supreme Court did not choose to extend the same constitutional protection to child pornography, arguing against its explicit and hurtful content. Supreme Court Justices argued that child pornography has no scientific, literary, artistic, or political value; they thought the material that was going to arise from child pornography was going to cause more harm than good if they were to allow it to be protected. As society began to change and computer animation technology advanced a growing question began to be formed: should virtual pornography be constitutionally protected, under the argument that it is a form of personal expression and that it’s content has significant scientific, literary, artistic, or political value? Unlike actual child pornography, which has to include two innocent children partaking in sexual acts, virtual pornography consist of two computer generated children engaging in sexual acts. The same rational and arguments that were used by the Supreme Court to determine the constitutionality of child pornography cannot be applied to virtual pornography. The pain and lifetime of suffering that child pornography brings to its victims was a big reason behind not extending the first amendment to such work; however, virtual pornography does not have any real life victims involved in its work. The images seen in virtual pornography are created by a computer developer and never include innocent children in the making of the movie or scene. I shall argue that virtual pornography should be protected as a form of personal expression because its content has scientific, literary, artistic, or political value and if it not allowed to be expressed freely some valued speech will be “chilled’ or lost at the fear of being prosecuted.
In order to delve further into the topic it is important to first define the legal meaning of child pornography. Child pornography is legally explained as any minor below the age of eighteen years of age that partakes in sexual activity or erotic behavior with the sole purpose of arousing the viewer’s sexual interest ( In New York v. Ferber- 1973, the Supreme Court ruled that child pornography was not entitled to first amendment constitutional protection and they offered five reasons why the government had significant interest to make such works illegal. The Supreme Court reasons to why child pornography should be banned are as followed: 1) the government has a high interest in preventing the sexual exploitation of children 2) there is a casual relationship between the sexual abuse...

Find Another Essay On Should We Support Virtual Pornography?

Support Same-sex marriage!! There are many reasons we should allow same sex marriage.

943 words - 4 pages advantage of them if they choose to marry. Without marriage, gays and lesbians do not have the right to do many things, such as change names, enter into a premarital agreement, and divide property after the relationship has ended, in vitro fertilization coverage, and no right to support from spouse or after divorce. Homosexual couples also do not have the right to visit a partner in the hospital because they are not family. No one should have to

What is Pornography? Essay

2261 words - 9 pages their own discretion to censor pornography because they feel that this kind of material should not be distributed legally. As soon as the courts start using their own discretion to decide what we as a people should or shouldn?t be able to enjoy, then we will be losing our constitutional right to make our own choices. ?Centuries of horrible religious war and persecution finally made Westerns societies realize that merely disliking the activities

Pornography Should be Regulated

2343 words - 9 pages When deliberating over whether access to pornography should be prohibited, four areas of contention must be elaborated upon and evaluated critically to provide a sensible basis on which a judgement can be made. Firstly, it must be concluded whether pornography can be classed as a form of speech, and whether it enjoys the same protections as art and literature under the principle. Secondly, works such as those of Catherine MacKinnon can be

Pornography. an Essay About How Pornography Has Become Part of our Everyday Lives and How it Will Remain that Way Because We Have Decided to Accept it.

1815 words - 7 pages to list the actions or thoughts that lead to problem situations related to Internet sex.Column 3 asks the addict to list the positive rewards of maintaining sobriety and of refraining from his or her primary problem activities.The last step is behavior change and support; this process should provide continuous support and affirmation that creates a positive self-image for the individual.To summarize "The nation has been pornified"(Smith,2010) We

The Wrongs Of Child Pornography From A Christian Perspective

3183 words - 13 pages toward women, which encourage inequality, sexual harassment and violence. These effects are felt both in the workplace and at home.The bible has a very straightforward viewpoint on what our view, as Christians, should be towards child pornography and pornography in general on the Internet. There are many different verses that show us how we should act towards pornography. One of the sections of the bible that addresses this is in Matthew chapter 5

The Harmful Effects of Pornography

1699 words - 7 pages Whether pornography is an excuse to make acts of violence public? A big number of famous scholars, no matter men or women, have given their opinions. Each of them has their own view, but we can sort them into two groups, which are against to serious censorship and willing to convict and uproot pornography. Because of pornography, women’s status can never be equal to men’s. Recently, a revolution about the perception of moral values comes out

Pornograhpy on internet

1109 words - 4 pages erotic material at such an early age? Do we have a twisted sense of morals if we support pornography? Or is it just a natural part of life that should be nurtured and encouraged?These questions and more are springing to peoples lips as we enter the technological age. The age of the Internet. Never before has pornography been so readily available. Through mail-order, at secret places around the schoolyard, or simply down at the local newsagent or


1232 words - 5 pages and modern day magazines, are all part of the stimulus material which is known as "pornography" or as it is legally put, "obscenity." Is it ethically right for our children to be looking at this erotic material at such an early age? Do we have a twisted sense of morals if we support pornography? Or is it just a natural part of life that should be nurtured and encouraged? These questions and more are springing to peoples lips as we enter

Why is Pornography Bad and Erotica Good?

2226 words - 9 pages its path as far as her earlobe." Is this pornography or is it erotica. Literature has more than one definition for sexually explicit materials, erotica and pornography; erotica is acceptable and pornography is not. To be able to answer this question, a definition of pornography and erotica must be provided. Once it is decided that something is either erotica or pornography, the next question that needs to be answered is whether it should be

The Effects of Violent Pornography on Male's Aggression towards Women

1296 words - 6 pages Introduction The area that I am interested in is the effects of violent pornography on men. There is a correlation between the amount of pornography consumed and attitudes that support violence against women. There is also an association between the type of pornography consumed (violent or non-violent) and their attitudes that support violence against women. Pornography contributes to the rape culture seen in today’s society. Men who watch more


1704 words - 7 pages repercussions or emotional implications. They tell us that is all a matter of free speech. They justify it as a victimless crime because we can¡¯t see any immediate victim.There is actually no smoking gun or any ¡°hard¡± evidence that proves that porno has killed something. Yet, there is plenty of circumstantial evidence that a death has taken place. Those who want you to believe pornography is a First Amendment

Similar Essays

We Must Make Virtual Child Pornography Illegal

2782 words - 11 pages The Supreme Court lifted a 1996 act banning virtual child pornography. The six to three ruling, led by Justice Anthony Kennedy, says the law violates First Amendment freedom of speech rights guaranteed to every citizen of the United States of America. Although many free speech advocates are shouting victory, many citizens across the country are lamenting over the loss in the fight against child pornography. Child pornography has been present

Should Virtual Child Pornography Be Banned?

1024 words - 4 pages the Supreme Court made a horrible decision, how they are ignorant for doing it, and how the internet sites show virtual child in a real way. Overall he failed to strongly support his argument in a convincing way. Debating if “virtual” child pornography should be banned is very hard because both sides made a good point. These two articles were not great at all but I feel Kaminer made a stronger argument than Rodriguez. She tried using more

We Should Not Censor Internet Pornography

1651 words - 7 pages and relieve sexual tensions.5" Opponents of this view are particularly concerned with the social effects of online pornography and its effect on the values and morals of minors who can access pornographic images. I will argue for the liberal side and argue that porn in both print form and electronic form should be constitutionally protected. The major piece of legislation that would infringe on the rights of Internet users was the

Saving Lives, Easing Pain Why We Should Support Stem Cell Research

915 words - 4 pages developed, as well as producing nerves in the spinal cord (N.I.H.). I feel that we are letting people watch their lives pass them by, and not even trying to save them. Why then, aren't more people supporting embryonic stem cell research, if it has this ability?Of course we don't want to see people suffering with a disease, or worse, dying from a disease. The debates arise over where embryonic stem cells come from. Embryonic stem cells are obtained