Views On Health Care Reform Evaluated

2524 words - 10 pages

While many political issues are controversial and emotional for voters in America, few issues have created an outcry in recent years like the debate over health care reform. The arguments for and against such a comprehensive overhaul of the United States health care system are numerous and wide-ranging, as demonstrated by the scores of showings of support and protest against it. While it seems unlikely that few in the country could understand all of the ramifications of such a large bill, virtually everyone could find something they liked or did not like in the bill. Indeed, the one unifying aspect of all of the debate over the reform was the fact that everyone acknowledged that reform was needed, but as to what that alteration should be was the contentious part of the debate. While multiple arguments exist against the bill and numerous arguments exist in favor of the bill, in the end it seems evident that while the bill may not be popular among the entire American population, it is a necessary step in the right direction.

One of the most common arguments against this type of health care reform was the claim that it would permit too much intrusion into our lives by the government. Many, rallying to the same cry that Henry David Thoreau issued a century and a half ago, “I heartily accept the motto,—"That government is best which governs least"; and I should like to see it acted up to more rapidly and systematically” (Thoreau, 1849), have expressed their complete opposition to increased government intervention into American lives. This basic idea is a fundamental component of our American system, although debate exists over the level to which it should be implemented. Many believe that the government is less efficient than the free market, since it operates outside of the typical financial boundaries that a system of supply and demand provides. This argument has little room for a counter-argument, since it is based upon an interpretation of basic American ideals and economics, rather than a more debatable topic. However, given the vast quantity of economic theories that abound, agreement on any economic matter is uncertain at best.

Critics have also pointed out the fact that other countries with similar or more drastic health care programs are doing poorly or failing. Indeed, one study found that:

“The findings suggest that universal health care systems such as Australia's, with mixed public/private funding and delivery allowing for 'choice' in heath care, may actually perpetuate health inequity. While such systems might ensure equity for patients with AMI, where guidelines for treatment are relatively well established, this is not the case for care of patients with angina, where high technology health care may be less urgent and more discretionary.” (Clements, Kelman, & Korda, 2009)

While comparing countries is invariably a difficult task given the wide varience in governments, cultural tendencies and economic realities, the...

Find Another Essay On Views on Health Care Reform Evaluated

Health Care Reform Essay

1207 words - 5 pages The Health Care Reform Bill was surrounded by an extensive array of factors and had many relevant elements which either supported or opposed the bill. This paper focuses on examining what the decision making procedure and particular issues linked with this specific process might have been in the developmental procedure and passing of the Health Care Reform Bill. The decision making aspects involved with the developmental and passing procedure of

Health Care Reform Essay

2754 words - 11 pages Koop (1996) says, "It may take five to ten years to find the right balance of managed care, physician autonomy, and patient rights. Health care reform poses the greatest political challenge to a democratic republic, because each of us is being asked to do something for all of us, and many of us feel what might be best for all of us is not best for each of us. Before we can enact the reform we need in health care, we should agree on the basic

Health Care Reform

1226 words - 5 pages realistic.  Obama Affordable Care Act presents a reasonable approach to effectively address this challange by building on the current system. This new policy will implement multiple strategies that include strengthening empolyer-based coverage (pay or play), expanding and funding public coverage, and creating a new national purchasing pool offering a range of health plan options for individuals and businesses. Although expanding pulic coverage

Health Care and Tort Reform

1649 words - 7 pages redress on wrongs done to them (“United”). That tort reform may simultaneously benefit citizens by providing affordable health care prices does not matter, because this legislation would take away these fundamental rights. Legislation must never take away rights, no matter at how minimal a level – a loss of freedom always beings at a minimal level. And then it continues until people are no longer free. Furthermore, law and government must stay in the

Health Care Reform in Unavoidable

2010 words - 9 pages still objected strongly to a government intervention and pressured the Roosevelt administration to discontinue the New Deal program. With the ongoing pressure from the AMA, and the beginning of the Second World War occupying the full attention of the Roosevelt administration, health care reform along with many other domestic goals was put on hold. Later during the war, the federal government enforced strict price and wage controls on many

Australian Health Care and Reform

3784 words - 15 pages Introduction A country’s health care system refers to all the institutions, programs, personnel, procedures, and the resources that are used to meet the health needs of its population. Health care systems vary from one country to another, depending on government policies and the health needs of the population. Besides, health care programs are flexible in the sense that they are tailored to meet health needs as they arise. Among the

Health Care Reform in the United States

1937 words - 8 pages “We will pass reform that lowers cost, promotes choice, and provides coverage that every American can count on. And we will do it this year.” The preceding is a powerful statement from the newly elected President Barak Obama. One of the main aspects of both political campaigns was health care reform. The above quote shows passion and encouragement, but the quotes about health care do not end there. Georgian republican gubernatorial candidate

Reform of the American Health Care System

926 words - 4 pages system. There have been many attempts to move towards a universal health care policy in the United States. However, none of the attempts have left with national health insurance. Instead, health care is constantly being reformed. The public option plan would be more convenient and less expensive. This will allow Americans to have a “more perfect union”. The reformed health care will relieve the stress and frustration on millions of American nation

Massachusetts Health Care Reform or Romneycare

707 words - 3 pages must show evidence of coverage on their income tax return or face a penalty. The legislation included a merger of the individual market into the small group market to allow individuals to get lower group insurance rates. (Wikipedia) The reform sought to address major issues in the current health care act of Massachusetts. One of the major issues the reform sought to address was individuals lacking insurance using emergency rooms as their primary

Health Care Reform: A Necessary Evil

1639 words - 7 pages , but even Barrack Obama himself, as the president is open for suggestions, so that the bill would sustain the needs of all Americans. Besides, for decades, Barrack Obama’s predecessors acknowledged that something wrong had been going on in our health care system, and they had been trying to fix it. We must admit, the purpose of the Affordable Care Act is undoubtedly marvelous, and the prognosis seems pretty good. But perhaps, the timing might not be perfect, and so causing so many controversies. According to Donna Dubinsky, and many others who have faced the same kind of problems, health care reform is necessary. What do you think?

The Necessity of Health Care Reform

1306 words - 5 pages need it. These changes need to happen to save the health care system. Many different ideas come up on ways to improve this country’s health care system. Everyone can agree that the prices need to be lowered, dropping people for preexisting conditions should never happen, and on the importance of Medicare. One can reach the definitive conclusion, America needs health care reform. Instead of everyone picking sides between Democratic and

Similar Essays

Health Care Reform Essay

970 words - 4 pages should at least be considered for the American people. This is not only because of the tradition of success associated with socialized health care, but also because it is what the people of America demand. "Sixty-five percent of Americans support the U.S. government guaranteeing health insurance for all citizens" (Dickie 1). The Untied States is a nation built on the wishes of the majority. The majority of Americans want a reform, so it is only

Health Care Reform Essay

1334 words - 5 pages a serious reform is needed such as the accepting the Patient Protection Affordability Care Act. The Patient Protection Affordable Care Act was signed into law on March 23rd, 2010 by Barrack Obama, but some do not agree with the "obamacare" are on the fast track to repeal the bill. The law would focuses on the health care reform in the United States by providing better coverage for those with pre-existing conditions, improving prescription drug

Health Care Reform Essay

849 words - 3 pages carefully thought through and its repercussions would be felt into the Clinton administration. The Clinton administration ideally wanted to implement new social reforms when it entered the White House in 1992. The plan for his Health Care reform had overwhelming support by the public and the media. On the Clinton home front, however, there was a lot of concern. According to Theda Skocpol “Clinton and his 1992 campaign advisors were obsessed with

Health Care Reform Essay

856 words - 3 pages into the Clinton administration.The Clinton administration ideally wanted to implement new social reforms when it entered the White House in 1992. The plan for his Health Care reform had overwhelming support by the public and the media. On the Clinton home front, however, there was a lot of concern. According to Theda Skocpol ?Clinton and his 1992 campaign advisors were obsessed with the avoidance of the word ?taxes,?? . The Clinton administration