Virtue: A Comparitive Essay Of Aristotle And Machiavelli

542 words - 2 pages

In Niccolo Machiavelli's The Prince and Aristotle's The Politics, two very different ideas on the subject of virtue have been proposed. In The Prince, Machiavelli states that "there is no virtue which it is more necessary for him [The Prince] to seem to possess than this last [religion]; because men in general judge rather by the eye than by the hand..." (47). Machiavelli believes that a successful Prince needs to only portray himself as virtuous because humans are naturally short-sighted and will judge by appearance rather than knowing the Prince and his true intentions. The intentions of any successful Prince must be for the sake of keeping power. On the contrary, Aristotle believes that humans practice virtues because embracing them are what it means to be happy. In this essay then, I will present a response that Aristotle would make to Machiavelli's claim above by examining each of their positions on the subject of virtue. Machiavelli thought virtues were one's desirable strengths or admirable characteristics that one should only use to take advantage of a given opportunity and further secure his end goal of power. When speaking of princedoms acquired by one's own arms and merit, Machiavelli states, "we shall see they were debtors to Fortune for nothing beyond the opportunity which enabled them to shape things as they pleased" (Prince, 13). Such is the case in Moses and the people of Israel. Moses was given an opportunity to free the enslaved and oppressed Israelites who were under the control of the Egyptians. Much like any leader who has acquired his princedom through...

Find Another Essay On Virtue: A comparitive essay of Aristotle and Machiavelli

The Myth of Perfection, semi-philosophical comparitive essay comparing "A Doll's House" by Ibsen and "The Metamorphosis" by Kafka

1314 words - 5 pages Perfection is a much sought-after quality, yet is completely impossible to obtain. Because we do not have a clear definition of what perfection truly is, when a person attempts to become 'perfect', they are usually transforming into what seems to be perfect to . In both 'A Doll's House' and 'The Metamorphosis', we see that human beings cannot achieve a state of total perfection. When Gregor Samsa, from 'the Metamorphosis', attempts to be the

A Comparison of Plato and Aristotle.

1892 words - 8 pages Plato and Aristotle, two philosophers in the 4th century, hold polar views on politics and philosophy in general. This fact is very cleverly illustrated by Raphael's 'School of Athens' (1510-11; Stanza della Segnatura, Vatican), where Plato is portrayed looking up to the higher forms; and Aristotle is pointing down because he supports the natural sciences. In a discussion of politics, the stand point of each philosopher becomes an essential

A comparitive essay between the representations of evil in; Lord of the flies by William Golding and Dr Jekyll and Mr Hyde by Robert Louis Stevenson

2326 words - 9 pages themes. Through this essay I aim to show how each of the authors explore the good and evil within man, then compare and contrast the way in which they present their ideas and finally summarise the story styles in the conclusion.The answer to the above question, how do the writers explore the themes of good and evil within man is of course different with each author. Golding uses lots of symbolism, everything connected with the book is symbolising

"Aristotle on Business Ethics" is a short essay on the ideas of Aristotle and how they may apply to the business ethics which we hold today.

1023 words - 4 pages corporations and partnerships would have the same basic mindset to work for one another for the sake of satisfying others and the whole community.Finally, one may wonder how human beings are to reach the happiness and live ethical lives which was mentioned previously in this essay. Aristotle believes that it is part of human nature and human need to be ethical. It is the role of a human being to fulfill one's potentiality and turn this potentiality

Analyzing Dante and Machiavelli´s Characteristics of a Good Leader

2115 words - 8 pages virtues and morals one is strong enough to stand by. The difference between Dante and Machiavelli’s understanding of human is also revealed through different ideas on the concept of charity and generosity, while Dante considers this a virtue, Machiavelli considers it an unproductive way to run a state. Machiavelli argues that it is great to have a generous reputation but once again, a Prince should not practice generosity and charity virtuously

An essay outline for a comparitive essay with the books "Frankenstein" and "Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde"

647 words - 3 pages Essay OutlineThesis statement: Both the creature and Mr. Hyde are not fully responsible for their brutal actions, are underestimated by their creators, and are forced to endure harsh consequences in order to protect society from their creators' bad judgment.Paragraph # 1 -"There were none among the myriads of man that existed who would pity or assist me..." (Shelley 137) .'F' speaking (society prejudice)"It was but for one minuet that I saw him

Comparitive Essay - the nerd, the jock, and the average man

674 words - 3 pages is very orderly, and his perfect management of his priorities and time have put him ahead of his competitors. Perfection and wealth are his two best buddies. Having been picked on during his high school years, he now cares not what other people think of him as long as he achieves no less than a perfect job. Also because of this, the nerd has developed an inward personality; he socializes solely to his own friends and has trouble grasping the

Machiavelli vs. Thoreau (Compare and Contrast Essay)

1040 words - 4 pages The way one should govern and the way for one to be governed will always be an ongoing struggle. How can a government maintain order and the safety of its people yet at the same time preserve its citizens' natural right to be free? The ideas from Niccolo Machiavelli, an Italian aristocrat, who published "The Prince" in 1513 for a Medici prince as a guideline on how to rule a country, gives a conservative approach to how one should govern. Henry

Poetry Comparitive Essay with the Discourse of Death.

1932 words - 8 pages sonnet X delves into the discourse of death. Although it was published in 1633, three years after his passing, Michael J. Cummings (publisher of a study guide website said it was thought to be written in around 1601 - 1610. It was around that time there was much death looming in London and this undoubtedly would have had some influence on why this poem was written. For example in 1603 London was hit with the bubonic plague

Utopia by Sir Thomas More this is sort of a comparison essay on More and Machiavelli but it is moer about More and his book, Utopia.

1061 words - 4 pages Would you like to see a society in which police would be unnecessary, politicians would be honest, and money would cease to exist? Or would you like to see a society in which political conduct operates independent of ethics, thus disregarding moral authorities such as classical philosophy and Christian technology? In retrospect the choice then comes down to Sir Thomas More or Niccolò Machiavelli. During a time where classical Greek and

This is a comparitive essay of the the novels, John Steinbeck's "The Pear"l and H.G Wells' "The Invisible Man". It shows how money, power and greed lead to one's downfall

1725 words - 7 pages extremity in the actions they commit and eventually succumbing to insanity.Greed, the excessive desire to acquire or possess more than one needs or deserves, is part of human nature and if controlled properly can be helpful in the legitimate pursuit of wealth. However, when it gets out of hand, it can consume and ruin lives. Kino finds this out the hard way through the death of his son, Coyotito. The dream for a prosperous future, despite the

Similar Essays

Aristotle: His Messages Of Virtue And Moderation In Politics

1409 words - 6 pages Aristotle (b. 384 - d. 322 BC), was a Greek philosopher, logician,and scientist. Along with his teacher Plato, Aristotle is generallyregarded as one of the most influential ancient thinkers in a numberof philosophical fields, including political theory. Aristotle wasborn in Stagira in northern Greece, and his father was a courtphysician to the king of Macedon. As a young man he studied inPlato's Academy in Athens. After Plato's death he left

The Virtue Of Generosity By Aristotle

1408 words - 6 pages In Nicomachean Ethics, generosity is the third virtue Aristotle examines. He directly addresses the idea of generosity to be the mean of wealth, meaning anything whose worth is measured by money. As presented by Aristotle, generosity is the intermediate of wastefulness and ungenerosity, wastefulness being the excess and ungenerosity being the deficiency. This virtue however, does not come naturally; generosity can arise through habit and takes

This Essay Is A Comparitive Essay Which Lays Out The Movements Of Post Impressionism, Cubism, Surrealism, And Dadaism.

1303 words - 5 pages Post-ImpressionismDuring the post-impressionism movement, an emphasis was taken away from the typical naturalism that flooded the impressionist movement. Colors were caked on the pieces with the idea that the colors would inspire certain feelings in the viewer. Blue colors were to be considered a cool color and red colors are warm. Colors during this movement not only brought out the moods of the viewers but also brought ideas. Red was

A Comparison Of Plato And Machiavelli

2537 words - 10 pages individual does what he does best for the interests of the common good and where the ruler is a philosopher king, this in turn leads to the manifestation of justice. It is relevant to clarify that the definition of virtue, common good and justice is different for each author.Plato and Machiavelli differ from methods of obtaining knowledge.Plato used more or reasoned approach while Machiavelli used an empirical approach. While Plato was aiming for