Virtue Ethics Approach Essay

1011 words - 4 pages

1. Identify the main pros and cons of a virtue ethics approach?
The virtue ethics approach is a theory that suggests that people are judged via their character, not specific actions. An individual who has developed good character traits (virtues) is judged as a morally good person. An individual who has developed bad character traits (vices) is judged as a morally bad person. Most of us have a mixture or virtues and vices. There are many pros and cons linked to this approach. The pros include
a. Emphasis on pleasure and emotion – it is good that we should enjoy acting virtuously
b. Moral education – being moral is a developmental process
c. Consideration of life as a whole – “One swallow does not make a spring” (Aristotle, 1976)
d. No decision procedure – moral decision making is too complicated to have a single criterion for decision
The Cons are:
a. It Offers no solution to specific moral dilemmas
b. Not everyone has the equal opportunity to develop morally – do we judge them the same?
c. Many non-virtuous people live happy lives, many virtuous people are miserable
d. Cultural relativism – whose virtues are best?
e. We recognise that some non-virtuous people are useful in our society; life would be dull without them

2. What are the strengths of using a virtue ethics approach to resolve your case study?
One of the desirability of virtue ethics is the elasticity to measure each situation independently, searching for action guidance in bearing in mind what a naturally virtuous person would do. This would be clarified and informed by the pertinent facts and personal ethical sensitivities of that situation. This permits and heartens creative resolutions to very difficult problems, which may be harder to discover when affecting rules and principles. For example, the adult patient in our case was diagnosed wrongly for a certain condition and subsequently treated using the wrong diagnosis. She trusts the original diagnosis and refuses a second treatment. The hospital is an institution that should be careful since it is trusted. Medical staffs are usually accorded with virtues like compassion and trustworthiness. Looking at these facts, the moral assessment might be quite different. The doctors may deduce that a different course of action would be virtuous.
3. What are the limitations / disadvantages of using this approach?
The approach offers no solution to the specific moral dilemma within this case. The difficulty with virtue ethics is that it does not openly specify which deeds are virtuous. What may appear virtuous to one individual may not be to the next. Everybody has their own suggestion of virtue in whichever circumstances once it is assessed, and even if they act with good objectives, it may not bring out the best in the circumstances.

4. A. For your critique use your own experience of applying virtues PLUS what does the literature say?
B. Does the literature support your assessment of the approach?...

Find Another Essay On Virtue Ethics Approach

Virtue Ethics' Application to Business Ethics

2410 words - 10 pages approach to ethics which relies on universal principles, results in a rigid and inflexible moral code, which we are obliged to follow as moral agents. These rigid rules are counterproductive because they oblige people to follow a certain way. Proponents of virtue ethics would argue in our secular society people don’t want to have a lawgiver, rather to make their own informed choice. Particularly in Kant’s ethics is a certain

Global Ethics: The Personal Philosophy of an American Expatriate

2173 words - 9 pages ). New perspectives in healthcare ethics: An interdisciplinary and crosscultural approach. Upper Saddle River, NJ: Prentice Hall. The University of Birmingham. (2010). Global ethics. Retrieved from http://www.globalethics.bham.ac.uk/aboutglobalethics.shtml Ward, S.J.A. (2009). Researching ethics. Retrieved from http://www.journalismethics.ca/research_ethics/approaches_to_ethics.htm Velasquez, M., Andre, C., Thomas Shanks, S.J., & Michael J. Meyer. (2010) Ethics and virtue. Retrieved from http://www.scu.edu/ethics/practicing/decision/ethicsandvirtue.html

Computer Ethics

967 words - 4 pages instance utilitatianism, Kantianism, or virtue ethics to issues regarding the use of computer technology. From a different perspective however, Computer Ethics can be viewed as very inclusive and broad, by including standards of business practices, code of conduct and public policy.In industrialized nations, technology has touched and modified many aspects of life; for instance, banking, shopping, medical care, employment and entertainment. In some

Ethics and Moral Reasoning

2105 words - 8 pages Aristotle's Virtue Ethics Aristotle in his virtue ethics states that a virtuous individual is someone with ideal traits. These characteristic traits normally come from an individual’s innate tendency but should be cultivated. After they are cultivated, these character traits supposedly become stable in an individual. Moral consequentilaists and deontologists are normally concerned with universal doctrines that can be utilized in any situation

Ethics: The Human Imperfection of Greed

993 words - 4 pages An ongoing problem in the United States and other countries are issues dealing with ethics. Many philosophers throughout the centuries have created works and theories on ethics, among them Socrates, Plato and Aristotle. Ethics may generally be defined as the study of morality (Cohen, p. 17). Aristotle on Nicomachean Ethics said Virtue… being of two kinds, intellectual and moral, intellectual virtue in the main owes both its birth and its

Linda Zagzebski: A Virtue Based Definition of Knowledge

1211 words - 5 pages must entail the virtue for it to be virtuous. Intellectual and moral virtues are defined within ethics. Ethics is the background in which Zagzebski’s definition is based. Zagzebski’s definition satisfies the desiderata within the scope of knowledge, which ranges from low to high-end epistemology. The Gettier problem is satisfied because the arrival to the truth is not accidental. The method of arriving to the truth is virtue based which

Nicomachean Ethics by Aristotle

1510 words - 6 pages example of bravery; a person had to have acted brave in a scenario to learn what it meant to in fact be brave. He also shows that society must first had to learn about what defines bravery to determine that a man is a coward. Thus, there is a scale, too much and too little, and the man who attains virtue is in perfect balance of the two extremes, which he deems vices of society. To sum Aristotle up in terms of his explanation of morals and ethics

Ethical Perspectives

1229 words - 5 pages right. One thing about the Greek concept of virtue (areté), which is also means excellence, is that it does not separate an individual's ethics from one's occupational ability. Both Plato and Aristotle used many examples of doctors, musicians, coaches, rulers, etc. to talk about the relationship between moral and professional excellence. Aristotle wrote, "Every excellence brings to good the thing to which it is the excellence and makes the

Ethics Game Simulation

878 words - 4 pages aspect, and tend to have a broad acceptance. People judge others more on their morals than their values. This would fit to the second case, which I had to find which option would make others happy. Whatever I choose there, they would have thought of me either as moral or immoral. "Virtue ethics is currently one of three major approaches in normative ethics. It may, initially, be identified as the one that emphasizes the virtues, or moral

Business Ethics

1441 words - 6 pages . The common sense philosophy of ethics should be implemented until the areas being discussed exceed the guidelines for altruism (Markkula Center for Applied Ethics, 2008). Utilitarian views produce the greatest balance between good and evil, or good over harm, while the rights approach is founded on beliefs that humans should have the choice to live their lives as they see fit

Ethics Awareness Inventory Analysis

789 words - 3 pages because they are attending UOP for an education and they want to learn.Equity is an ethical perspective that I relate to in the least. In this approach to ethics all attempts to plan social order are challenged. The rules and codes of ethics cannot be trusted from day-to-day. The correct choice for a particular situation and at a particular time may be different then it was yesterday and it is likely to evolve from several viewpoints. The reason that

Similar Essays

Advantages To A Rigorous Approach To Environmental Virtue Ethics

1854 words - 7 pages integrates the assumptions into the theory allowing people to more easily evaluate the claims. This is only a brief exploration of the advantages of taking a virtue-based approach for developing a system of environmental ethics. There may be other advantages to the virtue-based approach and there are also possible disadvantages (such as the possible challenges of translating virtues and vices into legal and political environments), but I believe this

Virtue Theory Essay

2522 words - 10 pages or character) rather than specific rules of conduct.Contemporary Virtue TheoryIn Western Philosophy, virtue ethics was the prevailing approach to ethical thinking in the ancient and medieval periods. However, this tradition was largely ignored during the early modern period as Aristotelianism fell out of favour. In the 20th Century, it returned to prominence in western philosophical thought.AnscombeElizabeth Anscombe published a paper 'Modern

Virtue Ethics Essay

627 words - 3 pages What kind of person should I be? In dealing with the question with virtue ethics, moral dilemmas such as this question will be investigated in order to compare differences and advantages as well as problems. Ethically speaking is doing what is right and if a person in question has good character and motivation she is behaving ethically. Virtue ethics is a very different approach to the other work by Aristotle. It does not primarily

Virtue Ethics And Business Ethics Essay

2835 words - 11 pages . Macintyre claims that by moving away from the utilitarian approach, we could retreat from this ‘moral dark age’ in which he feels us humans are currently encompassed. The contrast between Utilitarianism and Macintyre’s virtue ethics can be seen – to become virtuous is a dynamic lengthy process which requires oneself to move forward, but once achieved, processes such as Utilitarianism will not be necessary. Macintyre criticises