This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Coming To Terms With Free Will

1245 words - 5 pages

Coming to Terms with Free Will

Neurobiologists would like to treat the brain as a machine, tinkering with its parts and seeing how they interact as a mechanic might with a car engine. This kind of treatment works in many ways: when neurobiologists act like car mechanics they often succeed in explaining how our mental spark plugs interact with our mental pistons, and thus can perform useful tune-ups on the brain, along with other practical achievements. But to fully understand the brain, we must admit that in certain respects it is a very unique sort of machine, and one which raises problems unsolvable by car mechanic strategies. Perhaps the most subtle and difficult of these problems is the question of free will.

What is free will? It seems most scientists and philosophers can agree that free will is simply an organism's control over its own response to stimuli. The creators of such a definition would imply that the behavior of free-willed organisms is neither strictly determined nor random. But what is the difference between these three types of behavior? Before we dig ourselves any deeper in this pit of complex ideas, we should first make a certain distinction. Scientists differ with most philosophers on one facet of their method of inquiry: the former believe that data must be objective and public, while the latter feel that premises from rational introspection make up a portion of sound logic. Thus almost all scientists ascribe, unwittingly or not, to a faction of philosophy of mind which calls itself "behaviorism" and posits that the only valid way of examining mental states is in the behavior of other organisms. While this is a hefty claim, it is fairly useful in making sense of ideas about free will, and so I will momentarily put myself into behaviorist shoes.

Because mental control over one's actions is fundamentally an internal, private mental state, behaviorists lack a method to prove or disprove free will. However, new ideas in science do manage to leave room for its possibility. The Harvard Law of Animal Behavior states: "Under carefully controlled experimental circumstances, an animal will behave as it damned well pleases." While this at first appears to be a mere expression of frustration, it carries hidden significance. Animal behavior is impossible to predict beyond certain boundaries. While we can say with certainty that a dog, when asked about his favorite television show, is certain not to respond, we cannot say whether he will scratch himself or begin panting, even if our understanding of his brain and his environment is very extensive. Since the advent of "chaos theory," or "complex systems theory," a new understanding of behavior has risen which labels it neither random nor predictably determined. This new type is referred to as "ill-mannered determinism". It premises that in systems with a certain level of complexity and beyond, events become predictable only to a certain extent. Even if we can predict the...

Find Another Essay On Coming to Terms with Free Will

What's the Problem with Free Will?

1007 words - 5 pages Free Will This planet contains many forms of life from the birds in the air to the fish in the sea and everything in between. Each with their own set of instincts governing functions, primarily those of reproduction and survival. As humans, we believe that we are different; that we posses a capacity for higher-level brain function that allows human activity outside the parameters of primal, base instinct. As evidence, mankind has been able to

Where will the employment opportunities for people with disabilities be created in the coming years?

2831 words - 12 pages excluded for the labour market (CSO, 2011). This essay poses a number of sub questions – when discussing where employment opportunities for people with disabilities will be created in the coming years, how these employment opportunities will be created must also be considered. It is also necessary to explore some of the barriers that are currently inhibiting progress towards increasing employment levels among people with disabilities. Why is work

Where will the employment opportunities for people with disabilities be created in the coming years?

1394 words - 6 pages programme. Learners will have an opportunity to transfer to a programme leading to a FETAC certificate at the same level or progress to a programme leading to a FETAC certificate at a higher level with this provider or another provider. The learner will also have the opportunity to proceed straight into the job market. 9. LEARNER PROFILE This programme is aimed at early school leavers with a mild/borderline intellectual disability. The programme

Coming from Hong Kong adapting to live in Britain will be easy


The following Essay will aim to explain in terms of psychological study why familiarity is attractive

567 words - 2 pages people becoming friends is how close they live to each other. This is because it is much easier to get to know them as you will see them regularly. This then leads to the exposure effect. So therefore the regularity of contact increases the liking or disliking of someone. Some cynics would say,‘Familiarity breeds contempt’. (Cullis etal, 1999, pg296)But many social psychologists would disagree and say the more familiar people become with someone

We tell stories to come to terms with the world to harmonize our lives within reality

1767 words - 7 pages are not about harmonising our lives with reality, but are in fact satanic deceptions, the Mystery of Babylon the great, wanting to rule the World Order with her iniquities. Theoreticians have only given credence to myth by explaining things in psychological terms so that instead of paganism dying it has again been re-born, just like Nimrod!

John Locke's Social Contract and Natural Rights Argument in Relation to Free Will

2472 words - 10 pages therefore do not have a true free will. In my opinion, the problem of the existence of free will doesn’t involve the questioning of how it could physically exist. I believe it is more important to approach the problem with this question: “Am I free to do whatever I want?” In this modern age I cannot do whatever I want because I’m bound by morality and governmental laws that limit my freedoms in the interest of the preservation of other people’s

Fate and Free Will as Key Factors Leading to the Deaths of Romeo and Juliet

3230 words - 13 pages Fate and Free Will as Key Factors Leading to the Deaths of Romeo and Juliet In this report I will try to discuss in depth why I feel that fate and free will, were indeed a key factors leading to the deaths of young Romeo and Juliet in this Shakespearian play of love and tragedy. A consistent sense of foreboding is

Essay explaining one major challenge facing organisations in the coming decades and its implications for the kind of leadership and negotiation capabilities that they will need to develop

1594 words - 6 pages described as, "A term that is distinguished from technological development, yet can refer to several different compatible concepts" (Wikipedia)The degree of technological impact to an organisation will differ depending on the sector. Examples of this may be the Production, or service industries. The world is made up of many organisations with structures based on teams, and levels of work. Organisations operate from strategic, to tactical, all the way to

The subject of free will as shown in Kafka's "The Judgement", "A Report to the Academy", and "A Country Doctor"

687 words - 3 pages P.J. O'Rourke of Rolling Stone magazine once wrote, "One of the annoying things about believing in free will and individual responsibility is the difficulty of finding somebody to blame your problems on. And when you do find somebody, it's remarkable how often his picture turns up on your driver's license." Perhaps Franz Kafka, by not believing in free will, made his own bitter existance just slightly more bearable by not having to blame

"Walklate (1998: vi) suggests Feminism and Criminology may be contradictions in terms. To what extent do you agree with her?

1708 words - 7 pages criminological perspective it has many more definitions and takes on many subcategories, for example; liberal feminism, radical feminism, socialist feminism and postmodern feminism to name the four identified by Walklate (1998).As this essay title is particularly diverse it is not possible to adequately cover all aspects or subcategories of feminism in relation to its contradictory nature to criminology therefore this essay will be based around liberal

Similar Essays

Position Paper: "Coming To Terms With America's Changing Families."

824 words - 3 pages In "Coming to Terms with America's Changing Families" the author seemed to define "family" as any married couple. In my opinion, families are married couples with children, not just a married couple. He also talked a little about some predictions that were made early on in history. The predictions were about marriage and where it was headed. The prediction that marriage is dying is mind-boggling. That is what Robert Rector a representative of

Coming To Terms With Evil In Treasure Island

3061 words - 12 pages Coming to Terms With Evil in Treasure Island Robert Louis Stevenson's novel, Treasure Island, is a fast-paced adventure tale about a boy developing into an adult and coming to terms with the presence of evil in the world. Jim Hawkins is first portrayed as a naïve and innocent child. Throughout his adventures with Long John Silver, he matures into a heroic young man. Before the pirates enter Jim's life he lives with his parents in a

The Way We Really Are: Coming To Terms With America's Changing Families

1059 words - 4 pages family values still in existence. Values vary from house to house, culture to culture. Values are not meant to be harmful. They are the principles of the social and family structure. I hope that the leaders of tomorrow have the values they will need to succeed.America's families. 5ReferencesCoontz, Stephanie (1997) The Way We Really Are: Coming to terms with America's changingfamilies. In J. Post, A. Lawrence and J. Weber (Eds.), Contemporary Business Issues withReadings (pp. 375-382, Reading 4). New York: McGraw-Hill

The Problem With Free Will Essay

1602 words - 6 pages Free will can be determined as the ability or power to choose, which can include making free choices that are unconstrained by external circumstances, Descartes identifies the faculty of will with freedom of choice, "the ability to do or not do something" (Meditation IV), and even goes so far as to state that "the will is by its nature so free that it can never be constrained" (Passions of the soul,I, art.41). On this level it is often the