This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Vouchers And School Choice More Effective Than Affirmative Action

797 words - 3 pages

School Choice More Effective than Affirmative Action


If America is to become an equal society, then the direction of affirmative action must be changed. Rather than continuing to focus the brunt of our efforts on helping those individuals near the top succeed, we must implement policies designed to provide opportunities to those individuals at or near the bottom. Specifically, affirmative action must return to its original purpose--helping minorities move into the middle class through programs based upon equality of educational opportunity and job creation.


Affirmative action is still needed, but its efforts must be redirected. The truth is that minorities poised to break through the glass ceiling will do so, based upon sheer ability, but minorities on the bottom rungs of society need help to break through the cellar ceiling. These are the individuals for whom affirmative action can do the most good, consequently, these are the people upon whom our efforts should be focused.


When affirmative action was first instituted, the majority of Americans supported its goal of moving the poorest members of minority groups to an improved position in society. Over time, however, affirmative action proponents have lost sight of this goal. Affirmative action programs have ceased to function as a rising tide designed to lift all boats and have instead become preoccupied with helping those near the top. Too little attention has been paid to helping those at the bottom, as a result, the lives of minorities living in poverty have become increasingly bleak. Today, our inner-cities more closely resemble a war zone in Bosnia than they do an American suburb, and conditions continue to deteriorate. This is wrong, and as Americans, we have a moral obligation to improve these conditions.


Significantly improving the conditions of America's poorest minorities will require stronger, more effective policies based upon educational opportunity and job creation. For starters, the government must provide equality of educational opportunity.


Education is the key to breaking into the middle class, but the traditional educational structure institutionalizes inequality. Today, the quality of one's elementary and secondary education correlates directly with one's socioeconomic status. Children of successful parents get the better opportunities, while poor children, and almost all inner-city children, get a second-rate education. This perpetuates and widens the gulf between the haves and have-nots.


To become a truly equal society,...

Find Another Essay On Vouchers and School Choice More Effective than Affirmative Action

Housing Vouchers: More Than a Housing Solution

1736 words - 7 pages Housing Vouchers Vouchers: More Than a Housing Solution Introduction Many advocates and policymakers of housing for the poor believe that to achieve optimal human development of low-income households the location of the housing must be considered as well as the quality of the housing unit (Newman, 2008). According to Newman (2008), housing of the poor has to allow for economic independence and self-care while providing a safe and adequate

School Vouchers: Parents Need a Choice

4626 words - 19 pages student to student to teacher and worse. Therefore, how can the lawmakers of Pennsylvania’s General Assembly constitute not having a voucher program including sectarian institutions? Parents should have the choice of using their tax dollars to send their children to effective schools. These students and parents, of the Commonwealth, deserve more from their elected leaders. Pennsylvania needs to let the people vote on school vouchers, instead of hiding

Vouchers and School Choice - First Step Towards a Discriminatory Educational System

1936 words - 8 pages school district's membership could attend private school, while the next year, no more than 15% could be enrolled in private institutions. Upon enrollment, "the state superintendent shall pay to the parent or amount...equal to the private school's operating and debt service cost per pupil that is related to educational programming...The department shall send the check to the private school." Simultaneously, the program requires the

Traditional Classrooms Are More Effective Than Online Learning

2309 words - 9 pages and professors in the classroom allows personable relationships to form, which gives the student a feeling of personal connection to a class and the material taught within it. When students feel connected to a class, they will naturally be more interested, willing to learn, and willing to work hard to grasp material. In addition, when students in a traditional class feel they need more help than their professors can provide for them, they can

Corrections: Rehabilitation Is More Effective Than Retribution vs

1550 words - 6 pages assault is common, isolation is a mental challenge and the overall environment is an emotional nightmare. Prison is a very unhealthy place for anyone but even more of a detriment to our most vulnerable members of prison society; youth offenders, those with low IQ’s and mental retardation. Life without parole is in essence negating a person from existence without actually killing the individual. It is considered a mercy to be given life with the

Solar Energy is a More Effective Source Than Wind Energy

810 words - 4 pages Judging by this title, most people would probably skip reading this paper and go on to something more exciting. Don’t worry, I’m not going to try and sell something. The point of this paper is try and show the reader why solar energy is more effective. Is it possible for anybody to really prove that, or it just an opinion? Both energy sources have their advantages and disadvantages. But which one is the right one? Read on to find out more

Treatment is More Effective Than Jail for Drug Offenders

2418 words - 10 pages exceptional results. The percentage of addicts that completed the courses and stayed clean was seventy percent. Not only that but the reoffending rate of drug addicts entering the program was cut to twelve percent, compared to that of the thirty-five percent who served jail time (Riley 1). In Seattle, the numbers are not as high, but still a step in the right direction. ?More than forty percent given the chance so far have either declined, failed or

This is an evaluation of affirmative action. In the essay, I argue that affirmative action is no longer an effective means in achieving racial equality

1399 words - 6 pages would benefit. The Democratic Party platform tends to support Affirmative Action and hold the majority in most of the moralistic states.Another contributing factor to these moralistic states preserving Affirmative Action are their elected officials, more specifically the legislators. Moralistic states tend to have more amateurs in their legislature and therefore look at policy differently than if they were to have a professional legislature. The

To what extent were Stalin’s methods in removing opposition more effective than the Tsarist and other Communist leaders between the years 1855 t

895 words - 4 pages the institution more than Lenin because Lenin stepped away from the institutions of terror and Stalin was more involved in it indicating that it was more effective in Stalin’s regime. This is evident because in Lenin’s regime the cheka had executed 844 people from December to July, which compares nothing to Stalin as he had killed 1 million to 1.5 million over four months. As well as that, Service argues that there were 12,733 prisoners killed by

To what extent is integrated positron emission tomography/computer tomography (PET/CT) more effective than PET and CT alone in preoperative assess

2024 words - 9 pages supposed to be better than conventional assessment with CT or PET alone. Nevertheless, it is necessary to indicate the occurred shortcomings. Therefore, this article will compare PET/CT with solitary CT and PET by analyzing accuracy, sensitivity, possible risks, cost-effectiveness, and limitations criteria. Afterwards, it will conclude that this method of tomography is more beneficial than others. However, there are still some areas for future

Affirmative action.Talks about how affirmative action is the reason for more diverse student bodies, while at the same time, it might be the cause for more black failure rates in colleges

1700 words - 7 pages greater(Zuckerman 64). White students often find double standards and feel they cannot fight against them. They grow in all shapes and sizes, the separate student unions, theme dorms, yearbooks, and dances(Page 258). More than two thirds of the 30 UA students surveyed did not think that this was right(Martin). Minorities appear to increase the divide, because affirmative action never promised that all students, white and black, would get along

Similar Essays

Vouchers And School Choice Beats No Choice

842 words - 3 pages maximize their learning success.   The ideal choice program, in my opinion, would comprise vouchers, drawn from the child's home district and not exceeding the average amount spent locally per student. A voucher or draft is awarded upon the completion of an in depth interview of both student and parents, guardian or assigned mentor and an interview board consisting of school board and local business representatives, and nominated tax payers

A Case For Vouchers And School Choice

1063 words - 4 pages , would be provided with an incentive to educate students as well as they possibly could; teachers who did not perform would presumably be fired. School choice once again imposes upon teachers and teachers' unions a sense of accountability noticeably absent at present.   For all the rhetoric both parties directed toward children over the past year, it is time they both do more than lament the state of American public schools. Their penchant

The Problem Of Vouchers And School Choice

1138 words - 5 pages neighborhoods have fallen so far. One problem is that our society has stopped seeing public education as something that benefits the whole community. As our populace ages, especially in small, old towns, more and more voters begrudge spending on schools, students and teachers. School board candidates, knowing who votes, campaign as "taxpayer advocates" much more often than they run as "student advocates." The voters want to pay as little as

School Vouchers: A Harmful Choice Essay

3089 words - 12 pages private institutions through the use of vouchers, America's public education system will become less effective, students from low income families will be set further behind, and the First Amendment will be directly violated. The conservative economist Milton Friedman first suggested the concept of school vouchers in 1955. He laid out a plan, "to return tax monies to parents of school-aged children for tuition use in a variety of authorized public