Vouchers Are Not The Solution For Improving Public Schools

1762 words - 7 pages

Vouchers Are Not the Solution for Improving Public Schools
Missing Works Cited

“Vouchers lead us away from the basic American tradition of a free, quality public education for every student and undermine the kind of comprehensive, systemic school reform that is working […]” (Tirozzi, 1997). This quote taken from Gerald Tirozzi, the assistant U.S. secretary of education for elementary and secondary education, sums up the issue of vouchers. Milton Friedman, a free-market theorist, introduced vouchers, which funnel public funds to private schools, more than forty years ago (Resnick, 1998).
Vouchers redirect money that would have been spent on educating a child in the public school system to a private school of the parent’s choosing. Voucher use is based on two factors, student eligibility and school eligibility. Those students who would be eligible for vouchers are among those in low-income families. School eligibility widely varies state by state. In some states school eligibility is restricted only to nonsectarian private schools, where elsewhere any private school is eligible (Resnick, 1998). Those who support vouchers offer three reasons for their position. One reason being that most public schools are failing, secondly vouchers help the children who use them, and thirdly vouchers create competition that motivates public schools to improve (Resnick, 1998). However, opponents argue that funding should be put toward improving the current public school system for the masses instead of allowing a better education to an elite few. Research is largely opposed to vouchers. Vouchers imprudently use public funds to back religious education, degrade public education, and support elitism.

Vouchers are set up such that they take money from public school funds and redirect it towards private schools and sometimes-religious education. In 1997, a Cleveland Ohio judge ruled the constitutionality of vouchers and as a result a pilot program was installed. Cleveland was torn between those who adamantly opposed vouchers and those who supported vouchers. Ron Marec, president of the Ohio Federation of Teachers, said the “$5.25 million in state funds for the voucher program this year is money being denied to the public school system” (Walsh, 1997). This is money that for those who have been in any public school know is desperately needed for a number of purchases. The same funds that are going into the pockets of private schools could have funded, textbooks, building maintenance, after school activities, fieldtrips, almost anything that would result in the betterment of the public education for a number of students. Individually, students who qualify for a voucher receive as much as $2,500 to choose from a range of voluntarily participating private schools (Walsh, 1997). Opponents say that vouchers are bad public policy because any program that includes religious schools violates federal and state constitutional prohibitions against...

Find Another Essay On Vouchers Are Not the Solution for Improving Public Schools

Schools Are For Learning, Not Fashion

539 words - 2 pages I thought school was for learning; not for a fashion show. A dress code should be required in all public schools to promote better student behavior, decrease costs to parents and increase school safety by eliminating gang-related clothing. A uniform dress code would curve discipline problems and distractions while improving overall student behavior. By requiring students to adhere to a dress code, learning will be enhanced. For this purpose

Web Filters are Not the Solution

625 words - 3 pages Web Filters are Not the Solution The scene is perfectly clear in my mind. Twelve years old and just home from an overnight stay with a friend, I walked in the door with a Sex Pistols patch on my backpack, a clip-on earring in my ear, and a cherry Kool-Aid dye job. The initial looks of shock and horror on the faces of my parents were priceless - that is until they opened their mouths. I was grounded for a month

Pesticides are Not a Solution

1821 words - 7 pages Life is easy for the modern persons. The threat of starvation is not imminent. The days of hunting and gathering are over for the vast majority of citizens thriving in developed nations. If one is hungry they need only go to one of the many supermarkets to purchase food. The day to day has been simplified in so many ways that it is not hard to understand why the base step to that simplicity would be overlooked. Why question a good thing

What are the Affects of Bullying in Public Schools?

978 words - 4 pages What are the Affects of Bullying in Public Schools? What is Bullying? Bullying is repeated, aggressive behavior by one or more people, and it harms others physically and/or emotionally. Bullies are taught and not born. There are seven different types of bullies; The Confident Bully feels good about himself, he also has a big ego and shows no empathy towards his targets. Social Bully can pretend to be caring and compassionate about his victim

Why America's Public Schools are Flawed

731 words - 3 pages America’s public schools need changed in order for students to reach their full potential. Although many people believe America’s schools are better then they have ever been, this simply is not true. For years now America’s schools have, academically, been declining due to their low standards, not enough teaching professionals who care, and their extreme emphasis on standardized testing. The public school system in America is flawed because of

Public Schools should not implement school Uniforms By: Tan Ly

795 words - 3 pages Public schools should not implement school uniforms because uniforms are a false remedy for serious underlying issues in public schools, and children's homes. We are all born different; therefore, no two people are alike. The school's biggest argument is that brand name clothing is the cause of much and teasing, and creates discipline problems in our public schools. Many school officials also believe that clothes can be distracting to someone's

Prayer Should Not be Recited in Public Schools

838 words - 4 pages Abington vs. Schempp In 1962, the Supreme Court ruled that prayer should not be recited in public schools, but then again in 1963 there were some people that said that forbidding recitation of prayer was not enough. This issue was brought to the Supreme Court in the case Abington vs. Schempp. There were four states, one of which was Pennsylvania, that required ten verses of the Bible to be read every morning, and then students had to recite

School Uniforms Are a Good Idea in Public Schools

1439 words - 6 pages percent drop in assault and battery in elementary and middle school" (S4). These students are now more focused on how to build a better future for them. By putting on uniforms in public schools, there are so many students now more focused on their work instead of teasing or bullying. The opposing side argues that school uniforms should not be legalized in public school because there are no ways to express the inner being of one's true self. The

What should the government do about segregation in our public schools today? Does it matter to you, that students often attend public schools that are populated only by students of their own race?

665 words - 3 pages removed.National governments can try to do what they did not do back in the seventies. The national governments should pass laws to give state and local governments' power to try to help desegregate the public schools. One of the laws could be for example, that all state governments have the power to come into the public schools and see how the classes are sorted. If they come in and see that some classes are only filled with a single race then they can go

Reinventing the Corporation: Companies which have lost their moral values and feel they are not responsible to the American public anymore

1114 words - 4 pages Reinventing the CorporationOur corporations today have lost a lot of their moral responsibilities. I think some believe they are no longer accountable. They believe they can do whatever they want, whatever is going to make the largest profit, regardless of the consequences to their workers or to the public. The larger companies especially, are not generally responsible for much that they do. You will see every now and then that a company will be

"The term 'open society' has come into use in recent times. Are public libraries essential components of open societies? Why, or why not?"

1853 words - 7 pages government is elected by the citizens of that country. Intellectual freedom is important to citizens of a democracy because if they are to elect the government that best represents them they need to make a fully informed choice.Why is a public library essential to an open society?How is the role of a public library in an open society different to that of an academic library or other special libraries? Academic and special libraries do not provide

Similar Essays

School Vouchers Are Not The Solution

1178 words - 5 pages is that private schools are more successful than public schools. This idea is misleading as well. To date, there is no statistical data that shows private schools are achieving at a greater level than students in public schools. The reason for this can be several fold. First, we have the issue of accountability; second, we have the issue of the liberty of private schools to pick and choose their students; and third, private schools are not

America’s Failing Public Schools: Charter Schools Are Not The Solution

1955 words - 8 pages America’s Failing Public Schools: Charter Schools Are Not the Solution   It was with wild fanfare that the state’s Republican legislature and Republican Governor enacted their reforms for the state’s public school system. Among the panaceas was charter schools, a ‘90s education fad that gives individual parents the right to send their children to state-approved public charter schools at public expense. Politicians reasoned that less

School Vouchers Are The Solution Essay

1673 words - 7 pages the administration of schools. In a famous 1955 essay, he argued that there is no need for government to run schools, instead the government can partake in welfare by taking care of education through the provision of vouchers. Friedman believed that such a system will encourage competition, improve the quality, lower costs and thus will create a more dynamic education system (3). So, what are other factors that make the education-market so

Public Schools Are The Problem, Private Schools Are The Solution

1060 words - 4 pages schooling over public because public schools are not meeting their children’s academic, individual, and special education needs.      First, parents expect that their children will know how to read, write, and acquire basic math skills by the time they graduate. However, public schools throughout the United States are failing to teach these basic academic skills. The French Commission for American Education reported that: "If there be a nation