W102 Tma01 Civil Law Vs Criminal Law Open University Essay

1177 words - 5 pages

Question 1
Explain the differences between a common law system and a civil law system.
The main difference between the two systems is that in common law countries, case law is of primary importance, whereas in civil law systems, codified statues predominate. (Piyali Syam, 2014) I’m going to focus on three main differences which are considered to be the most important, then briefly cover other differences.
Civil law is said to be codified, as opposed to the common law which is uncodified. When something is codified it basically means that it has been written down somewhere and that all of the “rules” have all been collected somewhere. For example, the UK is said to be uncodified because all of the laws that we operate by are not collected in a single place. The laws of England and Wales have all been written down such as when an act is passed by parliament or when the court hands a decision down. The act and the decision are both written down, however, they are not all found in one place and this is why common law is uncodified.
The next point I would like to make is that judicial precedents are set to be binding in common law jurisdictions. This means that similar cases should be treated similarly. Lower courts have to follow the decisions that were made by upper courts, and matters that are dealt with in one specific way if in the past the facts are the same. With that being said, judicial precedents are not so important in civil law jurisdictions because the decisions haven’t been reached solely through the judges' own interpretation. The judges' role during civil law jurisdictions is to establish facts, ask questions, demand evidence, and to apply the provisions of the applicable code. Also, the opinions and views of the jury don't have to be unanimous as they are almost never involved in civil actions. Although they use their expertise they are not considered to be as “creative” as common law judges. The judges' role in common law jurisdictions is, to some extent, create the law and to interpret the statutes passed by parliament. Their role is therefore active and “creative” as opposed to civil law judges more passive approach. This is why judicial precedent is considered to be more important in common law countries than in civil law countries.
The final difference is that common law jurisdictions are more case law reliant and work a lot around custom and practice. In contrast, civil law jurisdictions are more reliant on legislation and constitution.
Question 2
Explain what legislative competence means in relation to devolution in the United Kingdom, including a relevant example from Scotland or Northern Ireland.
The word “devolution” refers to the process designed to decentralise a government and give more powers to other places. For example, the United Kingdom is obviously made up of England, Ireland, Scotland, Wales, and Northern Ireland. So in the process of devolution in the UK, the powers have been transferred from the UK parliament in...

Find Another Essay On W102 TMA01 Civil Law vs Criminal Law - Open University - Essay

civil law Essay

476 words - 2 pages ALI / UNIDROIT Principles of Transnational Civil Procedure Ukrainian national litigation 27. Appeal 27.1 Appellate review should be available on substantially the same terms as other judgments under the law of the forum. Appellate review should be concluded expeditiously. 27.2 The scope of appellate review should ordinarily be limited to claims and defenses addressed in the first-instance proceeding. 27.3 The appellate court may in the


1156 words - 5 pages Civil law is concerned and deals with the relationship between individuals and relates to civil rather than criminal wrongs with the aim of compensating the suing party for such wrongs (Gibson, Rigby, Ryan & Tamsitt, 2001, p28.1). A civil action is generally brought by the party who has been injured or otherwise suffered some form of loss as the result of a wrong which only directly affected him (e.g. trespassing into private property). When

Criminal and Civil Law in the English Legal System

1893 words - 8 pages impact on society itself. For example: a murder, theft or rape. Criminal law is dealt with in the Magistrates court and if very serious in the Crown court. It is said to be more difficult to win a case in the Magistrates court and Crown court than in a civil court as in a magistrates and crown court the evidence has to be proved beyond doubt and in a civil court evidence can be proved on a balance of probabilities

Natural Law and Civil Law

963 words - 4 pages Leviathan as bearer of supreme authority and nationals who posses certain inalienable rights. We should draw attention to Hobbes’ reasoning about natural law and civil or positive law. According to Hobbes they both match with scope, form and content. However, natural law, which is impartial, equitable, legitimate, and moral in natural state is not the law itself; it just disposes people to peace, mercy, and obedience. Natural law is the laws

Criminal Law Basics

1620 words - 6 pages “ Criminal law is the body of law that relates to crime.” (Wikipedia, 2014) This law encompasses several different aspects of our government and the ways used to regulate them. Maintaining the peace and order of the public is one aspect. Law enforcement officers also try to keep good conduct of the public. Anyone who places the safety of the public in jeopardy, is in violation of this law. Punishment is used in a variety of ways

International Criminal Law

852 words - 4 pages International criminal law What is Criminal Law? With the passage of time, people are becoming more and more cognizant of the fact that various nations have faced heavy losses due to conflicts amongst them. Today, world’s so called super powers are deeply in favor of adopting and implementing International Laws, which give details regarding the rights and obligations of the respective countries along with methods of dealing with each other

Politics and Criminal Law

1540 words - 6 pages Most Americans believe that criminal law drives criminal punishment. However, due to their lack of knowledge about the criminal system, they are wrong. At least according to a Harvard Law School Professor, William J. Stuntz. In his essay, The Pathological Politics of Criminal Law, he focuses on how criminal codes are misleading and filled with overlapping crimes. The rules are simply too broad, which often makes them morally wrong and socially

Criminal Law Case Study

1892 words - 8 pages 13th Edition, Oxford University Press HERRING, J (2001) Criminal Law 7th Edition, Palgrave Macmillan ORMEROD, D. (2011) Smith and Hogan’s Criminal Law 13th Edition, Oxford University Press Online Resources Criminal Evidence (2010) [Online] Available from - http://crimeandevidence.wordpress.com/category/stuart/ [Accessed 7th March 2014] E-Law resources, Causation in Criminal Liability [Online] Available from - http://www.e-lawresources.co.uk/Causation-in-criminal-liability.php [Accessed 8th March 2014] Law Teacher, Homicide – Murder [Online] Available from - http://www.lawteacher.net/criminal-law/cases/murder.php [Accessed 8th March 2014]

Concepts of criminal Law

2016 words - 9 pages button to open the gate at the Tate crime scene which had a bloody fingerprint on it, this sloppiness from law enforcement tampered the evidence at the crime scene making it unusable. The police officers that investigated the crime scene of the Tate murders made even more mistakes like  mixing their footprints with the bloody footprints that were found at the crime scene. There was also issues involving analyzing the blood samples from the crime

Criminal Law Investigation

640 words - 3 pages Criminal Law InvestigationMurderMurder is when a person of sound mind unlawfully kills any person with malice aforethought.To be convicted of murder, it has to be proven that the accused planned to kill the victim, or that the accused acted in a way that he/she knew would harm or kill the victim.To defend against murder, one could claim self-defence, that is, that they killed the person while defending themselves, if this was proven, the accused

Learning Criminal Law and English Common Law

1034 words - 5 pages On this first week I learned so much about how criminal law is evaluated, organized, and made. Also I learned about the English common law includes legislation, and a multitude of other legal norms that help on the evaluation of criminal laws, such as federal and state constitutions that are based on congress and state legislatures. It also includes how the lawmakers are made or changed by the judicial powers of review and how the judicial

Similar Essays

Criminal Law Essay

779 words - 4 pages which are related to the pertinent which the respondent proclaims, or which look to the tribunal, to be photojournalists, written or dramatic stuff (or to execute any relationship parallel to those materials): (a) The degree to which; (i) Has already or about to become accessible to the audience; or (ii) Is going to be of benefit to the audience (b) Any applicable law for the audience privacy. (5) This section says that – court composed of a tribunal; and a ‘relief’ composes of cures or law (other than in criminal lawsuit).

Criminal Law Essay

1982 words - 8 pages consistent decisions.________________________________________Bibliography________________________________________Books-Ashworth, A. (2004) Principles of Criminal Law (4th ed., Oxford University Press)-Elliott, C. & Quinn, F. (2004) Criminal Law (5th ed., Longman)-Herring, J. (2004) Criminal Law (4th ed., Palgrave Macmillan)-Martin, J. (2004) Comprehensive Guide to Criminal Law (2nd ed., Hodder & Stoughton)-Ormerod, D. (2004) Smith &amp

The Difference Between Civil Law And Criminal Law

979 words - 4 pages means that a judge or jury must believe their story and evidence more than the defendant’s version. They do not need to be convinced beyond a reasonable doubt. Civil disputes usually involve some harm, loss or injury to one party or their property. Unlike criminal law; however, civil law is primarily involved with compensating victims. If a civil action is successful, the defendant will be responsible for the

Common Law Civil Law Essay

665 words - 3 pages is open possibilityfor the same case.'In civil law countries, legislation is seen as the primary source oflaw. Thus, courts base their judgements on the provisions of codesand statutes, from which solutions in particular cases are to bederived.' (MacQueenH.L. 2000) By contrast, in the common lawsystem, cases are the primary sources of law, while statutes areonly seen as incursions into the common law and thus interpretednarrowly.Furthermore