Wal Mart: Good Or Bad? Essay

1363 words - 5 pages

The largest corporation in America with $378,799 million in revenues and employing 2,055,000 employees, Wal-Mart has become one of the greatest success stories in American history, but also one of the most controversial stories since Standard Oil (Fortune). But with all big business comes critics. Today's critics suggest Wal-Mart unfairly uses it power of size, which is goliath, to exploit employees and impoverish nations, ruin competition, and place undue pressure on the government. However, one item most critics fail to mention is that Wal-Mart creates consumer welfare. Throughout this paper, I will analyze each criticism of Wal-Mart and sufficiently cite evidence proving the greater good that is realized with the existence of Wal-Marts worldwide.Wal-Mart Costs JobsCritics of Wal-Mart and other big-box discount stores argue that jobs are lost due to two reasons: First, local retailers and other local businesses are forced to close as a result of the inability to compete with the lower prices. Second, the selling of foreign goods by Wal-Mart cuts revenues for domestic nonretail industries which in turn causes layoffs. Contradicting evidence, however, shows that "employment rose nearly 3 percent in the general merchandise store category" during the 2000 to 2004 time period; a period in which national employment was slowing declining (Vedder). In addition, Vedder and Cox performed a study involving sixteen different statistical tests measuring the relationship between job growth and the presence of Wal-Mart. The study concluded with only five tests showing a negative relationship and eleven with a positive relationship. If true, than how can Wal-Mart be responsible for the loss of jobs?Furthermore, critics would have the public believe that the greater number of Wal-Marts means the greater percent of unemployment. But as Vedder and Cox found, the unemployment rate declined throughout the transformation of Wal-Mart's presence in the United States from a relatively small presence in 1984 to a large presence in 2004 (Vedder). Of course, other factors could be the reason behind the coincidence, but for as strongly as the critics contend, the evidence seems to at least prove that Wal-Mart does not hurt job employment. Emek Basker, an assistant professor at the University of Missouri, concluded from his study that between 1977 and 1999 that for every Wal-Mart store established, the net gain in job employment was approximately fifty jobs (Job-Creation). In conclusion, the evidence sufficiently proves the mere opposite of what critics would have one believe.Wal-Mart Pays Low Wages and Exploits EmployeesLabor unions and critics continue to portray Wal-Mart as an exploiter of employees. However, when asked, employees showed no disdain towards Wal-Mart and recently voted against, in a lopsided fashion, the unionization of Wal-Mart, according to Vedder and Cox. Still, the labor unions continue to publish criticizing material on the internet, in movies, and...

Find Another Essay On Wal-Mart: Good or Bad?

Technology Good Or Bad Essay

1310 words - 5 pages Technology, Good or Bad? Imagine a world in which everything was run by computers, a society in which everything revolves around computers and makes everything hands free. This may sound like something that you dream about, but technology is reaching new levels daily. To some people this may sound amazing, but it also strikes fear into many people. A hands free society would make life a lot easier, but what happens when something goes wrong. The

Wal-Mart- How they got their start and bad reputation from employees, this article entails, lawsuits, timeline,and discrimination.

677 words - 3 pages The first Wal-Mart variety, opened in 1962, by Sam Walton in Rogers, Arkansas .The Superstore Giant now sells almost everything!. Although Wal-Mart began as a small variety store; within five years, Wal-Mart had opened an additional 23 stores with a total of 12.6 MM in sales. In May 1971, Wal-Mart acquired their first 100 percent stock split and listed on the NYSE one year later, within months, again Wal-Mart had yet another 100 percent stock

Yoga is Good or Bad?

574 words - 2 pages Yoga seems to be moving into the public eye much more these days. From breakfast-cereal ads to Oprah, we are seeing subtle appearances of yoga in the media. This has sparked a debate about how good or bad this commercialization for yoga. Here are some thoughts---and an invitation to share your opinion as well. References to yoga are popping up in more and more places everyday. This is a sign of how the times are changing. Today, advertising for

Corporal Punishment: Good or Bad?

514 words - 2 pages Corporal Punishment: Good or Bad?There are many different ways of disciplining a child. Corporal punishment is one of the main ones. Corporal punishment is defined as intentionally inflicting pain on the body for purposes of punishment or controlling behaviour. Corporal punishment comes in different forms, there is teachers punishing students as discipline, and then there is the most common form of corporal punishment which is the punishment

School Uniforms: Good Or Bad

1369 words - 5 pages School Uniforms: Good or Bad? Kelly Wiles Picture this: walking into a school and seeing that America's youth is not being judged by what they are wearing: whether their style is "cool" or not. "Uniforms are to the suburbs wildly" (Ferrandino, Newsweek). Whether students approve or not, uniforms are spreading across the nation. There are many advantages to this school clothing

Is Change Good or Bad?

567 words - 2 pages Myra SmithRobin ThomasEnglish 11023 October 2014Is Change Good or Bad?Most people are not satisfied with the life that they live. However, most people are afraid of change in their life. Almost all change is good, though in the short story, "A Rose for Emily," written by William Faulkner, Miss Emily Grierson is convinced that the type of lifestyle she lived throughout her whole life is the only correct way she should live. Throughout this story

is war good or bad

735 words - 3 pages our current president sucks, but he is far from being even close to the best president we've had over time.I think going to war isn't exactly ethical, but it is needed in times. Some countries get out of hand and bully smaller countries they can control. I feel bad for small world countries that don't have much of a military to defend themselves. That's why America acts like the world police. It's a good and bad thing though. I can see it from

war is good or bad

735 words - 3 pages our current president sucks, but he is far from being even close to the best president we've had over time.I think going to war isn't exactly ethical, but it is needed in times. Some countries get out of hand and bully smaller countries they can control. I feel bad for small world countries that don't have much of a military to defend themselves. That's why America acts like the world police. It's a good and bad thing though. I can see it from

Book Censorship: Good or Bad?

863 words - 3 pages present it. For example, a 4th grader will unquestionably hear more vulgar language on the school playground than they will in a book containing bad language. Children are probably more influenced by their peers and television than books. Although television is something that can be censored, humans can not be, so censoring books because of unsuitable language or violent/sexual scenes is ineffective.      The censoring

Are Advancements in Technology Good or Bad?

913 words - 4 pages Today the world revolves around different kinds of technology that are used for many things, some are necessary and some are not. Technology is a big part of our lives, and many would say we couldn’t live without it. Weather people like it or not technology is here, and it’s not going away. But a big question is; Is technology good or bad? Advancements in technology are bad For many reasons. Some are anyone who has a laptop can find someones

Is the national debt good or bad?

1109 words - 4 pages The National Debt Good or Bad? Spending financed not by current tax receipts, but by borrowing or drawing upon past tax reserves. Is it a good idea? Why does the U.S. run a deficit? Since 1980 the deficit has grown very big. Some say its a bad thing, and predict possible doom, others say it is a safe and stable necessity to maintain a healthy economy. In the beginning the Government only generated deficits during the War of 1812, the recession

Similar Essays

Wal Mart Great For Shoppers, Bad For Competitors

554 words - 2 pages Wal-Mart - Great for Shoppers, Bad for Competitors Wal-Mart can be a virus and a cure, since it has its pros and cons depending on the critiques perspective. From my point of view, Wal-Mart is an extremely efficient superstore, with amazing marketing skills, and coordination. However, Wal-Mart is also a bully and price decider, therefore, Wal-Mart is great for shoppers and bad for competitors. As a student; Wal-Mart is my primary resort

Competition: Good Or Bad? Essay

1197 words - 5 pages that he or she is the true victor. The victory was bought using money and so it is actually not worth anything at all.All in all, competition is both good and bad. When competition is managed properly, it is good as it drives people to strive to be better and shows the human spirit, but when competition gets out of hand, in serious cases like war, many lives may be lost. So, competition is only good when it is managed well.There is an alternative

Decentralization: Good Or Bad Essay

1069 words - 4 pages benefits of decentralization and whether they are good or bad for an organization.DecentralizationI would hate to work for a company where I had no say in anything that happened. I'm not saying that I need to make top management decisions or decide on the organizational operations, I would like to be able to make suggestions and have input on how to improve the company or how to make things run better and more efficient. Decentralization would allow me

Technology Good Or Bad Essay

1318 words - 5 pages Josh Rucci English 112 Linshi Li Final Draft Technology, Good or Bad? Imagine a world in which everything was run by computers, a society in which everything revolves around computers and makes everything hands free. This may sound like something that you dream about, but technology is reaching new levels daily. To some people this may sound amazing, but it also strikes fear into many people. A hands free society would make life a lot easier