Wal Mart Vs. Pyramids, By Laura Carlsen

968 words - 4 pages

In “Wal-Mart vs. Pyramids”, Laura Carlsen questions the super franchises business tactics and opposes their attempt to build on the sacred, holy land that was once Teotihuacan. In her argument, Carlsen suggest that building in this area would infringe on the country’s cultural heritage, one that goes back thousands of years. Laura Carlsen gives a compelling argument against Wal-Marts’ practices in Mexico by displaying effective uses of ethos, pathos, and logos, as well as her successful use of other rhetoric appeals.
Pathos in persuasive writing involves engaging the readers’ emotion. In the article, Carlson’s use of pathos is clearly present. She uses phrases such as “phenomenal takeover”, “commercial conquest”, “alleged discrimination”, and “cultural insensitivity” to describe Wal-Mart. These are powerful words of rhetoric in the sense that this language is used to a pick a side, one against the Wal-Mart franchise. These statements also arouse emotion by personifying the company as an empire, per say, overtaking territories everywhere. This, along with the use of language, such as discrimination and insensitivity, clearly evoke a negative outlook on Wal-Mart. Carlson is also able to conjure up anger amongst the reader by showing how Wal-Mart could care less for the land they are building on, as workers “had orders to hide any archaeological relics they found.” By presenting a side for her audience to take and her jab at Wal-Mart, Laura is able to appeal to the reader’s emotion and successfully includes pathos in her persuasive argument.
Logos is a persuasive tool used to determine the logic within an argument. What evidence does the writer have for the position he or she has taken. In Wal-Mart vs. Pyramids, Carlsen describes the city of Teotihuacan and the importance to the Mexican heritage it carries. “It’s dominion stretched deep into the heart of Mayan country in Guatemala, and throughout present-day Mexico City.” “The grand human accomplishment it represents and the power of its architectural, historical and, for many, spiritual legacy is central to Mexico’s history and culture.” These statements undoubtedly support her claim that building on such sacred land would undermine and interfere with the country’s identity. The article also states that this land is “the foremost symbol of the cultures heritage” and “constitutes part of its contemporary integrity.” The evidence presented describes the importance this ancient land is to Mexico and makes a logical claim against Wal-Mart construction. Laura’s use of logos is strong and gives her argument a backbone.
Ethos is the third of the primary persuasive devices and appeals to the credibility of the writer and whether or not he or she is trustworthy. Being that she has previously studied the economic crisis in Mexico and is currently a resident of Mexico City, Carlsen immediately gains her trust among her intended audience, making the facts she state more powerful. She is also able...

Find Another Essay On Wal-Mart vs. Pyramids, by Laura Carlsen

The quest for best Aldi vs Wal-Mart

995 words - 4 pages and 4,000 locations worldwide (Aldiuscareers.com). In 1962, the store we know as Wal-Mart opened in Rogers, Arkansas. In 1983, Sam Walton opened the first Sam’s Club in Midwest City, Oklahoma. By 1988, Walton had opened the first Wal-Mart Supercenter in Washington, Missouri. Wal-Mart went global in 1991, with a Sam’s Club opening in Mexico City, Mexico. Today in 2014, Wal-Mart employs 2.2 million associates, serves 200 million customers, with

A Critical Analysis of the Article "Progressive Wal-Mart. Really." by Sebastian Mallaby

1216 words - 5 pages from sharing in these gains by keeping them in scared and in poverty. Ever since I started working at a market I then realized not only Wal-Mart excludes its employees and the poor from sharing in gains. The low paid employees at Wal-Mart will never share in gains as long as they work at Wal-Mart. Mallaby admits Wal-Mart can treat their employees and other retailers unfairly, but as a result everyone can share in the 50 billion in savings that

Nickel and Dimed by Barbara Ehrenreich Essay Title: Wal-Mart Bureaucracy

1163 words - 5 pages gives testimonials from workers saying how they sense a feeling of family at Wal-Mart. Barbara then goes into a detailed account of why according to Wal-Mart, unions are unnecessary and don't have much to offer workers. Unions require payments, and you "lose your voice" to others who do the talking for you. Furthermore, you risk losing your wages and other benefits. Another tactic used by Wal-Mart is a coined term known as "time theft." Wal-Mart does

This case study is based upon the case article by Peter A. Stanwick and Sarah D. Stanwick titled; ‘Wal-Mart: But We Do Give Them a 10 Percent Employee Discount’, in which addresses the ethical issues...

1472 words - 6 pages Case Study: Wal-MartJune 12, 2012This case study is based upon the case article by Peter A. Stanwick and Sarah D. Stanwick titled; 'Wal-Mart: But We Do Give Them a 10 Percent Employee Discount', in which addresses the ethical issues facing Wal-Mart. According to Stanwick and Stanwick (2009, p. 409), the culture "has created a number of twenty-first-century problems for Wal-Mart."SummaryThe authors' viewpoint is that of the Wal-Mart employees are

Globalization

1156 words - 5 pages thoughts on Laura Carlson's argument. She believes that Wal-Mart is a symbol of cultural insensitivity and rampant capitalism. By citing the way Wal-Mart enterprise grew, within 42 years, becoming the worlds largest enterprise, she wants to give us the impression that the corporation is looking to do more than make money, but to actually change their culture. I believe that her agenda is blinding her from the truth, which is that the people of Mexico

Wal-Mart Uses Bribery to Enter the International Market

914 words - 4 pages obtain permits and licenses to construct, operate, and manage some of the stores. One specific case to analyze is the investigation that was made by the New York Times of how Wal-Mart entered into the Mexican market. The article illustrates the things that Wal-Mart did to gain “permission” to open strategic stores, among others, in Teotihuacan, very close to the pyramids and the tourist area. According to the research, the store opened in December

Company Selection Paper

1223 words - 5 pages performance in an easy to read written format (Wal-Mart stores, Inc. 2007). Target's website however, is a little different. Target combines the information from all four reports into an annual report that is prepared every year.Wal-Mart vs. TargetWal-Mart brought in $308,945 million in sales for the 2006 fiscal year whereas Target only brought in $52,620 million. A definite drawback to Target is the number of facilities. Target only has 1,444

Wal-Mart's Positive Influence on American Businesses

1031 words - 4 pages possible, the general goal has been to increase the quality of life. Whatever it might be; health and medicine, living conditions, or food, people have always tried to improve it. Wal-Mart is simply another attempt at improving life by providing a large range of goods at lower costs than competing retailers. In turn, this produces competition between these retailers leading to improved selection and quality of product and goods, ultimately

Walmart and why it is good for

1043 words - 4 pages to increase the quality of life. Whatever it might be; health and medicine, living conditions, or food, people have always tried to improve it. Wal-Mart is simply another attempt at improving life by providing a large range of goods at lower costs than competing retailers. In turn, this produces competition between these retailers leading to improved selection and quality of product and goods, ultimately bringing the quality of life to a higher

Wal-Mart Gender Discrimination

2257 words - 10 pages decision made. I mean look at the Dukes vs. Wal-mart lawsuit that took a decade to come to a final decision and the decision turned out to be a loss 5-4. More of these lawsuits were expected to continue to come in for the next year. When Dukes was representing those 2000 women she couldn’t really show too much evidence for them seeing how she hadn’t met a lot of them and only was going by their word. When the women were told they could file

The Cause and Effect of Wal-Mart’s Marketing Power

3319 words - 13 pages positions. Enraged by Wal-Mart’s demeaning assessment of women's worth, which allotted a higher pay scale to men, Betty Dukes with the help of civil rights activists and consumer groups filed a class action suit in Duke vs. Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. Although the plaintiffs would not be able to go forward with the class action suit as the courts felt that there were too many variables in the case, she and the other women were permitted to file

Similar Essays

Wal Mart Vs. Target Essay

1783 words - 7 pages service expected at the neighborhood mom and pop store. Wal-Mart was the innovative industry leader in the development and launch of the super store concept offering a one stop shopping opportunity. Wal-Mart sells goods similar to the household staples offered by Target, however; Wal-Mart's focus has historically been on the more frugal economy minded consumer.In 2005 Target ranked in the top 20 contributors nationwide, giving back $2 million dollars

Financial Analysis Of Sears Vs. Wal Mart

5340 words - 21 pages Sears well controlled than Wal-Mart in costs and expenses. But Wal-Mart has a lower gross margin that is because Wal-Mart believes in higher volume and low mark-ups.Operating profit/salesOperating profit is for a certain period divided by revenues for that period. Operating profit margin indicates how effective company is at controlling the costs and expenses associated with their normal business operating. Refer the exhibit 1-1,We can observe

Wal Mart Vs Women Equal Opportunity Employment

1079 words - 4 pages cases. These settlements are instilling the belief in many people that they can get rich quick by suing a large company and "cashing in" on the settlement the company will pay to protect their reputation.In a case such as women vs. Wal-Mart, I believe that the only way to make this a fair settlement would be to reverse the decision to make it a class action lawsuit. I make this judgment on the basis that by making this a class action lawsuit

Unethical Business Practices By Wal Mart Essay

829 words - 4 pages responsibility for their involvement. So, one would have to think this is not due to the lack of knowledge of the practices in the factories, but the choice to ignore and not care of these practices. In 2012, Wal-Mart choose to “make payments to Mexican officials of more than $24 million noted by The New York Times and in Asia there were 90 reports within a year and half period” (Sethi) to cover situations up demonstrating that money talks