War As A Form Of A Dialog Between Cultures

1061 words - 4 pages

If we are talking about dialogue, the first thing that comes into our mind is verbal, oral dialogue. And a good example of this in contemporary cultural context is translation. However, this is fairly new form of communication and the three much earlier and older ones are: war, love and trade.

At first sight they seem to be rather different, but in fact they have a lot of common features and in real life are closely linked together. A good illustration for this is marriage, which clearly belongs to the love-discourse. But it also involves trade (the widespread tradition of "selling" brides, dowry) and war (kidnapping brides).

As I already mentioned, war is the one of the oldest and most developed forms of a dialogue between cultures. We know that in its earlier stage of development Culture does not acknowledge others beside it. At that stage Culture is directly opposed to the everything around it: we, who live in side the Culture, are human creatures and the others, who live outside our cultural context, are not. However, with further development there the need arises for communication with Others, the need for dialogue.

War is the announcing of the presence of "the Other" de facto, even before Culture has acknowledged it yet. How can we say this? It's because we can only make a war with somebody who is equal to us. We can't do battle with somebody who is weaker - this kind of action is called ´hunting´. If we make war with somebody who is much stronger than us, it's not dialogue but monologue (nuclear bomb vs. stone axes). Particularly embarrassing in a cultural context is a civil war - you can't really fight against yourself.

Now - what are the reasons for war? It seems that there are so many, but actually they can be divided into 2 groups: 1) real reasons and 2) fake reasons or, let me put it in other way, cultures can fight for resources or for ideological reasons. Basically, war for resources is almost always the main reason and ideological ones are used to only cover it up. Why is this kind of smoke screen necessary, I'll come to that little later.

Firstly, reasons based on needs for resources could be divided into three main types:

natural resources (land, forests, minerals, water)
human resources (wives, slaves)
communication (roads, rivers, mountain passes)

Secondly, ideological reasons, which basically could be divided into two main types:

religion (quite a weak reason, has reached its peak nowadays, esp. Christianity)
following the Law (most common reason)
the wrong eating habits
the wrong sexual habits

So, as I said before, the first are real reasons and the others are so called ´cover-up´ reasons. The reason for ´cover-up´ is simple. Every culture has its Law, and the first and most important prohibition is that you should not kill another human being. Even if he has better lands or a prettier wife. But - you can kill a man who is not a real,...

Find Another Essay On War as a Form of a Dialog between Cultures

Dancing as a Form of Adoration

2579 words - 10 pages our love and adoration to the Lord? This research will show how dance is and should be more encouraged as a form of adoration. The dances of the Old Testament were not a personal pleasure as a means of showing enthusiasm, they were full of gesticulations, violent leaps, or hopping in a circle, rather than graceful poses or soft rhythmic movement (MacDonald, 45). That type of movement characterized Jewish dances both of ancient and medieval

Love as a Higher Form Essay

1212 words - 5 pages Love as a Higher Form      Love has always been a sensation that has both mystified and captured humanity. It is a unique emotion and, while it means something different to everybody, it remains to all a force that is, at its purest form, always one step above mankind. In love’s ability to exist differently from person to person, one can find love to be a conglomeration of different branches. It can be said that there

Discourse Analysis: PowerPoint as a Form of Communication

2760 words - 11 pages . Replacing formal written papers as a means of transmitting information, PowerPoint is now used to convey increasingly complex ideas, to include war plans. Using the invasion of Iraq in 2003 as a case study, discourse analysis reveals PowerPoint is destroying the Army’s ability to communicate effectively. Discourse analysis “is the study of the ways sentences and utterances are put together to make texts and interactions and how those texts and

Marriage As A Form Of Justice In Measure For Measure

1505 words - 6 pages Marriage as a Form of Justice in Measure for Measure Measure for Measure has long been defined by critics as a "problem" comedy due to its nonconformity to the typical comedic formula and conventional standards of Shakespearian comedy. Not only is there an absence of romantic love, the usual bawdy jokes concerning sex take on a dark twist, conveying instead images of death and destruction. Even the four marriages in the end do not

Capital Punishment as a Form of Deterrance and Permanent Incapacitation

1216 words - 5 pages Capital Punishment as a Form of Deterrance and Permanent Incapacitation Society has always used punishment to discourage “potential” criminals from unlawful action. Since society has the highest interest in preventing murder, it should use the strongest punishment available to deter murder. The death penalty is arguably the strongest deterrent for murder and the strongest punishment for other unspeakable crimes. If murderers are sentenced to

Globalization: A Form of Colonialism

1296 words - 5 pages Colonialism was a concept of superiority of one territory over another; it was a concept that originated centuries ago. Colonialism had been put into action throughout a long line of history and did not end after World War II in 1945. Even with resistance and efforts from independent states after the war, colonialism did not disappear and continued as a dominant system. It remained and changed its form, resulted in the process of globalization

Achondroplasia (a form of dwarfism).

1592 words - 6 pages estimated to be between 1.72 and 5.75 x 10-5 per gamete per generation (Chen and Wertelecki 1995 page 5). Most infants with achondroplasia are born unexpectedly to parents of average stature. The only form of prevention is through genetic counseling, which could help parents assess their risk of having a child with achondroplasia.Although achondroplasia can be passed on to offspring, the majority of cases occur due to a new mutation. Normally parents

Racism, a Form of Dehumanization

1473 words - 6 pages “The Bad Faith of Whiteness,” Robert Birt is one such philosopher who elaborates and expands upon this term “bad faith” from which racism has the ability to stem. In Lewis Gordon’s book “Existencia Africana” he claims, “that racism is a form of dehumanization, and that dehumanization is a form of bad faith” (Gordon 85). Such a claim sums up the concept nicely, but as others have continued to write about in their works, there is more complexity

Poverty: A Form of Slavery

3262 words - 13 pages Today they say that we are free, Only to be chained in poverty -- Bob Marley This paper will discuss poverty, the different types of poverty and their definitions and who is affected by each type of poverty. It will look at the some of the major reasons why poverty exists and what causes poverty, like such things as inequality, stratification and international debt. Some of the impacts of poverty will also be analyzed from a national

The New World: A Clash of Cultures

1820 words - 7 pages their rule very similarly to that of Spain. It was a very structured and rigid rule of law. The laws effect often times included the trampling of neighboring peoples rights and land. These cultures clashed with neighboring societies and often times included war between the different peoples. Spaniards quickly discovered that they could utilize this war amongst the different societies to their advantage. Many of the native people would join the

A Contrast of Oral and Literate Cultures.

923 words - 4 pages comes to establishing a functioning society:A writing system is not a marker of civilization. There aremany major urban cultures in the world that did not employwriting such as the Andean cultures (Moche, Chimu, Inca,etc), but that didn't prevent them from building impressivestates and empires whose complexity rivals those in OldWorld" (Origins of Writing Systems).Oral Cultures depend on individuals to study within an apprenticeship system in order

Similar Essays

Humor As A Form Of Cultural Expression

1284 words - 5 pages Humor as a Form of Cultural Expression How can one look at a culture and understand its origins, its values, its accomplishments and failures? Through art, poetry, or other literary, or scientific advances? Maybe even in its political standpoints? All of these methods are acceptable. There is one I did not mention in the above list however. It can be considered trivial by some, but I think it is also important. Perhaps we can understand a

Punishment As A Form Of Behaviour Modification

2326 words - 9 pages whereas Negative punishment involves the termination of positive consequences. In order to work, either case must weaken and decrease the behaviour which preceded the application or withdrawal of the stimuli. Skinner (1953) stipulated that we must defy the urge to label a form of stimuli as “desired” or “undesired” as a whole but rather to identify them by their effect on the observed subject. Whether punishment is effective depends on the criteria

Incarceration As A Form Of Punishment

1756 words - 7 pages Incarceration is thought of as a positive form of punishment, and negative form of punishment. The opinion varies with the type of person, and their experience from jail if they have gone. Most inmates while in prison will tell you it is a horrible place that should be gone. That would allow criminals to be free and that would let them cause harm to others or other illegal activities. Incarceration was not designed to be a paradise, it is a

Prostitution As A Form Of Deviance

836 words - 3 pages Prostitution as a Form of Deviance In sociology, the term deviance refers to all violations of social rules, regardless of their seriousness (Essentials of Sociology 136). Deviance is an individual or organizational behavior that violates societal norms and is usually accompanied by negative reactions from others. According to a sociologist S. Becker, he stated that it is not the act itself that makes an action deviant, but rather how