War Poems: Totoy’s War, State Of Siege, And War Is Kind

1821 words - 7 pages

“Totoy’s War” by Luz Maranan, “State of Siege” by Eric Gumalinda, and “War is Kind” by Stephen Crane

Throughout our history, both recorded and unrecorded, there have been countless violent battles fought. From small skirmishes to full on declarations of war, humans have been involved with battling on another for all the reasons that they have. The only thing alarming is that, as time and technology progresses, the number of casualties and collateral damage have been increasing as well. In addition, the implications to the human mind, brought upon by the excessive violence, can be equally damaging. With that being said, the psychological implications brought upon by war can be reflected in several art forms, such as poetry.
War poems usually deals with how the persona of a particular poem, reacts to life altering events such as war. “Totoy’s War” by Luz Maranan, “State of Siege” by Eric Gumalinda, and “War is Kind” by Stephen Crane are just three examples of the many war poems that exist. Each of the poems conveys different messages, as well as utilizing different methods to convey the said message, despite having one common theme.
The Fear of the Children
“Totoy’s War” by Luz Maranan is easier to read poem, as compared to the other two poems mentioned. The poem is about the fear that people have during war times and how it affects various people, of all ages. The poem itself has no subliminal message that it wants to portray to its readers and is very direct with the matter of war – no use of metaphors, ironies, or difficult figurative language, whatsoever. The dramatic situation in the poem is that a child, Totoy, came to the persona asking “Is there a war?” (Maranan 2) with fear in his eyes. The persona then goes into contemplation about war in general. The persona first thinks about the situation going on in Iran and Iraq. The lines “Which side is winning, / Or being destroyed?” (Maranan 9-10) suggests that the ultimatum in war is that you can only win the war if you destroy your opponent. The persona then goes on to think about Middle East, and if anyone could explain the complexities of the decades of war and hate. The persona then leads more to the western part of the word, and talking about the “nuclear bombs in Europe” (Maranan 14) and the “extermination and massacre / In Central America” (Maranan 15-16).
The poem then ends with two questions, ideas that the poem would like to convey. The first of which was more of a general question of who started the war. The other idea would be how a child, such as Totoy, react if the persona told him that even in the country that they live, war is near. The persona’s concern in “Totoy’s War” is more on the implications of war to a child. Totoy is supposed to be an innocent child, only concerning himself with playing, yet at his young age, he is already plagued by the fear brought by war. The persona is very troubled by this fact and it is believed to be the reason why the persona was...

Find Another Essay On War Poems: Totoy’s War, State of Siege, and War is Kind

Man, State And War Essay

1101 words - 4 pages Review Man, State and War If the study of international relations has a central focus, this one is the problem of war. Kenneth Waltz, examines the ideas of major thinkers throughout history of western civilization, and explores the works of both classic and political philosophers such as St. Agustine, Hobbes, Kant, and Rousseau, and modern physiologist and anthropologist to discover ideas intended to explain war among states and related

Personification of War in "Do Not Weep, Maiden, for War is Kind"

901 words - 4 pages The personification of war in the poem “Do Not Weep, Maiden, for War Is Kind” by Stephen Crane is a major contributor to the elaborate depiction of the negative impacts that come with warfare. The inside speaker of the lyric poem states how soldiers are used to kill other soldiers and their exponentially numerous deaths unarguably affect their lovers, children and families. The complex and recognizable structure of this poem contributes to its

Conlans state of War

1182 words - 5 pages Joseph Conlans “State of War; The Violent Order of Fourteenth Century Japan” is an depth look at Japans emerging warrior class during a time period of constant warfare in Medieval Japan. His work however doesn’t revolve around the re-fabrication and in-depth analysis of battles sieged like many contemporary examinations of wars and battles won and lost. Instead the author vies to navigate the reader on journey into the warrior class’s lives and

Compare And Contrast War Poems

693 words - 3 pages The first thing, which strikes the reader is that, both poems are about war, 'The Dead-Beat' being about the First World War (this can be figured out by the word 'Hun' used to describe German soldiers in the First World War) and the second poem is obviously about Vietnam.The first poem goes into detail about a certain even in the course of the war, however the second poem is really one about the futility of war, but it has a few war scenario

The State of Nature is a State of War

1484 words - 6 pages To understand Hobbes’s argument for why the State of Nature is a State of War it is important to understand Hobbes’s meanings of the terms State of Nature and State of War. The State of Nature is the condition where mankind is forced in contact with one another in a society where there is no authority to enforce power or laws. In this state, the lack of authority encompasses the lack of political institutions and the connotations associated

Comparative analysis on: Stephen Crane's poem "War is Kind" and William Butler Yeat's "On Being Asked for a War Poem"

579 words - 2 pages Both Stephen Crane's poem "War is Kind" and William Butler Yeat's "On Being Asked for a War Poem" have varied and different techniques and the two poems best illustrate to us the sub-theme of war: emotions aroused from war.The influence of Cranes "War is Kind" was from his compassion and empathy for the everyday suffering of war victims. Even though Crane never served in the United States military, he was a journalist that covered a number of

Comparing War Poems

1270 words - 5 pages language it uses, ideas it contains and the way it is structured between both poems, which Siegfried Sasson uses to demonstrate that war is evil, and should be stopped. The theme in Died of Wounds is that soldiers become shell-shocked and go insane. They also suffer from mental and emotional scars, long after the battle, and the pain and death are unknown and unimportant to those who support the war. The theme in Suicide in

Death in 'First Death in Nova Scotia' and in 'War is kind'

819 words - 3 pages Death is a common theme in many poems. It is viewed so differently to everyone. In the poems, 'Because I could not stop for Death,' 'First Death in Nova Scotia,' and 'War is kind' death is presented by each narrator as something different. To one it is a kind gentle stranger while to another it is a cold cruel being.A kind gentleman stranger personifies death in, 'Because I could not stop for Death.' The narrator of the poem is a busy person

Poems and Songs about War-Commentary

903 words - 4 pages find different poems that show the same feelings as the poem previously mentioned. Take for instance Stephen Crane's "Do Not Weep, Maiden, for War is Kind". Crane decides to use sarcasm to get his point that war is wrong across. He is telling the people who are awaiting their lover or father or son to return from war not to cry because war is "kind". It is so "kind" to them that it takes their loved ones away for a long time and sometimes

Comparison of Three First World War Poems

1897 words - 8 pages to them. Both of the poems are trying to point out that the war is not a jolly thing for men who will come back as heroes. The reality is that most men will not arrive home at all, and the ones that will arrive home will not want to talk about their dreadful time at war. The soldiers that attended the war will be emotionally and most likely physically scared. The war should be known for its true meaning and not the fake

What similarities and differences are there between the way the theme of war is presented in the poems?

1792 words - 7 pages different idea of war. Disabled had been written against the war but in "The Charge of the Light Brigade" had been written as propaganda to Britain.In the two poems "Disabled" and "The Charge of the Light Brigade", they show different ideas about joining in the war. In "Disabled" the soldier joined the war because he wants to make his girlfriend think that he is a hero "That's why; and may be, too, to please his Meg". Here, we have a young man

Similar Essays

Stephen Crane’s Portrayal Of War In "A Mystery Of Heroism”"And "War Is Kind"

887 words - 4 pages In “A Mystery of Heroism” and “War is Kind” a short story and poem, respectively, by Stephen Crane, Crane highlights and emphasizes the aspects of war such as heroism and the irony of war. Both works take place during the Civil War and both depict scenes of battle from the war. In “A Mystery of Heroism,” Fred Collins, a soldier who is thirsty, goes to the well in the midst of battle to get water. On his way back, he sees a dying man who’s last

Reality Of War In Crane's War Is Kind And Tennyson's Charge Of The Light Brigade

1857 words - 7 pages Reality of War in Crane's War is Kind and Tennyson's Charge of the Light Brigade         An overwhelming tendency to fight and battle has plagued humankind since the dawn of the written word. Countless wars have been fought since the dawn of man and most times such conflict exists simply for its own sake with no productive end. Immense human suffering and death can be caused by conflicts that hold little logical justification. Since the

War Poems Essay

545 words - 2 pages This is a review of war poemsWarWhen reading poetry on the subject of war, one's own feelings regarding the subject are evoked. This makes it easier to feel the words and what they say to you. Crane's selection, 'War is Kind' presents a dilemma from the outset as it uses two words 'war' and 'kind' that are dissimilar. Crane then highlights acts of destruction and despair with the 'kindness' of war. He notes that a child should not weep when his

"Naming Of Parts" By Henry Reed, And "War Is Kind" By Stephen Crane

917 words - 4 pages "War...ouhh....What is it good for...absolutely nothing!" sang Edwin Starr in 1965. He felt the same vibe that both Henry Reed and Stephen Crane felt in their poems, "Naming of Parts" and "War is Kind." Although these authors may not have said it as straightforward as Starr did in his hit single "War," they still had just as much hatred of war. Both Reed and Crane have developed their perspectives on war through their writing styles, their