Was, And If So To What Extent Was Alexander The Great, Cruel?

1223 words - 5 pages

The greatness of Alexander (the Great) is often a much debated question. The importance of such debates is arguably minimal- Alexander was quite clearly a great ruler, possibly the greatest to ever live. A much more disputable question regarding Alexander is that of his cruelty throughout his reign as Macedonian King. In order to ascertain the extent of Alexander's cruelty one must analyze a number of key events which occurred during his kingship. These include the actions he took following Phillips death, Alexander's Razing of Thebes, the slaughter of Greek Mercenaries at Granicus, The Siege of Tyre and the deaths of Callisthenes, Philotas, Parmenio and Cleitus.After Alexander's father and Macedonian King, Phillip was murdered in late 336BC Alexander took numerous steps to ensure that he succeeded his father as King. Firstly, he ordered the murder of his cousin, Amyntas, who also had some claim to the throne- his father had been a Macedonian King sometime in the past. Before labeling such an act as cruel one must first understand the customs and morals of ancient Greek antiquity. Killing someone, even a relative in order to gain access to the throne was at this time not at all unusual. Indeed, Phillip himself as well as countless others killed off competitors which naturally included relatives in their quest for the Macedonian kingship.The murder of Attalus was however a completely different story. His death can be attributed, almost single handedly to drunken comments he made during the wedding feast celebrations after the marriage of Phillip, to his second wife Cleopatra. According to Plutarch, he called on the guests to pray for a 'legitimate heir', implying that Alexander was not fit to take the reigns of Macedonia because of his mother, Oylmpias's foreign blood. Attalus's murder was thus revenge taken by Alexander because of a few insults directed at him and his mother. This was undoubtedly cruel. Their was no political motive behind this. Attalus's only crime was to voice his opinion- a dangerous move in the ancient world.After the revolt of Thebes in 335BC soon after Alexander had ascended to the throne, he took numerous actions which could be regarded as cruel. Firstly he slaughtered 6000 Thebans in order to take the city- many of which were needlessly slaughtered following surrender. Though Alexander's decision to not round up his troops were probably acceptable given the circumstances. Alexander had offered the Thebans amnesty if they surrendered and handed over their leaders. But they refused, and negotiators- friends of Alexander were strung up on the walls of Thebes like animals. Anger, rather than cruelty was the state of Alexander's mind at this point.His decision to hand the fate of Thebes over to the rival Greek states who were members of the league of Corinth has been described by historian, J.R Hamilton as a 'calculated act of terrorism'. The members of the league as enemies of Thebes chose to burn it to the ground, as...

Find Another Essay On Was, and if so to what extent was Alexander the Great, cruel?

To what Extent the Progressive Movement was Successful

1275 words - 5 pages . Progressive women were also dedicated in women?s suffrage. If we didn?t have the right to vote, men would be superior and take over everything. We would not have a voice in government or the right to elect candidates for presidency. Presidential candidate Hilary Clinton would not be able to run for presidency or have ballots for her being a presidential candidate. The Progressive era was a successful movement that brought contributions to America today

To what extent was the vision of Cambodia underpinned by the ideal of a class based revolution and to what extent was it based on nationalist xenophobia?

2303 words - 9 pages Cambodia on a socialist model. But to what extent was this vision of Cambodia underpinned by the ideal of a class based revolution and to what extent was it based on nationalist xenophobia? The policies of the Communist Party of Kampuchea were built on a feeling of inadequacy based on the grandeur of the Khmer ancestry and the more recent exploitation of the country by their colonial rulers. The country's elite, whether they were rich or educated

Alexander the Great: Was He Really That Great?

1125 words - 5 pages same for the way he ruled his empire. Throughout his life, Alexander commanded great armies, but his focus was always on war and continuing his campaigns, so much that he was rarely in Macedon to rule his empire. This is further proved from the quote, “Alexander could better cope with warfare than peace and leisure…” (-) Alexander inherited his passion for war and glory from his Father, King Philip II who had originally laid the plans to conquer

To what extent was the Civil War an important watershed in US social and economic history?

1749 words - 7 pages The period in American history prior to the Civil War was known as the "Great Expansion". Economic boom followed the expansion of the railroads westward across the continent and southward into Florida. The Civil War punctuated Florida's growth but left it relatively unscathed. Economic growth quickly followed the end of the Civil War.The Civil War split the nation. It was the most bitter conflict ever within the United States. The source of the

To what extent was Stalin's rule a disaster for the Soviet Union and its people?

915 words - 4 pages conditions and great pressure from the authorities who were also being pressured by Stalin to fulfil his unreasonable requirements.Collectivisation was disastrous in the way that millions died, peasants were forced to abandon their homes and farms and that agriculture did not become as successful as Stalin would have liked, however, collectivisation was a benefit to Stalin as he gained control over the countryside and the peasants. Not one person

Did watching the movie 'Alexander the Great' 2004 teach you anything you didn't know before? If so, what? Make a personal comment on the film.

1653 words - 7 pages out a lot of important events in Alexander's life eg. The burning of Persepolis and the Gordian knot. But admittedly it was very hard to squeeze all the things the Alexander the Great did in his lifetime into a 3-hour movie.Overall, Alexander the movie is pretty useful as a quick and easy way to get educated on the subject of Alexander but if you want more in depth information and exact details you would need to read a book or search for it on

To what extent was Lincoln a mandate to abolish slavery?

998 words - 4 pages , directly or indirectly, to interfere with the institution of slavery in the states where it exists. I believe I have no lawful right to do so, and I have no inclination to do so." Lincoln did, however, express his desire to stop the spread of slavery and even to see slavery abolished in the District of Columbia.Lincoln was acutely aware that slavery was protected under the constitution, yet he still expressed his discontent of it by saying he would be

To what extent was the Greek victory at Troy due to military tactics and technology, rather than military intelligence?

1520 words - 6 pages To what extent was the Greek victory at Troy due to military tactics and technology, rather than military intelligence?The Trojan War has been an epidemic for historians to express their viewpoints. It is the ultimate tale of love, war and deceit, the very morals that we hold so dearly to our heart. This story incorporates every ideology that we refer in our everyday of our lives. Military historians have used this tale not as a myth but as

"Why was the civil war so long and so bloody?"

1579 words - 6 pages of cotton to Europe as well as the importation of clothing and medical supplies which the South needed.The South had thought that if the Union cut of their cotton shipments to Britain then they would give support to the Confederacy. This did not transpire though, as Britain began to get their cotton from Egypt. Also, Britain was opposed to slavery and so gave any support to the North.In 1962 a Union fleet was able to penetrate the mouth of the

To what extent was Hitler a weak dictator?

2191 words - 9 pages To what extent was Hitler a ‘weak dictator’? The debate as to whether Hitler was a ‘weak dictator’ or ‘Master of the Third Reich’ is one that has been contested by historians of Nazi Germany for many years and lies at the centre of the Intentionalist – Structuralist debate. On the one hand, historians such as Bullock, Bracher, Jackel and Hildebrand regard Hitler’s personality, ideology and will as the central locomotive in the Third Reich

To what extent was Charles Albert a liberal King

760 words - 3 pages Ffion LaveryTo what extent was Charles Albert a liberal King?It is debatable whether Charles Albert was a liberal king or not. Much of his earlier career as the ruler of Piedmont was marked by contradictions and led to a change of focus and beliefs; this therefore leaves historians questioning what his true aims were. There is evidence of Charles Albert as an absolutist and oppressive monarch, through his choice to increase the power of the

Similar Essays

Was Alexander The Great 'great'? Essay

765 words - 4 pages 200,000 years later. In order to be so successful though, he had to be ruthless at times. He did many things in his life that were inhumane. He crucified 2,000 men military age after the defeat of the great city of Tyre and,  in legend, he beheaded a sailor because the man had worn the royal band that the prophets had deemed untouchable by common people. Nevertheless, the world isn’t perfect and if he had not done the things he did, Alexander would

Were Roosevelt's New Deals Responsible For Getting The United States Out Of The Great Depression? If So To What Extent

783 words - 3 pages Were Roosevelt's new deals responsible for getting the United States out of the Great Depression? If so to what extentFranklin D Roosevelt was elected as President of the United States in 1932 and he was dealt a very large task. He was elected during the time period of the great depression and the United States economy was very bad. Many believe it was Roosevelt who got the United States out of the great depression with his first and second new

To What Extent Was The U.S. Failure In Vietnam Predictable

1910 words - 8 pages A. Plan of Investigation The investigation evaluates to what extent the failure of the United States in the Vietnam War was predictable. It assesses how this failure was predictable in the long and short-term and what factors were involved. The two sources used for a deeper study are from America in Vietnam, by Guenter Lewy and The army and Vietnam by Andrew F. Krepinevich Jr. Their origins, purpose, values and limitations will be discussed to

Essay: To What Extent Was The New Deal "New"?

2689 words - 11 pages monopolies, which were a clear outcome of capitalism, and nineteenth century railroads were much too monopolistic for the populists. The railroads were supposedly another corporation that was impoverishing the common people. Poverty was so widespread by the 1890s that it caused many people to turn to populism in order to achieve what the two major political parties could not. The Farmer's Alliance was a coalition of farmers that sought economic reform