Was Eugenics Ever Moral? Essay

1370 words - 5 pages

Eugenics is the study or belief in the possibility of improving the qualities of the human species. Sounds good, right? But the question here is, is it moral to sacrifice someones life or the ability for someone to create life in the name of science? Surely Francis Galton and Gregor Mendel thought so.

In the nineteenth century, biology was at its peak. Charles Darwin, who just happens to be Galton’s cousin, had just introduced his idea of survival of the fittest. Galton then took that thesis and dissected it. The result of that mess was what we know today as eugenics. The initial proposal was for genetically perfect people to reproduce with others of the same kind. It was believed that mixing the inferior people and the so called perfect beings would “yield a corruption of blood”(Lombardo,8).

It was not until the Civil War ended when America started exploring this new world of genetics. People came up with the belief that “genetics appeared to be the cause behind human social problems - such as pauperism, nomadism, criminality,alcoholism, feeble-mindedness, rebelliousness and prostitution - as the inheritance of defective germ plasm” (Allen,4). As bizarre as this sounds, eugenicists and their wealthy followers swore by this. With this idea in mind, doctors in prison and mental institutions started sterilizing the inmates and patients. Their reasoning for doing this was that it was better to sterilize these genetically impaired people and let them go knowing there won’t be any other generations of that same problem than to keep them locked up under taxpayers dollar.

How could this have been moral? Even Galton, the man who officially named this branch of science called this negative eugenics. These men and women were sterilized without their consent or their families knowledge, but they were poor folks, so nobody really cared they did not have a say in anything. As long as this was done under the name of science it was okay. Also a big factor that made this possible was how all the people who supported this type of treatment were the rich and elite. These were politicians and business owners who practically ran the country. It was unfair to those lower class people who were targeted by these studies. They had nobody to represent them.

Not only the folks in the lower classes were affected by this so called science but immigrants as well. Henry Laughlin, the director of the largest eugenics organization in the beginning of the 20th century, did some research and came up with what he called the ultimate test to see if someone was genetically fit or not. The test was composed of questions american related, when immigrants were given the test, they were bound fail (Meikos,5). Among other bigger reason, eugenics played a role in limiting immigration in the United States after Laughlin presented his results of this research to the Committee on Immigration and Naturalization of the U.S House of Representatives.

What made this so unethical was the...

Find Another Essay On Was Eugenics Ever Moral?

Eugenics movement Essay

4165 words - 17 pages origin respectively. Therefore, the word literally means 'Good Generation or Origin'. Eugenics is largely based upon Darwin's theory that seeks to explain the evolution of civilization by using the hypothesis of "man's descent from animal"; in the case of humans it was a gradual evolution from 'apes'. The theory is based on the premise that all things living and non-living have a common ancestor and that all life is related in one way or another.The

Eugenics Brief discussion of eugenics in America

757 words - 3 pages instances violently. The idea of eugenics, or as the Nazis used the euphamism "creating a superior race" (when in fact they were murdering millions of people), has been both misused and misunderstood. Many people blur the distinction between genocide and eugenics. And the Holocaust created by the Nazis wasn't a method for eugenics but was a horrific example of genocide. Even the United States has used eugenics in some of their policies in the past

A Comparison of Myself to Adolf Hitler

1288 words - 5 pages known to be one of the most influential World leaders we’ve ever known. Although Adolf Hitler and I share similar aspects pertaining to our black-and-white thinking, views on eugenics, and our leadership abilities, there are considerable differences in our moral values and how our goals are approached. I tend to regard my views and personality traits as interpersonal and therefore avoid projecting them on other individuals; Hitler, on the other

Eugenics: A Reasonable Proposal

2196 words - 9 pages (Hansen et al S105). While Davenport’s theory was merely social science, the preexisting notions of what defined eugenics lead to its dismissal, and then subsequently forgotten as society moved on. As such, the consumer culture breed (pun intended) the polarizing opposite effect—without concern for mate selection and simple “hook-up” relationship ideals, populations in western developed nations blossomed without due consideration for possible


1820 words - 8 pages Heredity: Like begets like? Eugenics or force sterilization programs were government policies that attempted to force people to undergo surgical sterilization, and also aim to assimilate any genetic deficiency (Keith 2011). The pseudo-science behind eugenics was based on a misconception of heredity that assumed that the deficient inevitably passed down their pathology to their progeny, and with this misconception, heredity became related to the

Eugenics: Angel in Disguise or Pandora's Box? - ENGL111 - Essay

983 words - 4 pages 1 Angel or Pandora? Eugenics: Angel in Disguise or Pandora’s box? Eugenics is the philosophy that deals with advancement of the human race through the control of unwanted hereditary factors such as mental retardation and Down syndrome. The idea was pioneered by Francis Galton to improve the stock of our own species as we have improved that of others. Mendel’s law, proving the particulate nature of inheritance, was rediscovered in the early

Early 20th Century Eugenics as part of Modernism

1080 words - 4 pages As the sun was setting on the 19th century, a new theory, called eugenics was just beginning to rise. Eugenics is the idea that human mental, moral, temperamental and physiological traits are passed down through generations, and that society should attempt to foster the reproduction of those with favorable traits and discourage or eliminate those with less than favorable traits. In the early parts of the 20th century, eugenics was put into

The Support of Eugenics Using Darwinian Principles

1608 words - 6 pages injurious variations” (68). Therefore, variations in animals must be compatible with the natural conditions they live under, and the environment has an intrinsic preference for certain traits over others. For eugenicists, the civilized society was similar to nature as a selective environment. In Eugenics, Galton specified the desired characteristics or veritable traits for selection as “more vigor, more ability, more consistency of purpose

A persuasive essay must be written based on this question "Is genetic engineering good or bad?" give examples, evidence,

719 words - 3 pages you ever thought what our future world would be like? What will happen to the ingenuous people who could not afford genetic engineering? What will our world become when everyone is so called perfect and similar? Genetic engineering improves our lives but is it necessarily?For those who could not afford eugenics would have lack education, imperfect or so called "errors." Thus, chances of employments would be lower for them. They would have less

Nazi Eugenics and Racial Hygiene

1385 words - 6 pages , only some of those responsible for these atrocities ever faced justice. “Eugenics was a popular theory in the early twentieth century but is no longer taken seriously, primarily because of the horrors of the eugenic efforts of the Nazi regime in Germany.” Eugenics has had its reputation tainted, tarnished, and discredited by the Nazi’s crimes. Eugenics was misused “to legitimize policies of racial hygiene.” Because of the negative connotation

The Science and Myth behind Phrenology

832 words - 3 pages The Science and Myth behind Phrenology Phrenology is a phenomenon that attempts to relate one’s personality and mental capabilities with the form and structure of one’s skull. This “science” became popular in the nineteenth century as the Eugenics movement gained widespread approval. In Joseph Conrad’s Heart of Darkness, the reference to Phrenology is apparent in the scene where Marlow visits the doctor. “Then with a certain

Similar Essays

The Rise And Fall Of The Eugnics Movement

3927 words - 16 pages believed that a wide range of human characteristics were inherited, including mental, physical, and moral traits. This view was stimulated in part by Galton’s cousin, Charles Darwin, and his recent work in the field of evolution. Although Darwin didn’t play a direct role in eugenics, he had shown how man, despite his relative complexity as compared to plants and most animals, was still evolving. Because of this, Galton reasoned that humans could be

Eugenics Essay

1034 words - 4 pages The roots of eugenics can be traced back to Britain in the early 1880’s when Sir Francis Galton generated the term from the Greek word for “well-born”. He defined eugenics as the science of improving stock, whether human or animal. According to the American Eugenics Movement, today’s study of eugenics has many similarities to studies done in the early 20th century. Back then, “Eugenics was, quite literally, an effort to breed better human

The Misapplication Of Eugenics Essay

1249 words - 5 pages The concept of eugenics has to do with the belief or practice of improving the genetic quality of the human race (“Eugenics” 2010). The concept was first introduced by Francis Galton, a researcher who wished to apply Darwin’s theory of evolution to the human race. Much like many endeavors that start off with good intentions, the results of applying this concept in real life were gross crimes against humanity. The eugenics movement in the

Designer Babies Essay

1536 words - 7 pages selection, called eugenics, was to check for certain disease-bearing genes. This allowed for parents to choose non-disease bearing embryos using In Vitro Fertilization (IVF) (Steere, 2008). The technology has recently been developing into detecting various other physical traits that will undoubtedly become abused by the general public if it is brought to the commercial market (Suckling, 2000). The concept of eugenics was originally advocated by