Was Hitler A Strong Or Weak Dictator 11 A History

872 words - 4 pages

Debate: Was Adolf Hitler a Strong or Weak Dictator?
Connie Gao History
On April 30th, 1945, the strike of two gun shots in an underground bunker of the chancellery building has shocked the entire Nazi Germany. By the time when the Russians reached to the place, there were two burnt dead bodies. After confirmation, the bodies were no one else, but the Father of The Nation and his wife: Adolf Hitler and Eva Braun. The death of Hitler has marked the fall of Nazi Germany. Hitler once said, that the Third Reich will last for 1000 years, but, the reality has shown the lifetime of the Third Reich was only around 12 years. Therefore this had led to a strong debate about what Hitler have done to ruin this nation and whether Adolf Hitler was a strong leader or not.
There were two schools of historians that debated on this topic: the Intentionalists and the Structuralists. The Intentionalists believed that ever since Hitler came to power in 1933, the way that Hitler generate the policies of Nazi Germany has made him a powerful integrating figure as the center of the government. Intentionalists claimed that “Hitler was a very powerful ruler who operated in line with a ‘master plan’”.
The Structralists, however, view Hitler as a weak dictator and the third Reich wasn’t a powerful nation at all. In fact, later on Hitler’s actions were so random that people won’t be able to predict what he will do. In conclusion, people praise Hitler only because they wanted to please him because he was so influential that people didn’t tend to question either his power authority or abilities to rule the nation.
There are evidence that shows Hitler was a strong leader of the state. First of all, it is shown that Hitler has have absolute control of the entire nation: from the arm force and the economy to the control of ideology and education. All of these factors have pointed out that Nazi Germany was a totalitarian state and was controlled by Hitler alone. Second, the property of Nazi
Germany was a single party state. The ideology of the Nazi Party were constructed by Hitler’s own beliefs, and the 25 Point Program that Hitler had written, has become the “bible” and “guide” of the Nazi Party. This has resulted in Hitler to be the God of the nation. People, especially in the Party, had no doubt in his leadership and therefore made Hitler a strong leader. Additionally, due to the trust of the Nazi Party, Hitler has later gained control pf the security system, which...

Find Another Essay On was hitler a strong or weak dictator - 11A - history

Hitler as a Totalitarian Dictator Essay

4271 words - 17 pages Hitler as a Totalitarian Dictator Before I begin to answer the question, "to what extent was Hitler a totalitarian dictator", I must first expand on the meanings of these two widely used political terms. In the "Reader's Digest Great Encyclopaedic Dictionary", the definition of totalitarian dictator is as follows: "Totalitarian (adjective). Of, pertaining to, régime which permits no rival loyalties or parties and

Was Adolf Hitler a Madman or Genius?

4124 words - 16 pages German politics.With Hitler playing at politically maneuvering himself into power, as opposed to leading a rebel movement that would overthrow the government, the Reichstag was no longer as strong as it was when Hinderburg first came to power. Masterfully employing his political power, Hitler had soon painted Hinderburg into a corner. In January, 1933, President Hinderburg regretfully called Hitler to be Chancellor of the Reichstag.As Chancellor of

Napoleon: A Leader Or Dictator

611 words - 2 pages Napoleon: A Leader or Dictator. There are never ending inquiries on the nature of Napoleonic power. But reason can prove to one that the Age of Napoleon was infact a time of democratic rule. Through Political, Social, and Economical reforms, Napoleon Bonaparte did not only transcend France, but he changed the course of history for Europe and the World today. To begin, Napoleon proved himself a democratic leader thorough many Political

Napoleon: A Leader Or Dictator

651 words - 3 pages Napoleon: A Leader or Dictator. There are never ending inquiries on the nature of Napoleonic power. But reason can prove to one that the Age of Napoleon was infact a time of democratic rule. Through Political, Social, and Economical reforms, Napoleon Bonaparte did not only transcend France, but he changed the course of history for Europe and the World today. To begin, Napoleon proved himself a democratic leader thorough many

Was Hitler a great leader or a monster?

881 words - 4 pages his regime or who didn't fit his ideal Aryan description. Hitler stole the German people's freedom of speech and democracy, and their traditional values were exploited.Hitler was in many ways an inspiring leader and visionary and he did a lot of good for Germany. He provided employment and stabilized the economy, Hitler told Germans they were the master race and promised them the world. He played on national resentment, feelings of revolt and

Was Hitler a Warmonger?

1076 words - 5 pages party. The same party used to lead Germany into war. The stage of Germany after the crisis following World War 1 was set perfectly for the rise of a dictator. Citizens of Germany were living in extreme poverty and starvation causing the people to dive into a deep depression. Hitler was regarded as a World War 1 veteran hero receiving the iron cross for bravery on multiple occasions and rising to the rank of Lance Corporal. Germany was under the

Adolph Hitler, Joseph Stalin and a Turkish Dictator reflecting the fascist and communist worldviews on key political issues

3358 words - 13 pages This paper will present a platonic dialogue between Adolph Hitler, Joseph Stalin and a Turkish Dictator reflecting the fascist and communist worldviews on key political issues. To be more consistent, I wrote an imaginary story in order to create a context that these three people would come and talk to each other. According to the story the new Turkish Dictator did not have a certain political stand. He was about to take control of the country

Was Calley evil, or was he a more-or-less “normal person in abnormal circumstances”? - History 108 - Essay

977 words - 4 pages detailing the events at My Lai. New Investigations and Trials On November 24, 1969, Lt. Gen. W.R. Peers was directed by the Secretary of the Army to review “possible suppression or witholding of information by persons involved in the incident." After more than 26,000 pages of testimony from 403 witnesses were gathered, the Peers inquiry recommended that charges should be brought against 28 officers and two non-commissioned officers involved in a

To what extent was Stalin anything more than a brutal dictator?

1116 words - 4 pages Lenin and the structures put in place by Lenin etc. Or the idea that brutal dictators like Stalin are a guaranteed product of history in Russia (powerful men such as Ivan the terrible and Peter the Great have ruled Russia in the past but was it something about them or the government of Russia that made them 'great' and brutal?). Ironically if you take Karl Marx's line that it is men who create history not the other way round then although Stalin was

Was the fall of the Ming dynasty really a major break in Chinese history or was it merely a transition between one ruling house and another? What

2024 words - 9 pages standing soldiers of more than 1,000,000 troops. There are major changes of Chinese history happened in Ming Dynasty in regards to government and politics. Although the Ming dynasty was a power with political strength, the political hierarchy centralized around the emperor causing absolute power that could be misused without guidance. It was the first time in Chinese history with major changes in government reorganisation: prime ministership was

Was Napoleon a hero or a tyrant?

1337 words - 5 pages in the long run as he went down in history as being one of, if not the, most honored military leaders in the world. His military skill gave him the ability to establish a strong political government, where he had absolute power, which was what the people were looking for. Due to his meritorious military strategies and early revolutionary advancements as the First Consul and Consul for Life of France, Napoleon Bonaparte can be seen as a hero in

Similar Essays

To What Extent Was Hitler A Weak Dictator?

2191 words - 9 pages To what extent was Hitler a ‘weak dictator’? The debate as to whether Hitler was a ‘weak dictator’ or ‘Master of the Third Reich’ is one that has been contested by historians of Nazi Germany for many years and lies at the centre of the Intentionalist – Structuralist debate. On the one hand, historians such as Bullock, Bracher, Jackel and Hildebrand regard Hitler’s personality, ideology and will as the central locomotive in the Third Reich

Prompt: Was Romeo And Juliet's Love True And Strong Or Weak And Superficial (Provide Examples From Text)? Essay Topic: Romeo And Juliet's Love Was Weak And Superficial

1571 words - 6 pages what Friar Laurence says, through the fact that fate is always present, and through what Romeo and Juliet say. Although it may seem authentic and undisputable, William Shakespeare in his play, Romeo and Juliet, meant to depict Romeo and Juliet's love as weak and superficial and he did it in ways listed above. Their fondness may seem strong because throughout the play they did many things in order to be together. The climatic suicides at the end give the impression that they were done in the name of love. Or was it just that they were desperate- desperate to escape their families and troubled lives? Infatuation rather than love is what Juliet and her Romeo had.

Hitler: Leader Or Dictator Essay

1333 words - 5 pages Adolf Hitler was not born into power; instead he was elected as chancellor and later became dictator after president Hindenburg died in office. His rise to power can be traced back when he became leader of a group called the National Socialist German Workers Party, which would later be known as the Nazi Party. After a failed attempt at an up rise in Munich, he was sent to prison for 9 months. When he was released, he regrouped and reformed the

Hitler As A Totalitarian Dictator Essay

1156 words - 5 pages Hitler as a Totalitarian Dictator In order for me to begin answering the question whether or not Hitler was a totalitarian dictator I must first identify the significance of the key phrase ‘Totalitarian Dictator’ exactly what it means and what factors of a totalitarian dictator were employed in Germany. I believe a totalitarian dictator must attempt to control every aspect of life for the people of the nation also