This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Was It Necessary To Drop The Atomic Bomb To End World War Ii?

781 words - 4 pages

Professor Robert James Maddox argues that the atomic bomb was necessary to force the Japanese army to finally surrender and avoid a costly and heavy casualty war with Japan. On August 6, 1945, the United States dropped the first atomic bomb over Hiroshima, Japan. Three days after the initial bombing, another nuclear weapon was dropped on Nagasaki, a main Japanese city. President Truman and Professor Maddox both had the same belief that these bombs were crucial to Japan surrendering in the war. Maddox mentions that Japan was a beaten nation by the summer of 1945 and conventional bombings had reduced many of their cities to almost nothing. He goes on to say that although many rational ...view middle of the document...

Some Americans think that the first bomb may have caused the Japanese to surrender and dropping the second bomb was unnecessary. Professor Maddox says that the record shows otherwise.
Despite Professor Robert James Maddox’s beliefs, Professor Tsuyoshi Hasegawa argues that the Soviet Union had a larger impact on causing Japan to surrender than the use of the atomic bombs did. Hasegawa believes that if Truman had asked Stalin to sign the Potsdam Proclamation, the Soviet invasion of Japan would still do the trick forcing the Japanese to surrender. He also mentions that Hiranuma’s amendments was a terrible mistake and that the Japanese may have been more inclined to accept the Potsdam Proclamation knowing that it would not change the status of the emperor under their national law. If the Byrnes Note had included an indication that America would let Japan keep a constitutional monarchy with the current dynasty, Hasegawa believes that Japan may have surrendered on August 12 or 13, not the 14th.
He goes on to say that without the use of nuclear weapons and the Soviet entry into the war, Japan may have surrendered before November 1st, which was the day Operation Olympic was scheduled to begin. He also questions whether or not the Japanese would have surrendered based on the...

Find Another Essay On Was It Necessary to Drop the Atomic Bomb to End World War II?

The decision to drop the atomic bomb

1428 words - 6 pages given to the Japanese to surrender on terms assuring themthe possibility of a peaceful development in their homeland.2. Convincing warnings have been given that a refusal to surrender will be followedby the use of a new weapon.3. Responsibility for the use of the atomic bombs is with our allies.(Bernstein 19)Truman decided to drop the bomb because he felt it was the quickest wayto end the war with the least amount of American losses. Truman said

Truman's Decision to Drop the Atomic Bomb

509 words - 2 pages Imagine yourself making the toughest decision in your life, whether sacrificing a million of our men and thousands of war ships and plans, verses several thousand of Japanese civilian populists. This decision was on the shoulder of Harry S. Truman, the United States President, who had to make this decision by deciding whether or not to drop a newly designed weapon. The atomic bomb was tested in the sands of New Mexico, where it proved to be

Truman's Decision to Drop the Atomic Bomb

773 words - 3 pages Truman's Decision to Drop the Atomic Bomb Many debates have been provoked based on President Truman's decision to drop the atomic bomb on Hiroshima and Nagasaki in 1945. The debate is not solely based on the bomb being dropped, but more on the actual necessity and intention of the bomb being dropped. I believe that the Presidents decision was based dually on military

America's Decision to Drop the Atomic Bomb

2941 words - 12 pages to the Pacific War. It was a year after the bombing when “the U.S. Strategic Bombing Survey published its conclusion that Japan would likely have surrendered in 1945 without atomic bombing…and without an American invasion.” If Japan was on the verge of surrendering within the next half year, it would suggest that there was no necessity to drop the atomic bomb, certainly not to the degree that many claim. The Japanese were in such terrible

The Atomic Bomb: The Only Way to End the War?

1655 words - 7 pages thought out plan, the American military quickly resorted to alternatives that they believed could possibly end the war if it was successful. The quick solution that the United States resorted to was the atomic bomb. The American military leaders and scientists that saw the atomic bomb testing, in New Mexico, knew that it would be their best approach to making the loudest statement of dominance and that it would be the best way to force an

Understanding the Decisions to Drop The Atomic Bomb

1583 words - 6 pages The death of thousands in a moment, this was the power of the weapon the United States held in their possession. It was nearly the end of World War II. With Germany defeated and the Allied Forces ready for the cease-fire, only the Axis power of Japan stood in the way of the end of the World War. Worried about Nazi Germany’s technological advances earlier in the war, the United States began to research atomic energy and the possibility of

Problems with The Decision to Drop the Atomic Bomb

2000 words - 8 pages around the world. The forewarning that was given to Truman came not only from leadership within the American government, but from a scientific community that had an exhaustive understanding of not only the power of the atomic bomb but also the indelible mark that it would leave on Japan’s history. Author H. Compton a well-known physicist urged the President through a memo to the Secretary of War on not using the bomb. Compton wrote less

Deciding to Drop the Atomic Bomb on Japan

979 words - 4 pages Truman decided to drop the atomic bomb on Hiroshima, Kokura, Niigata, and Nagasaki because Japan attacked Pearl Harbor without warning. This occurrence happened at the end of WWII. America, China, and the United Kingdom joined forces to gain surrender from the Japan armed forces. The alliance, also called the “Manhattan Project,” tested an atomic device, and were able to make weapons based on two alternate designs. One was a uranium gun-type

was the atomic bomb on japan necessary

1570 words - 6 pages well.American leaders at the time, who were informed about the facts, did not believe that the atomic bombings were needed to end the war. When General Dwight Eisenhower learned in mid-July 1945 about secretary of war Henry Stimson's decision to drop the bomb, General Eisenhower was deeply troubled. He talks about his doubts on using this new weapon in his memoir, The White House Years. "During his [Stimson's] recitation of the relevant facts, I had been

The Usefulness of the Atomic Bomb in World War II

867 words - 4 pages With America and Britain’s supplies and money quickly becoming exhausted towards the end of World War II, the war with Japan had to cease. Even though the US had significantly weakened their numbers, the US needed a strong military win to get Japan to surrender. Without the use of the atomic bomb the war between Japan and America could’ve persisted for a few more years, but with the bombing or Hiroshima and Nagasaki the war was ended swiftly

Was Bombing Hiroshima and Nagasaki Necessary to End World War 2?

1892 words - 8 pages to finalize the war. The U.S. with this, made statements world-wide and have shown how much power they are capable of. All in all, Japan did take the harder punch at the end since it demolished the country of Japan and their cities and there were many casualties as well. List of Sources Burr, William. "The Atomic Bomb and the End of World War II: A Collection of Primary Sources." The Atomic Bomb and the

Similar Essays

Was Truman Right To Drop The Atomic Bomb On Japan?

1307 words - 5 pages The Second World War started in 1939's. In the beginning it was a war only in Europe, but as the time passed on, all world was getting involved in it. Some countries weren't happy about their situation and one of them was Japan. In this essay I am going to discuss why Japanese attack the US Pacific Fleet at Pearl Harbor, Japan getting stronger, about atomic bomb dropped on Hiroshima and Nagasaki, was Truman right to drop it.War in Pacific began

Was Is Necessary To Drop The A Bomb On Hiroshima?

565 words - 2 pages it was necessary to drop the devastating blast in World War II. Although it is hard to predict what would have happened if it wasn't, it is almost certain that the casualties that would result in continuing battles would have been greater. Thus I strongly believe that the Atomic bomb was necessary. USA had been fighting a fierce war with Japan since 1941 and the morale as well as the resources of the military was extremely low. It was an

The Decision To Drop The Atomic Bomb

903 words - 4 pages President Truman's decision to drop the atomic bomb on the cities of Hiroshima and Nagasaki were the direct cause for the end of World War II in the Pacific. The United States felt it was necessary to drop the atomic bombs on these two cities or it would suffer more casualties. Not only could the lives of many soldiers have been taken, but possibly the lives of many innocent Americans. The United States will always try to avoid the loss of

The Decision To Drop The Atomic Bomb

2000 words - 8 pages Voices. Glenview, Illinois: Scott Foresman and Company, 1992. Bloomfield, Janet. Why it Was Unnecessary to Drop the Atomic Bomb. [Online] Available http://www.oneworld.org/news/world/bloomfield.htm. 3/4/98. Brison, P. Research Resourse Packet (Bender, David L., Publisher Opposing Viewpoints in American History, Volume II: From Reconstruction to the Present. San Diego, Green Haven Press, Inc., 1996.) Gordon, Thomas and Max M