Was Leo Frank Guilty For The Murder Of Mary Phagan?

2730 words - 11 pages

In 1915, an unjust tragedy occurred. Leo M. Frank was lynched because he was thought to be guilty for the murder of 14-year-old Mary Phagan. However, was he actually guilty of the crime he was convicted for? More or less, Leo Frank was a victim of press influencing public opinion, the need for Hugh Dorsey (the prosecutor) to have a successful case, and racial prejudice of the time. Contrary to public opinion, Leo Frank was not guilty for murdering Mary Phagan.

Overview of the case

Reasons for conviction
When the public heard of the crime, the police perilously needed someone to blame. If a slayer of the 14-year old Mary Phagan were not found soon, public uproar would become uncontrollable. The public needed a victim to blame for the murder of a young white girl. Conditions in Atlanta were favorable for an outburst against the killer of an innocent soul, especially if the accused murder was non-Anglo- Saxon.
These are not the only reasons for urgency to find a killer; the Solicitor General of Atlanta’s circuit, Hugh M. Dorsey, desperately needed a successful conviction because he had recently failed to convict two accused murderers. He was concerned about putting together a case that would hold up in court; no matter what lengths he had to go to in order to accomplish this. Overtime, it became obvious that Dorsey did not necessarily believe that Frank was guilty, but recognized that the political values of his position were uncertain.
Because the opinions and activities of the police helped control public reaction, Leo Frank was almost immediately the victim of public clamor. The fact that he was Jewish generated both public and legal controversy. Press spread unstoppable rumors of Frank being a sexual pervert, having another wife living in Brooklyn, that his office was pasted with obscene pictures and that he had made advances to Phagan multiple times before the murder took place. Leaders of the state either refused to work against the mob spirit or joined in with the demand for Frank being guilty.
Although Leo Frank had lived in Atlanta for nearly 5 years, he often expressed his incongruous feelings of the Southern society. After it was suggested that Leo Frank was a suspect, the mob atmosphere of Georgia began to demand the blood of a Jew. Although he was believed to be guilty at the time, much evidence has surfaced that could prove this otherwise.

Evidence was not analyzed
Once the public believed that Frank was the killer, there was no turning back. The police and court had to make sure the evidence lined up to prove him guilty in order to prevent public uproar. For example, bloody fingerprints were found on the victim's jacket, but there is no indication that they were ever analyzed. Also, a trail in the dirt along which police believed Phagan had been dragged was trampled and no footprints were ever identified. The police feared that if this evidence did not line up against Frank, it...

Find Another Essay On Was Leo Frank Guilty for the murder of Mary Phagan?

Was the Murder of Julius Caesar Justifiable?

1146 words - 5 pages in 2012 alone. These cases are very hard to settle, and they rarely go in favor of the defendant. George Zimmerman, a neighborhood watch volunteer in Sanford Florida, fatally shot Trayvon Martin, 17, for believing he was armed. Martin wasn’t armed however, and Zimmerman underwent public criticism and hatred. The court spent months reviewing the case, and on July 12th, 2013, Zimmerman was found not guilty. Although Zimmerman supposedly acted out

Was the murder of JFK a conspiricy?

681 words - 3 pages Wing Plot" Theory: The assassination was planned by right wing political activists who had the support of rich businessmen who had strong conservative views. The killing of the president was carried out with the help of the Dallas police force who where able to frame Lee Harvey Oswald instead of them. The "American Intelligence plot" Theory: The assassination was planned by members of the FBI and CIA. Lee Harvey Oswald was a low level agent for one

A last new chapter for The name of the game was murder by Joen Lowery Nixon

577 words - 2 pages only believe what they see, not what they know"? Thinking that made sense, I tried remembering whose saying it was. That was it! The great magician of all times, known for his tricks using basic common sense. It was Houdini. But what did that mean? "Aunt Thea, that's a saying by Houdini," I finally said. "But what can that mean, a magician? We have to think very deep." I thought, and remembered something from a book I read, Houdini was born in

Who is guilty for the tragedy of Macbeth?

881 words - 4 pages , suffering from psychotic episodes and visions of ghosts, leading him to be distrusted and eventually turned against by his countrymen for his tyrannical behaviour. So who, then, is this tragedy the fault of? Could it be Macbeth? He was, of course, the one who stabbed King Duncan in the first place, and this is generally considered the event that triggered his eventual downfall. However, Macbeth is reluctant at first to commit the murder: “First, as

The Ideology of Leo Burnett

829 words - 4 pages Cadillac Automobiles and climbed the corporate ladder to become The Cadillac Advertising Manager. Being Head Advertising Manager was not enough for Mr. Burnett, he wanted to become the leader of his own Advertising Agency and he would make the riskiest business decision in advertising history! 1935: the depression era, Leo Burnett walks into a local Chicago bank and asks for 50,000 US dollars. Mr. Burnett used such funds to create his own Advertising

The Life of Leo the Lefty

966 words - 4 pages . Leonardo DaVinci was human. Above being a painter and sculptor, Leonardo could sing, draw, and was a horseback rider (Frere 35). He was also daring, original, had a talent for improvising, and was an accomplished athlete (35). Aside from all the great things Leonardo did, because of his many talents he had a hard time finishing projects (mos 2). Another personal fact was that he wrote his name Lionardo instead of Leonardo (Frere 29). There is also

The Characters of Leo Tolstoy's Anna Karenina

1816 words - 7 pages and family.         It is this epiphany that gives Levin his sense of roundedness. Levin has grown from the beginning of the novel when his search for happiness was centered on personal fulfillment through marriage.  By the conclusion of the novel Levin has reached a sense of personal satisfaction as well as personal salvation through his realization that love not only entails physical love, as that for his wife, but

Leo Tolstoy's The Death of Ivan Ilyich

887 words - 4 pages is God’s will that everybody dies someday. His receptivity and consciousness make him stand out amongst society. If one looks at PI’s last name of Ivanovich; which means son of Ivan, this seems to hint that one day PI will too one day see the light.      Gerasim was the butler’s assistant. Unlike any of the other characters in the story has a REAL sense of compassion and empathy towards others especially Ivan during his last weeks. Since

The Guilty of the Two in Macbeth

1776 words - 7 pages     In Shakespeare's tragedy Macbeth neither the Lady nor Macbeth himself is ever able to reach a compromise with their guilty consciences. And the results are fatal for them both. A.C. Bradley in Shakespearean Tragedy demonstrates the guilt of Macbeth from the very beginning: Precisely how far his mind was guilty may be a question; but no innocent man would have started, as he did, with a start of fear at the mere prophecy of a crown

Macbeth's Responsibility for the Murder of King Duncan

1801 words - 7 pages Duncan. At the start of the play, the three witches are together chanting a spell on Macbeth. This shows that Macbeth would not have the power to override the spell and would succumb to their spell. After examining the evidence, I have concluded that Macbeth was not wholly responsible for the murder of king Duncan because there were other influences that he could not prevent.

The Apology of Socrates: Guilty or Innocent?

954 words - 4 pages declaring the truth to every one of you whom I meet...(35). Socrates was found guilty by 281 votes to 220 and condemned to death.  He states that "...if death is a journey to another place, and what we are told is true--that all who have died are there--what good could be greater than this..." (40).  Socrates takes his accusers and his condemnation as a blessing from the gods.  He says that '...no evil can happen to a good man, either in life or

Similar Essays

The Lynching Of Leo Frank Kehillah Jewish High School Essay

500 words - 2 pages Southern Jewish History The Lynching of Leo Frank Leo Frank, born in Texas on April 17 of 1884 and killed in Georgia on August 17th of 1915, was convicted of murder in Atlanta, Georgia. He was an American factory superintendent, and owned the factory where a 13-year-old worker named Mary Phagan was killed. Religious prejudices against the Yankee Jew caused Frank to be found guilty, regardless of the evidence defending him and pinning the

Life Wasn’t Just For Leo Frank

1582 words - 6 pages Life Wasn't Just for Leo FrankLeo Frank was a Jewish man who lived and worked, as a superintendent and part owner of a pencil factory, in Atlanta in 1913. He was accused of murdering a 13-year-old Caucasian girl that worked at his factory. Though tried and convicted for the crime by a jury, the governor of Georgia eventually pardoned him due to overwhelming indications of innocence. Upon learning of the pardon, a lynch mob devised and carried

Hamlet Is Guilty Of Murder Essay

617 words - 2 pages resides in hell with the rest of the murder’s and other nasty sinners. Thank you, for taking your time to hear what I had to say. I urge you to make your own choice, but know that there is far too much evidence to think that Hamlet was anything other than guilty.

Guilty By Association/Essay On Frank O'connor's "Guests Of The Nation"

915 words - 4 pages The setting within Frank O’Connor’s “Guests of the Nation” helped support his central idea that inexperienced soldiers are at risk for emotional breakdowns. The story began by explaining how the two English soldiers Belcher and Hawkins, had been caught in war and were hostages of the Irish Republic Army (IRA). The English soldiers were guarded by a few IRA soldiers and sent to the residency of an old Irish woman. At the old