This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Was Napoleon The Son Or The Enemy Of The French Revolution? In This Essay, I Will Try And Investigate Whether Napoleon Bonaparte Brought A Positive Change To France Or Was He Just Another Tyrant.

3273 words - 13 pages

France was under the rule of the Bourbon family, King Louis XVI, until the French Revolution occurred in 1789 which ended to the Bourbon dynasty. France was in a state of chaos as the Federal Revolt, war and the Terror emerged in the following years (Morris 2000, 107). Nevertheless, the French still had hopes on one person who they believed could rescue and save their nation from all their political, economical and social problems.
Napoleon Bonaparte was born in Corsica in 1769, an island which had only become French the year before he was born. He was an artillery officer who seized an opportunity to make a name for him in 1793 when Toulon had revolted against the Revolution. He was awarded as a Brigadier General at the age of 24 after his successful win over the British and Spanish fleets in the revolt of Toulon. However, as Robespierre and his Jacobins fell apart, Napoleon’s career was ‘jeopardized’ and he was sent to jail for a month. Nonetheless, by 1796, Napoleon had achieved a meteoric rise in military and revolutionary society. In November 1799, Napoleon seized power of the French empire as The Revolt of Brumaire broke out, triggered by the failure of The Directory, until his fall in 1815 (Morris 110-114). During his regime, he was able to make progress, reforms, establish order, stability and create an influential, dominant and powerful empire in Europe.
The Napoleonic era has been assessed by many historians who come into two different conclusions. Some historians accuse Napoleon of being the enemy of the revolution mainly due to his despotic rule while other historians support Napoleon as a son of the revolution due to the positive changes he has brought to not only to France but Europe as well. And other historians believe that he was neither an enemy nor a son of the revolution but a fusion of both:he was not, however, merely a revolutionary or merely an enlightened despot; nor was he simply a combination of the two. He fused the Revolution and the ancient regime in such way as to produce an entirely new element (Lee 1982, 19).
Thus, Napoleon Bonaparte, a national hero, was neither a son of the revolution nor an enemy; he was an ambitious leader who made decisions that was best for him and France even if that meant that he had to mutilate the state into dictatorship with somewhat restricted liberty, equality and fraternity.
Napoleon used his absolute power to create new reforms in order to stabilize the government and make effective changes that brought progress. Napoleon’s “creation of the Legion of Honor in 1802 was fundamental to republican meritocracy” (Ihl 2006, 1). It abolished aristocracy in France and awarded people who served duties to the country. In other words, people were rewarded for their talent without the discrimination and prejudice regarding on their socioeconomic background; class privileges were eliminated. Before Napoleon seized power, the Bourbon family appreciated autocracy however, once Napoleon became the...

Find Another Essay On Was Napoleon the son or the enemy of the French Revolution? In this essay, I will try and investigate whether Napoleon Bonaparte brought a positive change to France or was he just another tyrant.

Was Napoleon a Betrayer of the French Revolution?

1164 words - 5 pages Was Napoleon a Betrayer of the French Revolution?The main objectives of the French Revolution were to ensure the people of France have freedom of religion, to abolish Feudalism, and to uphold the Rights of Man proposed by the National Assembly. Napoleon achieved nearly all of these objectives to a certain degree, for example he introduced the Perfect system to minimize royalist revolts and he was determined not to restore the monarchy in France

Napoleon Bonaparte Betrayed the Ideas of the French Revolution

647 words - 3 pages after battle for France, hence showing that he truly cared for the well being of the French people. On this behalf, Napoleon supported the idea, Fraternity, of the French Revolution. In conclusion, I believe that some of Napoleon’s choices of actions were highly contradicting to his claims and theories, resulting in him betraying the majority of the French revolutionist’s ideas. On the other hand I feel that at some point Napoleon did have

Napoleon Bonaparte. It was written to awnser a question for my grade 12 history class, "Was Napoleon a child of the Revolution?" My teacher was very impressed with my essay

791 words - 3 pages called the child of the revolution. His egoistic autocracy curbed the spirit of Revolution. He used to say: "The crown of France was lying on the ground, I picked it with my sword." However, the people of France suspected his intentions. Napoleon regenerated France, but destroyed many who came in the way of his ambitions. He desired to conquer the world and rule it as a world conqueror. If only Napoleon could curb the tide of his ambition he would

Was Napoleon Bonaparte a Hero or a Villain?

1653 words - 7 pages Was Napoleon Bonaparte a hero or a villain? During the Napoleonic Era, from 1799 to 1815, France became a military power gaining and controlling land throughout Europe. While some historians believe Napoleon Bonaparte was a ruthless dictator, his military accomplishments far outweigh any atrocities he committed. He helped France gain stability after the French Revolution and he also abolished the Feudal contract. Napoleon was a brilliant

The French Revolution: Napoleon

1270 words - 6 pages Mediterranean port of Toulon, protecting revolutionary France from its enemies, the British. Toulon was a French harbour full of royalists that deliberately invited the British to land in the harbour and stop the revolution, but Napoleon was sent in to stop this from happening. At the attack of Toulon, General Jacques François Dugommier said, “I have no words to describe Bonaparte's merit: much technical skill, an equal degree of intelligence, and

Considering the entirety of his career, was Napoleon Bonaparte good for France?

1512 words - 6 pages absolute control.In order to create the long term reforms that France needed there had to be a strong leader and Napoleon was there to take the reins. To understand why it had to be him, and why he needed to use absolute power you must envision yourself in the shoes of an everyday French citizen. During this time France was in Bankruptcy as one war after the other was fought out. Even during economic crisis the spending continued as the king and

Napoleon: Hero or Tyrant

1003 words - 4 pages Napoleon Bonaparte can be described as a Hero or Tyrant and it may even be a fair assertion to suggest he was both. Napoleon ended the French Revolution after 10 years of political and economical instability, he implemented significant civil reform, he implemented the ideals of the Revolution by advancing people from all ranks of society and he sowed the seeds of a free democratic republic to neighboring countries mired in their own outdate

Napoleon and The French Revolution

886 words - 4 pages The nation of France underwent a crucial revolution from 1789 to 1799. Amidst this period, Republicans took control of the French government from the King and later on The Declaration of the Rights of Man and of the Citizen was instituted to provide protection for its people. At the helm of these revolutions, Napoleon Bonaparte, a young general had began to win many foreign battles and was steadily rising in the army's ranks. It was through

Napoleon Bonaparte: Deliverer of the Revolution

1037 words - 4 pages Napoleon Bonaparte reminds me of a blank canvass that became a mysterious painting as the artist drew and painted on. Deliverer of the Revolution Widely misunderstood for his greedy ambitions he was labeled both as heroic and unimaginative at the same time. There is no doubt that the French Revolution created Napoleon Bonaparte. “The Revolution was a lesson in the power of evil to replace idealism, and Bonaparte was its ideal pupil.”(Pg. 29

Was Marie Antoinette a Cause of the French Revolution or Just a Victim?

1432 words - 6 pages the age of ten, she still had trouble in reading, writing, and speaking. In 1765, Holy Roman Emperor Francis I, her father, died of a stroke. He left Maria Theresa his position, and gave their eldest son, Emperor Joseph II, the throne. Because of this political, it became a requirement for Marie Antoinette to marry Louis Auguste. Her mother sent her to France and agreed on this marriage. It was hard to adjust her new life in their enemy country

Napoleon and why he was a success

2029 words - 8 pages fell or were captured in the retreat. All of his armies broke up, and he returned to Paris in hopes of getting more men and funds, but the French had given their all. The Tsar personally accepted the surrender of France. The agreement said that the old dynasty of kings would return. Napoleon thought he could expel the enemy from Paris but his supporters ordered him to abdicate. He was exiled to a small island called Elba where he would be

Similar Essays

Was Napoleon A Hero Or A Tyrant?

1337 words - 5 pages reason he was leader. They knew that he had led them to this point, their pinnacle, and they felt safe in the hands of the great Napoleon Bonaparte. "A revolution can be neither made nor stopped. The only thing that can be done is for one of several of its children to give it a direction by dint of victories," said Napoleon. He meant that revolutions are constantly occurring during life, whether on a small scale or large scale, reforms are

Was Napoleon A Liberator Of France Or A Betrayer Of The Revolution

606 words - 2 pages ambition was unable to be constrained by the limited power that this position allowed so he made himself emperor. He made it a goal of his to rule over a united Europe. His increase of power and change in priorities caused him to go back on his beliefs and betray his mission of emancipating France. Thus Napoleon became a betrayer the revolution.

Napoleon Bonaparte: The French Revolution Essay

1974 words - 8 pages not one simple cause of the French Revolution. It was a number of causes and we’ll begin to analyze that background now. The conditions of France before 1789 were poor. Society was divided into three classes called Estates, (Napoleon himself reports that almost ten million acres of uncultivated land belonged to the government, smaller states within France, or in the hands of individuals (“Extinction of Pauperism”, 12) Among this imbalanced

Napoleon Was Not A Son Of The Revolution

801 words - 3 pages , creating a mass French Empire. Although Napoleon was a product of the French Revolution and maintained the image as a “son of the Revolution,” idealism always fell to pragmatism as Napoleon’s main purpose was creating a strong unified France. Napoleon’s policies reflected some of the ideals of Enlightenment thought and he sought to spread them across Europe as he conquered. One of the core beliefs of the Enlightenment is that the universe