This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Was The Civilizing Mission Truly Meant To Civilize The People Of Central Asia?

1789 words - 7 pages

It truly was the great game. It was the struggle that took place between the two superpowers - Victorian Britain and Tsarist Russia over the lonely passes and the blazing desert of Central Asia. I would say that the great game was much like an enormous game of chess; with Russia seeking to expand its borders and Great Britain seeking to safeguard its interests in India. While it was never made clear in Hopkirk's book that the true Russian dream was the conquest of India and not of Central Asia, but I think that it was indirectly implied. When Younghusband met colonel Yanov he recounted "and he showed me, marked in green, a large area extending right down to our Indian watershed" (Hopkirk 465). This was the area that the Russians claimed to be their own or the area that they were going to conquer. Also, in many other encounters when a British officer and a Russian general met, the Russian general always mentioned how anxious his men were to face their ultimate battle with the British on reaching India.I think that Hopkirk in his book "The Great Game" has been very successful in giving a detailed description of this incredible tale of high adventure and political intrigue, conveyed here through the exploits of Cossacks, Muslim guerrillas, courageous travelers, spies, mapmakers and soldiers. The thing that is noteworthy about this book is the wealth of information that Hopkirk provides and still manages to make it interesting to the reader. He tells a complete story, but expands on issues and events that are both interesting and important.In my paper I will talk about the Russian and British conquest of this area for financial gain or, as the imperialists liked to call it, the "Civilizing Mission". I will try and prove that the true reason behind the imperialist conquests of Central Asia was neither the salvation of its people nor the so called Civilizing Mission, but making economic gain through finding new markets for their goods, and stopping other imperialists from gaining their conquered territory. In a way it was like the Cold War of the 19th century fought between Britain and Russia. While both countries wanted to take over each other's territory and trade, they always denied it and lied about it to each other.The so-called "Civilizing Mission" believed that it was the duty of all Christians to bring their message of salvation to others less fortunate. British and Russian rule, being based on Christian principles, was the ultimate benefit that could be bestowed upon the barbaric peoples of Central Asia. They (Christians) believed that it was their duty to free these people (Central Asians) from the rule of Muslim tyrants who knew no mercy and did not recognize sympathy and forgiveness of any kind. It was these convictions that drew the imperialists to Central Asia.I say that the imperialists were never really interested in civilizing Central Asia because, throughout the book, whenever the two imperialist nations conquered any area and signed...

Find Another Essay On Was the Civilizing Mission truly meant to civilize the people of Central Asia?

How the Schlieffen Plan was Meant to Work

2844 words - 11 pages living conditions and poverty. Prices kept rising, and people descended into poverty. A harsh winter led the potato crops to die, and the country was close to civil and political unrest. Strikes resulted in a halt in the manufacture of new weapons and equipment for the soldiers, and this in turn affected the war itself. The blockade effected the war, as this was why an armistice was called. However, it did not effect the

Explain how the schlieffen plan was meant to work

796 words - 3 pages have been the thought of people during the war.In conclusion to the question, I disagree with the statement although not entirely. By these sources you cannot gain any information or details about what the battle or Haig himself, but the attitudes of people towards Haig and generals at different times (when the war was on and modern day).D) Study sources F, G and H. do sources G and H prove that F is wrong?Source F is certainly different to sources

This essay was originally meant to promote the death penalty

989 words - 4 pages "The abolition of the death penalty in Canada in 1976 has not led to increased homicide rates. Statistics Canada reports that the number of homicides in Canada in 2001 (554) was 23% lower than the number of homicides in 1975 (721), the year before the death penalty was abolished. In addition, homicide rates in Canada are generally three times lower than homicide rates in the U.S., which uses the death penalty. For example, according to the U.S

It Was the War Meant to End All Others: Analysis & Compare/Contrast Issue relating to History of War

1520 words - 6 pages Andrew Weissmann "Lessons Learned from WWI" August 18, 2014It was the war meant to end all others. History proved this wrong, but the lessons learned from the start of World War I are still important today. Now is the time for the world's great leaders and global powers to review the Great War's history to do everything that they can do when conflicts between them arise to prevent unleashing another global war on the world.Because of the 100th

Explain how the Schlieffen plan was meant to work: GCSE Coursework

2290 words - 9 pages History Coursework - The First World War.Explain how the Schlieffen plan was meant to work.The Schlieffen plan was the strategy Germany planned to adopt in the event of a war in 1914. It was intended to bring a fast, effective victory for Germany, and was devised by Count Alfred von Schlieffen who was the Chief of the General Staff of the German Army.If a war broke out, Germany would be faced with a war in the west against France, and a war on

The Demographics and Socioeconomic Issues Affecting Central Asia

1013 words - 4 pages Central Asia, a region of almost 60 million people, is on a declining fertility trend. Since 1992 birthrates in every Central Asian country—Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, Tajikistan, Turkmenistan, Uzbekistan—have fallen by at least 25 percent due to a preference for smaller families and wider use of contraceptives. Lower fertility, lower life expectancy and increased emigration following independence from the Soviet Union in 1991 led to slower

The Mission Of The Church Is Mission

1368 words - 5 pages promise that he was ‘blessed to be a blessing’ (Genesis 12:1-3). While he never saw the fulfilment of this promise Abraham is remembered throughout history as the man who ‘believed God and it was reckoned to him as righteousness’ (Romans 4:3). The Psalmist tells us that all people are meant to ‘be glad and sing for joy’ as they praise God (Psalm 67). It was God’s intention that through His people God’s ‘way may be known on earth’. Even the

Looking Back at The Dawn of Federation: Was it truly significant?

2104 words - 9 pages Federation, it would still be a long time before it could truly be recognised as a country separate from the control of the British Empire. Citizens of Australia were still considered to be subjects belonging to the United Kingdom and the British Empire as whole. Laws made in Melbourne parliament had to be examined and allowed by the House of Lords in London before being ready for passage back in Australia. And Australia itself was still

The Empires of Asia

1384 words - 6 pages Akbar established its governmental structure.- Akbar, who ruled from 1556 to 1605, controlled most of what are now north and central India, Afghanistan, Bangladesh, and Pakistan. Jahangir, Akbar's son, ruled from 1605 to 1627 and was a patron of Persian culture. His son Shah Jahan reigned from 1628 to 1658.- He encouraged architecture and built the famous Taj Mahal as a tomb for his wife. Shah Jahan's son Aurangzeb took the throne from his father

How Nazi Ideology Was Entrancehd Into German People. Description Of The Methods Used By The Nazi's To Control The People

833 words - 4 pages took the form of propaganda and indoctrination and the other was based on terror. Propaganda was an important tool used by the Nazi's to revolutionise German social and cultural life and was significant in the creation of a society which conformed to and embraced Nazi ideology. The Ministry of Popular Enlightenment and Propaganda set up by the Nazi's and was headed by Goebbels and was responsible for directing "all tasks in the spiritual

To what extent was the colonization of Argentina good for its people?

1348 words - 5 pages defending themselves and their city than Mendoza had been. The city's port was named Santa Maria de los Buenos Aires. The life under colonial rule was not like that of most other countries, because what happened was that the Spanish claimed more and more land for themselves for agriculture and livestock until they began to mix with the indigenous people and this lead to the creation of a new race, called "mestizo". So basically, this meant that the

Similar Essays

Transformation Of Islam: Islam In The Societies Of Central Asia

1936 words - 8 pages lose its former influence in Central Asia. Even though Arabic remained the language of religion, the Turkic language had linguistic dominance among native and even foreign population since speaking Turkic was the best approach to local people (al-Kashghari, page 70). Moreover, Turks were mentioned in Koran as descendants of the prophet Nuh (Gardizi, page 60), for that reason, learning its language considered religious duty (al-Kashagari, page 70

Transformation Of Islam: Islam In The Societies Of Central Asia

984 words - 4 pages him to emphasize the role of Islam in the government. First, Nizam al-Mulk was born into a small nobility family, he grew up among the common people (Ibn Khallikan, page 90), and thus, he was familiar with the needs of a simple folk. This experience is reflected in his work in which Nizam al-Mulk accuses bureaucrats sitting in their palaces of sealing the fate of people without having a clear view of the situation, he believes that distorted

Islam In Central Asia And The House Of Culture

2137 words - 9 pages Muslim armies as well (3). So here is a point I will make. During the Umayyad Empire, it is not the case that all the people of Central Asia became Muslim right away or that this area was without struggle, indeed many of the local people did revolt against the Muslims and indeed there was fluctuation in people coming to Islam and then leaving again (7). This turmoil and struggle eventually calmed down at the end of the Umayyad Empire and the

How The Schleiffen Plan Was Meant To Work

1725 words - 7 pages How the Schleiffen Plan was Meant to Work The Schleiffen Plan was made between 1871 and 1905 by General count von Schleiffen. The main aim of the Schleiffen plan was to avoid a war on two fronts; they decided that they wanted to knock France out of any war with one lightening attack. In the time between the General’s retirement and the actual event, the plan was worked on and amended by many people