Was The Irish Civil War A ?Natural? Conclusion To The Events Of Previous Years?

1132 words - 5 pages

Was the Irish Civil War a ‘natural’ conclusion to the events of previous years?

     Some historians will say that the Civil War was a ‘natural’ conclusion to the activities of the previous year others will disagree. This essay will take the line that yes; the civil war was a natural and inevitable conclusion to the Anglo-Irish difficulties. In order to understand why the Civil War came about one must first understand how it came about by studying the actions of the previous years, the War of Independence and the Anglo-Irish Treaty. Then it is necessary to look at the feelings of the opposing sides of the Civil War. Finally one must look at history itself and compare the Irish War of Independence and the Civil War with similar cases. Once all steps have been taken the ultimate aim of this essay is to prove that the Civil War was a ‘natural’ conclusion to the previous years.
     The War of Independence (WOI) was fought between the years 1918 and 1921 and ‘was mainly limited to Dublin and the province of Munster, and the IRA victories were few and far between’ . Ireland had forgotten about its aspirations for Home Rule and was now looking for a more drastic form of Independence. The war had its origins in the formation of unilaterally created independent Irish parliament, called Dáil Éireann, formed by the majority of MPs elected in Irish constituencies in the Irish (UK) general election, 1918. This parliament, known as the First Dáil, and its ministry, called the Aireacht declared Irish independence. The Dáil knew that ‘England’s difficulty (was) Ireland’s opportunity’ and ceized the day. After the failed rebelion of 1916 public sympathies slowly but surely swung to the millitant IRA (and Sinn Fein).      By 1921 the WOI was a cause of British anxiety and embarressment and something had to be done. Once the Ulster province had been calmed by the Government of Ireland Act in 1920, the Lloyd George turned to its Nationalist neighbour. A Sinn Fein delegation, including Michael Collins and Arthur Grifith was sent to Westminster to negotiate the Anglo-Irish Treaty. It is important to note that President DeValera was not present. It is very possible that he knew there would have to be some comprimise made and he didn’t want to make it. After heated discusions and debates the delegation were given 2 days to sign the treaty or except war. Ireland could not support another war and so the delegation were forced to sign the Treaty and bring it home for ratification.
     The Treaty caused heated debate with some agreeing with Michael Collins that the Treaty ‘gives us freedon- not the ultimate freedom that all nations desire and develop to, but the freedom to achieve it.’ In fact, ‘the population at large was strongly in favour of the terms’ . However there was a strong minority within the Dail that were strongly apposed to it and agreed with DeValera that...

Find Another Essay On Was the Irish Civil War a ?natural? conclusion to the events of previous years?

Irish and Irish-American Transatlantic Struggles to the American Civil War

1537 words - 6 pages Irishmen joined the United States Army in the both the Mexican-American and Civil Wars. In the Mexican-American War, there were about 2,000 Irish-born soldiers and generals. To many Irishmen, the war was a stable income and escape from the ghetto (Watts, 36). In the Civil War, almost 150,000 immigrants served in the Union forces, while 85,000 Irishmen served in the Confederate forces (Griffin, 16-18). To the despised Catholic Irish, the Civil

Events leading up to the civil war in the 1850s

1185 words - 5 pages receive their own punishment such as a whipping (Kelly, Martin, "Top Five Causes of the Civil War"). Any officer who saw a runaway slave and did nothing would be punished as well (Kelly, Martin."Top 9 Events That Led to Civil War."). These circumstances, however, did not prevent slaves from risking everything and seeking freedom. In response to the Fugitive Slave Act, an intricate system was created to bring slaves to freedom called the


3997 words - 16 pages was so badly damaged that she had to be beached to stop her sinking. She was later towed to Gibraltar and remained there, interned, until the end of the war.5th February 1939The Nationalists captured Gerona.28th February 1939Manuel Azana resigned from the post of President of the Republic.SPAIN - FEBRUARY 19394th - 12th March 1939The failure of Dr Negrin's Communist Government to sue for peace resulted in a civil-war-within-a-civil-war on the

The events that caused the civil war.

1008 words - 4 pages balance of power between the Northern (free) and Southern (slave) states, these events were marked with extreme divisiveness and eventually violence. Many events lead to the American Civil War, but the more direct and influential ones being the Missouri Compromise, Uncle Tom's Cabin and the Dred Scott Decision. All three of these events respectively fueled the conflict. The Missouri compromise was the first issue to pose a conflict with the

The Foreshadowing of the Spanish Civil War: The Years before the Spanish Civil War.

3419 words - 14 pages owners, and in particular the 1934 revolts in Catalan and in the Asturias. The assassination of Calvo Sotelo simply acted as a catalyst, a signal for what was needed to purge the country.While the Spanish civil war officially ran from 1936 to 1939, the real problems arose in 1931 when the abdicated King Alfonso XIII agreed to democratic elections. It was the first time in nearly sixty years that free elections had been allowed in Spain. The

Major Events in the Civil War

637 words - 3 pages day ended with Martin Luther King Jr.'s "I have a dream" speech.Congress passed the Civil Rights bill. The Civil Rights Act of 1964 ended Jim Crow and outlawed racial, religious, and sex discrimination in public places. During the 1950s to the 1960s most of the Civil Right movement events took place. Blacks stood up to the oppressing whites and actually made a difference. Segregation was no more and blacks could vote. The laws passed

Spain's Pre-War Years, speaks of why the years before the Spanish Civil War of 1936 so confusing and unstable, resulting in the need for a totalitarian leader?

2811 words - 11 pages through several civil wars, finally coming to a head at what historians call the Civil War, in 1936-1939. Only after this Civil War (and for a period before it) did Spain see lasting peace; but both those times were ruled by totalitarian rulers: General de Rivera in 1923-1930 and General Franco in 1939-1975. The other years saw terrorism, assassinations, violence and innsurrections. This didactic essay will demonstrate the Spaniards' inability to

Pre-Civil War Study Notes 1776-1861. A comprehensive guide to major events, laws, and important people before the Civil War.

1166 words - 5 pages - a rebellion in late 1835 and early 1836 by residents of Texas, then a part of northern Mexico, against the Mexican government and military. The rebellion led to the establishment of the independent Republic of Texas. The short-lived republic was annexed by the United States as a state in 1845. These events were among the causes of the Mexican War (1846-1848) between the United States and Mexico, after which Mexico relinquished all claims to

Was the Civil War Inevitable?

1082 words - 4 pages Sandra StokesAmerican HistoryDr.Zaccarini12/07/00Civil WarThe civil war was the one and only war Americans had with themselves. Unlike the other wars, where America fought for their countries freedom or to assist other countries in need, the civil war was Americans against Americans; North against South. Eventhough, the civil war was an all American war, each side had a reason, and a purpose of why they fought in this war. Now, centuries later

Was the American Civil War fought to free the Slaves

786 words - 3 pages Was the American Civil War fought to free the Slaves? The American Civil war was fought between the Northern and Southern States of America. It was a case of the richer and more industrial versus the poorer and more agricultural. So was the war fought for the black slaves’ freedom or as just a division between two contrasting societies in one huge country? Firstly, there were extremely contrasting views on black

The battle of Gettysburg, which was a turnign point of the US Civil War.

1143 words - 5 pages The Battle of Gettysburg"The Turning Point of the Civil War"Goerge Meade General Robert E. LeeIn 1863, the small town of Gettysburg Pennsylvania was awoken to the beginning of what was to be the turning point of the Civil War for the Union. It began as a small skirmish, but by its end it involved 160,000 Americans to which would become one of the bloodiest battles ever taken place on US soil. I chose this topic because the Civil War and its

Similar Essays

Events Leading Up To The Civil War

1773 words - 7 pages cause of the Civil War, because it began to allow more slave trade. It also caused many differences to arise between the north and the south. 1820- The first census of the U.S. showed a population of four million. During the 1800’s there were many improvements. There were roads, turnpikes, river travel, steamboats, and canals. With these advancements, westward movement grew. In 1820 the U.S.’s population reached 9.6 million. This was a cause of

Events Leading To The Civil War

908 words - 4 pages was sentenced to hang. The election of 1860 was that of much competition. It was just one political party against another it was that of the North against the South; it was a political Civil war. Lincoln became the sixteenth president and received thirty-nine percent of the popular votes. Lincoln took just about the whole north which led to his victory, because the northern states had more electoral votes than the south. It was on December

In A Complete Essay, Describe The Events That Lead Up To The Start Of The Civil War.

1334 words - 5 pages The Civil War was caused by a myriad of conflicting pressures, principles, and prejudices, fueled by sectional differences and pride, and set into motion by a most unlikely set of political events.At the root of all of the problems was the institution of slavery, which had been introduced into North America in early colonial times. The American Revolution had been fought to validate the idea that all men were created equal, yet slavery was legal

Essay: Was The Spanish Civil War A Preamble To Wwii?

1138 words - 5 pages reasons as to why World War II was fought, fascism versus democracy. Many believe that because of this, the Spanish Civil War was a precursor to World War II. With the facts and data that are out there for scholars to read, it is not a fact that the Spanish Civil War was a precursor to World War II. However, the Spanish Civil War was used as a training camp for the Axis power, it was fought for similar ideas as those of Hitler and Mussolini, and