Was The New Deal A Good Deal For America?

738 words - 3 pages

Frank Kou
2/25/14
9-1

Was the New Deal a Good Deal for America?

In his presidential acceptance speech in 1932, Franklin D. Roosevelt addressed to the citizens of the United States, “I pledge you, I pledge myself, to a new deal for the American people.” The New Deal, beginning in 1933, was a series of federal programs designed to provide relief, recovery, and reform to the fragile nation. The U.S. had been both economically and psychologically buffeted by the Great Depression. Many citizens looked up to FDR and his New Deal for help. However, there is much skepticism and controversy on whether these work projects significantly abated the dangerously high employment rates and pulled the U.S. out of the Great Depression. The New Deal was a bad deal for America because it only provided opportunities for a few and required too much government spending.
The New Deal did not notably benefit the majority of people. Walter Procter, in a letter to FDR, wrote, “The American worker – manual or brain – is not a dumb brutalized self. He is a man…why should ‘opportunity’ mean only opportunity for the privileged few to exploit the helpless many?” (Document 7). In other words, he is saying that all workers are humans and deserve opportunities from the New Deal. A handful of people should not take advantage of the rest. For example, the government during the New Deal era gave money to farmers; in exchange, the farmers concurred to limit farm productions, thus raising crop prices. Virginia Durr reflected this situation, “Have you ever seen a child with rickets? Shaking as with palsy. No proteins no milk. And the companies pouring milk into gutters. People with nothing to wear and they [farmers] were plowing cotton” (Document 5). This clearly demonstrates that the New Deal programs did not cover even the most basic needs. Many citizens lived in a state of destitute with nothing to wear, nothing to eat. They hoped for the promises from the New Deal that were never kept.
The government during the New Deal era spent enormous amounts of money to execute the work programs. In 1929, the...

Find Another Essay On Was the New Deal a Good Deal for America?

The New Deal Essay

1595 words - 6 pages wasn't a good move, it put America back into recession, and made six million people unemployed. However, The New Deal did have many upsides to it when it was first introduced. Firstly, the failure with the banks was resolved, Roosevelt got people to have confidence in having their money in banks, again. Also, the New Deal created millions of jobs, practically solving unemployment for several years. In the process

The New Deal for Lone Parents

576 words - 2 pages figures by counting as successes for the New Deal those lone parents who voluntarily approach job centres and are not in the target group for the scheme. In fact, according to this study, independent research for the Government suggests that lone parents' chances of finding a job were lower in areas where the New Deal was piloted than in comparable areas without it. They also found that the expensive personal advisor system was failing massively

The New Deal

3647 words - 15 pages contemporary concepts and at the same time many long-standing philosophies introduced by the FDR. The New Deal itself, although very revolutionary, has its evolutionary aspects also, primarily based on the Teddy Roosevelt's Square Deal. The New Deal, a term that was never clearly defined became the label for all of Franklin D. Roosevelt's anti-depression efforts. From the very beginning of the New York governors run for presidency he pledged the people

The New Deal; Analysis

937 words - 4 pages to the all the new radical ideas that were being put through congress during the late 1930's. Though The New Deal was ultimately unsuccessful, President Roosevelt set some socialist acts that did help pull America through the Great Depression and set the stage for future acts to come.Conclusion:Unfortunately The New Deal faded away in the late 1930s mainly because Roosevelt grew overconfident in his own abilities to end the Great Depression. As a

The New Deal Reforms

1252 words - 5 pages The United States faced the worst economic downfall in history during the Great Depression. A domino effect devastated every aspect of the economy, unemployment rate was at an all time high, banks were declaring bankruptcy and the frustration of the general public led to the highest suicide rates America has ever encountered. In the 1930’s Franklin D Roosevelt introduced the New Deal reforms, which aimed to “reconcile democracy, individual

The New Deal

1584 words - 6 pages . This democrat, inaugurated on March 4, 1933, won the 1932 election against Hoover by a landslide. The new president made a promise to his citizens, “I pledge you, I pledge myself, a new deal for the American people.” He reassured Americans that he would change their lives. He promised to get people back to work and back in their homes (“New Deal Timeline 1). For the hundreds of thousands of unemployed workers, FDR’s promise was helpful and true

FDR: The New Deal

1998 words - 8 pages Outline Thesis: The various programs created by FDR’s New Deal helped bring the United States out of The Great Depression. Paper Outline Intro Who was FDR Why was he popular His views Thesis II.) The U.S. emerges from a depression About the depression Who was affected What the nation needed at the time FDR’s help during New Deal Who helped him Why they did it It’s effects on the nation Restoring Banks Why people lost

The New Deal

651 words - 3 pages Déanna Clarke-CampbellBlock 1 The New Deal Affects Many GroupsThe New Deal Brings New OpportunityRepresented important opportunity for minorities and womenWomen Make Their MarkNew Deal gave opportunities for women in gov't positionsFrances Perkins- first female cabinet member; sec. of laborPlayed a major role in creating Social Security System & labor legislationRoosevelt (encouraged by wife) 2 female diplomats & female federal

new deal

479 words - 2 pages Franklin Delano Roosevelt entered the White House in 1932 at the darkest hour of the Great Depression, promising "a new deal for the American people." The package of legislative reforms that came to be known as the New Deal permanently and dramatically transformed the politics and economy of the United States.Shortly after taking office, Roosevelt explained to the American people that his New Deal program would seek to deliver relief, recovery

New Deal

889 words - 4 pages Ziying LinMr. TivnanPer. 53 May 2013Was the New Deal Successful?Between 1920s and 1930s, there were many events happened, the Great Depression, the Dust Bowl, and the president election. A series of events brought American people together to conquer the hardship. For helping people went through difficulties, the president Franklin Delano Roosevelt created a plan which is called the New Deal to help people overcome the Great Depression. Though

New Deal

668 words - 3 pages John Mendez Mr. Rinard AP US History Period 4 New Deal The Depression of the 1930s was so severe that for the first time a system of welfare payments was introduced in the US to help the unemployed. At first, this came in the form of the government providing the states with funds to distribute; when this proved ineffective, the government launched its own work schemes. These measures, however, did not provide the economic stability that was

Similar Essays

The New Deal Was Not A Success

1056 words - 4 pages The Great Depression was one of the most terrible catastrophes in U.S. history, and resulted in the need for government help to pull the nation out of the depression. The New Deal refers to the programs and acts that came about as a response to the Great Depression. However, the New Deal was not successful in removing the country, either economically or socially, out of the Depression. The Agricultural Adjustment Act only resulted in waste of

How Sucessful Was The New Deal?

1027 words - 4 pages failures of the New Deal was that unemployment stayed high throughout the 1930's. The employment schemes did not provide work for everyone. The black people in America were still in a bad state. There were a number of improvements such as 200,000 black people were helped by the CCC and other alphabet agencies, but they also had a major burden that no laws were passed to stop the Ku Klux Klan or anyone else lynching them for sometimes no apparent

The New Deal Essay 603 Words

603 words - 2 pages it stabilized the businesses by taking the nation off of the gold standard and canceling any use of a gold payment clause in contracts. It required all privately owned stores of gold to be turned in and repaid in paper money. The New Deal reduced the amount of gold behind the dollar as a means for a further reduction in dependence on the gold standard. After experimenting with pushing the price of gold up by buying it in the open market

The New Deal Essay 880 Words

880 words - 4 pages workplace forever. Men were no longer looked at as the sole breadwinners for there families, and women were beginning for more work opportunities outside the home. The New Deal brought more women into government positions then ever before, and also laid the groundwork for the success of women today. Women in this time looked up to Rosie the Riveter, which was a popular piece of primary propaganda at the time aimed at motivating the working