Was The Renaissance A True Period Of Change, Or Solely A 'pre Renaissance'?

840 words - 3 pages

The only unequivocal statement regarding the Renaissance is that it brought about change, but beyond that point nothing else is certain. There are two diametrically opposed viewpoints: the Renaissance or that of the notion of PreRenaissance. The former being supported and undisputed until the 1920s, by that of Jacob Burckhardt; while the PreRenaissance initiative is Lynn Thorndike's rather modern notion. It is generally agreed upon that the Renaissance came about due to urbanization, departure from traditional monarchy and the formation of city-states, creating a sense of individualism. Even so, the contrast between the Renaissance and Medieval thoughts isn't as simplistic as it appears. Moreover, when looking at contrasts between periods they are gray at best. Calling the Renaissance "light" and the Middle or Medieval ages "dark" is like calling WWII advanced and WWI unsophisticated or Hinduism primitive and Buddhism modern; but rather, the latter is strongly based or rooted in the preliminary. The lack of strong differences between the two periods can best be described by the thoughts and works of the early 20th century theorists Haskins, Gilson, and Thorndike.Burckhardt places great emphasis on cultural achievement when describing the Renaissance, but throughout the Middle Ages, much of the same feats were uncovered. The American medievalist Charles Homer Haskins points out these 12th century accomplishments in his work, "The Renaissance of the Twelfth Century." During the period in question, there was a huge influx of wealth, Florence being the leader in this category. Florence was wealthy enough to create a financially stable middle class and even bourgeoisie which it was thought to earlier lacked; yet, on the contrary such was shown. Haskins notes that the twelfth century witnessed, "an upsurge in economic development and trade," resembling much of the renaissance economic developments. Though education appears largely focused on during the Renaissance, the foundation for such learning was laid earlier. The first universities which had started with bare outlines of liberal arts had spanned into incorporating Roman and ecclesiastical law, Greek philosophy, and Arabic science and medicine by the end of the 12th century. Moreover, the poet Dante is believed to have accomplished great feats in his "Divine Comedy," but rather, vernacular literature had prior been widespread. When universities arose as did the appearance of goliards or wandering students, many of which composed rhymed poetry in their native languages and with this creativity came individualism.An essential characteristic of the Burckhardtian conception of the Renaissance is "the appearance of...

Find Another Essay On Was the Renaissance a true period of change, or solely a 'PreRenaissance'?

The Knight at War. How did his role change and was their any place for chivalry on the battlefield during the late medieval period?

1794 words - 7 pages heavily armoured knights could break any unit. Knights lived their entire life to fight. They trained all day in the art of war and at tourney they practised war-games constantly. As time progressed they developed more discipline and cavalry units began to regroup and hit second or third units with a charge. However, throughout the period the discipline of knights was always suspect and the pursuit for personal glory a priority. What would a

Was The Renaissance a Revolution? Essay

1421 words - 6 pages The Renaissance is recognized as the rebirth of many studies manly found in Europe. It was a revival and rediscovery of arts and literature, the emergence of new scientific theories, philosophers, beginning of unfamiliar religions and writers who had the power to change future societies. I believe that the Renaissance in Europe was a revolution represented by the many great thinkers and artists who were able to make this time period significant

The Renaissance as a transitional period in Europe

691 words - 3 pages The Renaissance was the transitional period between the Dark Ages and the Age of Enlightenment. It's meaning, rebirth, symbolizes human, cultural, political, and economic regeneration. Events at the end of the Middle Ages, beginning in the 12th century, started a reformation of these ideals. The Renaissance started in Florence, Italy in the beginning of the 14th century. The Renaissance was earliest expressed through Humanism. The effect of

“Alfred was not only a great warrior, but more importantly a nation builder”. Explain whether or not this quote is a true assesment of King Alfred the Great.

1031 words - 4 pages Untitled "Alfred was not only a great warrior, but more importantly a nation builder". Explain whether or not this quote is a true assesment of Alfred. King Alfred the Great was not only a great warrior, but more importantly a nation builder. I think this quote is a true assesment of Alfred and I will explain why in the pages that follow. Alfred was born into a royal family in 849 in Wantage (now in Oxfordshire

Examining Whether or not the Boston Massacre was a True Massacre

1184 words - 5 pages were armed with clubs. Instead of a true massacre, the Boston Massacre was a propaganda ploy by Samuel Adams to enflame and unite the colonists to seek their independence from England. John Adams wrote the following: “The 5th of March, 1770, ought to be an eternal warning to this nation [England]. On that night the foundation of American independence was laid… The death of four or five persons, the most obscure and inconsiderable that could have

Was the Schlieffen Plan a true failure?

2664 words - 11 pages equipped properly, the Schlieffen plan would have been succeeded.Overall the Schlieffen plan was not stupid, but a great idea for German to defeat Allies. It was true that it had four weaknesses,: the underestimation of Belgium's defense, miscalculation of Britain and Russia, no consideration of limitation of soldiers. However, it could also be augured that Maltke's unwise modifications were the real factors for Schlieffen plan's failure

Was the league of nations a success or a failure?

3786 words - 15 pages members. It was conquered by the permanent members. These were the major powers: Britain, France, Japan and Italy in the 1920s. The temporary ones were elected by the assembly for a three year period. The permanent countries had a Veto. This means that they could say no to a decision even if all the others agreed and that would block the decision. On a Dispute or a problem, the council had three options/steps. First step: Verbal Sanctions, a

Patrons and Artisans of the Renaissance Period

1013 words - 4 pages The Renaissance period (1400 to 1700) covered art, literature, philosophy and government. Renaissance culture spread outwards from Florence, to other Italian cities and then, over the following centuries, to the rest of Europe. It is widely understood that it was a unique combination of several different influences that led to the Renaissance, with the social and political conditions of the era, combined with great wealth and the large number

The Victorian Period: A Time for Drastic Change. Does Wuthering Heights Accurately Represent the Victorian Period?

1310 words - 5 pages The Victorian period was a time filled with changes such as the women's rights movement, which drastically changed writing and the voice of women from that point on. Many changes in society both at home and out in the public made it so women had a voice in their everyday lives. With these changes, women were treated as equals among men, instead of being treated as servants, and their opinions were important. Thus the Victorian Era was a start of

Renaissance, a period that developed a renewed interest in arts

1276 words - 5 pages The renaissance was a period of European history that developed a renewed interest in the arts. The renaissance began in 14th century Italy, and spread to the rest of Europe in the 16th and 17th centuries. In this period, the society of the middle ages, which had an agricultural economy and a church-dominated intellectual and cultural life, was transformed into a society increasingly dominated by political institutions, with an urban, commercial

Was Napoleon the son or the enemy of the French Revolution? In this essay, I will try and investigate whether Napoleon Bonaparte brought a positive change to France or was he just another tyrant.

3273 words - 13 pages son of the revolution but a fusion of both:he was not, however, merely a revolutionary or merely an enlightened despot; nor was he simply a combination of the two. He fused the Revolution and the ancient regime in such way as to produce an entirely new element (Lee 1982, 19). Thus, Napoleon Bonaparte, a national hero, was neither a son of the revolution nor an enemy; he was an ambitious leader who made decisions that was best for him and France

Similar Essays

The Renaissance Was A Revolutionary Period

3025 words - 12 pages In history, revolution is the reason for constant shift in society. Many eras have come and gone and only some have left a significant impact on the world. In order for an era to be revolutionary, it has to leave a long lasting influence through social, economic and political means. Historians debate whether the Renaissance was considered a revolutionary period of history or not, however the Renaissance means “rebirth” and laid the foundation

The Renaissance Was The Period Of Rebirth In Europe. The Affects Of Greek And China Ideas On The Renaissaince.

1267 words - 5 pages turned in new directions. There will be a discussion about the Renaissance along with three examples of its significance, how classical Greek was related, and how China was related to the Renaissance.BodyIn the late Middle Ages in Europe, when the threat of invasion from the barbarians had lessened, people left the country for towns and cities so they could engage in more profitable pursuits. Life in the city was soon to change drastically when

The Renaissance As A Distinct Period Of Time

638 words - 3 pages known as; renaissance men. This means they are not only successful in one type of art but in all types of art, as well as math, science, and literature. The Renaissance was a distinct period in time that was separated from the Middle Ages and began a new era. The writers and thinkers of the fifteenth sixteenth centuries believed that they took part in a completely different era than the Middle Ages. They believed that they were part of a more

A Comparison Of Two Paintings From The Renaissance Period

939 words - 4 pages A Comparison of Two Paintings from the Renaissance Period Introduction      This paper will compare the themes found in the paintings “Madonna and Child with St. John the Baptist and an Angel” by Domenico di Bartolomeo Ubaldini (Puligo) and “Madonna Enthroned” by Giotto. Both paintings deal with fables from the Christian faith but were executed during different periods in art. The Giotto painting was created around 1310 and the Puglio