This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Was The Vietnam War Justified? Essay

6173 words - 25 pages

Introduction
“No event in American history is more misunderstood than the Vietnam War.” (Richard M. Nixon, 1985) Despite almost half a century of retrospect, numerous studies, and the declassification of military documents, former President Nixon’s assertion still holds truth. Of all the wars that the United States has fought in, the Vietnam War has compelled the most Americans to question what we were fighting for and why. Was the Vietnam War a just war?

The Just War Theory
The Just War Theory has been shaped over the centuries by historians and philosophers. However, the most systematic account of the Just War Theory was formulated by Saint Thomas Aquinas in his Summa Theologicae. According to the Just War Theory, the moral reality of war is divided into two parts. Wars are judged twice, first with reference to the reasons nations have for fighting and secondly, with reference to the means they adopt in the actual fighting. (Walzer, 21) The first judgment is referred to as jus ad bellum, or justice of war. The second judgment is referred to as jus in bello, or justice in war. Jus ad bellum provides guidelines for assessing whether a war is just or unjust while jus in bello outlines proper conduct in war. Jus ad bellum does not imply jus in bello. Likewise, jus in bello does not necessitate jus ad bellum. It is possible for a just war to be fought unjustly just as it is possible for an unjust war to be fought justly.
The principles of jus ad bellum are having a just cause, being declared by a proper authority, possessing the right intention, and having a reasonable chance of success. A war must meet all of these requirements to be regarded as a just war. The first and most important condition of jus ad bellum is having a just cause. This condition relies on what Saint Thomas Aquinas calls the Theory of Aggression. The Theory of Aggression can be summed up in six propositions:
1. There exists an international society of independent states.
2. This international society has a law that establishes the rights of its members—above all, the rights of territorial integrity and political sovereignty.
3. Any use of force or imminent threat of force by one state against the political sovereignty or territorial integrity of another constitutes aggression and is a criminal act.
4. Aggression justifies two kinds of violent response: a war of self-defense by the victim and a war of law enforcement by the victim and any other member of international society.
5. Nothing but aggression can justify war.
6. Once the aggressor state has been militarily repulsed, it can also be punished. (Walzer, 61)
From the Theory of Aggression it is clear that wars cannot be justly declared for political or religious beliefs, self interest, or aggrandizement. Only aggression towards the political sovereignty or territorial integrity of a nation can justify war. However, the tenet of self-defense can be interpreted to include preemptive strikes...

Find Another Essay On Was the Vietnam War Justified?

Was War Against The Confederate States of America Justified?

1660 words - 7 pages The Civil War was a trying time in American History; societies crumbled, lives were lost, and a nation was torn apart in order to be made whole. However, was this conflict inevitable? Were the North and the South destined to battle out their differences? Were the decisions made by President Abraham Lincoln to make war on the CSA justified? While there is much deliberation on this topic, the final answer is yes to each and every question. The

War Argument Essay: Was Dropping the Atomic Bombs Justified?

1120 words - 5 pages World War II was a war fought by almost all the countries on Earth. Though 71 countries participated, they were separated into the Axis powers and the Allied powers. Eventually, the Allies won the war after a span of 6 years, though one of the Axis powers refused to surrender to the Allies. That country would be Japan. Having Japan not surrendering yet had been a result that the Allies would not accept whatsoever. Consequently, the first bombing

Was American entry into the Spanish American War justified?

1212 words - 5 pages In the 1890's the United States became more aggressive and expansionistic than it had been for the past few decades. There was apparently a hunger for foreign conquest. The conflict with Spain derived mainly from the American desire to help the beleaguered Cubans with their independence from Spain. Americans wanted the war, which could well have been avoided, but they had little understanding of what the reults of the war would be. I believe

Was the 2003 war in Iraq justified and necessary?

11254 words - 45 pages Assignment aim.My aim in this assignment is to provide an objective view of whether the 2003 war on Iraq is justified.History of Iraq. For map see appendix 1. Weapons Of Mass Destruction (WOMD)Iraq is a country that was created after world war 1, by the then coalition. It neighbours with Turkey, Saudi Arabia, Iran, Syria and Jordan. It is split, pretty much in two by the rivers, Tigress and Euphrates. Habitation and life along these two

Was the bomb justified?

1536 words - 7 pages -militarize the intended city. Even though the US intentionally bombed civilians, the Truman administration believed it was the only way they could save American life and end the war as quickly as possible. All of Truman’s reasons for dropping the bomb in the time of war to save the lives of Americans were justifiable, although maybe not possibly morally justified, because the effects of the bomb were not yet known. The use of the atomic bomb

Iraq War: Was It Really Justified?

4031 words - 16 pages ideas are based on the information collected from the blogs on the internet.IRAQ WAR: WAS IT REALLY JUSTIFIED?INTRODUCTIONThe law shared by many nations in the world states that "We the peoples of the United Nations, determined to save succeeding generations from the scourge of war, and to ensure, by the acceptance of principles and the institution of methods, that armed force shall not be used, save in the common interest, have resolved to combine

Was the United States justified in declaring war on Spain in 1898

1056 words - 4 pages Was the United States justified in declaring war in 1898? For: ● Monroe doctrine dictates US intervenes ● be rid of european power → expansion ● spanish detrimental to american trade to caribbean → would get rid of them (commercial interests) ● america rose as a world power ○ sphere of influence ● positive example of jingoism, popular war ● relatively inexpensive ● few casualties ●

Was the US Justified in declaring war on Spain in 1898

1056 words - 4 pages Was the United States justified in declaring war in 1898? For: ● Monroe doctrine dictates US intervenes ● be rid of european power → expansion ● spanish detrimental to american trade to caribbean → would get rid of them (commercial interests) ● america rose as a world power ○ sphere of influence ● positive example of jingoism, popular war ● relatively inexpensive ● few casualties ●

The Vietnam War

2262 words - 9 pages disobedience, Americans were allowed to express their voice against what they thought as an immoral war in Vietnam. In the positive view of the antiwar movement, Americans challenged their rights to freedom of speech, freedom of assembly, and freedom of the press, and used civil disobedience to actually influence government decisions. However, looking at Vietnam itself, many others believed that the war in Vietnam was a justified

The Vietnam War

879 words - 4 pages "You will kill ten of us, we will kill one of you, but in the end, you will tire of it first". This quote was once spoken by the well-known protester Ho Chi Minh, in the time of the Vietnam War to motivate others to maintain their ironclad resistance against American forces.The causes of the Vietnam War were derived from the symptoms of the Cold War. The causes of the Vietnam War revolve around the simple belief held by America that communism

The Vietnam War

2411 words - 10 pages The Vietnam War was a war between the Capitalist United States and the Communist North Vietnamese army. This war started in 1964 and it ended in 1975, when the US withdrew its soldiers. The US joined the war to stop the spreading of Communism, because they didn’'t want Russia to gain more allies, as they had been in a cold war with them for years. In my opinion, an event is significant if it is still remembered today, meaning that it is used

Similar Essays

Was The War In Vietnam Justified?

1061 words - 5 pages Was the war in Vietnam justified? The Vietnam War was the longest war in the history of the United States it lasted from 1959-1975. Billions of dollars was spent trying to win and unwinnable war. Countless of lives were lost and America failed to achieve its objective. The origins of the war stem from the Indochina wars that occurred in the late 40s and early 50s. After many years of colonial war, the Viet Minh a communist group led by Ho Chi

The War Of 1812: Was The War Of 1812 Justified?

1126 words - 5 pages For America, the War of 1812 was justified. Clearly there were sufficient reasons for America to declare war with Great Britain. Time after time the British violated American rights and freedoms. Acts such as impressments, the attack on the USS Chesapeake, the violation of American neutral rights and waters, blockades on U.S. ports, and the ignoring of stipulations of Jay's Treaty and their Treaty of Paris all imposed threats on America. To

The Vietnam Conflict The Vietnam War Was A Long And

3733 words - 15 pages The Vietnam Conflict The Vietnam War was a long and frustrating experience for the American people. Even before the United States involvement began, North and South Vietnam were in conflict with each other. ?When Vietnam was divided in 1954, many Viet Minh who had been born in the southern part of the country returned to their native villages to await the 1956 elections and the reunification of their nation?(Microsoft Encarta Encyclopedia 99

Was The War In Iraq (This Time) Justified?

955 words - 4 pages The term war is defined as the following: 1) armed conflict or fighting between nations or factions. 2) Any conflict of struggle. The term "justified" is used to define the United States as free of blame for its part in the war. Was it right for us to go to war with Iraq? Were reasons for war the right ones? I have to rely on my personal opinion, which I feel this war was not justified.Saddam Hussein is out of power, for Iraq maybe it's