This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Waterboarding. What Is Waterboarding? Is Waterboarding Torture?

1335 words - 6 pages

Katie SchicklingProfessor LevanCOM 1011 December 2014WaterboardingThe CIA has authorized a variety of harsh interrogation techniques to coerce confessions, some considered questionable, leading to different fates of those detained, including death (Ross Brian, and Richard Esposito). One of these techniques is known as waterboarding. Although this may help officials to confessions that are true and deserved, waterboarding should not be allowed due to what John Stifton of the Human Rights Watch with ABC News calls a "mock execution" aspect of it and it could be wrongfully performed on people of innocence (Ross and Esposito). What part of the phrase "mock execution" does not seem like a form of ...view middle of the document...

The subject drowns from the inside, filling with water from the head down. The chest and lungs are kept higher than the head so that coughing draws water up and into the lungs while avoiding total suffocation (Is Waterboarding Torture?).With a topic that brings about so many issues, there is also a lot of confusion that arises. Contrary to popular belief, waterboarding is not: upright or face down dunking, asphyxiation, submersion, slowly dripping water onto a forehead or a simulation (Is Waterboarding Torture?). Upright or face down dunking is not waterboarding because when someone is dunked, the prisoner would be able to hold his/her breath and cancel out the purpose of waterboarding (Is Waterboarding Torture?). While being waterboarded, the inclined position of one's does not allow holding one's breath to stop the upper respiratory tract from filling with water (Is Waterboarding Torture?).Survivors of near-death drowning experiences report that the sensation of suffocation is the most terrifying aspect of the experience and the waterboarding process speeds up these sensations, long before oxygen starvation truly begins (Is Waterboarding Torture?). Waterboarding is often times closely compared to the famous "Chinese Water Torture" techniques used in different Asian countries, but they have been proven to have very prominent differences when compared in Episode 25 of the popular television series, Mythbusters (Is Waterboarding Torture?). Waterboarding is forcing large amounts of water into a prisoner causing choking and gagging, nothing close to a simulation (Is Waterboarding Torture?).Such a treatment, much like any other issue, is a highly and strongly debated topic. Herman Cain and Michele Bachman, whom are both republican politicians stated that they are in support of and would renew the waterboarding policy, which President Barack Obama has banned (Nordgren, Loran). Cain said, "I don't see [waterboarding] as torture. I see if as an enhanced interrogation technique," and other politicians, including Mitt Romney, agree (Nordgren). Bachman sees waterboarding an nothing more than an effective measure of interrogation (Nordgren).On the other hand, politicians Ron Paul, Jon Huntsman and President Barack Obama are completely opposed to the practice of waterboarding and as Paul stated, believe that "[Waterboarding is] really un-American to accept, on principle, that we will torture people that we capture" (Nordgren).Is waterboarding actually an enhanced interrogation technique or is it just torture? As defined by the United Nations Convention Against Torture, torture is "any act by which sever pain or suffering, whether physical or mental, is intentionally inflicted on a person" (Is Waterboarding Torture?). With this definition, a decision whether waterboarding is torture or not can be made depending only on how much pain is inflicted on the person being interrogated (Is Waterboarding Torture?).Anna...

Find Another Essay On Waterboarding. What Is Waterboarding? Is Waterboarding Torture?

Why Torture is wrong Essay

752 words - 3 pages how are we defining "terror"? Is it the product of people or of ideas, or is it the manipulation of government? Thus when the lines become so blurry, humans will inevitably hurt others along the way. No matter what our religious beliefs are, where we live, or the politics of our country - we are all human beings with individual rights and responsibilities that should not be violated.It is not morally permissible to torture Al Queda suspects or

Torture is a Violation of International Law

1625 words - 7 pages physical and mental pain perpetrated on a civilian by a government official or agent (UUSC). There have been plenty of arguments regarding whether or not it is acceptable to torture, if so, under what circumstances does it become adequate. A debate about this issue should not even occur because torture should never be acceptable under any conditions. Torture is never acceptable because of reasons of principle, consequential reasons, and violation of

Torture is Acceptable in Certain Circumstances

849 words - 4 pages data it can guarantee many lives (Messerli 1). A common question when dealing with the topic torture is, “Why would criminals give in to torture?” Well, Criminals, fugitives, terrorists, whatever you decide to call them are also people. All people no matter what your feelings are can although feel, therefore no matter who the person, torture would be painful. Human’s natural instinct is to stop the pain, mental or physical. Therefore, the

Terrorism: What is it?

629 words - 3 pages "Terrorism has been practiced throughout history and throughout the world. The Spanish Inquisition used arbitrary arrest, torture, and execution to punish what it viewed as religious heresy. After the American Civil War (1861-65) defiant Southerners formed a terrorist organization called the Ku Klux Klan to intimidate supporters of Reconstruction." (Internet reference) The above-mentioned are just two of the many terrorist acts not typically

What is Telephone Tapping?

1664 words - 7 pages What is telephone tapping? You may be asking this to yourself right now. Telephone tapping is “the monitoring of telephone and Internet conversations by a third party, often by covert means. The wiretap received its name because, historically, the monitoring connection was an actual electrical tap on the telephone line” according to Google's definition, used from Wikipedia. Where did it all start? Phone tapping was started in the 1890’s

What is Obesity?

1141 words - 5 pages individual at an increased risk for numerous conditions, diseases such as diabetes, hypertension, coronary disease, certain types of cancer and ultimately an earlier than necessary death. What most people do not realize is that it does not take being hundreds of pounds overweight to qualify as being obese. In fact some studies estimate that as much as 31% of the total population of the United States is currently obese. When broken down into age

What is a Hero?

954 words - 4 pages A hero is characterized as any person who is admired for their courage or achievements, thus serving as a model. Some other characteristics associated with a hero are bravery and daring. It is the manner of facing and dealing with anything that is recognized as dangerous, difficult, or painful that further defines a hero. A primary example of a hero is the courageous men and women, many of whom are employed in a regular non-military job

What is piety?

951 words - 4 pages What is PietyDuring the Periclean age (around 400 B.C.) in Athens Greece there was a man named Socrates. He was considered a very wise man by the Athenians. However there were men in power who did not care for him or his teachings; Claiming that he corrupted the Athenian youth and did not believe in the Greek gods, Socrates was put on trail. On his way to his trial Socrates met a man named Euthyphro, a professional priest who is respected by the

What is Love?

642 words - 3 pages What is Love? Love, love, love, we hear it every day, every where , it is used so often that we don’t really give it a thought. The question that needs to be answered is what really is love? Was love created so that hate can be suppressed? Is love something that both man and woman hope for when their world comes crashing down on them? Does love help relief pain and suffering felt by victims of natural disasters? Aphrodite, Venus, Cupid, and

What Is A Counsellor?

944 words - 4 pages What is a Counsellor? Introduction After reading, viewing, thinking and talking over this question, I came up with the following two informal attempts at defining what a counsellor is.1. A counsellor is someone who (by agreement) helps another in the process of sorting out a problem. To put it another way, counselling is an interaction between two people where a person who is trying to sort something out, uses the help of another.2. A counsellor

What is freedom?

867 words - 3 pages In reality, what is freedom? When can I person actually declare freedom? These questions are brought to mind after engaging in the novel, The Known World. Many characters in the novel are said to be “free” , but they do not seem to be in reality free. Yes, they may be free from some binds, such as slavery, but in most cases, those who claim to be “free” are the ones who are indeed, the most suppressed. Take John Skiffington for

Similar Essays

Waterboarding Is Torture Essay

1192 words - 5 pages not its use will get them in trouble. Emotions are running high as the patrol team lost four of their own just the day before. What should they do? For them the answer may not be crystal clear because they are emotionally charged and probably not to concerned for the well-being of their captive. However, waterboarding should be considered torture because it violates Title 18, Part I, Ch. 113C of the United States (U.S.) Code; it is an act of

What Makes Waterboarding Torture? Essay

683 words - 3 pages Why Waterboarding is Torture The US Reservations of the UN Convention against Torture defines torture as “any act by which severe pain or suffering, whether physical or mental, is inflicted on a person for such purposes as obtaining information from a person.” Waterboarding fits into this definition very well. In the “How to Do It” article waterboarding is described as filling up the upper respiratory system with water causing both physical and

Is Torture Ever Acceptable? Essay

898 words - 4 pages a “morally defensible” interrogation method (8). The most widely used reason for torture is when many lives are in imminent danger. This means that any forms of causing harm are acceptable. This may seem reasonable, as you sacrifice one life to save way more, but it’s demoralizing. The arguments that justify torture usually are way too extreme to happen in the real world. The golden rule also plays a big role in this; don’t do to others what you

Is Torture Effective? Essay

954 words - 4 pages must look at every avenue of approach, based on the reactions of the subject. The concern that information gathered via torture is inaccurate is a valid concern. So how does an interrogator know when information gathered during a torture session is accurate or not? The truth of the matter is that distinguishing between what is true or false can be immensely difficult, and in fact may uncover areas of grey. Interrogators are trained to tell when