Ways Of Reading And Jane Tompkins

1216 words - 5 pages

Ways of Reading and Jane Tompkins

In the book, Ways of Reading, the authors Bartholomae and Petrosky outline what they describe as a "strong reader". They characterize the attributes that collectively contribute to this title and then talk about the relations between a strong reader and a strong writer. The perspectives that Bartholomae and Petrosky discuss on ideas and textual analysis are very interesting and in point of fact remind me of the thought process of which I use when analyzing a reading.
" Strong readers often read critically, weighing, for example, an author claims and interpretations against evidence-evidence provided by the author in the text, evidence drawn from other sources, or the evidence that is assumed to be part of a reader's own knowledge and experience."(p.12)
The easy way to read a text is to observe the general plot and to formulate ideas about the text through a first reading. A strong reader cannot only observe a reading; they can analyze the text and formulate an opinion through not only their own perspective and opinion, but through utilizing their own ideas as well as those of the authors and societies'. Reading Jane Tompkins's Indians, we find that the "strong reader" description is quickly applicable.

In Tompkins's essay, the reader is fed the façade that Tompkins's is writing on the relations between the Puritans first entering this country and the Native Americans already residing there. Her introduction to this paper is a personal reflection of a memory she has retained since her childhood. The reason for writing this essay she explains, is to prepare for a course she was to be teaching. The essay appears to be that of exceptional quality. Not only does she analyze the sources of which she has looked for understanding, she begins to discuss the bias in which every reading is coated. Her essay quickly turns into an analysis of the bias facts issued by authors and it's effect on the final product. By the time Tompkins's has to conclude her essay, the essay has progressed into something that has nothing to do with Native American's relations; instead the initial subject has become a catalyst for her conclusion.

" I didn't know what the facts were. All I had, or could have, was a series of different perspectives, and so nothing that would count as an authoritative source on which moral judgments could be based. But, as I have just show, I did judge, and that is because, as I now think, I did have some facts."(p.686)
As shown in the passage above, the argument that Tompkins's is having with herself is generalized. The story behind this quote could be anything, Tompkins has utilized a story about "Indians" as it helped her structure her argument a little more efficiently. Also, reading the passage above, we see that Jane Tompkins has contradicted herself, this is another technique she uses to exemplify her idea, and she will clarify this contradiction later in the conclusion.
" The awareness...

Find Another Essay On Ways of Reading and Jane Tompkins

Exploring the Ways Jane Austen Satirises the Social Values of her Characters in Volume One of Pride and Prejudice

1056 words - 4 pages Exploring the Ways Jane Austen Satirises the Social Values of her Characters in Volume One of Pride and Prejudice In 'Pride and Prejudice', Jane Austen satirises many of the characters through the way in which they behave, react towards others, what they say and other characters reactions to them. Jane Austen however, does not mock the more sensible, intelligent characters, such as Elizabeth, Darcy, Jane or Bingley, but

Ways Terror is Cultivated in Chapter 26 of Jane Eyre

1246 words - 5 pages Analyse the ways Charlotte Bronte creates a sense of terror in chapter 26 and comment on how this is sustained in the context of the gothic genre elsewhere in the novel. ‘Jane Eyre’ is a 19th century novel written by Charlotte Bronte. Bronte creates a sense of terror in chapter 26 in various ways, including: the rendezvous with Bertha and Bronte’s description. The gothic style also plays a big part in numerous points in the book. “Jane

"There are as many different ways of interpreting and valuing texts as there are readers." Do you agree? (Charlotte Bronte's "Jane Eyre")

1117 words - 4 pages . Jane Eyre is not only a fable about a girl, but a modern feminist plea, as in the opinion of Pauline Nestor, author of Striking A Balance. In this respect, the novel fundamentally justifies the view that a text may be interpreted in as many ways as there are readers.Bronte's depiction of Jane's upbringing can be seen simply as a story about her sufferings as a young girl and her struggles with authoritarian figures at school, such as Brocklehurst

Watching But Not Reading: Limitations of First-Person Narrative in Film Adaptations of Jane Eyre

2362 words - 10 pages film is analyzed this information, which is crucial to the understanding of the mindset of Jane as an adult, can be missed. Without reading into the symbolic use of light, audiences are unaware of the lasting influence of Helen on Jane's character and of the extent of the feeling of confinement and repression that Jane experiences in her childhood. Without analyzing the varying volume and tone of young Jane's voice as she bounces back and forth

Watching But Not Reading: Limitations of First-Person Narrative in Film Adaptations of Jane Eyre

1926 words - 8 pages is present, but often times overlooked. This changes the way that viewers perceive and understand Jane, which in turn changes the way they interpret the film. The 1943 film adaptation of Jane Eyre, directed by Robert Stevenson and starring Joan Fontaine and Orson Welles, opens with the image of a book, bearing the title Jane Eyre, along with other production information. The pages then turn, as if the viewer was themselves reading the novel

Comparing the Ways in Which Billy Casper and Jane Eyre are Presented as Outsiders

2719 words - 11 pages company of each other, when the rare occasion of a break arose, Jane would remain by herself, alone. Jane's innocence was short lived when a clumsy accident caused her to be brought to the attention of Mr Brocklehurst on his visit. It is then that Mr B remembers her aunts parting requests; that Jane be watched by the other girls and teachers and to proclaim Jane's tyrannous and deceitful ways. Jane is humiliated and made

Why Students are Not Reading and Ways to Get them to Read More

1258 words - 5 pages Why Students are Not Reading and Ways to Get them to Read More "We shouldn't teach great books. We should teach a love of reading." B. F. Skinner "What is a reader?" and "What makes a good reader?" Out of 100 eighth graders surveyed at a middle school in Pennsylvania, 73% of them said that you have to read a lot and practice reading. When the same one hundred eighth graders were asked how they feel about reading, 55% said they love it

Analysis of Ways of War and Peace

1258 words - 6 pages Michael W. Doyle’s book Ways of War and Peace systematically analyzes classic theories like realism and liberalism that try to explain why nations wage war. However, not all theories discussed within the text are equal. In this paper I will try to argue that within the book written by Michael Doyle he paints a picture that the theory of realism is more applicable today then liberalism, even if that was not his original intention. Through careful

Comparison of Harry Potter and Jane Eyre

1058 words - 4 pages their respective schools. Both Harry Potter and Jane Eyre grew up and lived with their relatives. Harry Potter lived with the Dursleys while Jane lived with the Reeds. Reading their story and how they had to live every single day of their lives with such cruel, unkind and selfish relatives is heartbreaking. However, throughout the course of their story, their experiences and difficulties helped in shaping their characters and eventually

The Life and Career of Jane Austen

1065 words - 5 pages Jane Austen was an exceptional English author of romantic fiction novels. However, it was not until after Jane’s lifetime that she was well acknowledged as a writer. Jane grew up with a large family whom she was very close to. She was inspired by her family greatly, and because of this wrote about situations relatable to everyday life. She was also a very innovative author; she helped to shape new ways of writing in her works. Through examining

Light and Dark Sides of Jane Eyre

2484 words - 10 pages interval between day and night when time stops and examines itself” (Steinbeck 117). The pearl is also considered a symbol of love and sexuality, which derived from the Greek’s Aphrodite, Cleopatra, and Muslim tradition. All of those symbols are also themes within Charlotte Brontë’s Jane Eyre. The pearl while only mentioned in passing proves the ever present light-dark symbolism Jane Eyre is thriving in many little ways, just around the turn of a

Similar Essays

The Problem Of Understanding And Its Possible Solutions In "Our Time" By John Edgar Wideman And "Indians" By Jane Tompkins

895 words - 4 pages Both Jane Tompkins and John Edgar Wideman devote some of their paper to pointing out the difficulties they face when writing their essays, "Indians" and "Our Time" respectively. The two authors are trying to reach and give an account of the actual situation and circumstances of the subject of their writing, but in the process of creating their essays realize that this is something they would hardly achieve."Our time" was created to tell the

Indians By Jane Tompkins: How Bias Affect Ones Concept Of History

709 words - 3 pages "Indians" By Jane Tompkins: How Bias Affect Ones Concept of History Whenever you are in any educational situation, you are subject to perspectives and bias of the instructors. In an essay entitled "Indians," by Jane Tompkins, it discusses how different biases may reflect upon one's concept of history. It is imperative to realize that when learning, which generally involves someone's concept of history, we are consequently

Critical Reading Of Jane Austen's "Pride And Prejudice"

2309 words - 9 pages problems, which had earlier benn described to her by Colonel Fitzwilliam and for separating Jane and Charles Bingley. Darcy does not deny these accusations and leaves bitterly. The following morning, Darcy seeks Elizabeth out on one of her walks and gives her a letter in all manner of politeness. Upon her reading it, she changes most of her preconceptions about Darcy as he answers all of her charges with the utmost eloquence and politeness. As a

"A Room Of One's Own", "Letters To Alice On First Reading Jane Austen" And "Capote"

1403 words - 6 pages Making specific reference to A room of One's own, Letters to Alice on first reading Jane Austen and one other text evaluate the ways in which language shapes and reflects culture and values.Values, preoccupations and themes are all evident in literature through the use of literary techniques. However, other forms, such as film, allow, through cinematographic techniques, for these values, preoccupations and themes to also become evident. Virginia