Schumpeter's View Of Competition Essay

1110 words - 5 pages

Creative Destruction
The article titled “Schumpeterian competition and diseconomy of scope; illustrations from histories of Microsoft and IBM” by the authors Bresnahan, Greenstein and Henderson is a great attempt to address the creative destruction problem that face organizations mostly in the technology-led and innovation-based industries. In that respect, this paper is a reaction to the authors’ arguments with a view on their focus on diseconomy of scope in addressing the possible cause of the creative destruction problem. To achieve that objective, the argument begins by reviewing the author’s argument and introducing a counter argument that is then supported by a further review of their argument’s validity as well as the strength of the counterargument. (Bresnahan, Greenstein & Henderson, 2011)
Authors’ view
Schumpeter’s view of competition is that companies’ innovation is continuously destructive to processes and assets. In that respect, new technologies displace the older ones making way for greater growth than in the conservative and stable markets. The authors’ review of the failure by IBM and Microsoft provides a good description of that Schumpeterian competition and diseconomy of scope. In that analysis, the author’s address the question on the causes of creative destruction through which they challenge the view that failure in new technological areas by companies that have been successful in theindustry is explained by two scenarios. One being that the companies fear the cannibalization hence ends up under-investing in the new market. The other explanation challenged is that the companies tend to develop cognitive frameworks and organizational capabilities that slow their identification and response to new opportunities. In that respect, the authors argument is that the problem that faces such companies is the diseconomy of scope that greatly relates to the assets involved hence the initial success that is usually followed by failure for such new ventures. (Nerkar & Paruchuri, 2005)
Contrary to the authors’ argument, the new development and ventures by the old large firms in the industry enjoys economies of scale and scope that provides a comparative advantage against new entrants and competitors. In addition, market imperfections provide large companies like IBM and Microsoft with advantages in Research and development. Further, the large companies are capable of spreading fixed costs in addition to the ability to exploit the economies of scale and scope for actions like Research and development. Finally, the firms have a better access to downstream capabilities and complementary technologies. In that respect, those companies can enjoy economies of scope and scale hence the issue of diseconomy of scope is as a weak basis for explaining their failure with new ventures. (Nerkar & Paruchuri, 2005)
Counterargument
Schumpeterian competition’s definition in itself provides a preview of the nature of the market that organizations face. It...

Find Another Essay On Schumpeter's View of Competition

testt Essay

7757 words - 31 pages fl ected growing confi dence in the value of strategic planning. Strat- egy consulting boutiques expanded rapidly and achieved widespread recognition. How different the landscape looks today. The armies of planners have all but disappeared, swept away by the turbulence of the past de- cade. On multiple fronts, strategy has come under fi re. At the business unit level, the pace of global competition and technological change has

The Curse of Competition Essay

1987 words - 8 pages status, mates, and resources (Price). Competition also plays a large role in the world of video games. In fact, a competitive Super Smash Brothers player, Chris Fabiszak, wrote a book on his experiences as a competitive video game player. He shares his view on how a competitive nature affected him as a gamer: I think it was the taste of failure that really set me off, but I also became immediately interested in this subculture that I never knew

Karl Marx and Andrew Carnegie concerning their ideologies on class tensions

1808 words - 7 pages , society will benefit as a whole and progress will occur for everyone. Marx's utopian society could not exist due to the greediness of people that would try to seize power, which would create competition. Keen has taken the view of competition in the extreme which is rather unrealistic. Allowing a moderate level of competition will have a positive effect on society. Like Carnegie, the few wealthy should possess great resources that enable them

Competition Law in England

1468 words - 6 pages Although competition law has occupied a place in the body of English law for many centuries, modern statutory competition policy first emerged in the aftermath of the Second World War. From the point of view of present laws, the statutes then introduced lacked the ability to deal with the prevalent market situations and had a faulty enforcement mechanism. The competition regime in UK got a major push only after the passing of the Competition Act

the vital importance of establishing ‘a system ensuring that competition in the internal market is not distorted

2609 words - 10 pages , 2002) p 311]The defence of smaller firms has been arguably a reason behind adopting competition laws. The European Commission takes the view that small and medium sized firms should be protected from aggregations of economic power to improve inconsistency and effectiveness and ultimately to limit distortions of competition. An objective that goes accordingly with this is that of fairness and equity, forcing firms to behave in a certain way to

The Effects of Competition in Sports On Children Ages Nine Through Twelve

3178 words - 13 pages View, CA: Mayfield Publishing Company.Torres, C.R., & Hager, P.F. (2007). De-emphasizing competition in organized youth sport: misdirected reforms and misled children. Journal of the Philosophy of Sport, 34(2), 194-209. Retrieved from Academic Search Premier.Vallerand, R, Gauvin, L, & Halliwell, W. (1986). Negative effects of competition on children's intrinsic motivation. Journal of Social Psychology, 126(5), 649-657. Retrieved from Academic Search Premier database.

What are the incentives to innovate? Which market structure creates the best conditions for innovation?

982 words - 4 pages Untitled What are the incentives to innovate? Which market structure creates the best conditions for innovation? Foreword What is the key to the answer on topic questions? To my mind this is the potential of the company to receive profits and degree of competition on the market. In reality the research and development (R&D) activity is not cheap. Sure, there are a lot of examples when ordinary people made important

Was Singapore correct to exclude vertical restraints from the section 34 prohibition?

2081 words - 9 pages . Rationale for Excluding Vertical Agreements The rationale for excluding vertical agreements can be gleaned from the Second Public Consultation on the Draft Competition Bill . The Ministry of Trade and Industry (“MTI”) took the view that: [T]here is general consensus amongst economists that the majority of vertical agreements have net pro-competitive effect. As such, it would be more appropriate to retain the current approach to exclude vertical

The Paradox of Cooperation and Competition in Strategic Alliances - Towards a Multi-paradigm Approach

7012 words - 28 pages , cooperation, competition, strategic alliances, multi-paradigmINTRODUCTIONIn the 1970s and early 1980s, the strategic challenge for business was viewed primarily as protecting its potential profits from erosion through either competition or bargaining. This view of strategy underwent a change in the late 1980s. The need to pursue multiple sources of competitive advantage led to the need for building collaborative relationships with suppliers

The Auto Industry

814 words - 3 pages In the automobile industry, a great proportion of income comes from selling automobiles. Globalization is the inclination of world investment and business to move from a country and local markets to a worldwide environment, is a major factor that affects the auto market. More than ever, it has been easy for foreign auto dealers to enter the American market creating competition. Competition is a major factor that takes a toll on the auto industry

Block Buster Case Study

1090 words - 4 pages Blockbuster has 2800 video stores in 28 countries around the world, many of which are franchises. Its membership is thought to number 40,000,000+ people. Blockbuster manages $5 billion in annual sales, and is the top retailer for movie rentals in the US. Recently, however, it has been facing tough competition, in view of the fact that the five major Hollywood movie studios are planning to rent movies to college students directly, and in view of

Similar Essays

Wall Street Essay

2987 words - 12 pages like. From Schumpeter's point of view, the underlying cause of the next market crash, would simply be that the long wave of prosperity that began in 1938 is now over. According to Kindleberger's careful history mentioned above the speculative bubble in many past economic crises has often burst as the result of some purely exogenous event. If an army somewhere loses a battle, for example, markets crash as investors run for the exits. The IBD closes its' provocative article mentioned above by suggesting that the infamous Y2K bug might just play the role of the required exogenous force here. Let’s hope that they are wrong for once!

Understanding The Function Of Markets Through Different Theoretical Perspectives

2439 words - 10 pages . 2- The ease of entry and exit from the market; and 3- The type of products and to what degree it is differentiated. Dynamic Competition: Schumpeter's view of this model of competitive markets stands on the basis of competition over innovations in products and process and not price competition. So firms that do not move ahead faster than their competitors will fall behind and eventually will go out of business

Radical Innovation In Large Companies Essay

1440 words - 6 pages distinction between exploitation of existing technology and exploration of new technology (1). Exploitation has to do with refining or expanding existing products or processes, whereas exploration involves something fundamentally new, including new products, processes, or combinations of the two. In my view, incremental innovation usually emphasizes cost or feature improvements in existing products or services and is dependent on exploitation

Globalisation And The Contradiction Of Peripheral Capitalism In Nigeria

9693 words - 39 pages Nigerian economy". In view of this, besides our introduction, the paper has being divided into six sections. We shall first look at related literatures towards defining the concept; we shall employ Immanuel Wallersteins theory to understand globalization as a global economy, succinctly look at the Nigerian economy, then the contradictions, we will look at some step to be taken. Finally, our concluding remarks will follow.THE CONCEPT OF GLOBALISATION