This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

We Must Abolish Capital Punishment Essay

798 words - 3 pages

In Support of Abolishing Capital Punishment

          The purpose of this study is to present a handful of arguments stating why capital punishment should be abolished. Retribution, humanity and race will all be explored in this paper on the controversial subject. Two authors will be looked at in this study; Robert Johnson and Jack Greenberg. Both contend that the death penalty is a farce in their country; the United States, which is the only country in the entire Western democratic world that enforces capital punishment.

        People who oppose the death penalty agree that the main purpose of capital punishment should be retribution. Robert Johnson, Author of Death Work: A Study of the Modern Execution Process, however, suggests that people often lose sight of what the meaning of retribution is:

                    Retribution means giving criminals the punishment they deserve,
                    and this is a sensible and just notion. The virtues of retribution can
                    easily be lost sight of, however, because retribution is generally
                    tinged with revenge, and vengeance is considered a base motive
                    that in turn debases any punishment with which it is associated
                    (Johnson, 149).

          Johnson firmly believes that people who support the death penalty resort to primitive ways of thinking, and therefore, the death penalty is a form of “Moral Outrage” which should not be accepted in our society.

          He also believes that the death penalty contradicts the idea of a “civil society” which we supposedly live in. Johnson uses Anthony Amsterdam’s observations to help support his argument: “They are expected to sit back quietly and observe decent courtroom decorum throughout a proceeding whose purpose is systematically and deliberately to decide whether they should be killed”(Amsterdam, 150). In Johnson’s view, we cannot justly call ourselves a humane society when our view of a humane society is one that kills for punishment.

          A philosophical approach is also taken by Johnson on Death Work. In quoting Plato, he in effect points out that two wrongs do not make a right: “We ought not to repay injustice with injustice or to do harm to any man, no matter what we may have suffered from him”(Plato, 150). Johnson sympathizes with Plato, claiming we must offer a moral lesson to the killer instead of taking his life. “To be humane”, Johnson elaborates, “punishment must not only be civilized, conforming to some notion of a fair measure of pain or loss, but also...

Find Another Essay On We Must Abolish Capital Punishment

Should We Use Capital Punishment? Essay

1259 words - 5 pages Should We Use Capital Punishment? Capital punishment is an extremely controversial issue on which some people have strong views. Capital Punishment is when a criminal is punished for committing crimes, such as murder, by being put to death. One reason for many people being against Capital Punishment is that inhumane methods are used to kill criminals. In the past, methods such as stoning, gassing, hanging

Capital Punishment Must Be Put To Death

1800 words - 7 pages murder. In many states the murder must also come with a number of aggravating factors or circumstances. The families of murder victims should be able to depend on the justice system to fairly convict the criminal, but not to get revenge on the criminal. It is a myth that executions give closure to the families and loves ones of murder victims. “Ultimately, the moral question surrounding capital punishment in America has less to do with whether those

We Must Abolish Nuclear Weapons

1799 words - 7 pages fear that if a terrorist gets nuclear weapons then we will be attacked starting a nuclear war in our country many more countries. So I want nuclear weapons abolish so we won’t destroy ourselves terrorist from getting their hands on these weapons of mass destruction and destroying civilization as we know it and to prevent. Works Cited "Nuclear Weapons." Current Issues: Macmillan Social Science Library. Detroit: Gale, 2010. Gale Opposing Viewpoints in Context. Web. 28 Mar. 2012. About Nuclear Power, Weapons, Waste and Contamination. Web. 30 Mar. 2012. .

Capital Punishment: How We Can Improve

561 words - 3 pages think everybody wants to hear.Now I do not believe that we should put everyone in a jail to death. I am saying that murderers, rapists, and more serious crimes of that nature should be allowed to have the option of the death penalty. I believe it should be recommended for serious crimes. Capital punishment should be handled by a case-by-case basis, because every case is different. The idea is to use capital punishment for the people who need it. If

Capital Punishment- Who are we to take a life?

763 words - 3 pages the past hangings, guillotines, and many more ways of capital punishment were used, in the 20th century we have less horrific ways of punishing individuals with less costly ways. Incase the convicted are innocent and are later proved to be not innocent, they can then be released. As well as, life imprisonment in a maximum security jail is more effective towards other delinquents to teach them of castigation rather than death sentences.

Should We Use Capital Punishment?

643 words - 3 pages Capital punishment (also known as the death penalty) has been around in the United States since the 1600s. It has been used today and in previous decades to justify and punish several offenses. The British have played a tremendous influence in America’s use of the death penalty over any other country. The first ever recorded execution was in 1608 in the Jamestown colony of Virginia when George Kendall was discovered to be a spy for Spain

We Must Put an End to Corporal Punishment

2410 words - 10 pages , that they will certainly have abusive or violent tendencies as an adult, but research does show that children learn by example. Are violence, hurt, pain, and submissiveness the kind of examples that we as parents want to set?     Another very important effect of corporal punishment is actual physical harm and injury to the child. One small swat on the bottom will probably not leave any physical damage, but most spanking does not

Captial Punishement

640 words - 3 pages Callous, calculating cruelty is not the type of treatment we should be expecting from society. Can we really expect to progress with disgusting acts like capital punishment? Capital punishment is one of the most irreparable crime society commits without consequence and it must be abolished from modern society. “An eye for an eye, A Tooth for a Tooth” is the one of the most common arguments used to justify capital punishment. Humans are known for

Capital Punishment

557 words - 2 pages Capital PunishmentCapital Punishment is whereby a government punishes an offender by putting them todeath for a certain crime. Throughout history many arguments have been raised onwhether or not to abolish capital punishment. Some believe that capital punishmentshould be abolished for various reasons such as, cruelty and discrimination. They alsobelieve that it does not deter crime. However, these arguments either haven't been provenor aren't

Human Rights

594 words - 2 pages , the capital punishment serves and benefits society as a whole by saving innocent lives (Schabas, 1996).Human rightsI know my opponent will bring up this argument so I might as well write about it now. In Article 3 of the United Nations Declaration of Human Rights, it stated, "Everyone has the right to life, liberty and security of person" (Schabas, 1996). However, if we really followed this rule then society would greatly differ. According to it

The Use of Capital Punishment on Convicted Murderers is an Effective Method of Deterrance

1545 words - 6 pages life imprisonment. They’re view that capital punishment is administered arbitrarily, is supported by the 1972 United States Supreme Court ruling to abolish capital punishment. The Supreme Court ruled, in the case of Furman v. Georgia, that the state statutes were void of standards, and gave too much discretion to the judge and juries. The Supreme Court found that blacks that killed whites were more likely to receive a sentence of death than

Similar Essays

Abolish Capital Punishment Essay

610 words - 2 pages does not allow it. There have been many studies performed that prove that people have been wrongly accused of life imprisonment and if they would have gotten the death penalty, it would be impossible to bring them back. Also, the cost and religious matters help to outweighs the opposing side of capital punishment.Death penalty Facts., L. Mei. Capital Punishment Cruel and Unusual. Wylie: Information Plus, 2000.Robinson, A. Bruce. The Death Penalty. 28 May 2002. Ontario Consultants on Religious Tolerance.

Abolish Capital Punishment Essay

1563 words - 7 pages noose is placed around the neck, with a knot behind the inmate’s left ear. A trap - door which is below the inmate, is open and the inmate falls through causing a rapid dislocation of the neck (The Corrections Professional, 1996). One of the main arguments against capital punishment is that we have to move away from the need of retribution. Human instincts work in a way that we want to immediately hurt the person who wronged us. This notion of

Capital Punishment Must Be Abolished Essay

4184 words - 17 pages penalty. According to Michael Reggio, this led to many reforms in Britain’s death penalty laws: In 1823, five laws passed, exempting about a hundred crimes from the death [penalty]. Between 1832 and 1837, many capital offenses were swept away. In 1840, there was a failed attempt to abolish all capital punishment. Through the nineteenth and twentieth centuries, more and more capital punishments were abolished, not only in Britain, but also all

Capital Punishment Must Be Abolished Essay

1321 words - 5 pages Capital punishment is used to bring justice to the crimes of murderers in our society, but is it really just? Studies show that the death penalty is cruel, morally wrong, and sometimes painful. It robs the criminal and the public of their humanity and undermines the value of life. The public should come to realize the cruelty of this law, and this form of punishment should be abolished from the government's criminal justice system