We Must Ban Therapeutic Human Cloning

2876 words - 12 pages


   The Senate is considering a proposal to outlaw human cloning. Two alternative proposals would ban only "reproductive cloning," which would mean explicitly legalizing human cloning but not the implantation of a clone embryo into a womb. Pro-cloners are willing for the most part to outlaw reproductive cloning because it isn't safe, but they oppose a ban on cloning for research and experimentation--known as "therapeutic cloning"--arguing that such a cloning license is necessary to the development of future medical treatments for human ailments. This opposition to a ban on human therapeutic cloning is misinformed.

 

The case against cloning, including therapeutic cloning, has mainly been argued on grounds of morality. Opponents have warned that creating embryos through cloning for the purpose of research (with the full intention of destroying them later) is a breathtakingly radical enterprise. For the first time in history, human lives will be created for the explicit purpose of exploitation. Such considerations have led activist Jeremy Rifkin to opine that the cloning debate is to the 21st century what the slavery debate was to the 19th.

 

Unfortunately, we live in a time of widespread and extreme non-judgmentalism, an era when many Americans simply do not respond to moral arguments in public policy debates. For these folk, what counts is not right versus wrong, but whether it will or won't work--in a word, utility.

 

Does this mean that the public policy amoralists among us must end up by default on the pro-cloning side? Not at all. There is increasing evidence that therapies based on cloned embryo cells would be so difficult and expensive to develop and so utterly impractical to bring to the bedside, that the pie-in-the-sky promises which fuel the pro-cloning side of the debate are unlikely to materialize. Not only is human cloning immoral but it may have negative utility--in other words, attempting to develop human cloning technologies for therapeutic use may drain resources and personnel from more useful and practical therapies.

 

To understand why therapeutic cloning fails the utility test, we must take a quick look at the significant difficulties facing embryonic stem cell research. Embryonic stem cell researchers hope to create medical treatments that would use undifferentiated cells--known generically as stem cells--extracted from 5-to-7-day-old embryos known as blastocysts. During natural gestation, these stem cells eventually "differentiate," that is, they transform into bone, neurons, muscle, organs, blood--indeed, all of the more than 200 different tissue types in the body. Researchers hope to learn how to harness this ability by extracting stem cells from embryos, transforming them into specific tissues, and then injecting the tissues into patients to treat medical ailments.

 

In their enthusiasm for embryonic stem cells--and in an effort to assure ample funding for the research--some...

Find Another Essay On We Must Ban Therapeutic Human Cloning

Religion Studies - Therapeutic human cloning needs to be made available to all people, regardless of financial or economic position, when it becomes frantically available.

848 words - 3 pages all revolves around the same context, human rights. They can't prejudice like this. It is not something that's materialistic; it's just another chance of life. We are taking away the chance of another life that only the rich are able afford, whilst the poor cant. Therapeutic cloning is morally wrong, but in the same context, it already exists. Because of this, it should be available for everyone. There is a thin line between savings someone's life and gaining money. Everyone deserves opportunities.

Cloning: The Benefits and Where to Draw the Line

2257 words - 10 pages attention, sparking concern about the ability of science to clone human beings. The prospect was unsettling to many countries; several nations, including Great Britain, outlawed human cloning altogether. The World Health Organization condemned the idea of human cloning, and the United States passed a law preventing federal funds from being used on research for human cloning (Therapeutic). In addition, fifteen U.S. states have enacted laws banning

Therapeutic Cloning

2585 words - 10 pages Cloning is the use of technology to compose a precise genetic copy of a living organism. The term ‘cloning’ can also be applied to copying cells, a gene or a part of DNA (Healey, J 2007). There are two main techniques of cloning: reproductive and therapeutic. Reproductive cloning is the cloning of a human being. Reproductive cloning has a lot of ethical barriers but some scientists believe that reproductive cloning may one day be legal

Human Cloning Goes Global

874 words - 3 pages ." France and Germany originally proposed that human reproductive cloning be banned under a treaty to be negotiated at the U.N.   A United States Senate judiciary committee is also reviewing the human cloning issue this week. The Senate is considering three bills on human cloning. Senator Sam Brownback (R-KS) is the sponsor of a bill (S.1899) that provides a comprehensive ban on human cloning, both "therapeutic" cloning and reproductive

Human Cloning Examines the issue human cloning. Debates the pros and cons and the ethical issues surrounding the procedure. Describes political efforts to outlaw the process.

1198 words - 5 pages is the world that many people hope for, where people can clone copies of lost loved ones and continues living as if they never left.The science of human cloning is a very controversial topic in the United States, as well as in the rest of the developed world. The biggest reason why cloning is controversial is because in therapeutic cloning, stem cells are harvested from cloned human embryos, which kills those embryos. Religious groups and "right

Cloning VS Religion

1410 words - 6 pages Buddhists support therapeutic cloning, but also refute reproductive cloning. Therapeutic cloning is a laboratory technique for creating a clonial embryo, using an ovum with a donor nucleus (wikipedia.org). Buddhists support the research and experiments of therapeutic cloning because the purpose of it is not to create a human, instead it is to make items that can be used for humans. The idea of therapeutic cloning is to create new skin, or nerve

Cloning, Pros and Cons

3749 words - 15 pages reproduction) is now closer to reality (Daniel & Levine, 2001). Types of Cloning There are actually two types of cloning: reproductive cloning and therapeutic cloning. Reproductive cloning is making human beings asexually. In reproductive cloning, the offspring receives genetic information from one parent through a duplication process in a laboratory. DreamTech International states, "All we need is a tiny swab of cell tissue from the inside of

Argument for Human Cloning

2277 words - 9 pages understanding our ancestors or other prehistoric species, and it benefits parents who lost their beloved children, or those who cannot have children. Argumentative Point 1 Tension of whether or not to ban cloning has occurred in a long period of time. Since 1998, Controversy about whether to ban the procedure of applying human embryonic stem cells, a method classified as therapeutic cloning has spread around the world. On the other hand, cloning

The Effects of Human Cloning on Medicine

2312 words - 9 pages about reproductive cloning but seem to be torn on the idea of therapeutic cloning (“Human Cloning: House Approves Cloning Ban”). In 1997, reproductive cloning was prohibited, and President Bill Clinton prevented the use of federal funds for human cloning research (ProQuest Staff). In 1998, the FDA announced their ability to regulate human cloning, and human cloning was banned in nineteen different European nations (ProQuest Staff). In 2001, The

Should cloning be legalized? Arguments pro-cloning and anti-cloning.

963 words - 4 pages of 2001 and 62% in January of 2003. Medical bodies like the Canadian Medical Association and the Collège des Médecins du Québec have come out in favor of regulating therapeutic cloning, not banning it.While it is important that we, the public, win the right to have such promising technology as cloning be exercised in our lives, we must proceed with caution, as the President of the Unites States has so aptly noted: "We must advance the promise and cause of science, but must do so in a way that honors and respects life."

Human Cloning

3506 words - 14 pages their life, as is now required after transplants. There would not be any danger of organ rejection. Figure 4: Human Therapeutic Cloning Source: Advanced Cell Technology, Inc. Worcester, Massachusetts, 2004, Human therapeutic cloning [online] Available form URL: http://www.lef.org/magazine/mag2002/mar2002_report_cloning_01.html (Accessed Tuesday March 2008) Procedure 1. Take a woman's ovum, and remove its DNA. This converts it to a form of human

Similar Essays

We Must Stop Cloning Now! Essay

632 words - 3 pages We Must Stop Cloning Now! Did you know it took 277 tries to finally create the first mammal clone, Dolly? The process of cloning is not even close to being perfected to be used on animals or humans. It would also cause many different problems in the world if we did start cloning. We should stop this practice because it has to many flaws, it destroys individuality and uniqueness, will cause over population, and is against many

We Must Ban Genetically Modified Foods

731 words - 3 pages applied and who are to benefit. Biotechnology will concentrate power into the hands of a select few, which in turn will enhance farmers' dependence and force them to pay inflated prices for seed-chemical packages.Genetic engineering poses the greatest danger of any technology yet introduced. The damaging effects of genetic engineering are irreversible, but we have the capability to prevent a catastrophe before it occurs. We must take precautionary

We Must Ban Assault Weapons Essay

2503 words - 10 pages -automatic rifles to fully-automatic rifles, people have a greater firing power. They can shoot at a more rapid pace with more fire power. Due to criminals converting such weapons, police officers have to upgrade their fire power to semi-automatic weapons to therefore putting more dangerous weapons on the streets. The Federal assault weapon ban would virtually eliminate the possession of semi-automatic weapons for police officers and criminals

We Must Put And End To Human Trafficking

4130 words - 17 pages is imperative for a more substantial effort to be put forth in order to combat the growing number of human trafficking cases. This effort must not be merely centered on individual countries fighting local cases; to see true results, countries must work together globally to punish offenders from each nation. This issue should be of great concern to people worldwide and the initiative must be taken to raise global awareness on this topic. In order