This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

We Must Not Treat Muslims As We Treated The Japanese

966 words - 4 pages

We Must Not Treat Muslims as We Treated the Japanese


The terrorist attacks on 9-11 have frequently been analogized to Pearl Harbor. In many ways, the analogy is apt. Just as that attack launched us into World War II, the attacks on the World Trade Center and the Pentagon have launched us into a new kind of war, against terrorism. But waging this sort of borderless war poses great risks, not only to the soldiers commanded to fight but also to core American values. In this way, Pearl Harbor raises other disturbing memories, those of the internment.


Like the recent explosions on the East Coast, the bombing of Pearl Harbor on 12-7, shattered our feeling of national security. How could this have happened? Ordinary individuals, prominent journalists, and government officials soon started pointing the finger at the Japanese in America. Viewing these "Orientals" as incurably foreign, speaking foreign languages, perpetuating foreign cultures, practicing foreign religions (Shinto, Buddhism), American society could not distinguish between the Empire of Japan and Americans of Japanese descent. As General DeWitt, in charge of the Western Defense Command, put it, "A Jap's a Jap." In testimony, he elaborated: "[R]racial affinities are not severed by migration. The Japanese race is an enemy race and while many second and third generation Japanese born on United States soil, possessed of United States citizenship have become 'Americanized' the racial strains are undiluted." As government reports rushed to the conclusion that Japanese Americans aided and abetted the attack, the wheels of the internment machinery began turning.


On February 19, 1942, President Franklin Roosevelt issued Executive Order 9066, which authorized military commanders in the Western U.S. to issue whatever orders were necessary for national security. Although prompted by DeWitt's ominously titled "Final Recommendation" for mass internment, the Order conveniently made no mention of race or ethnicity. In March, Congress criminalized disobedience of military regulations issued pursuant to the executive order. By December, an efficient, empowered military had concentrated nearly all Japanese on the West Coast into ten desolate camps, surrounded by barbed wire and armed sentries. All this without the declaration of martial law. All this without any individualized determinations of guilt or disloyalty.


The internment was challenged in courts of law, but the Supreme Court affirmed the constitutionality of the curfew and exclusion orders in the 1943 and 1944 cases of Hirabayashi, Yasui, and Korematsu. While protesting loudly that racial prejudice should trigger the highest scrutiny, the Court nevertheless deferred to the government's vague claims of military necessity. Was the internment in fact justified as a matter of military necessity? A Congressionally appointed blue ribbon commission concluded in 1982 that the "broad historical causes which...

Find Another Essay On We Must Not Treat Muslims as We Treated the Japanese

We Must Stop Racism Essay

1733 words - 7 pages title”. Because she has Indian decent, her skin color is brown, because of this many did not know her actual heritage. According to Global Voices, “she has found herself at the receiving end of a slew of racist comments online,” these comments and tweets were directed against Arabs, Africans, Muslims, and Indians (A. Ray, 2013). According to the Huffington Post “anyone who was watching Twitter as they watched the Miss America 2014 pageant saw a

If We Must Die Essay

732 words - 3 pages “If We Must Die & The Flea” The two poems “If We Must Die” by Claude McKay and “The Flea” by John Donne both authors use animal images in similar and different ways. McKay and Donne both use death of an animal as an analogy to get their point across in each poem. Claude goes on to use his animal imagery to show honor in analogy of honor and death compared to the life of a hog. John uses his analogy of his sexual motive to the actions of

We Must Elimiante Pennies

1081 words - 4 pages with your help. We are a species of sentimentalists. The only reason we have pennies is because we like pennies, and we grew up with pennies, and we like Abraham Lincoln. But as John Green said in a statement to “If Abraham Lincoln were alive today, he would say, why is my face on a coin that is worth one twenty sixth of what it was worth when I was president.” And second because it is not an issue you can really fight

Why We Must Laugh

1490 words - 6 pages matter. Not only an immense and terrible tragedy, the Holocaust is also an extremely well-recorded tragedy. But the Holocaust itself is generally polished over in such works of entertainment, either given a short-lived mention or existing solely in the background as a present threat. After all, it’s just too serious. Nevertheless, several filmmakers have attempted to find humor in this humorless event. Oftentimes, one finds moments of black humor

We Must Reduce Unemployment

1717 words - 7 pages is not doing its job. Why Should We Worry About Unemployment The terror and fear that are produced as a result of unemployment are captured in a book titled Hard Times which states, “Against the backdrop of a robust economy, hundreds of thousands of people in this country remain out of work for long periods of time, causing economic and psychological hardships for entire families” (Cottle, 2001). Unemployment poses a great problem to the

We Must Remain Strong

1314 words - 5 pages BACKGROUND Rosa Louise Parkes was born in Tuskegee, Alabama in 1912. She was the grand daughter of former slaves and the daughter of James Mc Cauley, a carpenter and Leona Mc Cauley a rural schoolteacher.Parkes had a strong religious background, her belief in God and her religious convictions are the core of everything that she has done, and still does today.Society at the time did not treat people equally, white ruled blacks & men ruled

The Problem With How We Treat Bipolar Disorder

804 words - 4 pages challenges to Bipolar disorder that I have no ideas of what the best method of treatment could be. I do know that as science continues to advance hopefully we will develop a plan that does not cause as much devastation for the people suffering.

We Must Promote Diversity in the Workplace

623 words - 2 pages respected and not ignored, and where everyone feels comfortable (Wiliams, 2010, p. 231). As the face of business changes, so too must the climate in which employees work. Diversity is far more than a set of laws or a component of training, diversity is a part of everyday existence. The impact of diversity on business is such that diversity training, awareness, and sensitivity not only impacts the environment in which employees work; diversity impacts

We Must Promote Diversity in the Workplace

1248 words - 5 pages & Sondak, 2011). As Canas and Sondak point out, there is not one, definitive definition for diversity and individual organizations must determine their own definition. An organization’s definition of diversity will set the foundation for how diversity will be managed within the organization (Canas & Sondak, 2011). A Business Case for Diversity Many might look at diversity as simply a social issue; so why is it important for organizations to

We Must Increase the Minimum Wage

1534 words - 6 pages community’s will become better and more people will be working at the same job, not every day changing to a different job to see which pays more. As Jeff karoub said “There might be some employment losses but wage gains for those still employed are likely to be larger’’ I personally think that they should just take their chances and if they are with the union then I think nothing will happen to them. And even if they did lose their job that doesn’t mean

We Must Not Allow Wealthy Donors to Control U.S. Politics

1806 words - 7 pages possible solutions for it. In order to fix our economy and prevent future crises, we must have political reform in campaign finances, controlled lobbying and thorough background checks. Today the United States government properly defines itself as a representative regimen. We as the people of government have every right to select our representatives in congress. But most often the people we select to represent us fail. Currently the government

Similar Essays

We Must Not Regulate The Internet

2148 words - 9 pages networks. Some of these nodes have special programs to enable other client nodes to connect to it and exchange information with it. These computers, known as servers, can host any sort of information to exchange. Some host e-mail, some web pages, and others can host FTP (file transfer protocol). (Tyson) Privacy on the internet is not the government’s responsibility. The resent explosion of the popularity and use of the internet, we now face a new

Persuasive Speech: We Must Not Speed

878 words - 4 pages be the loss of one’s life. This world is very beautiful and life is great blessing but I don’t know why people risk their life for sake of few moments of fun. This life is yours and you have right to live it the way you want but others life is not your possession. While driving fast you must keep in mind that you are not only risking your life but threatening others life too. The most common line when someone stops us from driving fast is that

Censorship We Must Not Restrict Speech

554 words - 2 pages We Must Not Restrict Speech                  Racism, sexism and homophobia is growing on college campuses around the country.  In response, many universities have adopted policies that address bigotry by placing restrictions on speech. The alternative to such restrictions, many administrators argue, is to allow bigots to run rampant and to subject their

We Should Treat All Explicit Knowledge As Problematic

2050 words - 8 pages “We should treat all explicit knowledge as problematic” Explicit knowledge is knowledge that has passed through the process of articulation or is subject to articulation. It is also able to be codified and also amassed in particular media. This knowledge is also manageably convenient to transfer from one place to another. Encyclopedia and online sources such as the Wikipedia are very good examples of sources of explicit knowledge. Most people