This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

We Must Protect Animals From Needless Experiments

2899 words - 12 pages

We Must Protect Animals from Needless Experiments

Picture this: Researchers place a dog in a device called a “shuttlebox” which consists of a box divided into two compartments separated by a barrier. Hundreds of intense electric shocks are delivered to the dog’s feet through a grid floor. At first the dog is able to escape the shock by jumping across the barrier, but then the barrier is replaced by a piece of plate glass. The dog is tested again and, as expected, tries to jump over the barrier, but instead he smashes his head into the glass. The researchers observe that the dog’s reaction to his situation includes such symptoms as “defecation, urination, yelping and shrieking, trembling, and attacking the apparatus.” After ten or twelve days the dog ceases to resist the shocks. The conclusion of this experiment is that a combination of the plate glass barrier and foot shock was “very effective” in eliminating jumping by dogs (Singer 36).

No medical benefits emerged from this experiment, yet this same experiment continues to be carried out by other researchers. In fact, every 24 hours in this country, about 200,000 creatures die in the name of medical and scientific progress, some in experiments like the one just described (Satchell 4). Many of these experiments are repetitive and unnecessary. Congress needs to pass a law preventing cruel and unnecessary experimentation on animals.

The Animal Welfare Act was passed in 1966, the only Federal law that directly defines the rights of animals. The act sets standards for lab animals’ living conditions but sets no regulations on actual experimentation. The act was amended in 1970, setting standards for the transportation, housing, and handling of animals sold as pets, exhibited, or intended for research, but once again in actual experimentation, there were no restrictions. The act was most recently amended in 1985, when Senator Dole attached it as a rider to that year’s farm bill. The amendment requires animal-care committees established at every research facility to review planned experiments and procedures involved. Each committee must also have one public representative as an equal voting member (United States Code 7:2131).

This amendment has also turned out to be weak. Ann Chynoweth, a researcher for People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals (PETA, an animal activist group), commented that “There is basically no limit to what can be done to an animal once it is taken out of its cage” (Bresnick 20). The problem arises because the animal-care committees often function as an uncritical peer-review system. For example, at the University of Oregon, the former president required that everyone on the committee take a pro-vivisection oath. Stephen Wise, president of the Animal Legal Defense Fund, found that in his area’s thirteen animal-research facilities, including those at Harvard and MIT, the public representatives included “an exercise teacher, a secretary, and an...

Find Another Essay On We Must Protect Animals from Needless Experiments

How can we protect our private information from others?

1726 words - 7 pages , Petronio explains the way in which we coordinate our need to self-disclose to others with certain boundaries and regulations. If we decide to self-disclose with others, the person we self-disclose to becomes a confidant, or in other words becomes a “co-owner of the private information” (Griffin, 2006). There then becomes a need in which these “co-owners” must establish and “negotiate mutually agreeable privacy rules [and defined boundaries] about

We Must Save the Great White Shark from Extinction

4284 words - 17 pages We Must Save the Great White Shark from Extinction The Great White Shark, immortalized by the Hollywood film Jaws, is at the midst of an international controversy. The shark, despite its notoriety, is in danger of extinction. A conflict over the fate of these sharks has existed for decades, but with recent attacks the debate has come to the forefront. The environmental conflict over the Great White Shark has yet to reach a conclusion, as

Climate Change: We Must Reclaim Energy from Wastewater

1030 words - 4 pages fuel cell, is from a clean source. The research presented in this case study outlines the technology necessary for clean hydrogen production. As concerned scientists and citizens it is our responsibility to encourage the shift from fossil fuels to clean energy sources. In the future wind energy farms, and fuel cell power plants could supply enough power for local communities. In addition to changing our energy sources we must also encourage the

Poetry must not stray too far from the ordinary everyday language which we use and hear' (T.S. Eliot). Discuss this statement

1551 words - 6 pages Poetry must not stray too far from the ordinary everyday language which we useand hear' (T.S. Eliot). Discuss this statement in relation to ONE OR MORE poetsstudied on the moduleThe Metaphysical poetry of the seventeenth century is known for its use of wit. The emphasis is put on the intellect displayed by the poets in their complex conceits, arguably best advocated by Donne. I would be more inclined to Grierson's opinion that, "words such as


613 words - 2 pages animals. Then we will bring forward some reasons why tight restrictions have to be placed on experimentation with laboratory animals.It has been stated that the use of animals in laboratory tests is necessary in order to protect people from being experimented on (Cheesewhiz, 2002, para. 1). A majority of people think thatreactions of laboratory animals against medical substances and cosmetics may be useful to check these substances´ effects

Needless Animal Research, Testing, and Experimentation is Wrong

964 words - 4 pages ,p21). Animals suffering in experimentation labs are in just and cruel to animals. It is wrong to harm an innocent animal of any wrong doing, when the animal doesn't know right from wrong. It is argued that people have an obligation to animals, so that we can protect their welfare. Charles Fried claims "physical harm as an impingement upon the body which either causes pain or impairs functioning" (Fox, p85). Many animals experience pain

Animal expermentation

902 words - 4 pages men who go around and murder people then we should give some to animals. Why is it that the humans that hurt other humans get the right to live a live with stranger poking, touching them or forcing them through experiments but animals do? “No federal law protects these small animals from even the cruelest experiments. But mice exhibit easily recognizable winces, grimaces, and other facial expressions showing they feel pain. Despite their small size

Why Animal Testing Should Be Illegal

1019 words - 5 pages aspirin would not exist today if we had relied on animal testing , because the drugs had caused lethal side effects on animals. For example, penicillin is toxic to guinea pigs and aspirin is poisonous to cats. Differences between humans and other species can give inadequate and erroneous information when animal data is applied to human diseases and drug responses. The inexact results of animal experiments can endanger humans and animals. Animal

What the Government Should do About Animal Testing

2125 words - 9 pages animals are not able to give consent because they are not as developed as we are as a species. Great apes have found to be excluded from this because they are able to communicate and give consent. In other cases though, we must make the decisions for them and hope to advance our own species. To limit the suffering we must employ the three R’s. With these in mind we will be able to make the right choices even if animals cannot. As an advocate for

Animal Rights

2191 words - 9 pages unnecessary testing of animals is inhumane and unethical when alternative methods are available. The anti-vivisectionists say we should allow no experiments on animals and the animal utilitarians, or vivisectionists, claim that we can do anything to animals if it is for the ultimate good of humanity. Perhaps they are both wrong. Much can be learned from treating animals that are already sick or injured in testing new life-saving drugs and surgical

Case Study: The Benefits of Animal Testing

1757 words - 7 pages animal experimentation. Animal testing allows doctors to save countless lives. Without it, Amy along with countless others would die. Animal testing is a largely debated and controversial issue. It was first introduced in the United States in the 1920s (Goldberg 85). Since then, there have been many advances in the field of medicine and science. These advances are due largely to the fact that animals are used in experiments and research.  Animal

Similar Essays

Persuasive Speech: We Must Protect Our Environment

1100 words - 4 pages ATTENTION GETTER: Every day, I see the effects of pollution. From the trash that’s thrown into bushes to the murky lakes to the smog-filled skies, these are examples of the negative human impact on the environment. PURPOSE (state specific purpose, relate topic to audience and establish credibility): The cars we drive every day release toxic exhaust gases into the atmosphere that damage it. We should try to do better to reverse these effects

We Must Strive To Protect Privacy In Technology

574 words - 2 pages We Must Strive to Protect Privacy in Technology Technology is getting more and more complex as the years come and go. The availability of personal information is easier to access and the risk of it being tampered with is also high. As the years pass, the threat of privacy invasion gets greater and greater and easier to happen. There are several ways that privacy is able to be invaded and there will only be more to come. Americans have

How Do We Farm If We Must?: Analysis With Peter Singer's Down On The Factory Farm And Stanley Curtis's The Case For Intensive Farming Of Food Animals

2537 words - 10 pages aspirations of revising the current model into one that is not only more humane, but also sustainable for the environment and for the growing human population. Though our sympathies are immediately swayed by Singer's work, we must remain cognisant that, as Singer himself said, “We can't take our feelings as moral data, immune from rational criticism” (The Lives of Animals 89). Though Curtis's work seems at times overly cold in its utilitarian views

We Must Safeguard Children From Online Predators

1007 words - 4 pages In the recent years, our society is witnessing a rapid growth in underage sex crimes due to the online predators. Crimes originated from the internet activities are impacting all cultures, religions and geographic locations. Unfortunately, many sick individuals are overlooked by our law enforcement, and as a result they are victimizing children nation-wide. There is no worse crime than the attacks against youngsters because they are the