This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

We Must Regain Our Lost Civil Liberties

1676 words - 7 pages

With our nation’s tragedy of September 11, 2001, arose a deeply shaken America, shocked by the extent of the cruelty. An act of terrorism of that magnitude had never been seen before in our country. Patriots quickly came together, supporting the president to pass legislation, known as the USA Patriot Act, to tackle internal and external threats to this nation. The debate ensued, focused on which types of surveillance technology should or shouldn't be allowed for arresting terrorists. However, the question remains as to how these devices are going to be used, and how personally are those who use them held accountable. The purpose of this paper is to confirm that the proposed monitoring and archiving of users’ information on social networking sites would represent yet another erosion of our civil liberties for only a minor gain to our national security.
The USA Patriot Act or simply the Patriot Act sanctions the use of wiretaps, additional surveillance of technology, such as voice mail and e-mail, trap and trace devices, and demands for educational and business records. The Department of Justice justifies that such actions in criminal investigations, have been used for years. However, this action comes under intense scrutiny by critics such as the ACLU who maintain that the secrecy surrounding the use of such tools as well as lower criteria for attaining the authority to use them “represents a broad expansion of power without building in a necessary privacy protection” (The USA PATRIOT Act: Myth vs. Reality, n.d.).
The Patriot Act was signed into law on October 26, 2001, 45 days after the terrorist attacks on September 11th. The debate over what the Patriot Act actually allows law enforcement officials to do, however, creates focus on the balance of national security and protection of civil liberties. One of the laws included in the Patriot Act is the Electronic Communications Privacy Act or ECPA. The ECPA is used to monitor and retain information while intercepting “….email and other electronic communications…” and specifies the government’s access to this type of information (The USA Patriot Act, 2005, p.4). One difference between the ECPA and other laws included in this Act is probable cause. The ECPA does not mandate probable cause, thus posing serious privacy violations with the use of trap and trace devices.
According to Gerdes, in the book, “The Patriot Act,” a trap and trace device is described as “a device which captures the incoming electronic or other impulses which identify the originating number of an instrument or device from which a wire or electronic communication was transmitted” (Gerdes, 2005, p.119). The trap and trace information, which is tailored to electronic communication, can only be relevant during court proceedings when an attorney provides a judicial certification before the installation (The USA Patriot Act, 2005, p. 5). According to the ACLU, the trap and trace devices...

Find Another Essay On We Must Regain Our Lost Civil Liberties

“We must fulfill our destiny” Essay

1007 words - 5 pages States and it’s expansion. However, the questions it revealed were disputable. The discussion about Manifest Destiny revealed many for and against arguments. Maybe, the opponents made the most persuasive argument as they claimed Americans can’t talk about accomplishing a destiny while they kill innocent natives. William Ellery Channing accurately describes in one of his letters to Henry Clay: “There is no necessity for crime. There is no fate to justify rapacious nations, any more than to justify gamblers and robbers, in plunder… We talk of accomplishing our destiny. So did the late conqueror of Europe [Napoleon Bonaparte]” (Allard par. 60).

We Can Unite Our Country Under Terrorism as We Did During the Civil War

1437 words - 6 pages Adored, hated, desired, and abused, the United States of America has celebrated 234 years of freedom. Since July 4, 1776, America has sought liberation from every oppression. Independence day was only the beginning in a victorious future of deliverance; however, every war threatens to scatter the unity of this powerful country. The Civil War was a deadly age in American history. When a foreign opposition threatens and terrorizes our unity

Have We Lost Our Way? Examining the Purpose of Libraries in a Post Literate Society

1824 words - 7 pages to get meaning across long before words came along, now we are just getting back to our roots. Johnson freely admits that for many people print reading is limited to short personal or functional pieces such as signage or blog entries. In other words, people do not need to read words anymore, or at least not much. Herring is more than a little alarmed by this turn of events. He mourns the decrease of reading as it harkens, to his mind, a

We Must Keep Our Own Identity

1172 words - 5 pages and right after we sang the English version of happy birthday we would sing the Polish version. That tradition is gone now; I'm not sure why we stopped. I was the only child who knew the words and my family didnít tell them to me, I learned them from my friend. America puts out the idea that we should let our identities melt away and assimilate into one culture. It is forgotten that people's different cultures are what makes America great and

Persuasive Speech: We Must Protect Our Environment

1100 words - 4 pages now; otherwise, our world will continue to get filthier and eventually become uninhabitable. STATE THESIS & MAIN POINTS: I’m going to persuade you that going green is one solution you could do to help improve the environment by first explaining the problem, then by explaining the factors responsible for pollution, and lastly by listing ways that can help solve this problem. Connective: First, I’ll explain the problem we are facing. Body (3

Beowulf Lost this essay is about how we hav lost a bit of our human history due to the alteration of this originally pagan text

974 words - 4 pages a series of translations, lost numerous Pagan elements. Some may argue that the translations, having been done by monks who wished to alter the offensive Anglo-Saxon lifestyle, have given the text many unnecessary Christian references. This ancient text is an invaluable connection to our past and our culture but with these various discrepancies in religion the pure form and view of what was then a polytheist society has been destroyed.There is

Religion has no place in politics, therefore, church and state must remain separate if we are to preserve our individual freedoms

756 words - 4 pages In order to explore religion and politics in America, we must first begin with our country's roots in 17th century Europe. There was heavy conflict, over religion, involving the Catholics and the Protestants of England, and across Europe. They were two different religions who shared the principle that there should be one religion, everyone should be forced to follow it, and that government should enforce it. Therein lay the problem, how can

American civil liberties are defined as civil rights designed with the purpose of limiting government intervention in citizen’s affairs (Civil Lib

1113 words - 5 pages while’” (Boykin and Larsen 1). Boykin and Larson expressed that despite the initial role that decreased civil liberties played in post-9/11 national security, the time of those limited liberties has passed and those freedoms must rightfully be restored. After more than a decade, citizens have developed a strong desire to regain those rights that the government initially denied them. Those rights are revoked due to a problem that is responsible for

Civil Liberties

1564 words - 6 pages it suppresses one's inspiration. Also, opponents argue the idea that technology is threatening the privacy of American citizens. David H. Holtzman, a security and technology expert, argues that "our privacy is shrinking quicker than the polar ice cap; technology is eroding it faster than the legal system can protect it. This trend cannot be reversed in any obvious way. Privacy, as we know it today, is lost" (172). Without a doubt

American Civil Liberties: Do Americans Have Enough Protections for Civil Liberties, or Not?

1742 words - 7 pages for civil liberties or not.   In order to fully understand what constitutes as a civil liberty the definition of a civil liberty must first be established. A civil liberty is defined as “Those rights, such as freedom of speech and religion, that are so fundamental that they are outside the authority of government to regulate” ( Schiller, Geer, & Segal, 2013). Essentially meaning that a civil liberty is a basic human right that not even

Russell Feingold: A Patriot Against the USA Patriot Act

1137 words - 5 pages that our battle against terrorism would be lost “without firing a shot” if we were to “sacrifice the liberties of the American people.” Feingold duly defended American civil liberties at the risk of his career, truly exemplifying political courage as defined by John F. Kennedy. Feingold’s position as the only senator voicing opposition to the Patriot Act did not come without controversy. Despite all difficulties, Feingold never questioned his

Similar Essays

Impact Of Terrorism On Our Civil Liberties

2247 words - 9 pages /11 attacks allowing the government to use many means to detect terrorism threats or possible threats to the nation. The questions stem from the core of civil liberty, what are the liberties that we are granted? “Civil liberties are the personal freedoms of individuals that are protected from government intrusion” (Losco and Baker, Pg. 65). This definition ties in with other definitions of what civil liberties are and what is promised to the

We Must Promote Literacy In Our Community

1295 words - 5 pages become a more complex system. Having access to reading and writing has continued to be the single most important approach to acquiring the knowledge and education into society. As everyday people, we use our access to literacy as a way to achieve our goals, expand our own intelligence and build our potential. It’s many forms of social access that have evolved through not only education in schools, but the many libraries and archives, radio and

The U.S. Patriot Act And The Risk Of Losing Our Civil Liberties

1841 words - 8 pages thoughts on civil liberties forever. Becoming and staying a free society is a very difficult balance in which we must maintain or security by not limiting our freedoms. Liberty in America rests on our complex constitutional system of checks and balances. But sadly this very fabric of liberty and freedom was shattered on the morning of September 11, 2001. This act of terror changed everything because it was the very first global attack of a massive show

We Must Stop Overpopulation And Pollution Of Our Environment

1384 words - 6 pages We Must Stop Overpopulation and Pollution of Our Environment Once we humans hit on the idea of agriculture about 10,000 years ago, we had a means for exponentially increasing our population. Even as mere 2-legged, wingless creatures, humans could expand to cover the world, and pull from the earth nutrients to support this massive layer of people. The population increase has continued, and there are disagreements as to if and when the