We Should Not Censor Internet Pornography

1651 words - 7 pages

Pornography is an age-old phenomenon that has been under much modern-day scrutiny. With the recent proliferation of online pornography, possible social ramifications of sexually explicit material on uncontrolled mediums have become the subjects of intense debate. Proponents of a liberal approach toward pornography argue that access to online smut is a constitutionally protected freedom and "a harmless diversion that serves to satisfy curiosity and relieve sexual tensions.5" Opponents of this view are particularly concerned with the social effects of online pornography and its effect on the values and morals of minors who can access pornographic images. I will argue for the liberal side and argue that porn in both print form and electronic form should be constitutionally protected.
The major piece of legislation that would infringe on the rights of Internet users was the Communications Decency Act (CDA) of 1996. The CDA labeled the transmission of "obscene, lewd, lascivious, filthy, indecent, or patently offensive" pornography over the Internet a crime. It was attached to the Telecommunications Reform Act of 1996, which was then passed by Congress on February 1, 1996. The bill was created to outlaw obscene material on the web and impose fines of up to $100,000 and prison terms of up to two years on anyone who knowingly makes "indecent" material available to children under eighteen5. The Act used sweeping generalizations, which banned all forms of nudity in written and graphic form on the Internet. The clauses of the Act were so broad that posting pictures of famous works of art on the Internet, such as Michaelangelo's David, would be grounds for a heavy fine. Sexually related articles and photos, which are constitutionally protected in tangible form, would have been deemed unconstitutional in electronic form. Although the United States Supreme Court declared the Act unconstitutional, many congressional representatives still feel that the Act should remain intact.
One major flaw of the CDA is that it uses "community standards" to judge what is considered legal on the Internet. Unlike most forms of media, the Internet has no defined community; it is a decentralized, ungoverned body that is accessible to every person with a computer and a telephone line in the world. If there are "community standards," to which community do they belong? Do they belong to the communities of the Netherlands where prostitution and marijuana are legal, or to the communities of Bible-belt American, where family values are top priorities? The CDA went beyond its jurisdiction by claiming that "community standards" was the device with which to measure indecency. The standards of conservative lawmakers should not be the standards that gauge the appropriateness of the Internet, and these lawmakers are wrong to assume that their morals are mirrored in "community standards" throughout America.
The vast library located on the Internet would be transformed into nothing more...

Find Another Essay On We Should NOT Censor Internet Pornography

Should We Support Virtual Pornography? Essay

1707 words - 7 pages In today’s fast developing and modern society the thought of seeing two grown adults having sex is still considered taboo. Most Americans cringe at the thought of seeing pornography and dismiss the act as nothing more than a senseless lewd act. Yet, the Supreme Court held that pornography was to be considered a form of personal expression and should be protected under the first amendment (New York v. Ferber, 1973). The Supreme Court did not

We Should Not Fear Cloning Essay

1797 words - 7 pages We Should Not Fear Cloning   With the successful cloning of animals, many people have reacted with frightening and usually uninformed ideas about what cloning is and what researchers hope to achieve through it. Many wish to ban all cloning without even looking at the positive things that cloning will be able to provide for us in the future and with continued research. Like any new technology, people are at first afraid, but this is no

We Must Not Regulate the Internet

2148 words - 9 pages from other countries (Crews). And of course stifling our advertising industry would just drive up the cost of the products we buy anyway. The government should not increase its laws on pornography In 1998 the U.S. government tried to start a new legislation to protect children while online from adult rated content. It was called the child online protection act (COPA) and it was a failure from the beginning. Even though it was put in place, much

The Internet Should not be Censored

1406 words - 6 pages that they are opposed too. With this proposal to filter the internet politicians choose what they want to censor, not a judge! The resources that are being used for the internet filter are better spent elsewhere to protect children, as this proposal is a waste of money. This proposal will just liken the Australian Government to the governments of China, North Korea and Burma. Countries that are very restrictive with their information and their

The Internet Should Not Be Censored

1121 words - 4 pages The internet should not be censored. Now what information could the government be hiding from us? This will be a question asked more often if the government's internet filter proposal goes through. The internet filter can hide information about controversial topics from existence in Australia. We citizens are to make our opinions and then vote for who we think has our best opinions. This is undemocratic, and is also against our human right of

We Should NOT Increase the Minimum Wage

2383 words - 10 pages all do something more to change what needs to be changed. Although should not sacrifice what we know is right and give up on all of our beliefs by folding over to our opposition. There is a stark difference to not working out problems with your opponents, and giving up what you feel to be true. Jim Hightower wrote an article about President Obama's speech in which he said he wants the minimum wage to be raised to nine dollars an hour

Youth access to Internet Pornography; should it be banned? Title: Trash Folder is full.

1450 words - 6 pages censored everyday to not permit pornography, so censoring the Internet should not be different. Occasionally it is difficult to judge what constitutes pornography, to decide what stays and goes, but it can be done.Dick Thornburgh and Herbert Lin agreed, "although only a small fraction of material on the Internet could reasonably be classified as inappropriate for children, that small fraction is highly visible and controversial"(45). It may take a

Why we should be Careful with our Internet Identity

856 words - 4 pages Why We Should Be Careful With Our Internet Identity The Internet as a whole has changed the way the world works, in turn changing the way security works. With the Internet, world communications is at most of America’s finger tips. These security changes directly affect most of America. The main area I wish to look at is social media, the mainstream center of America. Social Media is currently so common that some children ask for social media

We Should NOT Judge Students by Test Results

776 words - 3 pages We Should NOT Judge Students by Test Results Are people who get good grades and/or who get high scores on tests more intelligent than those who do not? Can we just distinguish people who get good grades and/or high scores on tests are more intelligent than those who do not get good grades? I firmly believe that it is not fair to judge people who get good grades are more intelligent than those who do not. Test scores are not a fair

Is There Knowledge We Should Not Seek or is there?

1226 words - 5 pages Is There Knowledge We Should Not Seek or is there? Or Is Knowledge Inherently A Good Thing And Can Only Persons be harmful?In the modern world we have witnessed the capability of science to produce weapons of mass destruction and improve our ability to cure diseases. We have seen on our televisions the effects of the wars that were 'needed' to contain communism, and many witnessed the human race extend our reach to space. Anything known to

an opinion paper on whether or not we should return to the moon

673 words - 3 pages Opinion paper on returning to the moonOver the last three decades one of the most talked over and questioned subjects has been whether or not to return to the moon. Many people have the view of "been there, done that" when it comes to the moon, and believe that we should look ahead, not behind. However I think that returning to the moon still has many advantages to offer us.For example, it has now been discovered that there is a possibility of

Similar Essays

The Government Should Not Censor Internet Pornography

2374 words - 9 pages requiring an Internet filter is unnecessary and should not be implemented. There has always been a negative outlook upon pornography because of its supposed correlation with sexual violence; however there is no substantial evidence to support this claim and warrant a filter of all Internet pornography. Although in the 1970s and 1980s, studies performed by Donnerstein and Berkowitz (1981) and Zillmann and Bryant (1982

The Government Should Not Censor Pornography

3153 words - 13 pages worthiest of causes, the ends cannot always justify the means. As responsible citizens, we should endeavor to seek the best possible solution to our problems, while not going further than necessary. In the case of pornography, appeals for government censorship and regulation are big solutions to relatively small problems. To borrow a metaphor from rock musician Frank Zappa, such notions are "the equivalent of treating dandruff by decapitation" (268

Public Libraries Should Not Block Internet Pornography

2079 words - 8 pages Since the internet has been available in schools and libraries in this country, there has been a debate about what should be accessible to users, especially minors. The amount of information disseminated on the world wide web is vast, with some sources valuable for scholarly and personal research and entertainment, and some sources that contain material that is objectionable to some (ie. pornography, gambling, hate groups sites, violent

Why We Shouldn't Censor The Internet

1444 words - 6 pages culture is how this freedom has prevented anyone from efficiently limiting connections to these such sites. The place where internet censorship is most commonly present is in schools, where it raises many issues and questions about the effectiveness of installing the filters. Rather than censor the internet, we should educate its users and take steps to make it more open. The most common reason used to attack school internet censorship is that they