Well, Is It Alive Or Isn’t It?

980 words - 4 pages

Unless you’ve been a coma for the past couple of weeks, the Senate is in throes of confirming another Supreme Court nominee. It’s been all over the news. TV and Talk-radio pundits are in the midst of a major “issue-oriented” feeding frenzy. The nominee is Elena Kagan. And, as usual, the Lefties can’t say enough good about her, while the Righties can’t say enough bad about her.

I’m not going to get into the nominee’s qualifications for the job. She meets all Constitutional and statutory mandates. The nation elected Barack Obama as its current president. As such, he gets to choose his nominees and unless the Senate finds some Earth-shattering tidbit of a disqualifier, she’s going to be confirmed as the next justice on the Supreme Court.

I’ve learned to dismiss (COMPLETELY) two things when it comes to appointee confirmation hearings. The first is all of the political posturing, partisan wind-baggary, and blathering pontifications coming from the U. S. Senate. The second is the plethora of meaningless side issues aimed at politically pigeonholing nominees for the sake of scaring the hell out of the public.

Relative to the first item above, our Founding Fathers not only gave us our Constitution, they also instilled a sense of endearing freedom into a fledging nation that went on to kick King George’s butt. Unfortunately, though, it’s been at least sixty-years since we’ve had a sitting U. S. Congress concerned about anything other than its collective reelection posturing. As well, hoards of voters have become too stupid to realize it.

Relative to the second item above, we seem stuck with partisans that have learned to elevate emotional chaos to an eardrum-shattering level of noise by reducing the debate to a hissy fit contest between the ORIGANALISTS, seemingly always on the Right and the LIVING DOCUMENTISTS, seemingly always on the Left.

For the sake of clarity, “Original Intent” theory holds that ALL interpretation of the written Constitution should be restricted to what its authors intended the words to mean. Closely aligned with this is “Original Meaning” theory, a view that is based on the idea that interpretation of the written Constitution should be restricted to a meaning that was assigned by reasonable normative thinking of the times.

In other words, we should always interpret the written Constitution as meaning the same thing as what its drafters and contemporary society at that time intended the words to mean.

LIVING DOCUMENTISTS, conversely, hold that the Constitution is dynamic and adaptable to accommodate contemporaneous societal changes. In other words, human life is intimately tied to circumstances that often change over long periods and our Founding Fathers gave us a Constitution and the means to accommodate such changes.

And, herewith charges of judicial activism from both the Right and the Left constantly question judicial integrity. But’ it’s the system they gave us and we need to make the best of it.


Find Another Essay On Well, is it ALIVE or ISN’T it?

Is it Freedom or Censorship? Essay

1448 words - 6 pages to blur the lines, to the point that it is all seen as gray terms.Freedom of speech is no longer just that, it has become an issue of protected or non-protected speech. Along the way somewhere created these two new subcategories for freedom of speech. Non-protected speech is considered speech that lacks social redeeming value and is not essential to democratic deliberations and self-governance. You may talk about overthrowing the government, but

Isn’t it ironic that two stories could have separate accounts

1651 words - 7 pages nothing; it will not kill me. I shall not die of a cough? (36,1,3). Poe shows his sarcastic humor here. It is ironic that Fortunato brings up the topic of dying. He will not die from the cough, but by Montresor?s revengeful plan. Other examples can be seen when Montresor toasts Fortunato?s long life as well as when he says that he is a mason, but not in the sense that Fortunato means.Another very interesting passage in which there is verbal irony is

This is a very well explained summary of the play named "Romeo and Juliet. It is for grades 10th or higher.

5974 words - 24 pages young men. The Nurse goes off and returns with the news that the man's name is Romeo, and that he is a Montague. Overcome with anguish that she loves a Montague, Juliet follows her nurse from the hall.Act II, prologueThe Chorus delivers another short sonnet describing the new love between Romeo and Juliet: the hatred between the lovers' families makes it difficult for them to find the time or place to meet and let their passion grow; but the

Caffeine, is it Helping or Hurting America?

1404 words - 6 pages caffeine is harmful or addictive, that is because when they think of someone being addicted to something, they think of street drugs or alcohol. Just because a person does not have to go to rehab, or do other things to cure addiction does not mean they are not addicted. People do not really think of it in the same way, because it is not brought to people’s attention, and they do not hear about it as much as they would with other types of

Animal Testing: Is it Right or Wrong?

1609 words - 7 pages Animal Testing- Is it Right or Wrong? Everyday, people all around the world use facial products, receive vaccinations and take antibiotics or medications that have been previously tested on animals. Rarely people think about whether or not animals have been tortured to use the products that they are using, but simply only think of themselves and their own well-being. “An estimated 26 million animals are used each year in the United States for

The Shepherd's Passionate Heartbreak...Or is it?

1217 words - 5 pages leaves you feeling cold and lonely (which goes to show without saying that the imagery of both poems is compelling). Both poems are written with the same AABB rhyming scheme with quatrains and closed form. The second matching the first most likely being done to make it clear that it was a response to the first, as if the title wouldn't be enough. The use of rhetorical devices occurs throughout each poem as well, such as the alliteration "Time

Capital Punishment: Is It Right or Wrong?

2149 words - 9 pages Capital Punishment is a controversial topic discussed in today's society. There is a heated debate on whether states should be able to kill other humans or not. People that are in favor of the death penalty say that it saves money by not paying for housing in a maximum prison. Those opposed say that it is against the constitution, and is cruel and unusual punishment for humans to be put to his or her death. I believe that the death penalty is

Is it the Author, or his Content?

1788 words - 8 pages literature from authors such as “Plato, Aristotle, Euclid, Plutarch, and many other writers of the ancient world” (“About”). Today, much of Card’s interests as a child still coincide with his interests as an adult, and typically can be found in most of his literary work. Card once wrote that “there is always moral instructions whether the writer inserts it deliberately or not… but when [he] write[s] without deliberately expressing moral teachings

Is it Homer Kowalski or Stanley Kowalski?

650 words - 3 pages , compared to the serious, and mature tone of A Streetcar Named Desire. Although, The Simpsons is humorous show, it does shine light on the realities of modern culture. Nevertheless, the episode “A Streetcar Named Marge” draws a serious comparison between Homer Simpson and Stanley Kowalski and their violent behavior, interest in bowling, and use of alcohol. This episode of The Simpson’s suggests that there are similarities between the characters

Abortion is it right or wrong

1810 words - 7 pages ABORTION Presently, one of the most complex and emotional dilemmas facing modern society is that of abortion. The complexity of this dilemma has caused controversy throughout the nation. It has raised many fundamental questions such as who has the right to make the decision to abort a child, the female or the male? It has also raised many moral questions, questions that differ among society. Societies' view on abortion has been greatly

Is It Cute or Crossing the Line?

1146 words - 5 pages audience and give young girls a sense of maturity. Witnesses of the photograph understood Morin’s intent, but most of the concern arises from the fact, that if an individual were to have taken the photo in different circumstances, it would be identified at child pornography. Personally, it does not seem as though Morin wanted to sexually promote her child-based line, but coincidentally, she did this. Knowing it is a lingerie line for young girls

Similar Essays

"The Definition Of Life (Or Is It?)" Question: What Does It Mean To Say Something Is Alive, Conscious, And/Or Intelligent? Requirements: 1000 2000 Words

1529 words - 6 pages with RNA molecules from Tetrahymena and other organisms to see if he could make one.” As the proto-cell would be based on the RNA, not on scratch, it seems reasonable to conclude that it is a building block of life and therefore alive. Extremely uncomplicated entities such as these are created from fundamental chemical parts, like fats and a simple metabolism, and also from molecules that carry information, including RNA or DNA. This method of

Spam: It Isn’t Just E Mail Anymore

2438 words - 10 pages a problem being present. If time and money is being spent in developing proactive solutions to dealing with spam e-mails, there is an obvious supply of consumers who want to have spam e-mails reduced in their lives. Spam e-mail not only consumes the e-mail resources, but it takes the consumers’ time and energy in order to either reply to or erase the messages that are always flooding in. Contrarily, it costs the spammers nothing to send 10

The American Dream Is Alive And Well.

2224 words - 9 pages The American Dream is Alive and WellIt is part of the ethos of this country that you ought to be rich. You ought to be, unless you have taken some specific vow of poverty such as priesthood, scholarship, teaching, or civil service, because money is the way we keep score. This feeling has been a long time in the making. It goes away sometimes in depressions, when briefly wealth becomes suspect and poverty is not dishonorable. The rest of the time

Hamlet: "Madness, Or Is It?" Essay

914 words - 4 pages disposition on),/That you, at such times seeing me, never shall,/With arms encumb?red thus, or this head-shake,/ Or by pronouncing of some doubtful phrase,/ As ?Well, well we know,? or ?We could, an if we/ would,?/Or ?If we list to speak,? or ?There be, an if they might,?/Or such ambiguous giving out, to note/That you know aught of me ? this not to do,/ So grace and mercy at your most need help you,/Swear.? (1. 5. 195-207). Hamlet says that he is going to