This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Were The Third Reich And Italy Totalitarian States?

1864 words - 7 pages

Were the Third Reich and Italy totalitarian states?First of all it is important to define what a totalitarian state is. The Concise Oxford Dictionary describes a totalitarian state as, "relating to a form of government that permits no rival loyalties or parties, demanding entire subservience of the individual to the state". Therefore I will explore whether the Third Reich under Adolf Hitler and Fascist Italy under Benito Mussolini fit the description above.What is definitely clear is that when Hitler became chancellor of Germany on the 30th January 1933, he was as Peukert says, "nowhere near being a personal dictator". Papen was vice chancellor, Hindenburg president and there were only 3 Nazis in a cabinet of 11. However as Joll says, "Hitler wanted to remove all rival opposition". Therefore Hitler cleverly coordinated a series of actions that removed all this opposition. On 27 February 1933, Hitler blamed the Communists and a young Dutchman van der Lubbe for setting the Reichstag building on fire, therefore diminishing a lot of the support for the Communists and also as Carr says, "giving Hitler the perfect opportunity to attack them in the future".The Enabling Law passed by Hitler on 23rd March 1933 meant that Hitler could ignore the constitution and had the power to make laws for four years. Soon after Hitler also ended all self-government by states and also broke all the opposition of the Marxists by replacing the Trades Unions with the German Labour Front.In July 1933, Hitler passed a law stating that the NSDAP were the only party allowed in Germany. Finally the Night of Long Knives on 30th June 1934 ended almost all opposition to Hitler when SS men, as Peukert says, "swooped on everyone considered to be a threat and shot them after one minute trials". The main victims being Rohm, Gregor Strasser and von Schleicher and the numbers dead were probably in excess of seven hundred.As Joll points out, "With Hindenburg's death (Aug 1st 1934) Hitler could now make Germany a totalitarian state". So it is very clear that Hitler intended to make Germany a totalitarian state and the fact that his actions I have described above first removed and then permitted no opposition, in my opinion fits very well with the Concise Oxford dictionary's definition of allowing "no rival loyalties or parties".From 1933 onwards, there are a great many examples of Hitler's total power, control and rule in Germany. In June 1933 the Hitler Youth movement was formed under Baldur von Schirach. This required boys aged 8-16 to serve in various uniformed associations, practicing drill and keep fit. By doing this, the boys were as Peukert says, "indoctrinated" with Nazi ideas of Hitler and prepared for military service and ultimately war. Hitler also exerted control over girls and many served in the League of German Maidens where they worked on farms and in factories and were prepared for motherhood, "to breed pure Aryans and good German soldiers"(Carr).Another example of the...

Find Another Essay On Were the Third Reich and Italy totalitarian states?

Propaganda by Radio in the Third Reich

2507 words - 11 pages total control of the content of radio programming was necessary because pessimism or lack of hope among Germans would not be tolerated. At all costs, discontent, revolt and anarchy from the inside needed to be avoided. Talk of the flaws of German leadership could have torn the Third Reich apart, so it was essential that citizens believe in the government’s policies and actions as well as perceive that positive results were being achieved. With the

The Third Reich, 1933-45(germany) Essay

774 words - 3 pages Reichstag building was destroyed by fire. The Nazis blamed the fire on the Communists, and on February 28 the president, invoking Article 48 of the constitution, signed a decree that granted the Nazis the right to quash the political opposition. Authorized by the decree, the SA arrested or intimidated Socialists and Communists.The election of March 5 was the last held in Germany until after World War II. Although opposition parties were severely

Anti-Smoking Propaganda In The Third Reich

1347 words - 6 pages present world, studying the outcomes of such restrictive policies leads us to a straight forward question of just how effective they were. Recent work has indicated that while certain sorts of science were annihilated under the Nazi administration, different sorts thrived. Sciences of a connected nature were particularly empowered, as were sciences that fit inside the bigger system of Nazi isolation and annihilation. Little consideration, however

Führer's Birthdays: Personality Cult in the Third Reich

1498 words - 6 pages his adoring people. In other words, the images themselves were propaganda artifacts, carefully crafted to generate pro-Nazi sympathies. A film that calls itself Personality Cult in the Third Reich might be expected to analyze how these images were manufactured and in what ways they contributed to the cult. Instead, all it does is show the original films, virtually without commentary. Given the extent to which the film's "interpretive" commentary

Fascist Italy and Nazi Germany as Totalitarian Atates

1810 words - 7 pages return of German greatness. Hitler carried out conscription and full-scale rearmament, annexed Austria, Czechoslovakia and invaded Poland. They even formed the Axis and withdrew from the League of Nations. Both were accountable for the outbreak of World War Two. In a nutshell, we may say that both Fascist Italy and Nazi Germany were totalitarian states though there were some differences.

The Common Factors that Led to the Establishment of Totalitarian Regimes in Italy and Germany in the Inter-War Period

1358 words - 5 pages individuals to the State, etc. During the period 1919-39 there saw the rise of totalitarian regimes in some European countries. The most important ones in Western Europe were Nazi Germany and Fascist Italy. Their respective rise to power shared many similarities but there were some differences. The leaders of Fascist Italy and Nazi Germany were Benito Mussolini and Adolf Hitler respectively. The aftermath of the First

Compare and Contrast the Unification of Germany, Italy, and the United States

2967 words - 12 pages Compare and Contrast the Unification of Germany, Italy, and the United States From the 1790s to 1814 French troops successively conquered and occupied the area that later constituted the German Empire. French domination helped to modernize and consolidate Germany and -- toward the end -- sparked the first upsurge of German nationalism. In different ways the French emperor Napoleon I helped German unification. It was important that he

5(b): How far were the roles of Bismarck and Cavour decisive in the unification of Germany and Italy?

2071 words - 8 pages , he goes on to say, "as for the failure of the Marxist regimes...I do not consider theformer have been a true Marxist regime, they were far more concerned with theirnarrow national interests [3]". It is important to establish however, that the regime did notressemble a totalitarian regime until Stalin took over. Lenin established the Cheka for thecivil war and only gave his party complete autonomy to maintain control. It was Stalin

Hitler’s Reich and 1984: The Repercussions of Totalitarianism

2868 words - 11 pages mind” when composing the novel (Enteen 206). As a result, Big Brother and the Oceania Empire have uncanny resemblances to the government of the Third Reich of Germany. Hence, political experts label both of these influential powers as totalitarian. Alfredo Rocco, a theoretician of Fascism, explains totalitarianism as “‘an absolute monopoly of authority by the state’” (qtd. in Gleason 146). Though some seek to find a distinction, the Orwellian

Italy and the European Union

1731 words - 7 pages The idea of a united Europe was present in Italy even before the end of the Second World War. As a matter of fact, in June 1941, E. Rossi and A. Spinelli, exiled on the island of Ventotene, published the so-called 'Ventotene Manifesto', which promoted a federation of states of Europe that, in their view, could prevent war, binding European countries closer together. The Manifesto encouraged the settlement of single European currency, army and

Essay is about:Mussolini and Fascist Italy Q: How important were the Lateran Treaties of 1929 between the Italian State and the Papacy in consolidating Mussolini's hold on power in Italy?

1102 words - 4 pages Church. The Church resisted but its clubs were required to limit themselves to religious objectives and lost much of their attraction when their sporting facilities and teams were closed down. The Church survived, however, and retained the commitment of the vast majority of Italians. This survival on its own seriously undermines any claim that Italy under Mussolini was a totalitarian state. The survival of the Catholic Church's privileges and

Similar Essays

How Accurate Is The Claim That The Effects Of Wwi Were The Most Important Reason For The Rise Of Totalitarian Governments In Italy During The Period To 1939?

1164 words - 5 pages The rise of totalitarian governments in Italy became a decisive issue in the history of Italian politics. Many historians believe that the effects of the First World War were the most important reason for the rise of these fascists. However the war simply accelerated the necessity for a new and reformed government. Many factors existed before the war and the First World War simply highlighted the necessity for change. In addition, without the

The Third Reich And Entartete Künst

1275 words - 5 pages because his soul is noble. “We have nothing to hide, we are the master race, strong and healthy,” these men were saying. (178, 179) It is ironic when one considers that it was encouraged for men to sculpt the male nude for the purpose of celebrating the male body and yet homosexuals across Europe were murdered in gas chambers. A large amount of sculptures carved during the Third Reich depicted men to be naked, primarily that of war

The Rise And Subsequent Fall Of The Third Reich

4816 words - 19 pages to keep Germany powerless inhibit his plan. Hitler always believed that the Germans in Central Europe were overcrowding its cities and towns. His Third Reich needed more than the traditional German lands to provide enough living space for the German people. Prior to expansion, he planned to secure Lebensraum (living space) in the Ostlanden (lands to the east, particularly Poland and Russia). That, however, was not the Hitler’s first

Racial Theories Leading To The Third Reich

1275 words - 5 pages Racial Theories Leading to the Third Reich The Nazi State of the Third Reich is clearly defined by racial theory put into practice. One reading Burleigh and Wipperman's book; The Racial State, learns of these different racial theories and how they are implemented under Adolf Hitler in the Third Reich. As one learns when reading The Racial State, Adolf Hitler's eugenic and racial-hygienic theories were not original. Theorists long