West Memphis Three Essay

651 words - 3 pages

Paradise Lost is the first of three documentaries chronicling the story of the West Memphis Three (Jason Baldwin, Damien Echols and Jessie Misskelly) and the allegations made against them regarding the mutilations and murders of Christopher Byers, Michael Moore and Steven Branch. The film gives an insight into the investigation of the case with a great deal of detail using crime scene footage, court hearings and interviews.
Though it may be argued that the making of this film was wrong, I believe that its creation was ethically right. It is understandable that the graphic nature of the documentary and the explicit content may have been off-putting to some audiences, but filming Paradise Lost allowed important details and inconsistencies - that would have otherwise been overlooked or ignored - to be documented and scrutinized. It was important that the public was made aware of all aspects of the case, instead of taking the police allegations at face value because ...view middle of the document...

The primary reasons that the boys were suspected and convicted of the murders were their style of dress and choice in music and how their small community linked those factors to Satanism and occult rituals. The arrests and imprisonment of the West Memphis Three came when Jessie Misskelly, who was 16 years old at the time with a below average IQ rating of 72 made a false confession after hours of incessant police scrutiny and questioning. The West Memphis Police Department deduced that, based on the evidences which they believed to be true, the boys were guilty. Their argument was flawed because:
1. Townspeople wanted answers in the case of the murders; wanted immediately to positively identify threat or suspected killers
2. West Memphis Three were seen as threatening because of their style of dress/ choice in music and therefore it was almost immediately deduced that they had committed the murders; to convict a person of a crime, the mens rea (guilty mind) and actus reus (guilty act) must be proven
3. Evidence against accused was circumstantial (ie., confession made by Misskelly under circumstances) and invalid; there was no physical evidence linking the West Memphis Three to the crime nor was the intent (mens rea and actus reus) in any of the accused proven
4. Deductive reasoning can only be valid if established with certainty
5. Therefore, according to the philosophy of deductive reasoning, the West Memphis Three could not have been guilty
What is believed to be true, right and good in West Memphis (a community deeply rooted in Christianity) is almost in direct juxtaposition with the alleged Satanic lifestyles of the accused. Popular relativism, by definition, is the idea that the majority in a society or a social group determines perceived moral truths and rights. Because the boys liked a certain style of clothing and music, they were pariahs in their society, and therefore morally incorrect by definition of popular relativism.

Since it is objective (at least to the Western world) that killings, especially of that nature are wrong, the community attributed that with their belief in the wrongness of the way of life of the West Memphis Three.
In conclusion, Paradise Lost was created as an aid to the public in the hopes that

Find Another Essay On west memphis three

Wrongfully Accused and Convicted: “The West Memphis Three”

1096 words - 4 pages the “West Memphis Three”. The case involves three teenage boys from West Memphis accused of killing three 8 year old boys. After being reported missing a day later, the victims were discovered in a drainage ditch. During that time, there was no supporting evidence collected at the crime scene to prove who committed the murders. A lieutenant who contacted a juvenile officer in Memphis both agreed someone in a cult executed the gruesome murders. The

A Comparison of Arthur Miller's "The Crucible" and "The West Memphis Three"

873 words - 3 pages Unjust Justice Systems;A comparison of the West Memphis Three and The CrucibleImagine sitting at home one night and having police officers show up at your hose and arrest you for a crime you had no idea was committed. Three teenage boys in West Memphis, Arkansas and over thirty-nine characters in The Crucible went through exactly that. The West memphis three is the trial of three teenage boys who were charged with killing two eight-year-old oys

what should never be

1024 words - 5 pages called the West Memphis Three; the case drew a lot of attention after HBO released a documentary about the case. The West Memphis Three were three men that were convicted as teens for brutally murdering three young boys as a “Satanic ritual.” The West Memphis, Arkansas Police arrested the three teenagers, Damien Echlos, Jessie Misskelley and Jason Baldwin. They lacked physical evidence, the crime scene had been tampered with, there was no murder

West memphis 3

543 words - 2 pages The West Memphis Three were guilty. That's the truth.On May 5, 1993, Damien Echols, Jason Baldwin and Jessie Misskelley (ages 18, 16 & 17 at the time) killed Michael Moore, Steve Branch and Christopher Byers (all age 8). They beat them with fists, then beat them sticks, hogtied them, sexually assaulted them, tortured Branch and Byers with a knife, cut off Byers' genitals, then dumped their bodies in a ditch. The killers were arrested a month

false confessions in juveniels

1265 words - 6 pages juvenile lawyer to help these adolescents and keep false confessions from leading to a sentence they don’t deserve. I case I will refer to that many may not know about, are the West Memphis Three. These were three boys Damien Echols age eighteen, Jessie Misskelley age seventeen, and Charles Baldwin age sixteen, all charged with the murder of three eight year old boys in West Memphis, Arkansas, as a satanic ritual.the boys were taken in for

The West Memphis 3 Murders

850 words - 4 pages The West Memphis 3, were three teenagers who were accused of the brutal murder of 3 eight-year old boys in West Memphis, Arkansas. The boys were believed to have been killed as part of a satanic ritual. By the next day, the police had already found their first suspect Damien Echols and were questioning him. Echols was considered a suspect because of his interest in the Wicca religion and officers investigating the case both thought that the

Paradise Lost 2: Revelations - A Look Into The Terrifying World Of Justice This Article Is An In Depth Analysis Of The Movie Paradise Lost And Paradise Lost 2 Relevations

2284 words - 10 pages with Jessie's confession, his story of the murders did not correlate to the scene of the crime.The trial of the West Memphis Three included many irregularities. The trials consisted of many admissions from witnesses, yet no hard evidence that proved their guilt. Hearsay from many witnesses, and the confession by Jessie Misskelley were the only sources used in trial as "hard" evidence against the three. Hearsay does not function well as solid

Elvis Presley

1260 words - 5 pages transferred to the mainstream, it was time for a change.Born January 8, 1935, in East Tupelo, Mississippi, Presley was the son of Gladys and Vernon Presley, a sewing machine operator and a truck driver. Presley's twin brother Jesse Garon was stillborn, and he grew up as an only child. At age three, his dad was sent to prison for forgery. It seems that Vernon, Travis Smith, and Luther Gable changed the amount of a check from Version's boss from $3 to $8

They Say: Ida B. Wells and the Reconstruction of Race, by James W. Davidson. Ida B. Wells as a parallel to African Americans trying to gain empowerment in post-emancipation America

1412 words - 6 pages out and removed from the first-class ladies' coach by the train conductor. In December 1884 the circuit court ruled in her favor, but three years later the Tennessee Supreme Court reversed the decision. That experience prompted Ida B. Wells to write letters to Memphis weeklies and, later, to African American newspapers like the New York Freeman and Gate City Press.During her tenure as a writer for these papers, Ida B. Wells wrote several articles

Satanic Panic in the South

3407 words - 14 pages Satanic Panic in the South On the evening of May 5, 1993, three boys from West Memphis, Arkansas, were last seen riding their bikes together. In the early evening, Chris Byers' stepfather, John Mark Byers, reported that his stepson had not come home and he was becoming worried. The police were also notified of two other boys who had been with Chris and were considered missing, Michael Moore, and Stevie Branch. The police and the

Archaeology of South Abydos

1415 words - 6 pages Nile floodplain and the high desert edge. Senwosret III was the central point, were Umm el-Gaab was located just east of Senwosret III temple. Senwosret III’s temple was built with limestone in the middle and brick enclosed. The gateway of the temple had flags and poles which cornered the flood plain. Interior of the buildings were separated into three different blocks East, West and the core. The East block, was the storage area, also used to

Similar Essays

The West Memphis Three Murder Trial

1215 words - 5 pages "I see a perfect explosion, God's ammunition dump, going up in flames of righteousness, Satan storming heaven, his artillery captain, a fiercely grinning fool with red flayed cheeks, Damien by name, never to be Michael Hutchison again. The end is near. Kiss your ass goodbye people, it's time to pay up. Now is the judgment. I am the judge."-Damien Echols, (West Memphis Three Facts). The West memphis three is considered one of the most unfair

The Crucible And The West Memphis Three

1163 words - 5 pages Revenge, the abuse of authority and the desire for power are all present in both Arthur Miller’s play The Crucible and the case regarding the West Memphis Three. To understand the connection you need to know something about the case. Three young boys were murdered on May 5, 1993 (Leveritt 5). They were stripped of their clothing, their hands were bound and they were forced underwater in the nearby creek where they stayed until they were found

The Nightmare Of The West Memphis Three

877 words - 4 pages In his article, “The Nightmare of the West Memphis Three”, Rich explores how the people of Memphis drew horrific conclusions about people based on the lifestyle they chose to practice. The article highlights the trials and tribulations faced by the accused three young teenagers. Rich does this by citing the popular documentary series “Paradise Lost” which is an in depth analysis into the lives of the accused, the victims’ families and members

Injustice For All: The West Memphis Three

3409 words - 14 pages shadowy forest, several busy freeways, a murky stream, and three lifeless young bodies. One parent describes the act; “Imagine all the evil that you could think of, of how someone could be murdered, and that’s how these three children died.” The fear of such things quickly spread through the town of West Memphis, Arkansas on May 6, 1993. The scene at Robin Hood Hills was a gruesome one on that hot afternoon. The discovery of three bodies, each an