What Are The Main Strengths And Weaknesses Of The Rational Choice Approach To Religious Behaviour?

1742 words - 7 pages

'WHAT ARE THE MAIN STRENGTHS AND WEAKNESSES OF THE RATIONAL CHOICE APPROACH TO RELIGIOUS BEHAVIOUR?'BIBLIOGRAPHY1) G. Becker, 1986, 'The economic approach to human behaviour', pp. 108-22 in J. Elster (ed.), Rational Choice. Oxford: Blackwell.2) L. Iannaccone, 1990, 'Religious practice: a human capital approach', Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion, 29: 297-314.3) S. Bruce, 'Religion and rational choice: a critique of economic explanations of religious behaviour', Sociology of Religion, 54: 193-205.4) H. Bredemeier, 1978, 'Exchange theory', pp. 420-56 in T. Bottomore and R. Nisbet (eds), A History of Sociological Thought. New York: Basic Books.5) Lecture Notes.6) J. Sloman, 1996, Economics. London: Harvester Wheatsheaf.One of the pioneers of the rational choice theory has been Gary Becker. He states that this approach can be applied to all human behaviour, including religion. This approach has three assumptions. It assumes that people engage in maximising behaviour. When applying this approach to religion we are not concerned with money. We are concerned with the maximisation of personal benefits. When we make a decision we weigh up the costs and benefits and choose the option which offers the most benefit. Secondly, there are 'markets that with varying degrees of efficiency allow the actions of different participants to function together efficiently.' Thirdly, prices and other market functions can affect demand and supply, controlling desires and affecting the actions of consumers. Becker explains that price is not described in money terms but as a shadow price. For example, muslims cannot drink alcohol.This approach involves four theorems. Firstly, a rise in price reduces the quantity demanded. The example he gives is if people have to put more time and effort into having children then less people will do so. Secondly, a rise in price increases the quantity supplied, the example given is women in the labour market. Thirdly, competitive markets are more efficient then monopolistic markets and lead to the diversity of a product. Fourthly, a tax on the output of a market reduces that output eg the punishment of criminals is a tax on crime.Finke and Iannaccone have applied this theory to religious behaviour and understand that the high degree of religion in America is attributed to the existence of a free market and therefore competition and diversification in religion. Finke argues that in a free market start up costs are low and this leads to new ideas and more diversity and therefore more chance of everyone finding a religion they like. Also in a competitive free market earning a living acts as an incentive to clergy to work harder and try to tailor their religion to suit the demands of the consumer. He also suggests that state monopolies are less efficient in the absence of competition and believes that state churches would therefore allow high costs.Bruce highlights some weaknesses of this theory. He states that the early Christian...


Assess the strengths and weaknesses of the Weimar Republic. This essay asses the strengths and weaknesses is of the Weimar Republic that is argued to be the main reason why Hitler rose to power.

1536 words - 6 pages Assess the strengths and weaknesses of the Weimar Republic Due to the defeat in the First World War, the Allies imposed the Versailles treaty on Germany. It was the foundations for the Weimar republic and was met with controversy. The Weimar republic was a huge success for democracy, bringing it to Germany for the first time, however laid the path for the rise to Fascism. Nevertheless, it did withhold initial political and economic

Rational Choice Theory, rational choice approach to crime causation,rational choice theory and deterrence theory's impact on crime prevention strategies

529 words - 2 pages The rational choice approach to crime causation is composed of several different concepts. According to this theory, criminal behavior is the product of careful thought and planning. Offenders choose crime after considering both personal factors-money, revenge, thrills, entertainment- and situational factors, such as target availability, security measures, and police presence (Siegel, 2008). Once the decision has been made to commit a specific

Examining the Strengths and Weaknesses of the Argument for the Existence of God Based on Religious Experience

634 words - 3 pages existence of consciousness, human opportunities to do good, the pattern of history, miracles and religious experience. However, Swinburne’s cumulative argument is only as strong as the individual arguments themselves. There are plenty of weaknesses of the individual arguments to count against the cumulative argument. Religious experiences only tip the balance if the preceding arguments have been persuasive in themselves. He is simply putting loads of weak arguments together to make another weak argument.

Analyse the key strengths of the argument for the existence of God based on religious experience. Evaluate the view the weaknesses of this argument lead to its rejection.

1627 words - 7 pages "What is religious experience?" A religious experience can be described as a non-empirical occurrence and can be perceived as supernatural; or a "mental event" undergone by an individual, it can be spontaneous or may be brought as result by intensive praying. The receiver usually seems to have been "drawn into a deeper" knowledge and awareness of God; however the experience itself is not a substitute for the Divine. The experiences are usually

It is argued that the Activity Based Costing approach produces more accurate product cost information. Critically evaluate the strengths and weaknesses of this statement.

2296 words - 9 pages advantage by focusing attention on activities". Activity Based Costing is used as a tool in Activity Based Management. Activity Based Costing follows a set of steps, which relate costs to activities and then to the products depending on the product's usage of the activities (Stickney, M and Weil, pp 153). The steps that ABC uses are firstly the identification of the cost object that has been chosen and the direct costs that are related to the product

What are the key assumptions of rational choice individualism. Are they valid assumptions? Cite examples to support your examples.

2000 words - 8 pages plain sight: the secret of society is that it was made by men, and there is nothing in society but what men put there' (Homans 1961: 385).This is the approach that rational choice theorists use to understand social phenomena. Homans believed that there are not independent or economic social structures, everything was created by man. Every institution depends on face to face interaction and exchange. Exchanges of money and approval simply become far

strengths and weaknesses of the ontological argument

983 words - 4 pages The Strengths and Weaknesses of the Cosmological Argument for the Existence of God The Strengths and Weaknesses of the Cosmological Argument for the Existence of God The Strengths and Weaknesses of the Cosmological Argument for the Existence of God The cosmological argument seeks to prove the existence of God by looking at the universe. It is an A posteriori proof based on experience and the observation of the world not

The Strengths and Weaknesses of the Articles of Confederation

894 words - 4 pages Strengths and Weaknesses of the Articles of Confederation The years 1781 to 1789, the years known as the "Critical period" were the reign of the Articles of Confederation... were those years a highlight in American history, or a time that is best to be forgotten? The argument can go either way it really depends on how you look at it. The question is; were the Articles an effective system of government? Well, while something might not be

Financing the Mozal Proect - What solution would you recommend to the IFC? How would this strategy help Mozambique? What are some weaknesses of this strategy? What are its outweighing strengths?

961 words - 4 pages the IFC's mission, as it would be promoting sustainable private sector investment in the developing country of Mozambique while at the same time helping to reduce poverty and improve people's lives. There are various sources for the viability of this project. Firstly, the aluminum industry demand is strong and is expected to grow at 2% to 3% per year; combined with the efficiency and low cost advantages that Mozal would have to offer, revenues

The Perspective of Rational Choice

1722 words - 7 pages . All theories in this perspective recognize power as deriving from unequal resources in the exchange process. “Some versions of rational choice theory emphasize the ways in which patterns of exchange lead to social exchanges and social injustices” (Hutchison, 2008, p. 49), but I see social exchange as based on self-interest, not in a selfish way. One weakness in this perspective could be that it assumes all people are rational and goal directed

The Strengths and Weaknesses of the Sociocultural Perspective

983 words - 4 pages role that society and adults have on cognitive development. The weaknesses are that it doesn’t address biological or individual influences that shape people. Overall, all of the perspectives are going to have strengths and weaknesses. Until we gain more knowledge about the mind and behavior, we won’t be able to draw accurate conclusions that everyone can agree upon. For now, psychologists continue doing research, come up with new perspectives

Similar Essays

The Strengths And Limitations Of A Rational, Strategic Approach To Organisational Change

5116 words - 20 pages rest (presumably non rational and/or strategic) of the approaches outlined here. Resisting such an option, it is argued that there are multiple ways to be rational, and this makes it possible to define what we shall call Rational Modes corresponding to the various approaches discussed in this essay and characterised by long lists of strengths and weakness reflecting, not so much inherent limitations of the Modes

Discuss The Strengths & Weaknesses Of Anti – Social Behaviour Orders

1721 words - 7 pages carried out was in 2002 and it stated that ASBOS are too slow too obtain and are too expensive for what they actually are (NACRO - 12/11/2002). The most recent report states that ASBOS are being used too hastily in a bid to resolve the Anti - Social behaviour (NACRO - 07/12/2006).Also discuss the negative side of the Respect Action Plan,Key points of S Ludlam and M Smith, Governing as New Labour (2004) (Chapter 11)Discuss the New Anti -Social

The Three Main Theories Of Deviance And Their Strengths And Weaknesses

2887 words - 12 pages The Three Main Theories of Deviance and Their Strengths and Weaknesses A functionalist analysis of deviance looks for the source of deviance in the nature of society rather than in the biological or psychological nature of the individual. Although functionalists agree that social control mechanisms such as the police and the courts are necessary to keep deviance in check, many argue that a certain amount of deviance

The Strengths And Limitations Of The Behaviourist Approach In Explaining Behaviour

2150 words - 9 pages The aim of this essay is to describe and evaluate the strengths and weaknesses of the behaviourist approach in terms of ability to explain behaviour. This essay will briefly outline the historical development of the behaviourist approach and include psychologists ranging from Watson to Bandura. This essay will describe in detail the different perspectives held within behaviourism from classical conditioning to the social learning theory and