What Do Grown Children Owe Their Parents?

995 words - 4 pages

The thesis statement of the article is that usage of the word "owe" undermines the mutual friendship and love that makes a person fulfill his/her responsibility towards his/her parents . I disagree with the statement and believe that the author has presented a poor argument. The basis of my standing is that the author has misinterpreted the meaning of the term "owe" to support her argument. I believe the word "owe" only represents the gravity of a responsibility.

The author defined "owe" as a form of obligation that is to be fulfilled unwillingly. In support of her argument she presented the case of friendship. When two people are friends they help each other, but they are not obliged to make their share of sacrifices. She stated that the term "owe" undermines the role of mutuality. "Owe" represents obligations that must be fulfilled irrespective of the person's emotions. Thus, the term "owe" should not be used to refer to a child's duties towards his/her parents.

Before analyzing her argument, it is necessary to look into the term "owe." There are two types of "owe"; one is backed by the legal system. For example, if a person borrows money from someone, it is required by law to pay that money back. Another "owe" is responsibility that is backed by morality. For example, if a person sees that someone had an accident; it is a moral responsibility to call an ambulance.

The author fails to distinguish between the two types of "owe" that have been mentioned above. "Owe" simply represents responsibility. For example, if a person loves another person, a responsibility to look after the loved person comes into existence by itself. There is no legal system that will force a person to protect his/her loved ones. In a case, emotions take the policing role of the legal system. The emotional attachment forces the person to look after his/her loved one.

The author used examples where it shows that if X helps Y without Y asking for the favor, then it is not Y's responsibility to help X. However, I find this argument faulty. If Y does not help that is only because of Y's unique moral values. If Y's moral values insists on returning X the favor, then Y will help X. But if Y's moral values do not support it, only then Y will not help X.

Thus, we can see that in any case either of the two policing bodies is in action and it depends on how the policing force acts. One policing body is the legal system and other is the moral values.

Hence, usage of the term "owe" has nothing to do with how a person responds to his/her surrounding environment. Moreover, I suggest that the usage of the term "owe" clarifies what it is expected of a person in a social surrounding. When a child is...

Find Another Essay On What Do Grown Children Owe Their Parents?

Incarcerated Parents and Their Children Essay

2592 words - 10 pages ). This program helps in the reunification of children with their parent during and after incarceration. The CCIP focuses on family reunification as well as educating children of their parents’ immurement. They allow them to know what their parent has done to become incarcerated, which puts an ease on themselves. ”Prison nurseries have the potential to promote rehabilitation of incarcerated mothers, while also providing the physical closeness and

Children and their ties to the Parents

763 words - 3 pages their parents and orphans who have never had parents the importance and value of having them near us today. For those who are blessed with a father and a mother may not realise it but their parents hold a very special place within our hearts because of which what ever they may say, good or bad, gets to us, it touches our hearts and we react the way we do. Parents guide their children with what may seem as small advice but has a big meaning. They

Same-Sex Parents and Their Children

852 words - 3 pages Same-sex parents and their children Nowadays, the question of gay marriage is one of the most heated and controversial. Over the years, same-sex couples are fighting for the legal recognition for their marriages and their right as parents. Parenthood is one of the most valuable experiences in a human life. After finding a partner, it is natural for people to want to raise children. Homosexual parent are the same in ability and commitment to

What causes parents to physically punish their children and what effects can it have on the child's development?

1041 words - 4 pages with more verbal and physical aggression towards the child as the parent becomes less sensitive towards the child, which results in physical punishment. Although all parents want what is best for their child, many parents may not realize how physical punishments and discipline may effect the development of their child.Corporal punishment is a common strategy that parents use to discipline their children and also holds many short term effects that

How Children Develop Friendships and What Parents Can and Should or Cannot and Should Not Do to Help

1384 words - 6 pages Friendships broaden children’s horizons; they share their joys, secrets, and accompany them on their journeys into ever wider worlds. However, friends can also gossip, betray, tease, and exclude. Children can cause untold suffering, not only for their peers but for parents as well. In Best Friends, Worst Enemies, Michael Thompson, Ph.D., Catherine O’Neill Grace, talk about the role that friendships play in the lives of children from birth to

Children Should Take Care of Their Aging Parents

1266 words - 5 pages only can get at home .However, children should think about their aging parents what do they really want? They only want professional care or a better and happy atmosphere with their family’s every day. It is not necessary children should take care of their elderly parent, but we really need to think about it because parents work their entire lives to support their family and we owe them a lot. So, in my opinion children should be responsible for their aging parents.

The Pain on Children of Losing Both of their Parents

831 words - 4 pages Imagine the thought of losing everything you have at such a young age, and having to do everything on your own without any help. The thought of losing one’s parents and being put through foster care is a child’s worst nightmare. In the book “Grief Girl” a teenage girl has to endure the pain of losing both of her parents and help take care of her younger brother. Losing a parent is not the only issue children have to deal with, but it is one that

Different Methods That Parents Use to Raise Their Children

1865 words - 7 pages “unlikely to take part in their children’s activities,” and often provide nothing more for their children than food and shelter (Hibbard 271). Permissive-indulgent parenting is another method; parents of this type exhibit high responsiveness but low demandingness. This means that they give their child abundant freedoms and do not apply rules or demands, but display love and acceptance (Hibbard 271). A third type of parenting – authoritarian

Roman Parents Did Grieve for the Death of Their Children

2706 words - 11 pages the means of parents to express their true feeling on epitaphs due to cost. Just because epitaphs tended to be generic doesn’t mean parents cared less, simply that the cost was too much. Sadly this is very speculative and the simple answer is no one can say for sure if the Romans grieved for their children like we do today. It must be remembered however that we don’t go too far the other way based on limited evidence that we know to represent the

How a Parents Psychological Health Affects their Children

818 words - 4 pages childhood with a parent not mentally sound, or a genetic predisposition to a mental disorder can expose the child to the development of psychological disorders or damage. Whether it’s biological or environmental, personality disorders including depression, narcissism, and anxiety in parents directly affect their children. Everyone has someone they looked up to as a kid; children look to their parent to see how they should behave in society. When a

Why do parents blame celebrities for their childre

689 words - 3 pages Why do parents blame celebrities for their children's actions? Where are the parents? Irresponsible parents use celebrities as an excuse for their lack of interest in their children's lives. I strongly agree that the parents should be at fault. Parents who know their children's thoughts and feelings towards things are usually the best parents. If parents know what their children are like, you should know more about their personality. If a parent

Similar Essays

Is Socialisation Something That Parents Do To Their Children?

1615 words - 6 pages Is socialisation something that parents do to their children?Socialisation is an interactive and dynamic process by which children make sense of their lives. It is the process through which a child becomes an active competent participant in one or more communities.How much of this process is carried out fundamentally by parents, and how much by other "sets" of people a child comes into contact with, will be the subject of this essay. The extent

Parents And Their Children Essay

1225 words - 5 pages , authoritative parents, permissive parents, and neglecting parents. Authoritarian parents, though severity varies, are those who exert complete control over their children and expect complete and unquestioned obedience. They often punish misbehavior and do not reason with policies. This type of parenting is unsympathetic and reserved creating space between them and their children. The results of this type of parenting style include but not limited

Children And Their Parents Essay

1569 words - 6 pages . Further, background clutter that may distract from the facial features or provide visual cues other than resemblance, that may link a child to a parent may have affected these results. To improve on this Christenfeld and Hill (1995) should have taken their own photographs of children and parents. However this would have been time consuming and require a longitudinal study to access photographs of individuals at different ages. Finally, it was not

Parents Hitting Their Children Essay

710 words - 3 pages Parents Hitting Their Children For this coursework, I will be looking at whether parents should be allowed to hit their children or children that are being looked after by them. Like most questions there are usually two sides to the argument. The 1st reason why parents should be allowed to hit their kids is to enforce a form of discipline. The other reason why hitting children is bad is because by hitting a