What Does The Notion Of Legitimacy And Social Contract Have To Do With Corporate Disclosure Policies?

2666 words - 11 pages

What does the notion of legitimacy and social contract have to do with corporate disclosure policies?IntroductionIn recent years, corporations have increasingly used their annual reports to voluntarily report information relating to their social actions, particularly those concerning the natural environment (Gray et al.1995). More specifically, corporations have been changing their disclosure policy towards the "triple bottom line reporting", where in addition to economic performance, social and environmental issues of the company's performance are given (Deegan 2002). This has drawn the attention of researchers, and a number of theories have been postulated as to why companies disclose such information. According to Deegan and Rankin (1999), there is increasing evidence that the willingness to make such disclosures may be motivated by an intention to moderate the perceptions of the corporation which are held by important groups within society. Furthermore, organisations might use the disclosures as a defend policy when the organisation's legitimacy is in threat (ibid).In this study, we will focus on the role of social contracts and organisation legitimacy, and how can these aspects influence managers' policies to corporate reporting. We will first examine the underlying literature of legitimacy theory and social contracts. This will help us understand the importance and the role of social contracts that act as a motivation for managers to voluntary disclose information, and its ability to influence such disclosures. At a later point, we will give empirical evidence supporting (or criticising) our findings.Legitimacy theory and social contractResearchers have adapted the "system-oriented theories" to address the issue of corporate disclosures. The system-oriented theory, as explained by the Legitimacy theory and Stakeholder theory, argues that the organisation is influenced and has influence upon the society it operates. Both Legitimacy and Stakeholder theory derive from a broader perspective of political economy theory. As Deegan(2002) explain, political economy theory does not consider company's reports as neutral and biased documents, but rather as a product of the interchange between the corporation and its environment in an attempt to reconcile and accommodate a variety of sectional interests (Deegan, 2000). Similar to the legitimacy theory, stakeholder theory supports the same view of the relationship between legitimacy and corporate disclosures. The theory suggests that expectations of various stakeholders will have an effect on the disclosure policies of the company. Different groups will have different views about how the company should operate, and each group will have a different impact on the company. Therefore, the company will not respond to all the stakeholders equally, but rather paying more attention to the more powerful groups. Due to their similarity, Deegan (2002) argues that the two theories should not be treated...

Find Another Essay On What does the notion of legitimacy and social contract have to do with corporate disclosure policies?

Illustrate the notion of corporate ethics put forward by Dempsey with one recent example from the corporate world.

1508 words - 6 pages "Achieving commercial success in ways that honour ethical values and respect people, communities, and the natural environment". "Overview of Corporate Social Responsibility", (Business Ethics Awards, pg.1)According to Dempsey, corporate ethics are perspectives that assist a company instincts to look out for our own individual (organisation) welfare keeping in mind the obligation and morale of the society in which it operates and the development

What do the texts you have studied have to say about the positive and/or negative effects of institutions?

1131 words - 5 pages individual. It shows us how the fight for power within this institution can prove to be fatal, but the positive is that Brett achieved what he was aiming for.After analysis of the above, it can be concluded that the institution has many influences on an individual, both positive and negative in nature. It's the lessons that are taken out of these experiences that determine the true effect that it can have. Institutions such as the farm consist of a

"Gender Roles and Fashion " How do clothing fashions aid in the social construction of gender? What does a woman or man say about herself or himself with various pieces of clothing?

901 words - 4 pages created by the masculine conception of what femininity should be. These criteria set up the dominant/subordinate relationship standard because women lacked the power to challenge the male point of view. Lorber suggests that "as a process, gender creates social differences that define 'woman' and 'man'" through interactions and expectations of peers and family. As a stratification, gender ranks men's work superior to women's, regardless of skill

What does Utilitarianism Has to do with a Surgeon

1806 words - 7 pages performing such an operation every time a situation like thos would arise. One of the potential rules would claim that: whenever any surgeon can kill one healthy person for the basic purpose of transplanting his organs to save more than one person who actually needs them, then he can surely do it. However, as a result of this situation, some major issues may arise. For instance, relatively healthier people will stop going to the hospitals and many

What Contributions have Migrants Made to the Economic, Social and Cultural Development of Australia?

1122 words - 4 pages , it has only been able to benefit economically. Exposure of different foods has led to many people opening restaurants in many cities. Thus, more jobs have been created. They have also brought their music and dance for people to sample. What was once a country obsessed with country music and bush dancing is now a nation intrigued by the sounds of reggae and Latin and the movements of the Samba and Pasadoble.Migrants have also brought their Custom

How to balance corporate and social responsibility with the need to enhance financial performance.

549 words - 2 pages fundraisers. Two of the benefits of having a higher corporate social responsibility a company can increase its reputation; this will increase chances of forming new clients, and satisfying old ones. Finding great employees is never a problem with companies who have a high corporate social responsibility, because it will draw in and hold on to all top notch employees.Priscilla Wisner, an assistant professor at Thunderbird, The American Graduate School of

How far have the police embraced the notion of 'diversity' as a response to recent legislation and governmental policy initiatives?

2154 words - 9 pages in the diversity of species the principles of evolution that operated to generate the species: variation, competition and selection" (Thorndike & Benhart 615/1982)So have the police begun to embrace the notion of diversity? Do they as an organisation accept the differences between peoples and recognise the value of having that difference within the workplace? The difficulty lies with the fact that the police although overall is one body, it

How the 'social contract' described by Hobbs and Locke led to the formation of the United States and the citizens role in maintaining the social contract today.

1680 words - 7 pages bring forth idea's that would challenge system of oppression that man lived under. Thomas Hobbs (1588-1679) and John Locke (1632-1704) were both "Social Contract Theorists". A social contract was when a group of men who had ties (economic and social) made a "contract" with each other to protect themselves from the tyranny of the King. If the Kings attack one of the "contractors," then the others in the contract would come to his defense. In time this

'After all, y'know, we're respectable citizens and not criminals.' To what extent do you agree with Gerald? How does the author lead us to challenge this assertion?

1521 words - 6 pages her.At approximately this point of the play, Sheila Birling starts to shift to the side of Inspector Goole. She begins to think that sooner of later the truth will be salvaged out of every one of them and does not try and hold any resistance to hide secrets and even starts to aid the inspector in persuading the Birlings and Gerald to admit to the crimes that they have committed.Next in line in the chain of events is Mrs. Birling. Mrs. Birling is

I Have To Do What?

855 words - 4 pages society allows of them. On their birthday most teenagers go out and get their learners permit; which means they are legally allowed to drive. Also, at the age of fifteen, they are legally allowed to work once they get their workers permit. So, at this age our society is basically saying that we can support ourselves with transportation and money, but we cannot decide where we will live and what our earnings provide for. As teenagers they have the

Social Reformist and Market Liberal approaches may have been suitable for the social condition of the 20th Century, but 3rd Way welfare policies are more relevant to the 21st Century.

2925 words - 12 pages This essay will look at the social conditions that existed for each of the political parties and the welfare policy approaches that each party adopted in relation to the NHS. Initially I will look at Social Reformist policies followed by Market Liberals. But as a consequence of the research the essay will demonstrate that New Labour has used a collaboration of existing ideologies to create a set of welfare policies, which they claim are relevant

Similar Essays

"Corporate Financing And Investment Decisions When Firms Have Information That Investors Do Not Have: A Critique."

1672 words - 7 pages that what would happen when information is not symmetry among each party in market? And this is the central issue they focused on the entire paper.The idea in this study is to systematically explain the theory of pecking order which means that generally firms have preference for internal finance, debt, hybrid and equity respectively. Moreover, the authors try to explain some corporate behaviours implied form the pecking order theory such as when

With Reference To The Social Contract And One Painting By David, Discuss The Way Rousseau And David Explore The Notion Of Duty To The State.

1619 words - 6 pages state that made major changes to their society.Rousseau explores the notion of duty to the state by addressing the fundamental problem of who the legitimate ruler should be. The opening statement of The Social Contract says "Man was free ..." (Block 3, p. 96). If men were free, then men were equal and should have equal rights to rule. But that does not ring true in a society when one lives under the authority of the state, for they cannot both be

A Review Of The Article "Why Students With Special Needs Have Difficulty Learning Mathematics And What Teachers Can Do To Help." Covers Congnition And Strategies

524 words - 2 pages Mathematics Teaching in the Middle School, Feb 2003"Why students with special needs have difficulty learning mathematics and what teachers can do to help" pg. 308For the past two decades, US public schools have been blamed for students' poor performance in mathematics. As a response to our nation's low ranking in recent international comparisons, there has been an increase in number and difficulty of mathematics course requirements for

'hitler's Charismatic Personality And Policies Only Partly Explain The Nazis' Rise To Power In 1933.' To What Extent Do You Agree With This Statement?

889 words - 4 pages charismatic he was. Many people also claim that if you listen to what Hitler said during his rallies and speeches, most of it is not very impressive. Without the propaganda and technology surrounding the Nazi campaign, they would not have gone very far. Although they should not be considered the chief factors in the party's growth, Hitler's appeal and policies were important to the Nazi rise.